’s Reponse To Mather Essay, Research Paper
Sewall s Response to Mather s The Negro Christianized
Cotton Mather and Samuel Sewall clearly disagree on the legality of slavery. For Sewall, it is most important that slaves be given the same freedom as all men; for Mather, it is most important that slaves be Christianized and given the opportunity of eternal light through the grace of Jesus Christ. Christianizing slaves, according to Sewall, neither makes possession of them legal nor improves the providence of their masters.
Mather indicates that Christianization of African slaves will accrue benefits to their masters in the next life while Sewall believes that Christianization ameliorates the possibility of their masters receiving God s grace. According to Mather, You deny your Master in Heaven, if you do nothing to bring your Servants unto the Knowledge and Service of that glorious Master (Mather, 335). So to Mather, a master disserves not only God and Africans but also himself by missing the opportunity to Christianize his slaves. On the other hand, Sewall writes, The extraordinary and comprehensive Benefit accruing to the Church of God, and to Joseph personally, did not rectify his brethrens Sale of him (Sewall, 326). Essentially, Sewall believes that any attempt to improve the quality of a slave s life (Christianization or otherwise) does not outweigh the immorality of their purchase and possession. For he that shall in this case plead Alteration of Property, seems to have forfeited a great part of his own claim to Humanity (Sewall, 324). Consequently, owners, in Sewall s view, jeopardize their own salvation ( Humanity ) by owning slaves.
In addition, Sewall feels that it is wrong to separate Africans from their native land and that attempts at Christianization, if any, should occur in Africa; however, Mather writes that Christianization offers both removal from their savage land and salvation. To Christianize them aright, will be to fill them with all Goodness. Christianity is nothing but the very Mass of Universal Goodness (Mather, 335). In addition to this Goodness , of course, Mather believes that Christianization offers the hope of salvation to Africans. Sewall does not necessarily disagree with Mather s position on the benefits of Christianization; however, Christians should carry it to all the World, as the Israelites were to carry it towards another (Sewall, 327). In other words, Christians of the New World and Europe, in order to truly improve the situation of native Africans, should offer Christianity to Africans in their native lands. And for men obstinately to persist in holding their Neighbors and Brethren under the Rigor of perpetual Bondage, seems to be no proper way of gaining Assurance that God has given them Spiritual Freedom (Sewall, 327). Thus, the Christianization of Africans in America does not offer hope of salvation to native Africans as they are still bound to their masters and not to God.
Moreover, Mather believes that the law of Christianity allows for slavery, while Sewall argues that the Bible offers evidence to the contrary. Mather would like the reader to assume that biblical justification for slavery exists. He writes, Suppose these Wretched Negroes, to be the Offspring of Cham (which yet is not so very certain,) (Mather, 334). This is Mather s method of avoiding the topic of biblical justification entirely. This is in stark contrast to Sewall who writes, But it is possible that by cursory reading, this Text may have been mistaken. For Canaan is the Person Cursed three times over without the mentioning of Cham (Sewall, 325). Sewall simply states that those condemned to slavery are not the Africans that men enslave today. Later in his piece, Mather writes, What Law is it, that Sets the Baptized Slave at Liberty? Not the Law of Christianity: that allows of Slavery; only it wonderfully Dulcifies, and Mollifies, and Moderates the Circumstances of it (Mather, 336). According to Sewall, It is most certain that all Men, as they are the Sons of Adam, are Coheirs; and have equal Right unto Liberty, and all other outward Comforts of Life (Sewall, 324). So Sewall clearly believes that Africans should not be enslaved. He offers further evidence when he writes, It is Observable that the Israelites were strictly forbidden the buying, or selling one another for Slaves (Sewall, 326). As the Israelites were all brothers in God s eyes, and Psal. 115. 16 offers clear evidence of the brotherhood of all men, the purchasers of slaves of the New World are clearly violating God s law by buying their own brothers according to Sewall (Sewall, 324).
Christianizing slaves, according to Sewall, neither makes possession of them legal nor improves the providence of their masters. Sewall would have responded by noting Mather s avoidance of the legality of slavery. I would argue that Mather is the one who Dulcifies, and Mollifies, and Moderates the issue of biblical justification by refusing to answer Sewall s specific arguments against slavery in his piece. Remember that Ames writes slavery with the master as agent in general, thwarts the generall Canon, What you would have men do unto you, even so do unto them: Matth. 17.12. 3.3 (Sewall, 327). In Sewall s opinion, by violating the Golden Rule, slave owners clearly place themselves in a precarious position.
Works Cited
Mather, Cotton. The Negro Christianized. The Literatures of Colonial America. Ed. Susan Castillo and Ivy Schweitzer. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishers, 2001. 333-37.
Sewall, Samuel. The Selling of Joseph. The Literatures of Colonial America. Ed. Susan Castillo and Ivy Schweitzer. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishers, 2001. 323-27.
Другие работы по теме:
Literature and theatre of the USA
The literature of the USA: colonial literature, unique american style and lyric. Realism, Twain, and James, postmodernism, modern humorist literature. Postcolonial poetry, Whitman and Dickinson, modernism. Proto-comic books. Superman and superheroes.
American Literature books summary
We are lucky to present you Short Summaries of the Books You Have to Read in the course of the English Literature by Stulov Thursday, April 3 2002 Contents AN OVERVIEW OF THE DEVELOPMENT FROM THE 17TH TO THE 20TH CENTURIES 2
Salem Witch Trials Essay Research Paper Many
Salem Witch Trials Essay, Research Paper Many of the American colonists brought with them from Europe a belief in witches and the devil. During the seventeenth century, people were executed for being witches and follower of Satan. Most of these executions were performed in Salem, Massachusetts in 1692.
Analysis Of Veiwpoints On Tragedy Essay Research
Paper The question of what defines tragedy has been an issue addressed by several different literary minds since the day of Aristotle, the first person to define tragedy. When Aristotle first defined tragedy he believed tragedy was something reserved for a person of noble stature. He said this person was eventually brought down by a tragic flaw, hence the term tragedy.
Louisa May Alcott Essay Research Paper Louisa
Louisa May Alcott Essay, Research Paper Louisa was born in Germantown, Pennsylvania on November 29, 1832. Her parents, Bronson and Abigail May Alcott decided to name their second daughter after her aunt, Louisa May Green. Her father was a noted New England Transcendentalist philosopher and educator who worked only irregularly throughout Louisa May’s life.
Elizabeth I 2
Elizabeth I & Marlowe’s Faustus – Pragmatism And Lasting Accomplishment Vs. Impetousity And Fleeting Essay, Research Paper Henryk Jaronowski English 9H, 7
Salem Witch Trials Essay Research Paper Historical
Salem Witch Trials Essay, Research Paper Historical Overview and Brief Analysis Amidst millenniums of debate, argument, and conflict concerning racial prejudges and those issues which surround their implementation, there has consistently existed a certain historical prejudice regarding various stereotypical ideas for those things which people can not understand or explain logically.
Tradgedy 2 Essay Research Paper Foolis HeartsTragedy
Tradgedy 2 Essay, Research Paper Foolis Hearts Tragedy Essay Oedipus Rex, Macbeth, The Great Gatsby Throughout literary history tragic heroes have managed to deceive everyone but themselves. The tragedy lies in the fact that the they believe they can fool themselves as well as everyone else. Tragic heroes always seem to bring their own downfall upon themselves just when the believe they are invincible.
Evolution Vs Creation Essay Research Paper Stephen
Evolution Vs. Creation Essay, Research Paper Stephen A. Gauthier Evolutionism and Creationism It has been said that the major difference between humans and beasts is that humans are curious about their beginnings. They question where they came from and how they ended up where they are. There are several theories as to how humans came to exist, but none have created such a controversy as the debate between evolutionism and creationism.
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper Richard B
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper Richard B. Sewall claims that Melville’s vision in Moby-Dick is “a cruel reminder of the original terror,” in which all moral judgements are accompanied by tensions, paradoxes, and ambiguities. In response to this statement, I agree that all moral judgements are fraught with tensions, paradoxes and ambiguities.
Henry David Thoreau Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry David Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau was a man who expressed his beliefs of society, government, and mankind while living under his own self-criticism. Thoreau believed he had many
Emily Dickenson Essay Research Paper The concept
Emily Dickenson Essay, Research Paper The concept of death to some is a sad incident. For Emily Dickenson it was the only way to escape her feelings of hurt, loss and lonliness. And based on her religous beliefs, Emily found in spirituaul death the transfer to the perfect world so she could retrieve her lover, liberty, and happiness.
The First Frontier Life In Colonial
America Essay, Research Paper The First Frontier: Life in Colonial America John C. Miller Lanham: University Press of America, 1966. In his historical novel The First Frontier: Life in Colonial America John C. Miller tells of the taming of a harsh frontier. He tackles such topics as Puritans versus Quakers, southern plantation versus cities, and everyday life in the colonial period.
Emily DickinsonWhy She Is An American Poet
Essay, Research Paper Emily Dickinson, a creative poet during the mid-nineteenth century, wrote what many consider to be truly American poetry. To understand why Dickinson is considered a
Salem Witch Trials Essay Research Paper In
Salem Witch Trials Essay, Research Paper In the winter of 1692, a wave of witch hysteria surrounded the settlement of Salem Village in the Massachusetts Bay Colony. The accusations began with two little girls who were acting strangely. There are many underlying factors to why these thoughts of witchcraft started coming about.
The Life Of Emily Dickinson Essay Research
Paper The Life of Emily Dickinson Although she lived a seemingly secluded life, Emily Dickinson’s many encounters with death influenced many of her poems and letters. Perhaps one of
Emily Dickinson Analysis Of Works Essay Research
Paper Literary Criticisms of Emily Dickinson’s PoetryThroughout Emily Dickinson’s poetry there are three main themes that she addresses: death, love, and nature; as well as the impact of “the word”. When discussing these themes she followed her lifestyle and broke away from traditional forms of writing and wrote with an intense energy and complexity never seen before and rarely seen today.
Salem Witch Trials
– The Crucible Essay, Research Paper Because I’ve been working with the materials of the Salem Witch Trails of 1692 for so long, many people have asked me if I’ve seen the play or film The Crucible, and what I think of it. Miller created works of art, inspired by the actual events for the artistic/political purposes Miller intended: first produced on Broadway on January 22, 1953, it was in response to the panic caused by irrational fear of Communism during the Cold War which ultimately resulted in the anti-Communist hearings by Senator Joseph McCarthy which started on Feb. 3, 1953.* In Miller’s tales (there are slight differences, which I won’t bother to get into unless it’s a major difference), a lovelorn teenager is spurned by the married man she loves, and in her revenge, she fans a whole community into a blood-lust frenzy.
Race Relations In The US Essay Research
Paper I’ve discovered the real roots of America these past few days and decided that writing about it was better than killing an innocent victim to soothe the hostility I feel towards my heritage. I picked up
Colonial Times Essay Research Paper The colonial
Colonial Times Essay, Research Paper The colonial period was A time of much change, as is the modern period. Many people viewed things differently in the colonial period than they do today. The people of the colonial period had much more traditional values than the people of today.The people of the colonial period thought of religion much more sternly than I do.
Untitled Essay Research Paper BODYINTRODUCTION TO EVOLUTION
Untitled Essay, Research Paper BODYINTRODUCTION TO EVOLUTION What is Evolution? Evolution is the process by which all living thingshave developed from primitive organisms through changes occurring overbillions of years, a process that includes all animals and plants. Exactly howevolution occurs is still a matter of debate, but there are many differenttheories and that it occurs is a scientific fact.
What Is Tragedy Essay Research Paper Tragedy
What Is Tragedy? Essay, Research Paper Tragedy is defined as an extremely sad or fatal event or course of events; a story, play, or other literary work which arouses terror or pity by a series of misfortunes or sad events. The first important tragedies appeared in ancient Greece in the 400s B.C. with works of Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides.
Theory Of Evolution Essay Research Paper Theory
Theory Of Evolution Essay, Research Paper Theory of Evolution What is Evolution? Evolution is the process by which all living thingshave developed from primitive organisms through changes occurring overbillions of years, a process that includes all animals and plants. Exactly howevolution occurs is still a matter of debate, but there are many differenttheories and that it occurs is a scientific fact.
Another Salem Witch Trials Essay Research Paper
The Salem witchcraft trials of 1692, which resulted in 19 executions, and 150 accusations of witchcraft, are one of the historical events almost everyone has heard of. They began when three
Theodore Roosevelt Essay Research Paper The second
Theodore Roosevelt Essay, Research Paper The second of the four children of Theodore Roosevelt, Sr. and Martha Bulloch Roosevelt, Theodore Roosevelt (hereafter TR), was nicknamed “Teedie”. TR suffered from asthma and terrible nearsightedness, conditions which his father urged him to supercede by saying, “You have the mind, but not the body; you must make your body.” To help his son, Theodore Sr. built a gym at their home where “Teedie” developed a constitution, which would later be referred to as “strong as a Bull Moose”.
Literature in New England
Pilgrims, puritans in new England: historical, descriptive writers. The new England clergy: Theology in New England. The first half of the century, the personal touch. The revolutionary period. Writers of new York and Pennsylvania. Poetry, South, North.