Billy Budd Essay, Research Paper
Herman Melville’s Billy Budd, Sailor is evidently an extremely divisive text when one considers the amount of dissension and disagreement it has generated critically. The criticism has essentially focused around what could be called the dichotomy of acceptance vs. resistance. On the one hand we can read the story as accepting the slaughter of Billy Budd as the necessary ends of justice. We can read Vere’s condemnation as a necessary military action performed in the name of preserving the political order on board the Bellipotent. On the other hand, we can read the story ironically as a Melvillian doctrine of resistance. Supporters on this pole of the debate argue that Billy Budd’s execution is the greatest example of injustice. They argue that the execution is a testament of denunciation, deploring the shallow political order of a paranoid military regime. I do not wish to argue either side of this debate. I have pointed it out to illustrate that Billy Budd, Sailor is a text about principles of right conduct, or at least this view is held by critics. Is Vere’s conduct right or wrong? This is the basic question at stake. In this sense it is a text about moral values and ethical conduct. However, considering that Billy Budd, Sailor is an ethical text, what I find most curious about it is the mysterious absence of the emotion guilt. Here we have a story about two murders. Billy obviously kills Claggart and Vere (Although it is indirect, ultimately the decision is his) kills Budd. Neither of these murderers shows the emotion of guilt in the form of remorse. For a narrative which tries so hard to situate the reader in an ethical and moral position of choosing interpretations, isn’t it somewhat ironic that the characters themselves don’t exhibit that which would seem to be the most ethical and moral of emotions following the taking of a persons life? Where is the guilt? This is the question I have sought and found a possible answer for in this paper.
I have said that neither Billy Budd nor Captain Vere exhibit remorse following their acts of killing. Immediately following the fatal blow to Claggart we are shown no outlet of emotion stemming from Billy. Whatever emotion he may be experiencing is not accounted for by Melville. Indeed, he is silent and nothing is revealed of his physiognomy as Vere orders Billy to exit the scene: “This order Billy in silence mechanically obeyed.” This is not behavior one would typically expect from someone who just accidentally murdered someone. An ethical or moral reaction would seem to be one of surprise and inquiry such as, “My god, What have I done!” or something to that effect. Instead Billy is mechanical. When he reemerges for the trial, Billy says this to account for his actions: “I did not mean to kill him. But he foully lied to my face and in presence of my captain, and I had to say something, and I could only say it with a blow, God help me!” This statement illustrates Billy’s emotional reaction to his crime. Firstly, he shirks the full weight of his action by pointing to its accidental nature, which surely accounts for something, however in his own mind this is a complete reprieve. Billy is sorry that Claggart was killed, but he is sorry in the way a schoolboy is sorry. He states the utterance as a response without truly feeling apologetic. Indeed this statement is an appeal to save himself more than a eulogy to Claggart, however a feeling of remorse for murdering another human being is nowhere to be found. His concerns are not at all for the one he killed, but for himself as is indicated by “God help me!”
After the hanging of Billy Budd, the narrative ceases to relate the events on board the Bellipotent. For this reason, we are never shown Vere’s emotional reaction to his decision to hang Billy. The only reaction we are presented with is immediately before the death, when Billy cries out “God bless Captain Vere!” At this moment Vere “stood erectly rigid as a musket in the ship armorer’s rack” Melville accounts for Vere’s emotion at this point by describing it as “stoic self-control or a sort of momentary paralysis induced by emotional shock.” Either Vere is completely indifferent or unaffected by joy, grief, pleasure or pain at the penultimate moment, or he is overcome by the weight of the events and is physically frozen. In either case, no release of emotion is evident and Vere’s inner feelings regarding his action are conspicuously concealed from the reader.
In each instance, moral and ethical dilemma is laid out for the readers to squirm under. Indeed, as Joseph Schiffman says regarding the execution, “…does not the reader gag?” But what about the characters? Why are the readers coerced into a moral stance while the characters exhibit none? Earlier I asked the question what happens to guilt? To understand the relationship of guilt as it applies to these two characters, Captain Vere and Billy Budd, I will examine their relationship in the context of what Neitzsche calls the “contractual relationship between creditor and debtor” in the second essay of On The Genealogy Of Morals entitled, “’Guilt,’ ‘Bad Conscience,’ and the like.” Captain Vere is the creditor and Billy Budd is the debtor.
According to Nietzsche, “the major moral concept Schuld [guilt] has its origin in the very material concept Schulden [debts].” Guilt therefore, comes from the initial stages of human cultural development. The fundamental societal actions of barter, selling, trade and traffic of goods is directly analogous to the beginnings of the notion of requital for injury endured. The debtor makes a promise to the creditor, a promise to repay.
To inspire trust in his promise to repay, to provide a guarantee of the seriousness and sanctity of his promise, to impress repayment as a duty, an obligation upon his own conscience, the debtor made a contract with the creditor and pledged that if he should fail to repay he would substitute something else that he “possessed,” something he had control over; for example, his body, his wife, his freedom, or even his life…
This form of compensation to the creditor even had legal bounds. There were legal evaluations as to the specific value of various body parts which could be removed by the creditor as compensation. In place of a compensation of money, land or possession, a recompense in the form of pleasure is provided to the creditor. The pleasure lies in inflicting bodily harm or injury as requital for injury upon the debtor. In this sense, “The compensation, then, consists in a warrant for and title to cruelty.”
Surely, we don’t want to think Captain Vere executes Billy Budd in order to gain some kind of sick pleasure as an act of repayment. However, the concept of recompense in the form of pain for injury, which is fundamental to this creditor and debtor system, is present in Vere’s actions. In the sense that punishment is the means to gratification for the creditor, Vere employs, interprets and adapts a procedure of punishment for Billy Budd. A procedure that is prescribed by law, but which is inflicted in what Nietsche describes as:
Punishment as a declaration of war and a war measure against an enemy of peace, of the law, of order, of the authorities, whom, as a danger to the community, as one who has broken the contract that defines the conditions under which it exists, as a rebel, a traitor, and breaker of the peace, one opposes with the means of war
Vere, regardless of how he personally feels, as a military disciplinarian he
must see Billy as a transgressor and enemy of the peace of his ship. Billy’s crime has upset the law, order and authority of his community on board the Bellipotent. As a result, Vere must requite the “debt” and employ punishment.
Punishment, in the Nietzschian sense, thus supposes that every injury has some sort of equivalent that can be paid back or requited. Essentially, injury can be remunerated by pain. This is essentially how punishment works in human culture, and how it works in Billy Budd, Sailor. In most cultures, we punish and inflict pain by locking transgressors in prisons outside of society or by killing them by various means. This is in effect, an infliction of pain. The same is true in Billy Budd, Sailor, the punishment is a hanging which certainly is a punishment including pain. The notion of compensation for injury by inflicting pain is what is essential for discovering what happens to guilt in the text.
Punishment is ideally supposed to invoke feelings of remorse. We punish to make sure that the feeling of guilt is felt in the guilty person. As Nietsche says, “one seeks in it the actual instrumentum of that psychical reaction called ‘bad conscience,’ ‘sting of conscience.’” Thus, in accordance to the action of Vere, ideally the punishment should cause a “sting of conscience” in Billy Budd. However, as Nietsche illustrates and as the text of Billy Budd, Sailor confirms, seldom, if ever is this the case. Punishment itself precludes the guilty party from experiencing remorse: “prisons and penitentiaries are not the kind of hotbed in which this species of gnawing worm is likely to flourish” Indeed, locking someone in a filthy prison for committing a crime seldom causes that person to really feel remorse for their crime. If you need evidence of this you need only look at the number of repeat offenders in our justice system. Punishment generally makes people hard and indifferent. In the act of punishing, the punisher (creditor) is placed in a position of power over the punishee (debtor). This power vs. powerless relationship alienates the guilty one and alienation strengthens the power of resistance. By resistance I mean the act of opposing the force which seeks to impose a feeling of guilt. Therefore, for someone to feel remorse or guilt, they must feel it from within themselves. The punishment inflicted by others (the injured ones) is nothing to the cause. In this sense, punishment and guilt are contradictory forces. Punishment impedes and precludes the emotion of guilt from being experienced.
It is the punishment that precludes the expression of guilt and remorse in Billy Budd, Sailor. To read the story as either accepting or resisting an ethical dilemma is perhaps a moot point. The ethical thrust of the story could possibly be to indict mans insatiable need to punish and requite injuries through erroneous means. As Nietzche seems to think, “we may unhesitatingly assert that it was precisely through punishment that the development of the feeling of guilt was most powerfully hindered.” If we conceive of the text of Billy Budd, Sailor as situating the reader for an alignment with this viewpoint, then perhaps the reader “gags” at the death of Billy Budd not for the seemingly unfair and unjust killing of a sympathetic character, but instead for its illustration of a social system inherently disjointed at its foundation; one which doesn’t make sense considering human nature, but one which is so inextricably linked to society that it is doubtful that it could ever, or will ever, be changed.
Другие работы по теме:
Religious Symbolism In The Scarlet Letter And
Billy Budd Essay, Research Paper Herman Melville and Nathaniel Hawthorne were contemporaries of each other. They lived very different lives, one living as a sailor for four years and the other attending an Ivy League school, yet their writing reflects a similar style, as shown in Melville?s Billy Bud and Hawthorne?s The Scarlet Letter.
Melville
’s “Bartleby The Scrivener”: Introduction Of Character Essay, Research Paper Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener”: Introduction of Character In the first three paragraphs of ?Bartleby the Scrivener,? Melville
Billy Budd Thesis Paper Essay Research Paper
When reading the book Billy Budd by, Herman Melville, You use your mind to create the setting, characters and the meaning of one thing to another. When one let s someone else tell you what is happening: who a character is, and what a ship looks like, they then are forfeiting a large part of a story. As one reads a book, you are the director, the staring actor and the producer.
Billy Budd Essay Research Paper In the
Billy Budd Essay, Research Paper In the novel Billy Budd, Herman Melville challenges traditional Romantic values. Melville sets a stage on which the ideals of the Enlightenment and Romantic thinkers clash. His faith in the Romantic ideals is evident in his comparison of the trials of Billy Budd to the trials of Jesus Christ.
Billy Budd Essay Research Paper There is
Billy Budd Essay, Research Paper There is much to be said about innocence. If one is with innocence than one can do no wrong. But that is not all to be said. Innocence is not always a good thing. It could make one naive or blind
Billy Budd
– Individualism Essay, Research Paper There is much to be said about individualism. Feelings of freedom and endless possibilities for individual growth are presented throughout these two novels. Although being an individual has its high points, it is not always the road to take. Billy Budd and Ignatius Reilly were both prime examples of individuals.
Billy Budd Essay Research Paper Joyce Carol
Billy Budd Essay, Research Paper Joyce Carol Oates writes that Herman Melville?s novels have artistic difficulty because he uses fiction writing as a preachy parable. Oates believes that Melville?s writing is annoying for the modern reader to interpret because of contemporary expectations that writing be entertaining and less like a heavy sermon.
Bill Budd Essay Research Paper Herman Melville
Bill Budd Essay, Research Paper Herman Melville s Billy Budd is a story about true goodness. It entails the conflict of good and evil, but more than that it portrays innocence in its most purest form.
Herman Melville Essay Research Paper Portrayed through
Herman Melville Essay, Research Paper Portrayed through the characters of his novella Billy Budd, Herman Melville reveals his feelings on society; he believes justice should prevail over evil, however, evil overcomes goodness and innocence. Each character defines a specific characteristic of society.
Innocence Vs Evil Essay Research Paper Too
Innocence Vs Evil Essay, Research Paper Too much innocence is not always a good thing, but a little helps from doing wrong. In the case of Billy Budd, innocence was not an important factor, therefor it did not save Billy’s life. His ignorance partly reflects his lack of experience. Billy can’t read or write so he knows little about the world except what he has seen out at sea.
Billy Budds Innocence Essay Research Paper Billy
Billy Budds Innocence Essay, Research Paper Billy Budd~ There is a lot to be said about innocence. If one is with innocence, than one can so no wrong but that isn?t all. Innocence is not always a good thing. It can make a person na?ve or blind to certain or all evils, which would seem as if they were blind from the world.
BILLY BUDD Essay Research Paper Before the
BILLY BUDD Essay, Research Paper Before the Fall, Adam and Eve were perfect. They were innocent and ignorant, yet perfect, so they were allowed to abide in the presence of God. Once they partook of the fruit of
Billy Budd 2 Essay Research Paper Billy
Billy Budd 2 Essay, Research Paper Billy Budd, a 19th century novel written by Herman Melville, involves three main characters: Billy Budd, John Claggart and Captain Vere. Throughout the first nineteen chapters, Melville portrays each character with distinct personality, in which case Billy Budd is represented as the simple-minded sailor, Claggart is viewed as the villain, and Captain Vere is seen as the honorable superior of the ship.
Bartleby Essay Research Paper Bartleby The Scrivener
Bartleby Essay, Research Paper Bartleby- The Scrivener In Herman Melville s Bartleby the Scrivener , the author uses several themes to convey his ideas. The three most important themes are alienation, man s desire to have a free conscience, and man s desire to avoid conflict. Melville uses the actions of an eccentric scrivener named Bartleby, and the responses of his cohorts, to show these underlying themes to the reader.
Bartleby Essay Essay Research Paper Bartleby EssayDiscuss
Bartleby Essay Essay, Research Paper Bartleby Essay Discuss the conflict of the individuals’ need to communicate his individual thoughts and feelings versus the desire of society’s institutions, for conformity in Melville’s “Bartleby, the Scrivener” and Updike’s “A & P.”
Billy Budd As A Christ Figure Essay
, Research Paper On first glance, Billy Budd is little more than a sea story involving a sailor wrongly accused of mutiny. However, upon closer examination, one observes that Melville s novel possesses a deeper significance. Melville presents the protagonist, Billy as a handsome, young sailor. Nonetheless, Billy Budd can be seen as a Christ-figure through his experiences with Captain Vere, Claggert and his crewmembers aboard the Bellipotent.
Good Vs Evil In Billy Budd Essay
, Research Paper Ryan Fischer English III Okma 19 April 2001 Good Versus Evil in Billy Budd Good versus evil is a very common theme in many different types of literature. One literary work which portrays the battle between good and evil very affectively is Billy Budd by Herman Melville. In this novel, good is portrayed through the character of Billy, while the character of Claggart portrays evil.
Billy Budd Sailor Essay Research Paper
“Billy Budd, Sailor” Herman Melville seems to be an evil person; he has no remorse for any one. In one scene of the story Billy Budd shows his courage by trying to save another sailor’s life. The nasty Lieutenant Ratcliffe sends a sick man up the mast to man his post. This sick sailor was very weak and could barley stand up strait on his own feet, but he was too proud to admit his illness.
Herman MelvilleS
“Billy Budd” Essay, Research Paper As portrayed in the Bible, Adam and Eve were the perfect human species. This was only a result because of their complete innocence. God let them remain in his presence because of this reason. After the devil conned them into eating fruit from the Tree of Good and Evil they became unclean.
Herman Melville 2 Essay Research Paper Herman
Herman Melville 2 Essay, Research Paper Herman Melville: Life, Works, and Critical Evaluation Herman Melville, American novelist of the 1800 s wrote various novels that present radical themes. Many of his works reflect his life and his past adventures. In some of his writing it is obvious that he is reflecting on some of his past experiences that he had.
Herman Mellvile Essay Research Paper Herman Melville
Herman Mellvile Essay, Research Paper Herman Melville, An American Novelist Herman Melville is widely regarded as one of America’s greatest and most influential novelists; known primarily as the author of Moby Dick. He belonged to a group of eminent pre-Civil War writers-American Romantics or members of the American Renaissance-who created a new and vigorous national literature.
Billy Budd Was Captain Vere Right Essay
, Research Paper Billy Budd: Was Captain Vere Right? Captain Vere makes the right decision by executing Billy Budd. If CaptainVere lets Billy live the rest of the crew might get the impression that
Billy Budd 2
Billy Budd’s Biblical Connections Essay, Research Paper Billy Budd?s Biblical Connections This book report is about Billy Budd, by Herman Melville. It was Melville?s final novel, and was published in 1924, over 30 years after his death. Billy Budd is a basic battle of good and evil, with evil deceiving good, and good taking the final victory.
Critical Essay On Billy Budd Essay Research
Paper Critical Essay on Billy Budd Charles Reich’s assessment of the conflict in Billy Budd focuses on the distinction between the laws of society and the laws of nature. Human law says
The Hanging Of Billy Budd Essay Research
Paper The Hanging of Billy Budd The hanging of Billy in Melville’s Billy Budd was a questionable and complex decision made by Captain Vere. Captain Vere, or “starry Vere,” chose to coincide with the law rather than spare Billy to make himself happy. The hanging of Billy was necessary for order to remain on the ship and for justice to prevail.
Billy Budd Essay Research Paper In
Billy Budd Essay, Research Paper In Henry Melville s novel Billy Budd, the protagonist, Billy Budd, is a young impressed sailor aboard an English Battleship. Billy shows his actions toward a Christ Figure through his innocence and ignorance, which he shows while interacting with Claggart, the ships Master of Arms.
Billy Budd Essay Research Paper Billy
Billy Budd Essay, Research Paper Billy Budd: Perfect Character In Unjust Microcosm An allegory is a symbolic story. Herman Melville’s Billy Budd is an example of an allegory. The author uses the protagonist Billy Budd to symbolize a superior being who has a perfect appearance and represents goodness. Melville shows the reader that a superior being can be an innocent victim of evil and eventually destroyed.
Moby Dick By Herman Melville (1819 -
– 1891) Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick, or, The White Whale is a book of amazing depth. It can be read on several levels: for over a century it has captivated young readers, naturalists, historians and literary scholars
Moby Dick 3 Essay Research Paper
“I Try All Things; I Achieve What I Can” (Herman Melville in MOBY DICK) Herman Melville, in his novel, MOBY DICK, combined the results of large amounts of research in history, personal narratives, and scientific tracts with his own experiences on a whaling ship. He wanted his book to be an allegory, full of psychological and symbolic richness.
Moby Dick Symbolism Essay Essay Research Paper
In chapter 110 Herman Melville?s Moby Dick Queequeg is getting very sick and is near death so he orders the ships carpenter to make him a coffin with a lid, in the shape of a canoe. Once the coffin/ canoe is finished Queequeg decides to live and turn the canoe/ coffin (because it is both) into a sea chest. During the next few weeks Queequeg carves little figures and symbols in the coffin/ canoe/ sea chest thus turning it in to a coffin/ canoe/ sea chest/ work of art.
Moby Dick By Herman Melville Essay Research 2
?Moby Dick? By Herman Melville Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick In the novel ?Moby Dick? by Herman Melville, the apparent themes: good vs. evil, civilized vs. uncivilized, and conventional vs. unconventional