Paper
Literary Criticisms on The Waterworks by E.L. DoctorowLiterary Criticisms (mostly book reviews) on the novel The Waterworks, by E.L. Doctorow focus on different topics. One talks of the author and his style in writing the novel. Another describes Doctorow’s love for New York city, which can be seen throughout the pages of his various novels. There is one that discusses the aspects of Utopia in the novel. Also, “The New Yorker” has an interview with him discussing his work. Ted Solotaroff, in “The Nation”, claims that this novel, which takes place in 1871, serves as a literary link between Hawthorne, Melville and Poe and the post-Civil war figures, such as Twaine, Howells and Crane. The earlier writers are characterized by dark meditative tales and romances, while the later ones wrote realistic stories. Also, the actual writings differed, in that the earlier writings were written in an intensely literary language while the later writings drop a step to incorporate the spoken idiom. Hence, The Waterworks is a link between these two contrasting styles. The narration of the story is told in a straight forward, reportorial fashion. In fact, the narration would have been described by Melville as an “inside narrative” because it’s inhabited by the mind and heart of the narrator. However, the story itself is quite imaginative and murky (Solotaroff 784, 785). One can also see the techniques of Poe in the characters of the story. Edmund Donne, the on honest detective in New York at the time is reminiscent of Poe’s M. Maupin, the first of the gentleman investigators. In this sense Doctorow’s Donne is the sleuth of the democratic future. This again ties together the writings of the pre and post Civil War eras. Dr. Sartorius also plays a role in tying in the two eras. He is a man whom personifies the search for scientific progress for the sole sake of science. He is in fact a man with one foot in his time and one foot in ours, due to his many scientific findings (Solotaroff 786-790). I, of course, do not have the necessary background to give a solid rating of this review. However, Solotaroff does seem to prove his point, and it is a novel concept. I like the idea that Doctorow uses a certain style of writing which is indicative of the time period he is writing about. Walter Goodman in “The New Leader”, chooses to comment on Doctorow’s strong love for New York. In Doctorow’s novels, mainly Ragtime, World’s Fair, and The Book of Daniel, he takes us through the history of New York City. As McIlvaine,the main character, states “The soul of the city was always my subject” (Goodman 35). One can see Doctorow’s affinity for the old city in his writings: “…all at once the block and tackle were raising the marble and granite mansions of Fifth Avenue, and burly cops were wading throughout the stopped traffic on Broadway, slapping horses on the rumps, disengaging carriage wheels, and cursing the heedless entanglements of horsecars, stages, drays, and two-in hands, by which we transported ourselves throughout the business day” (Goodman 35). Goodman goes as far as to exclaim that when Doctorow writes, “You have not seen them [the villains of the story], except in the shadows, or heard them speak, except in the voices of others…they’ve been hiding in my language” he is admitting a creative failure in not developing his villains (Goodman 34, 35). He claims that Doctorow’s most vivid writing is reserved for New York’s underside and could not be matched in all other aspects of the story (Goodman 34, 35).
It is true that Doctorow’s love of New York is easily seen throughout the novel. However, I am in total disagreement with Goodman’s closing statements, that Doctorow had failed in other aspects of the story. Specifically, the quote that Goodman brings describing the villains is misunderstood by him, I believe. I think that Doctorow kept his villains hidden on purpose. This is supposed to give the reader a sense of the events that occurred during that time period. The Tweed Ring was always hidden away, and not out for everyone to see. So too, Doctorow is presenting his villains in the same manner. The theme of a utopia is also quite prevalent in the novel. The wealthy elderly men in the novel have tried to set up a system in which they would live way past their life expectancies. However, in the words of the novel itself it was an “obverse Eden” (DeKoven 68). So the story in fact uses a “characteristic postmodernist narrative” in which it contrasts the “powerful utopian desire and at the same time representing thoroughgoing skepticism concerning the possibility of its fulfillment” (DeKoven 78). In the story, the utopia is related with the urban capitalism and political corruption of its times. As the capitalism and corruption are able to strive, the anti-Eden is able to continue its existence, but as McIlvaine and Donne uncover the corruption the anti-Eden falls apart (DeKoven 75-87). The utopia issue is a fascinating concept. In the post-Civil War era many wrote about it. However, in this story Doctorow shows us the negative aspects of it. He shows us how one cannot truly exist. Humans can only build an “obverse Eden”. And even if they can build one (be it an Eden or not) it will not continue in existence. “The New Yorker” has an actual interview with Doctorow, who comments on many of the topics brought up by the book reviews. As for the common theme of New York in his novels, he replies that it’s nothing he has done intentionaly, but rather something that naturally happened because of the fact that New York is the source of his imagination. He also says that he wrote the book to also make the readers take notice that some of the problems in the novel are no different from that of those that exist today. Some examples of this that he gave are the vagrancy of children and the constant isolation of the rich from others. Doctorow also made an interesting little comment on how he got the inspiration for the novel. He says that on one morning a fog came over the city, covering the World Trade Center, the Woolworth building…the twentieth century. And as he had said to himself “This is Melville’s New York you are looking at!” (The New Yorker 195). I found this article very interesting, in that the reader got to see what the author himself had seen of his novel. The reader gets to see his love of New York, and his throwback to Melville’s times. Although he does not specifically address his feelings on a utopia, it is quite evident from his writing what his thoughts on it are.
Другие работы по теме:
Parent Relationships Essay Research Paper In many
Parent Relationships Essay, Research Paper In many of the works of literature I have read in this particular class, I noticed that many of the characters are parents. Which leads me to ask the following questions? How are parent/child relationships represented in early literature and how do these representations compare with representations, either real or literary, in our society?
Critique On Huck Finn Essay Research Paper
Critique of Southern Depiction used in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn A common question while reading The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain is if the South was really as it was depicted in this novel. A topic that was quite common in criticisms was the portrayal of speech in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
Rimbaud Essay Research Paper Part II
Rimbaud Essay, Research Paper Part II A man so confused and confusing as Arthur Rimbaud, it is a wonder that he can even be analyzed, critiqued, and judged by his literary works. Never the less it has been done, however how accurate can they be, when even Rimbaud said in his Lettre Du Voyant that for the I is someone else.
Life Of Equiano Essay Research Paper Olaudah
Life Of Equiano Essay, Research Paper Olaudah Equiano (Gustavus Vassa) was kidnapped from his African village at the age of eleven. Shipped through the ardous “Middle Passge” of the Altantic Ocean. More than two centuries later, this work is recognized not only as one of the first works written in English by a former slave, but perhaps more important as the paradigm of the slave narrative, a new literary genre.
Epic Of Gilgamesh And The Book Of
Genesis Essay, Research Paper The Epic Of Gilgamesh is an important Middle East literary work, written in cuneiform on 12 clay tablets about 2000 BC by the oldest human author that we can name. The Epic tells the story of a great Mesopotamian king,Gilgamesh,who finds his kindered spirit and goes on a spiritual quest for understanding of death and the after life.
Literary Terms Essay Research Paper Figurative Language
Literary Terms Essay, Research Paper Figurative Language - Language using figures of speech, such as simile, hyperbole, metaphor, symbolism and personification to form imagery is figurative language. It is used to increase shock, novelty, appearance, or illustrative consequences.
Assimilation In Schools Essay Research Paper I
Assimilation In Schools Essay, Research Paper I believe that the most common of these three is assimilation. Assimilation occurs in many different ways in our schools, and it is unfortunately a part of life that we all have to learn to accept, no matter the consequences. America is more commonly known as the melting pot, one would assume automatically that the schools would consists of numerous cultures yet we still insist on forcing the American way of life onto many of our students.
The Waterworks Essay Research Paper The WaterworksOver
The Waterworks Essay, Research Paper The WaterworksOver the course of the novel, The Waterworks, by E.L. Doctorow, Doctorow uses various comparisons. Both with the charachters and plot, Doctorow uses parallelism to give the reader a deeper sence of the corruption and its eventual downfall, during the post-civil war times in New York.
Truth In The Water Works And In
Cold Blood Essay, Research Paper In E.L Doctrorow?s novel, The Waterworks, Mr McIlvaine suggests that some stories were, ?not… reportorially possible… that there are limits to words in a newspaper? (page 201). The character Mr McIlvaine like Truman Capote the author of In Cold Blood are both journalists who have found stories to which they feel newsprint, in itself would not have brought justice.
Wuthering HeightsBronte Essay Research Paper Critique Wuthering
Wuthering Heights-Bronte Essay, Research Paper Critique- Wuthering Hieghts Wuthering Hieghts is the prototype of all the gothic novels. It contains all the literary elements such as, symbolism, supernatural, and the dark solemn mood classic to all gothic novels. Although the book was well written and rich with literary devices, it did not retain my attention.
The Adventures Of Huckelberry Finn
– Critique Essay, Research Paper Critical Biography Mark Twain, the pseudonym of Samuel Clemens, was, as a literary writer, a genius. His use of numerous literary devices throughout the novel are quite unique. Examples of them would be, irony;
Comparison Essay Essay Research Paper Comparison EssayThere
Comparison Essay Essay, Research Paper Comparison Essay There are many different ways to explain the beginning and creation. Genesis and Edith Hamilton?s ?Mythology,? are two of many literary works you can find. Both show how characters were created and formed. They give detailed understanding and examples of creation.
Essay Writing Essay Research Paper email 7cdgqlinkqueensucaEssay
Essay Writing Essay, Research Paper email: 7cdg@qlink.queensu.caEssay Writing An essay is a literary composition. The purpose of a good formal essay is to try out an idea, thesis, or opinion, within the confines of a proper literary composition. To do this successfully one must know their topic, formulate a thesis, and finally write the essay.
Watership Down 2 Essay Research Paper Watership
Watership Down 2 Essay, Research Paper Watership Down as Good Literature Watership Down, by Richard Adams, is considered good literature because of the literary techniques and because of the plot. Several literary techniques are used to pull the reader in and the plot is a well constructed to hold their attention.
Macbeth Literary Essay Essay Research Paper Literary
Macbeth Literary Essay Essay, Research Paper Literary Essay – Macbeth In William Shakespeare s Macbeth, the play s central character Macbeth displays the atrocities created by greed, one of the play s many themes. The play Macbeth, illustrates to the reader how greed for power and wealth can destroy oneself and everyone in his treacherous path.
Marvell Vs Herrick Essay Research Paper Corretta
Marvell Vs Herrick Essay, Research Paper Corretta Sanders Poetry Essay Englis 1302 Instructor Mize Herrick vs. Marvell “To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time” by Rober Herrick and Andrew Marvell’s “To His Coy Mistress” have many similarities and differences. The tone of the speakers, the audience each poem is directed to, and the theme make up some of the literary elements that help fit this description.
Herrick Vs Marvell Essay Research Paper Corretta
Herrick Vs Marvell Essay, Research Paper Corretta Sanders Poetry Essay Englis 1302 Instructor Mize Herrick vs. Marvell ?To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time? by Rober Herrick and Andrew Marvell?s ?To His Coy Mistress? have many similarities and differences. The tone of the speakers, the audience each poem is directed to, and the theme make up some of the literary elements that help fit this description.
Literary Analysis Of A
& P Essay, Research Paper Literary Analysis of A & P The short story A & P, by John Updike, can be broken down into a number of components, which include characters, setting, plot, point of view, and the theme.
Geographical Knowledge Essay Research Paper
Not overly impressive knowledge ? many geographical books came to aid literary understanding. ? Map most important for officials to conceptualise land on their borders etc.? Theodosius II orders map of the world. ?
E.L. Doctorow
’s The Waterworks Essay, Research Paper CITY OF THE LIVING DEAD E.L. Doctorow’s The Waterworks mixes a bizarre horror story with the sights and sounds of 19th-century Manhattan
Visions And Voices Essay Research Paper Visions
Visions And Voices Essay, Research Paper Visions and Voices The biographical film of Langston Hughes is both informative and entertaining. It approaches Hughes s life with insightful observations from the people that personally knew him. The film goes into detail on his family background and early life before his poetic success, and continues through his life in Harlem, his literary achievements, and legacy.
Spring Essay Research Paper George Manley Hopkin
Spring Essay, Research Paper George Manley Hopkin s poem, Spring is a sonnet. The poem deals with the rebirth of a soul. Hopkins writes his poem about the season of spring. Within the poem, Hopkins uses imagery as well as literary devices to portray his meaning.
Metaphysis Essay Research Paper Hello I
Metaphysis Essay, Research Paper : Hello: : I need help, I have somes question would help me. 1. do the criticisms that hume makes of Design Arguments all apply to Thomas’ Teleological Argument?
HG Wells Essay Research Paper HG Wells
H.G. Wells Essay, Research Paper H.G. Wells writings were influenced by things such as Darwinism, the first World War, and involved extensive predictions, futuristic inventions, and humor.
Vision Essay Research Paper Literary analysis Vision
Vision Essay, Research Paper Literary analysis: Vision Out of the Corner of One Eye. The main character of “Vision out of the Corner of One Eye “, a short story by Luisa Valezuela, goes through a complete one hundred-eighty degree change over the course of the story.
Literary Techniques Essay Research Paper 1 ImageryImagery
Literary Techniques Essay, Research Paper 1. Imagery Imagery is one of the main techniques used through out Waiting for Godot. The first image that appears is a tree. This simple tree in the middle of a desolate setting alludes to many symbols. To start, the tree represents the Tree of Knowledge, for it creates a reverse Garden of Eden.
William Shakespeares Tragedy Hamlet Essay Research Paper
William Shakespeare?s tragedy Hamlet has been one of the most controversial works of all time. There have been so many criticisms on this book and opinions on what the main theme behind the play is. Many themes have been proposed such as revenge, sex, reality and jealousy. I myself believe that there is no one theme behind Hamlet and it is a complex with work with many complex ideas behind it.
Symbolism Essay Research Paper In the novel
Symbolism Essay, Research Paper In the novel To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee, symbolism is the key literary device. Symbolism is when one thing stands for another. It is a sin to kill a mockingbird. This is because mockingbirds do not harm anything, they just sing to you. The mockingbird symbolized both Tom Robinson and Boo Radley.
Shakespeare Authorship Essay Research Paper No discussion
Shakespeare Authorship Essay, Research Paper No discussion group on Shakespeare would be complete without someone discussing whether the Stratford man really whote all the works attributed to Shakespeare. Some claim Christopher Marlowe to be the author; others, Francis Bacon; and several web pages are devoted to the premise that Count Edward deVere wrote these books.
Great Gatsby 5 Essay Research Paper Fitzgerald
Great Gatsby 5 Essay, Research Paper Fitzgerald s Masterpiece F. Scott Fitzgerald s The Great Gatsby is an enchanting novel, which tells an exquisite story through various techniques characteristic of a gifted author. The story has elements of deceit, high hopes, fallen dreams, and false intentions which make it thrilling to read.
Huck Essay Research Paper Elements of Racism
Huck Essay, Research Paper Elements of Racism in Huckleberry Finn Despite all the criticism, of racism and other questionable material for young readers, Mark Twain?s The Adventure of Huckleberry Finn is a superbly written novel, which in the opinion of this reviewer should not be remove the literary cannon.
Transendentalism In Emerson
’s Poetry Essay, Research Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson always considered himself a poet despite his many volumes of Essays and other works. Therefore this essay only deals with Emerson s poetry. Emerson told a lot with his prose but he told more with his poetry. Often, fundamental aspects of transcendentalism are shown through literary devices in his poetry.