Paper
Brett Ashley: Whore or Herione
After a thorough reading and in-depth analyzation of Ernest Hemingway s riveting novel The Sun Also Rises, the character of Brett Ashley may be seen in a number of different ways. While some critics such as Mimi Reisel Gladstein view Brett as a Circe or bitch-goddess, others such as Carol H. Smith see Brett as a woman who has been emotionally broken by the world around her. I tend to agree with the latter of these views, simply because of the many tragedies that befell Brett. She is a heroine who, despite being wounded by love and war, continues to pursue true love.
Mimi Reisel Gladstein does make an excellent case for Brett as a modern-day Circe or bitch-goddess. Brett is a . . . drunkard, a nymphomaniac, or a Circe who turns men into swine. . . (58). She has this transforming effect on several men throughout the course of the novel. Because of her extreme physical beauty, men such as Robert Cohn and Mike Campbell place Brett on a pedestal where she can do no wrong. Robert offers himself to Brett, then follows her around as if on a leash, sniveling and squealing as if he were swine (58). While Brett saunters around on her sexual escapades, she does not take into account the feelings of Jake, the man who truly loves her, because he is unable to meet her sexual needs. Brett does bother with Jake s frustrations; she uses him only as an emotional support to fall back on when the flings leave her emotionally unsatisfied. Brett s bitchery is fully revealed by her treatment of Jake. . . he truly loves her but she uses Jake to get the emotional fix she cannot find is sexual union . . . this is ironic since she would most likely find both if Jake were fully functional (59). By looking at her treatment of Robert Cohn, Mike Campbell, and Jake Barnes, Brett could easy be seen as a self-centered, promiscuous nymphomaniac whose quest for love destroys men but leaves her relatively unharmed.
As Carol Smith points out, however, . . . analyzing Brett in terms of bitch-goddess or Terrible Mother does not do justice to her (55). Smith s quotation is well-founded. Hemingway has done much more with the character of Brett than it may seem. She is a good woman the world has broken . . . a complex woman who has endured much (55). These views are solidly-based as well. The two marriages that Brett entered into were loveless; the first with a man who died of dysentery during the war, and the second with a British Naval officer who returned from war suffering from a rather intense case of shock. Her love life is described by Theodore Bardacke as a . . . casualty of war in itself, has decayed into alcoholism and a series of causal sex relations (12). These events have not only marred Brett, but they have also desexed her. Brett s . . . clothes, her mannish felt hat and bobbed hair, all are indications of her loss of true sexuality (13). Her traumatic experiences with love and war, . . . drive her from her bar to bar, from man to man, city to city. None of it is any good: her polygamy, with or without benefit of justices of the peace, leads only to more of the same. . . Brett is not good for the men she knows (Smith 54). Perhaps the most frustrating relationship for Brett is the one involving Jake. Both of these characters, . . . struggle with their desire to be with each and [more importantly] the realization that they can never be lovers (55). Brett expresses her feeling of torment best when she states, Don t touch me….I can t stand it….I simply turn all to jelly when you touch me (Hemingway, 33-34). All these circumstances have profoundly affected Brett; all of these occurrences as well as the changes that they caused, were out of Brett s control and can be used as evidence for the argument that Brett is a woman who has been, . .. emotionally stunted by a shallow world without spiritual meaning, and has become a woman devoid of womanhood (Bardacke 12).
Having done such intense research on the topic of Brett Ashley, I find that both arguments are very compelling. I believe, however, that there is another view of Brett Ashley that can be supported. She is both a bitch-goddess and a wounded-heroine. The bitch goddess stereotype is supported by treating men like toys to be disposed of when she grows tired of them. Robert Cohn is an excellent example. She uses him to get away when the two of them take a weekend in San Sebastian, only to later reject his later attempts to give their relationship any sort of special meaning. Robert is so devoted to her and his worships her so intensely that his pride is destroyed. As Mimi Gladstein points out, The final memento he has to carry away from his encounter with Brett is a sock in the face from Pedro Romero (Gladstein 58). Mike Campbell, as well, is another man who is reduced in his association with Brett. To be truthful, not much can be said for Mike to begin with, but after his relationship with Brett he is left alone and penniless. Then there is Jake Barnes, who, despite loving Brett truly, is only used as an emotional crutch for Brett to back-upon. Yet, for all her faults, I still do not see Brett as a bitch-goddess. She has certain positive mothering qualities that are also evident. She and Jake met in a hospital while she was a nurse during the war. Mike Campbell even mentions her mothering qualities, She loves looking after people. That s how we came to go off together. She was looking after me (Hemingway, 206). Brett also takes care of Romero after his fistfight with Robert, and she tries to maintain peace among the group with at the fiesta. It would be a draw between the title of queen-slut bitch and broken heroine if it were not for Brett s dealings with Romero. Brett did actually love Romero , but she choses to leave him because she knows that she is not good for him. The age difference between Romero is stressed when Brett states, I m thirty-four, you know, I m not going to be one of these bitches that ruins children (247). This statement is key because, for the first time in a long time, Brett is putting another person s welfare before her own. This action preserves the only thing left to Brett, her self respect. This sacrificial act has make her heroic and she returns to Mike and his shallow, alcoholic world because that is her world as well.
While some critics perceive Hemingways character Brett Ashley as a witch or Circe, others see her as a heroine crushed by fate, love, and war. While there is evidence that supports both claims, I believe Brett is a mixture of both that, in the end, becomes more heroic by sacrificing to protect another person s welfare and returning to the world that is her own.
Works Cited
Bardacke, Theodore. Hemingway s Women: 1950, Ernest Hemingway: The Man and His Work. Ed. John K. McCaffery (Cleveland: World Publishing, 1950), pp. 342-44. Rpt. in Brett Ashley. Ed. Harold Bloom. New York: G.K. Hall and Co., 1995. pp.12-13.
Gladstein, Mimi Reisel, Hemingway, The Indestructible Woman in Faulkner, Hemingway, and Steinbeck. (Ann Arbor, UMI Research Press, 1986), pp. 59, 62. Rpt. in Critical Essays on Earnest Hemingways The Sun Also Rises, ed. James Nagel. New York: G.K. Hall and Co., pp.58, 59.
Hemingway, Ernest. The Sun Also Rises. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1926.
Smith, Carol H., Women and the Loss of Eden, Ernest Hemingway: The Writer in Context, Ed. James Nagel (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1984), pp132-4. Rpt. in Critical Essays on Earnest Hemingways The Sun Also Rises, ed. James Nagel. New York: G.K. Hall and Co., 1995. 54-
Другие работы по теме:
Sumerian Relation To Present World Essay Research
Paper Today’s world has benefited from all the technologies and gains by the Sumerians. The rises of the cities (back then) are related to the growth in United States. We have a baby boomer happening every so often and it helps make progress in this country. The buildings are always changing to bigger and better things so I think we’re making pretty good developments.
A Clean WellLighted Place Essay Research Paper 2
A Clean, Well-Lighted Place Essay, Research Paper Ernest Miller Hemingway was born in Oak Park, Illinois July 21, 1898. He died in 1961 at the age of 63. Hemingway is known to be one of the most influential writers of the twentieth century. He has written more than one hundred short fiction stories, many of them are well known around the world.
Great Gatsby And The Sun Also Rises
Essay, Research Paper Live for the day, because tomorrow may never come, an often-heard motto in the 1920 s and the themes of two well-known novels of the 1920 s. The Sun Also Rises, by Ernest Hemingway and The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, are two novels about the lost generation. They are striving to find an order for their world, a world that has been shattered.
The Tide Rises The Tide Falls Essay
, Research Paper The ocean is one of the most powerful forces on this earth. It stops for nothing. This idea is represented in the poem “The Tide Rises, the Tide Falls” by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. In this particular poem, the ocean is the symbol for life. Although many things are dependent on the ocean, it is dependent on nothing.
The Price Of Objectivity Critical Analysis Of
The Sun Also Rises) Essay, Research Paper The Price of Objectivity The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway is one of the pre-eminent works of modernist literature. It set the tone for the several decades of literature that was to follow. It delves deeply into the lost generation that was created after the first wold war.
Sun Also Rises And Jake Barnes Essay
, Research Paper People often mentally distance themselves from their peers do to flaws and irregularities that they may suffer from. In The Sun Also Rises Jake Barnes
Descriptive Essay Essay Research Paper Person He
Descriptive Essay Essay, Research Paper Person: He stands five foot five. His hair is blonde and brown. His eyes are brown as well. He listens to punk music, Nofx being his favorite band. He likes to go fishing in his grandmother’s back yard, and hunt as well. He is nice to all who are nice to him. He never turns down a friend in need, even if he is in need as well.
Mt St Helens Essay Research Paper Mt
Mt. St. Helens Essay, Research Paper Mt. St. Helens Top of Volcano Blown Off In Blast! 18/04/82. 60 people were killed today when Mt. St Helens blew its top
Macbeth Essay Research Paper MacbethIn a tragedy
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Macbeth In a tragedy the main character rises to greatness, then continues to fall down a shame spiral which leads to their down fall.An example of a tragedy is Macbeth. Macbeth is driven up the hill of greatness a rise, then his untamed ambition leads him to death. The process of a tragedy is slow to let the audience become comfortable with the power and happiness of the main character.
Good Earth Sun Also Rises Identity Essay
, Research Paper The Good Earth and The Sun Also Rises: Establishing an Identity In many works of fiction, a main character is faced with problems while attempting to achieve their personal goals. Through solving these problems and attempting to reach their goals, characters discover their own personal identity in life.
Industrial Revolution Essay Research Paper How Global
Industrial Revolution Essay, Research Paper How Global Warming Relates to the Industrial Revolution Global Warming relates back to the Industrial Revolution in many ways. During the Industrial Revolution many new inventions were made that would make life easier for people back then and also in the future.
Enthalpy Essay Research Paper What are the
Enthalpy Essay, Research Paper What are the thermodynamic standard conditions? 298K, 1 atm pressure, concentration of 1mol per dm3 What is enthalpy change? The heat change measured at a constant pressure and
Everything That Rises Must Coverge Essay Research
Paper The short story ?Everything That Rises Must Converge?, by Flannery O?Connor tells the story of Julian, the main character and his thoughts and feelings toward his mother. Julian is a college graduate who has a fair understating of the world he lives in, and because of this finds difficulty dealing with his mother and her views of the world.
Everthing That Rises Must Converge Essay Research
Paper Everthing That Rises Must Converge In “Everything That Rises Must Converge,” Flannery O”Connor used two fictional characters, Julian and his mothers, to contrast with each other on how they react to different changes that were taking place in their lives. From the outlook, the story took place in a time when slavery was outlawed in America and when black people were allowed to ride on bused with white people.
Flannery Oconner Essay Research Paper Flannery O
Flannery Oconner Essay, Research Paper Flannery O Connor s use of the protagonist in the three stories Everything That Rises Must Converge , A Good Man is Hard to Find , and Revelation are all expressed through characters that do not fit the typical protagonist mold. As you will see the three protagonists have many similarities.
Saint Helens Essay Research Paper Tracie Knowlton7th
Saint Helens Essay, Research Paper Tracie Knowlton 7th period Many things can happen before, during, and after a volcanic eruption. A volcanic eruption is an extraordinary thing. You never know what is going to turn out as in the end.
Honest Iago Essay Research Paper Honest Iago
Honest Iago Essay, Research Paper Honest Iago In William Shakespeare’s Othello, despicable Iago, the ultimate villain, uses his intelligence and resourcefulness to exact his vengeance. By creating chaos and causing people to doubt each other Iago rises to power. In the deaths he causes as he achieves his revenge, he provides a shocking representation of absolute evil and a metaphor a out human nature.Iago’s extreme villainy, originally fueled by his jealousy of Cassio’s position, bloomed into a much greater passion.
Hero In Hemingway
’s Writing Essay, Research Paper Hero in Hemingway’s writing The Sun Also Rises The remarkable thing about the book was its liberal use of dialogue and how Hemingway used it to carry the reader through the book. There was no plot in the book in the sense that there was no twists, intrigue, or goals for any of the characters and the dialogue was the only thing that moved the reader through the book.
Alienation Paper Hemmingway Essay Research Paper Alienation
Alienation Paper Hemmingway Essay, Research Paper Alienation Paper The novels The Old Man and the Sea and The Sun Also Rises are both written by Ernest Hemingway. Some of the aspects of the stories are similar, and some are different. Each book presents a character that has been alienated, but the method used to present the character varies.
Untitled Essay Research Paper A Farewell to
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A Farewell to Arms The overall tone of the book is much different than that of The Sun Also Rises. The characters in the book are propelled by outside forces, in this case WWI, where the characters in SAR seemed to have no direction. Frederick’s actions are determined by his position until he deserts the army.
Welfare Essay Research Paper In brief first
Welfare Essay, Research Paper In brief, first, the global economy has brought with it high rates of unemployment and economic inactivity in much of Europe. It has also generated strong pressures to de-regulate and create flexible labour markets with sharp rises in wage dispersion, part-time, temporary and casual employment particularly in the UK and USA.
Taekwondo Essay Research Paper Eng Comp ITaekwondoTaekwondo
Taekwondo Essay, Research Paper Eng. Comp. I Taekwondo Taekwondo, usually thought of by most people as just a way of fighting, and as being a brutal sport. People consider it brutal because of all the kicks, punches, throws, and arm and wrist locks; they usually aren?t open minded enough to see the way it benefits people especially children.
Sun Also Rises Essay Research Paper Ernest
Sun Also Rises Essay, Research Paper Ernest Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises is set in Europe after World War I and talks about the life of a group of expatriates, and their summer journey from Paris to Pamplona in Spain. This novel vividly depicts the time period since it shows the atmosphere of despair and disillusionment following the First World War.
The Sun Rises Essay Research Paper The
The Sun Rises Essay, Research Paper The Sun Rises Mankind, through its hardships and struggles, has created many outlets to tell of its trials and tribulations. People have a need to relate their stories to other people. Music, art, prose, cinema, and poetry are among some of the most common types of storytelling.
Ernest HemingwayS
“The Sun Also Rises” Essay, Research Paper Code Hero Ernest Hemingway is one of the authors named “The Lost Generation.” He could not cope with post-war America; therefore, he introduced a new type of character in writing called the code hero. He was known to focus his novels around code heroes who struggle with the mixture of their tragic faults and the surrounding environment.
The Great Depression Essay Research Paper THE
The Great Depression Essay, Research Paper THE GREAT DEPRESSION The year of 1929 began a time period of horror in America. It was the beginning of the great depression. A time in which many lost their
The Sun Also Rises By Ernest Hemingway
Essay, Research Paper The Sun Also Rises In Ernest Hemingway s The Sun Also Rises, Jake Barnes is a lost man who wastes his life on drinking. Towards the beginning of the book Robert Cohn asks Jake, Don t you ever get the feeling that all your life is going by and you re not taking advantage of it? Do you realize that you ve lived nearly half the time you have to live already? Jake weakly answers, Yes, every once in a while.
The Sun Also Rises 3 Essay Research
Paper Hemmingway’s The Sun Also Rises In the novel The Sun Also Rises , written by Ernest Hemingway the main character makes a decision to introduce the woman he loves
The Sun Also Rises A Review Essay
, Research Paper The Sun Also Rises: A Review [I cannot express to you how glad I am that I am taking this class. I am thoroughly enjoying Hemingway. The Sun Also Rises is one of the best books I've
Ecline And Fall And Sun Also Rises
Essay, Research Paper Though Ernest Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises, and Evelyn Waugh’s Decline and Fall are written by two different authors, they share similar content and themes. In The Sun Also Rises, Brett desires Jake but cannot commit as a result of Jake’s impotence. Similarly, in Decline and Fall, Margot cannot commit to Paul because of his time in jail.