Essay, Research Paper
The decision in the Gibbons v. Ogden case is, in my opinion, a very just
and fair one. Many believe it to be the first anti- trust decision in U.S.
history. The economic results cannot be over-estimated, a different
decision could have resulted in completely different circumstances than with
which we are accustomed to today. The free flow of commerce, which we
seem to almost take for granted in modern economics and business, may have
never been a possibility without decisions such as this. Monopolies did not
allow for equal division of business and therefore was unjust. If all men are
created equal they should be given equal opportunities. The New York
Livingston-Fulton monopoly clearly subjected any potential competition to
harsh conditions that would make it impossible for them to keep up in their
business. Travel by steamboat was much faster than any other means in the
time of this case and to give complete control to only one partnership was
unfair. Under the constitution Congress has the right to regulate commerce.
Although the monopoly was a form of internal state trade regulation it
directly impacted on inter-state trade after a number of states passed laws
to come back at the New York monopoly. Therefore, Congress had the right
to intervene and end the monopoly.
To completely understand the impact of the Gibbons-Ogden decision
it is necessary to understand the situation surrounding it. In 1798 Robert R.
Livingston secured an exclusive twenty year grant from the New York
legislature. By the terms of this grant he could exclusively navigate by
steam the rivers and other waters of the state, provided that within two
years he should build a boat which would make four miles an hour against the
current of the Hudson River. The legislature had no faith whatsoever in the
project but the decision was still made against the many jeers. The terms
of the grant were not met and it was renewed in 1803, this time to
Livingston and his new partner, Robert Fulton. It was renewed once more in
1807 and finally that August Fulton’s steamboat made its first successful
trip from New York to Albany. The following year the Legislature, fully
aware of the practical significance of Fulton’s achievement, passed a law
stating that for each new boat navigated on New York waters by Fulton and
Livingston that they should be provided with a five year extension to their
monopoly, which may not exceed thirty years. The monopoly was made
further effective by not allowing for the travel of any other steam boats
along New York waters, unless licensed by Fulton and Livingston. Any
unlicensed vessel should be forfeited to them. Naturally this monopoly
worked hardships against on what would be Fulton and Livingston’s
competition. Neighboring states began to pass retaliatory laws against the
New York partners. In other words, as Cushman states on p. 187, “an
achievement of which had seemed destined to enlarge the means of
communication and develop the commerce of the nation appeared to be
embroiling the states in bitter antagonisms and commercial warfare such as
prevailed during the dismal period of the Confederation.”
Ogden and Gibbons had once been partners. They became rivals and
Gibbons began to navigate steamboats between two points in New York
under the authority of a coasting license obtained from the United States
government. Ogden secured a license from Fulton and Livingston. Upon
Ogden’s petition the New York court had enjoined Gibbons from continuing
his business. Chancellor James Kent had wrote the opinion of the court in
this case claiming the whole Hudson River belonged to New York, upholding
the validity of the New York statute establishing the monopoly and
repudiating the idea that there was any conflict involved between federal
and state authority. (Cushman, 187) Gibbons appealed to the Supreme
Court, presenting the first case under the commerce clause of the
constitution-Article I, Section 8 which provides congress with the power to
“regulate Commerce with foreign Nations and among the several States, and
with Indian tribes.” In his decision, Mr. Chief Justice John Marshall held
that the New York monopoly was unconstitutional in that it interfered with
the power of Congress over interstate commerce.
Webster’s argument against the validity of the steamboat monopoly
may be his best ever before the Supreme Court and Marshall’s decision may
have been his only truly popular one. Marshall delivered the opinion of the
court, saying that the laws giving exclusive privilege are repugnant because,
“1st. To that clause in the constitution which authorizes Congress to
regulate commerce.
2d. To that which authorizes Congress to promote the progress of science
and useful arts…” (Cushman, 188) Marshall’s decision helped to start the
U.S. on the road to the free flow of business.
There is though, as always, another side to this case. The commerce
which Congress may regulate can be taken as the transportation and sale of
commodities. In this case, Gibbon’s coasting license could not protect him
since he was carrying passangers, not goods. The monopoly only requires
that boats, once in New York waters need to be operated by means other
than a steam if not licensed. This law then is only a regulation of internal
state trade, not of commercial inter-state trade, therefore Congress cannot
have regulate since it is not affecting inter-state trade.
I think it was made obvious that this law was affecting inter-state trade.
New Jersey, Connecticut, Ohio, Georgia, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania,
Tennessee, New Hampshire, and Vermont all passed laws as a result from the
Livingston-Fulton monopoly. Congress had the constitutional right to end the
monopoly, “so accustomed are we to the free flow of commerce among the
states that it is hard to conceive how the nations might have developed if
the arguments in favor of the monopoly had prevailed…”(Cushman, 187)
Marshall’s decision demonstrated a clear improvement of the government
under the Constitution, as well as began to set limits against trusts.
America, as a free nation developed from the needs of men to be equal,
should be equal economically too. Monopolies prevented free flow and fair
competition among businesses and was definitely an unconstitutional
characteristic of our nation. In today’s times it is hard to imagine business
life like that, but for our economic system to have made it this far,
decisions like Marshall’s were very necessary. Business, by its nature
consists of competition. Whether or not that competition will be beneficial
or not to the individual depends on many factors, but one of these factors
should not include monopoly laws preventing them to try and outdo rivals in a
fair way. Although some may argue that the intended effect of the
Livingston-Fulton monopoly law itself was internal, it had a impact causing a
total of 9 other states to react by passing laws to counteract it, so it
obviously had a impact on the rest of the nation-direct or indirect-and
needed to be taken care of and Mr. Chief Justice John Marshall took the
appropriate actions.
Другие работы по теме:
Kansas
& Nebraska Act Resolved Essay, Research Paper Kansas & Nebraska Act Resolved Essay submitted by Unknown The Kansas-Nebraska act was a proposal by Sen. Stephen A. Douglas which said that
Lottery Essay Research Paper The LotteryThe story
Lottery Essay, Research Paper The Lottery The story takes place in a small town with a population of about three hundred. They are all gathering for a lottery in the Town Square. The lottery has been a tradition since the beginning of the town?s history. Some parts of the ritual had been forgotten and they even lost the original black ballot box.
Ethical Behavior Essay Research Paper Is it
Ethical Behavior Essay, Research Paper Is it fair to measure a politician?s public worth by his/her sexual behavior? This a question which has been brought before me and requires an answer, or a position on which I stand, fair or unfair? Well, I think it is fair.
Let The Punishment Fit The Crime Essay
, Research Paper Sir William Schwenk Gilbert stated in the first act of The Mikado ?Let the punishment fit the crime.? In society punishments are given to make people suffer for their wrong doings. Is it fair that when man breaks rules but only in the name of righteousness that he be punished? In the novel One Flew Over the Cuckoo?s Nest by Ken Kesey, the author skillfully portrays man as one who suffers for breaking the rules, while trying to stand up for his beliefs and inspire others.
Democracy Essay Research Paper DemocracyThesis Is democracy
Democracy Essay, Research Paper Democracy Thesis: Is democracy a possible form of government? With out it the world would be full of chaos and injustice. Democracy is the form of government that America has today. We are able to vote on whom we want to run our government. We have a say in what goes on in our lives and our future.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper At the
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper At the end of “The Lottery,” by Shirley Jackson, Tessie Hutchinson said, “It isn’t fair.” Tessie was correct; the lottery wasn’t fair. Death wasn’t fair, especially if you were the sacrificial lamb for the sake of tradition.”Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon,” took many innocent lives each year since the first settlers.
Comerce Clause Essay Research Paper The United
Comerce Clause Essay, Research Paper The United States Constitution gives very specific powers to congress. These powers are very limited and are each enumerated in the text of the Constitution. One of the powers is ?[t]o regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes? (Article I, Section 8).
Electoral College 2 Essay Research Paper Electoral
Electoral College 2 Essay, Research Paper Electoral College: It s time for reform It s not fair. It s not fair to the candidates running for office, not fair to the campaign volunteers and especially not fair to the American people. Although the Electoral College System was originally considered to be a brilliant innovation that cleverly solved a cluster of 18th-century problems, as we approach the 21st century, we confront different problems and our constitutional system of presidential selection does not look so brilliant.
Decisions Essay Research Paper Decisions Decisions DecisionsPeople
Decisions Essay, Research Paper Decisions, Decisions, Decisions People make decisions every single day, even if they know it or not. Whether it is an important decision as in buying the right car, or a little decision as in deciding what to eat for lunch. No matter what the decision maybe, one has to make choices everyday.
John Marshal Essay Research Paper The Influence
John Marshal Essay, Research Paper The Influence of Marshall s Court The Supreme Court, under John Marshall, had a great influence on the development of the powers of our present day government. John Marshall s court was responsible for greatly increasing the powers of the Supreme Court and the Federal Government.
Unfair Justice Essay Research Paper Unfair Justice
Unfair Justice Essay, Research Paper Unfair Justice? In spite of the horrible results the newly acquitted Mr. Elliot’s actions had, he didn’t do anything “wrong”. It is thisdilemma the U.K. have raged over the past few weeks after thejuvenile delinquent killed the father to three, Mr. Osbourne. Thereal problem here is that the people have felt deceived by theirown law, so what consequences are we now facing? No matter how unfair the acquitting of Mr.
Life Through Narrative Essay Research Paper One
Life Through Narrative Essay, Research Paper One of the primary themes of Kaye Gibbons? novel Ellen Foster is the vitality of storytelling in the human life. The fact that ?narrative is the only art that exists in all cultures? (Morton, 2) indicates that storytelling is instinctive in all humans. ?Nothing passes but the mind grabs is and looks for a way to fit it into a story, or into a variety of possible scripts?? (Morton, 3).
Gibbons Primat Research Essay Research Paper Scientific
Gibbons, Primat Research Essay, Research Paper Scientific Name: Hylobates lar, Family: Hylobatidae, Order: Primates, Class: Mammalia, Geographic distribution: Tropical rainforest of Southeast Asia. White-handed gibbons lack a prehensile tail and they use a form of locomotion called brachiation to swing from tree to tree and branch to branch.
American Fed Essay Research Paper American federalism
American Fed Essay, Research Paper American federalism is a form of government in which the constitution distributes governmental powers between the national government and the subsidiary governments of the states. Article I, Section 8, and the Tenth Amendment are good examples of this definition. In Article I, Section 8, the Constitution defines the powers delegated to the national government, such as the power to regulate commerce and to enact laws necessary and proper for the execution of its powers.
American Law Essay Research Paper Throughout the
American Law Essay, Research Paper Throughout the United States there are many different laws among the fifty states that make up this union. The laws are different throughout the states because of the need of the laws. Living in one state and not having the advantages or disadvantages of a law in another state would not be that unfair or unequal.
Medical Terms Essay Research Paper I agree
Medical Terms Essay, Research Paper I agree and disagree with genetic engineering. I feel that it is only fair to let somebody who can not get pregnant to able to use invitro-fertilization and to pick what the child would look like. However, to choose whether sperm was from an Olympic athlete or someone with very high intelligence levels is unfair and unethical.
John Marshall
’s Court Rulings Essay, Research Paper Hamilton was a federalist and served as the secretary of the treasury in the 1890s. He was a strong supporter of a centralized federal government. He also advocated loose interpretation of the u.s. constitution and the use of the elastic clause. Which was an ambiguous power of the federal government stating that ?congress can do what it is proper and necessary? john Marshall?s epitomizing of these Hamiltonian principals and philosophies can be seen in several of his court rulings.
Marketing Ethics Essay Research Paper The question
Marketing Ethics Essay, Research Paper The question of whether or not marketing is completely unethical is the question most critics of marketing seem to be focusing their attention on. Ethics provide the basis for deciding whether a particular action is morally good or morally bad (Britt 553). But, each individual develops different opinions, moral standards, and values.
Ogden Nash Essay Research Paper Have you
Ogden Nash Essay, Research Paper Have you ever heard adults talking about their spouses and all the troubles they have to put up with because they love them? In the poems The Trouble With Women Is Men and What Almost Every Woman Knows Sooner or Later, Ogden Nash talks about the troubles women go through daily with men and how frustrating it can be.
Ogden Nash Essay Research Paper Ogden Nashs
Ogden Nash Essay, Research Paper Ogden Nash?s Trash Ogden Nash was born on August 19,1902 in Rye, New York and was raised there and in Savannah, Georgia. He received his education from St. George?s School in Rhode Island and, a short while at Harvard University. His first published poem Spring Comes to Murray Hill was featured in the New Yorker Magazine in 1930.
A History Of The Early Assertion Of
Judicial Power Essay, Research Paper A History of the Early Assertion of Judicial Power Once upon a time there were several men planning out the best way to divide the power in a fledgling new country. Some of them wanted one big power, and others wanted three smaller ones where the power was roughly equally divided.
Justice Essay Research Paper JUSTICEWhat is justice
Justice Essay, Research Paper JUSTICE What is justice? Justice is defined as administering a deserved reward and rightfulness or lawness, according to Funk & Wagnall’s Standard Dictionary. Although this definition proves to be true in most cases, it is not always used correctly. If justice is supposed to be fair, then why are so many people found innocent-after already serving a sentence for a crime they didn’t commit.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John MarshallIn
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall In early American history, the powers of the executive and legislative branches of the government were already well defined. However, the judicial branch needed to establish its position as an equal of the other two branches. John Marshall was crucial in making this happen.
Federalism Essay Research Paper Federalism the balanced
Federalism Essay, Research Paper Federalism, the balanced division of state and federal powers, is an essential principle of the United States Government. On occasion this balance is contested or violated and court cases ensue. These court cases over time have shaped and defined federalism and the powers, rights, and position of state and national governments.
Developing A Procedurally Essay Research Paper Developing
Developing A Procedurally Essay, Research Paper Developing a procedurally Just performance appraisal process When organizations make decisions about people, such as whom to hire or promote, appraisal ratings or merit raise to give, or how important that the decisions are seen as fair and just. Research has shown that at least two aspects of justice influence employees?? job satisfaction and organizational commitment and both must be considered in organization decisions.
Oakland County 4H Fair Essay Research Paper
“The Oakland County 4-H Fair” The first week in August, in Davisburg, Michigan there is a small county fair that is jumping. From the top of the elevated water tower a all can be seen. Pig races, lumber jack show, and a carnival bright as can be. The clamorous noise as the fair goes on can be heard by people on the other side of the splashing hills.
Ellen Foster Essay Research Paper At the
Ellen Foster Essay, Research Paper At the age of ten, most children are dependent on their parents for everything in their lives needing a great deal of attention and care. However, Ellen, the main character and protagonist of the novel Ellen Foster, exemplifies a substantial amount of independence and mature, rational thought as a ten-year-old girl.
Federalism From Its Beginning To The Present
Essay, Research Paper From its early beginning in the minds of the Framers of the Constitution to its state today. The United States system of federalism has changed greatly through landmark court decisions, congressional decisions, and strong presidential influence. In the next few paragraphs I will take you through the history of federalism in the United States.
The Giver Essay Research Paper The GiverSome
The Giver Essay, Research Paper The Giver Some say when you have the freedom to chose you really have no freedom at all. Many countries don t give their citizens the right to make their own decisions. In the
Judicial Activism Vs Judicial Restraint Essay Research
Paper Judicial activism and judicial restraint are two opposing philosophies when it comes to the Supreme Court justices’ interpretations of the United States Constitution; justices appointed by the President to the Supreme Court serve for life,and thus whose decisions shape the lives of “We the people” for a long time to come.
Attribution Theory Essay Research Paper Attribution Theory
Attribution Theory Essay, Research Paper Attribution Theory: Is It Really Fair? One of the easiest theories to accept and understand is Heider’s Attribution Theory. This theory is used to explain how a person comes to a quick decision about someone or their personality, based on that person’s behavior.
Rome Essay Research Paper Rome was a
Rome Essay, Research Paper Rome was a major power because it always made certain its own military prowess was preeminent. There have been many ideas presented as to the fall of the Roman Empire. Many believe that Rome declined morally and the violence and decadence of the societal norms led to the demise. Gibbons has been credited with the theory of the influence and transference of Christianity over the Roman system of Gods and Goddesses that perpetrated the fall.