, Research Paper
Jo Hawkins
Assessment 2 Semester 1 1998
?A playwright with a social conscience?.
Analyse the ways in which Arthur Miller presents Eddie Carboni as a victim of
Brooklyn in the 1950?s.
In his play, A View From the Bridge ,(1955), Arthur Miller (1915-) portrays the
protagonist, Eddie Carboni, an uneducated Italian-American longshoreman, as a victim of
American society in the 1950?s. Set in Red Hook, an industrial area of Brooklyn, Eddie
lives with his wife, Beatrice and her sister?s child, his niece Catherine, of whom he is
unwittingly over protective. Life is hard but even until the arrival of two illegal
immigrants, Marco and Rodolpho, who are relatives of Beatrice. When Rodolpho forms a
relationship with Catherine, Eddie is threatened in a way he can neither articulate nor even
acknowledge. He does his best to destroy this relationship in order to preserve his
unchanging lifestyle and when his attempts fail, he calls the immigration department and
turns informer. When challenged by Marco, Eddie fights to uphold his honour and is
killed. Through this conflict, Miller explores the issues of gender roles and justice within
American Society. This is achieved by the skilful use of theatrical conventions including
character and setting. As Miller?s succeeds in presenting Eddie Carboni as a victim of
society he proves himself to be ?a playwright with a social conscience?
Miller explores the changing gender roles in Brooklyn of the 1950?s, detailing the demise
of patriarchy and Eddie?s reactions to this dramatic social change. This confusion,
accentuated by the arrival of two submarines, Marco and Rodolpho, serves to highlight
the underlying sexual tension between Eddie, Catherine and Beatrice. This tension is
present from the beginning of the play as Eddie laments, ?you?re walking? wavy? to
Catherine , acknowledging her sexuality , his jealousy apparent as he voices his
disapproval. The admission of Catherine into the work force is hard for Eddie to accept
as her maturity becomes harder for him to ignore. His pride also begins to faulter as he
learns that Catherine earns more money in her first year as a stenographer, than he does as
an experienced longshoreman. Beatrice recognises Eddies hidden desires before he or
Catherine are aware of it, this becoming apparent in the first act as she snaps at Eddie ?I?m
not mad, you?re the one is mad?. With the arrival of Marco and Rodolpho, Eddie
struggles to uphold his position as head of the family. Rodolpho possesses an unconscious
femininity that patriarchal Eddie does not understand and his developing relationship with
Catherine causes much jealousy and resentment. As Eddie struggles with his own gender
identity and strong feelings for Catherine he turns to the law in an attempt to find justice.
The differences between justice and American law is explored by Miller through Eddie?s
moral and social conflict as he tries desperately to stop Catherine from marrying
Rodolpho. The play begins with an exposition from Alferi, a middle class lawyer who acts
as an impartial commentator for most of the play. Alferi connotes that the
American-Italian population has a disrespect for written law with roots that spread deep
into their Italian ancestry. Consequently, he acknowledges their own system of family law
and it?s Mafia parallels. Miller recognises the strength and validity of family law, the
nature of which remained incomprehensible to American society. The differences between
the two cultures are highlighted and criticised as Alferi reminisces, ?Oh, there were many
here who were justly shot by unjust men.? Eddie, blinded by a passion for Catherine he
cannot understand, does not recognise the differences between these cultures and alienates
himself from both of them by refusing to compromise between both. Informing the
immigration bureau of Rodolpho and Marco was not an illegal act , Miller simply presents
it as immoral. Eddie becomes a victim of both societies as he attempts to conform to
both.
Miller uses the other characters to provide drama and further the plot, limiting their
development as complex individuals. In this way, Miller?s forms a true portrait of Eddie
as the betrayer, marginalising those whom he betrays. It is through Beatrice that Eddie?s
desires become articulated and Catherine becomes aware of the reasons he resents
Rodolpho. Catherine?s own loyalty for Eddie makes her feel guilty for loving Rodolpho
and when she recognises his misplaced passion she gains enough strength to leave. Eddie
blames the immigrants for the dramatic social change he experiences, not recognising that
they were only the catalyst. He never accepts them and therefore cannot understand them,
a folly that leads to the eventual communication breakdown. Rodolpho is well liked by all
who know him therefore Eddie?s rejection of him is considered unjust and emphasises his
apparent jealousy. Marco, however is very quiet and restrained until the plays tragic
conclusion in which he makes damning accusations of Eddie in front of the whole
Neighbourhood when he shouts, ?That one! I accuse that one!?. The strength of this
words have more impact as they contrast Marcos usual character and indicate his great
anger, justifying his later vendetta. When Eddie refuses to conform to unwritten civil law
he is victimised by his own family and those he had helped in the past.
Setting is used in A View from the Bridge to create contrast between the American and
Italian cultures and to make the themes more potent. Rodolpho does not conform to the
male Italian stereotype and is therefore unacceptable to Eddie. As a blonde man, set in a
tight knit society of Italian-Americans he serves as an example of the new generation of
men more in touch with their feminine sides and less dependent on patriarchy as a control
mechanism. On arrival into America, Rodolpho and Marco are awed by Eddie and
Beatrice?s ?clean, sparse, homely? workers flat. The audience is therefore sympathetic to
these immigrants and their predicament. The fact that they had broken United States law
is marginalised to such an extent that the conservative American audience of the 1950?s
that Miller wrote his play for would reject their own morality, at least for the plays
duration. By encouraging the audience to disregard preconditioned moral standards
concerning illegal immigrants in America, Miller encourages them to sympathise with
Eddie whose own morality is likewise divided.
Miller explores the themes of changing gender roles and justice through victimisation of
the central protagonist, Eddie Carboni due to his moral dilemma. Theatrical conventions
used in his portray include setting and character development. The introduction of the
two illegal immigrants, Rodolpho and Marco proves to be the catalyst for the revelation of
the underlying sexual tension between Eddie, his wife and his niece. The tension is
accentuated as Eddie?s position as head of the household is threatened by Catherine?s new
job and the success of the two submarines in conforming to American society. The
differences between family law and the constitutional law are also explored as it is Eddies
refusal to obey both and make a compromise that causes his own downfall. Miller never
truly develops the other characters into complex individuals but uses them to futher Eddies
own development. The setting is used to contrast the two cultures and the two types of
justice, promoting audience sympathy for the two immigrants Rodolpho and Marco which
leads to a greater understanding of Eddies morality. By gaining audience sympathy and
positioning them to see an different aspect of Brooklyn in the 1950?s, Miller displays a
heightened social conscience as he presents Eddie Carboni as victim of his own rigid
morality.
Другие работы по теме:
Analysis Of Veiwpoints On Tragedy Essay Research
Paper The question of what defines tragedy has been an issue addressed by several different literary minds since the day of Aristotle, the first person to define tragedy. When Aristotle first defined tragedy he believed tragedy was something reserved for a person of noble stature. He said this person was eventually brought down by a tragic flaw, hence the term tragedy.
Obsenity And The Law Essay Research Paper
The First Amendment protects our freedom of speech, however there are a few exceptions. Obscenity is one of these exceptions and is a form of unprotected speech. The Supreme Court has repeatedly held the view that obscenity is not a First Amendment right, however the definition of obscenity is vague and has caused many debates.
Authur Miller Essay Research Paper With the
Authur Miller Essay, Research Paper With the Death of a Salesman during the winter of 1949 on Broadway, Arthur Miller began to live as a playwright who has since been called one of this century’s three great American dramatists. He has also written other powerful, often mind-altering plays: The Crucible, A View from the Bridge, A Memory of Two Mondays, After the Fall, Incident at Vichy, and The Price.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper The production
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper The production of THE CRUCIBLE by Arthur Miller had many high points of suspense and action. Mainly involving the trials and tribulations of John Proctor. Mr. Philip G. Hill’s view of Miller’s THE CRUCIBLE is strong; emotion filled and does an excellent job of summarizing this classic production.
The Crucible My Point Of View Essay
, Research Paper The Crucible by Arthur Miller was written during the early 1950s at the time of Senator Joseph McCarthy’s House Un-American Activities Committee hearings on the infiltration of Communism in the United States and the loyalty to democracy of many prominent U.S. citizens. The McCarthy hearings pitted artists and performers against each other as they were called to testify about their own loyalty and what they knew about the loyalty of others.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper Abigail Williams
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper Abigail Williams portrays Miller’s affair with the inner voice and guilt. Arthur Miller saw guilt as a habit of mind capable of being over come. It is seen in Abigail who exhausts her conscience to get herself out of trouble by accusing Tituba, and then to seek revenge on the adults who make her life miserable.
Glen Miller Essay Research Paper When Glenn
Glen Miller Essay, Research Paper When Glenn Miller was born on March 1, 1904 in Clarinda, Iowa, he was to become one of the greatest musician, and songwriters in all of history. He was born into a friendly, caring, middle-class family. His family greatly supported all of his
Crucible By Miller Essay Research Paper John
Crucible By Miller Essay, Research Paper John Proctor was the main character in the play The Crucible, written by Arthur Miller. Will the truth set you free? In Proctor?s case of choosing truth over
Crucible 2 Essay Research Paper It is
Crucible 2 Essay, Research Paper It is more noble to die with integrity than it is to compromise one s principle in order to live. —– Danforth: I say, will you confess yourself, Goody Nurse? Rebecca: Why it is a lie, it is a lie;; how may I damn myself? I cannot, I cannot. —–Arthur Miller s, The Crucible, was a play with many themes.
Crucible Salem Episode Essay Research Paper The
Crucible Salem Episode Essay, Research Paper The Crucible The Salem witch-trials, are an historic event that occurred during the Puritan era. It was the witch-trials that decided the fate of so many of the
The Crucible Essay Research Paper ARTHUR MILLER 2
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper ARTHUR MILLER, SALEM AND COMMUNISM In this paper I am going to talk about the relations between the Salem witch trials and the Cold War. Covering this with evidence and facts about the theme. I think that this is a fair comparison and is very interesting what they have in common.
Review For A Canticle For Leibowitz Essay
, Research Paper A Canticle for Leibowitz Walter M. Miller, Jr.’s A Canticle for Leibowitz treats religion very differently than does most science fiction. Miller’s Brother Francis is charged with discovering the meaning of faith and God in the wake of total nuclear destruction. The particular religion extent in Miller’s future is the venerable Catholic Church, an institution that has survived near-annihilation before.
Saving Private Ryan Essay Research Paper Captain
Saving Private Ryan Essay, Research Paper Captain John H. Miller John H. Miller, played by Tom hanks in the outstanding Spealburg production Saving Private Ryan, was the captain of the American Army. Miller is truly a complex and mysterious character portrayed by his unwillingness and uneasiness when discussing his past.
After The Fall Essay Research Paper After
After The Fall Essay, Research Paper After the Fall Arthur Miller has written many great plays in his life, such as A View from the Bridge ,Death of a Salesman ,The Misfits, The Crucible, and After the Fall. Out of all his
Willy Loman The Modern Tragic Hero Essay
, Research Paper A tragic hero is known to be the protagonist who causes his own downfall, is seen as greater than the average man, and is aware of his misfortune. In Arthur Miller?s Death of
Deciet And Trickery In The Canterbury Tales
Essay, Research Paper Deceit and Trickery in the Canterbury Tales In Geoffrey Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales, the reader is introduced to the tales of the miller and the reeve, which are both written in the fabliau genre. Both the Miller’s Tale and the Reeve’s Tale demonstrate quick, snappy endings that entertain the audience.
Interesting Facts Of The Crucible Essay Research
Paper Pennee Eagatatt November 22, 2000 English III The Interesting Facts of The Crucible Was The Crucible, by Arthur Miller, just an “irrational fear?” (Arthur Miller’s The Crucible: Fact & Fiction Par.1). The panic of Communism during the Cold War and Senator Joseph McCarthy’s anti-communist hearings on February 3, 1953 led to this “irrational fear.” There are several major differences from the true version of the story and Miller’s version.
Daisy Miller Essay Research Paper I have
Daisy Miller Essay, Research Paper I have noticed several postings I would like to comment on in addition to adding my own little spin to this discussion. I believe Daisy was simply acting
Arthur Miller And View From The Bridge
Essay, Research Paper My initial reaction to the play was absolutely hideous, and my malcontent was vibrant. I felt that reading A View From The Bridge was a tedious waste of time
A View From A Bridge Essay Research
Paper When Arthur Miller writes a play, he tries to develop a modern tragedy. Miller successfully depicts a tragic hero in his play A View From the Bridge in the character Eddie Carbone.
The True Authority
– The Crucible Essay, Research Paper Picture what it would be like to go back in the days of the Puritans. The people you’d expect to see would be kind, honest, religious and in every way ethical because that’s how a Puritan should be. Although there were many good Puritans, you’d turn around to see that some were deceiving, vindictive, dishonest, and disloyal.
Love In The Canterbury Tales Essay Research
Paper Henry Louis Mencken stated, “Love: The delusion that one woman differs from another.” This motto rings true for the travellers that Geoffrey Chaucer accompanied on the pilgrimage in The
View From The Bridge Critique Essay Research
Paper Arthur Miller s A View from the Bridge is a modern tragedy set in 1950 s Brooklyn about a man s obsession with his niece, and what that obsession ultimately brings about. Eddie Carbone, the protagonist of the play also happens to be the antagonist, because he ultimately is fighting against himself with his desires for his niece.
Miller Spring Essay Essay Research Paper Miller
Miller Spring Essay Essay, Research Paper Miller Springs Essay My science class and I went to Miller Springs to learn about sediments and nature a few days ago. The good and bad sides of the trip I will explain below.
Captain John Miller Essay Research Paper Captain
Captain John Miller Essay, Research Paper Captain John Miller The character Captain John Miller in the movie “Saving Private Ryan” played by Tom Hanks represents the ideal soldier in a time of great despair. He shows courage and bravery throughout every scene. His troops will not disagree with him because of the respect he has for his authority; thus they have the utmost respect for him.
What Is Tragedy Essay Research Paper Tragedy
What Is Tragedy? Essay, Research Paper Tragedy is defined as an extremely sad or fatal event or course of events; a story, play, or other literary work which arouses terror or pity by a series of misfortunes or sad events. The first important tragedies appeared in ancient Greece in the 400s B.C. with works of Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides.
Tragedy And The Common Man Essay Research
Paper In Arthur Miller?s 1949 essay, “Tragedy and the Common Man,” Miller began by saying, “In this age few tragedies are written.” This particular essay was published in the New York Times, was also the preface that was prepared for “Death of a Salesman” in 1949. Before Miller?s “Death of a Salesman,” there was only one type of tragedy?that which fit Aristotle?s definition.
Miller VsCalifornia Essay Research Paper Miller v
Miller Vs.California Essay, Research Paper Miller v. California A recurring problem that we have here in the United States is how to define obscenity and to answer the question is the material containing the obscenity protected the First Amendment, stating the freedom of the press provision. Finally one day the Supreme Courts ruled that obscene works are not protect by the constitution but that ruling only caused more problems.
Arthur Miller Essay Research Paper Arthur MillerArthur
Arthur Miller Essay, Research Paper Arthur Miller Arthur Miller found himself one day writing a play somehow based on a true story in his youth. With this he adds suspencion to the play, by adding creative scenes where his style is shown. After the play’s success, Miller’s mother Augusta, found an early manuscript called, “In Memorian”.In Memorian, was a forgotten autobiographical fragment that Miller had written when he was around 17 years old.
The Crucible Book Review Essay Research Paper
Arthur Miller, the son of a wealthy father who lost all of his money in the crash of 1929, quit school as a young child to support his family by holding several different odd jobs. From these jobs, Miller learned about the life of a simple man of America who became the highlight of many of his works (View from the Bridge, The Misfits).
Crucible Evaluation Essay Research Paper The Crucible
Crucible Evaluation Essay, Research Paper The Crucible Evaluation When Arthur Miller sat down to write the Crucible, it is obvious he took many things into account. The presentation of the book is very well thought out. As for the history aspect of the book, it is obvious that he did a lot of research even though there are still some discrepancies.
Crucible Essay Research Paper
Cunningham-1 David Cunningham English III-AP November 10, 1999 The Crucible Comparison Essay The Crucible is a drama, based on the Salem Witch Trials and reconstructed by Arthur