Chinese Room Essay, Research Paper
Through the use of his famous Chinese room scenario, John R. Searle tries to prove there is no way artificial intelligence can exist. This means that machines do not posses minds.
The debate between those who are in favor of strong and weak artificial intelligence (AI) is directly related to the philosophy of mind. The claim of weak AI is that it is possible to run a program on a machine, which will behave as if it were a thinking thing. Believers of strong AI say that it is possible to create a program running on a machine which not only behaves as if it were thinking, but does actually think. Strong AI followers argue that an installation of a computer program is considered a mind as real as the mind of any human.
Searle’s claim is that any installation of a program is an operation. The lack of meaning, he states, means that the computer program does not have true understanding and is not truly thinking, it is simply computing and processing symbols. He presents this argument by using his famous Chinese room. Searle begins by talking about a newer computer program written by Roger Schank, which he uses to answer, or at least try to answer, questions about a problem it has been given. Searle remarks that this choice of program is not directly relevant to his argument, but is merely an example. He then suggests that instead of running the program on a machine, that it can be represented as a series of written instructions that he could follow. To make sure he is following the instructions, everything is expressed in Chinese, since Searle did not know the language.
The complete situation has Searle in a room where Chinese symbols are passed through one slot of the room along with English instructions on how to read them. He then computes them and passes out the meanings through the second slot in the room. Searle’s actions resemble Schank’s program. The input is the Chinese and instructions, and the output is the translated story. Since he is the installation of the computer program, it shows the reader how other installations, such as a program running on a machine, must lack the same understanding of Chinese and of the stories as he does.
The Chinese room offers a good starting point for thinking about the claims of strong AI, but it does not completely prove they are false. It is not at all surprising that Searle running the program does not show understanding of Chinese since the program, in any of its installations, never seems to understand it in the first place. The program was only a simple story, which could give answers to certain questions, but also made no attempt to ever really understand the story. Searle shows no proof that his theory can pass the Turing test.
If the program were really able to pass the Turing test, Searle’s scenario would be different than the program. A machine may take a fraction of the time to compute a problem compared to the length of time Searle would need to complete the same thing. The main thing to keep in mind here is that Searle stated in his first example that it is clear he has no understanding of Chinese. In reality, the actions of Searle must be complex. Searle avoids any comeback remarks that the robot may have. It claims that Searle has no understanding of Chinese, whereas the machine, when considered a whole, does. The robot argues that if the program were installed in the machine, it would be able to carry out true understanding of it.
The Chinese room example neither disproves the claims of AI, nor does it prove that Searle’s conclusions cannot be drawn from a different argument. He is still fixed upon his view. He still believes that the installation of a program alone can never be enough to generate true understanding. The Chinese room leaves any support to this view up for grabs. I think machine don’t have minds. They are only as smart as the person who programs them, though they may be able to calculate tasks at a faster rate. The only type of mind a machine has is a human-implied mind given to it from the creator of the program.
Другие работы по теме:
Your Smile Essay Research Paper I see
Your Smile Essay, Research Paper I see you across the room, Laughing with your friends. Not noticing me watching you, Staring at you. Not noticing me. I?ve grown to the point of obsession
Poem Du Fu Essay Research Paper It
Poem: Du Fu Essay, Research Paper It is often contended that the greatest and most important works of Chinese poetry was produced during the Tang dynasty. Many critics consider Du Fu to be the greatest Chinese poet during the dynasty and quite possibly of all time. His unique style and mastery of Chinese language is unparalleled.
Visual Analysis Essay Research Paper A Tour
Visual Analysis Essay, Research Paper A Tour of the restaurantOn a casual day drive through Old Town Chicago, people may drive by a restaurant with a big sign with two large strange Chinese looking characters and on the bottom says Kamehachi. As one look more closely, the restaurant is pact with people. The valet parking is busy running around, and a line of people waiting to get in.
Philosophy Of Mind Essay Research Paper In
Philosophy Of Mind Essay, Research Paper In this paper I plan to show that Searle is correct in claiming that his Chinese Room Analogy shows that any Turing machine simulation of human understanding of
Creative Writing Essay Research Paper When I
Creative Writing Essay, Research Paper When I first stepped into this class I did not know what to expect. It was the second class of my first day in Brooklyn College. When I came in the room I wanted to sit in the front of the room so that I would be able to concentrate on the teacher, but the first row was already fill up so I took the second best thing and sat in the second row.
Iron And Silk Essay Research Paper In
Iron And Silk Essay, Research Paper In the book Iron and Silk, written by Mark Salzman as his point of view, is all about China. Throughout the book, Mark experiences many differences between the Chinese culture and his own American culture. Chinese people want to save face by doing some weird things. First example, kissing in China over the age of two is embarrassing for both children and parents.
China 5 Essay Research Paper Commentary on
China 5 Essay, Research Paper Commentary on China The press in China has come a long way since the CCP took over the Chinese government in 1949 and it will continue to expand it’s freedom as we go into the 21st century. They were denied the right of freedom of speech and freedom of the press for all those years, that now the Chinese people have a hunger for information and knowledge of other countries culture and industrialization.
Writing Styles Of Good Earth Compared To
Chinese Sagas Essay, Research Paper Every author has his or her own style of writing. The way authors use words to create ideas give them different styles. One interesting writing style is that of Pearl S Buck, the author of The Good Earth. Peter Doyle criticizes Buck’s writing style as “almost biblical”. Pearl Buck’s writing is also compared to Chinese sagas.
Chinese Poetry Essay Research Paper Although the
Chinese Poetry Essay, Research Paper Although the Chinese poetry I encountered was relatively short, their significant was not at all compromised. It did not matter that these poems were written hundreds of years ago they felt relevant to me. They reminded me of what should be a priority of life, finding inner peace.
Chinese Remainder Theorem Essay Research Paper CHINESE
Chinese Remainder Theorem Essay, Research Paper CHINESE REMAINDER THEOREM WHAT IS IT ? Mathematics plays an important role in our world, as we know it. It is used everyday to solve all kinds of complex problems enabling us to create a better place for everyone to live in. One particular aspect of Mathematics known as the Chinese Remainder Theorem has a very interesting background.
Chinese Kites Essay Research Paper The Kite
Chinese Kites Essay, Research Paper The Kite: China, Fifth/Fourth Century BC. Two kitemakers, Kungshu P’an who made kites shaped like birds which could fly for up to three days, and Mo Ti (who is said to have spent three years building a special kite) were famous in Chinese traditional stories from as early as the fifth century BC.
China Boy Essay Research Paper Megan hinted
China Boy Essay, Research Paper Megan hinted that slapping children in the face was not Chinese. “We are not in china, Megan,” Edna would say through her teeth. “That is precisely the point I am striving to make.” (Page 97)
The Silk Road Essay Research Paper The
The Silk Road Essay, Research Paper The Silk Road is the most well-known trading route of ancient Chinese civilization. Trade in silk grew under the Han Dynasty in the first and second centuries. Originally, the Chinese trade silk internally, within the empire. Caravans from the empire’s interior would carry silk to the western edges of the region.
Mrs Spring Fragrance Essay Research Paper Mrs
Mrs. Spring Fragrance Essay, Research Paper Mrs. Spring Fragrance Sui Sin Far portrays the effects of “Americanization” on the Chinese who arrived in America during the early 1900’s, in her story of “Mrs. Spring Fragrance”. She describes the processes that the Chinese characters in the story undergo as they slowly begin to accept the American culture as their own.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
Get In Essay Research Paper Click Here
Get In Essay, Research Paper Click Here If YOU Have Friends! Can’t find the paper you need? Try Collegiate Care Comparing Casablanca to 1984 Charlie Parker at Storyville
Untitled Essay Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay The movie Sand Pebbles focus was on the flag. The flag was not only a symbol of a nation, but of nationalism, militarism and imperialism. During the 1800’s and early 1900’s there was a severe foreign influence in China. During this time period the European nations wanted to trade with the Chinese, but the Chinese had no interest in the European products for at the time China was self sufficient.
Chinese Family Essay Research Paper The Chinese
Chinese Family Essay, Research Paper The Chinese Family For the last two decades, Chinese families have gone through a lot of changes. Much of the old structure and many of the old values of the traditional family have been replaced with a modern twist.
History Of Korean 2
History Of Korean & Chinese Immigration Essay, Research Paper The first immigration of Koreans to the North Americas happened in the early 1900??s near the year 1902. They came to America to work on the sugar plantations in Hawaii.
Chinese Immigration Essay Research Paper
“The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was the first significant law restricting immigration into the United States. Those on the West Coast were especially prone to attribute declining wages and economic ills on the despised Chinese workers. Although the Chinese composed only .002 percent of the nation’s population, Congress passed the exclusion act to placate worker demands and assuage prevalent concerns about maintaining white “racial purity.”
Op Essay Research Paper Article Critique
Op Essay, Research Paper Article Critique ? New Hotel Project The article talks about the possibilities of making ?One card, For Many Doors?. They are trying to make a room key with an internal credit card. Using a new system guests will be able to check in and issue a room key (double encoded) using their own credit card.
A Sacred Place Essay Research Paper A
A Sacred Place Essay, Research Paper A known scared place to me in my life, is my bedroom. Their are many valuables which I keep in it because of the fact that I still live at home. So until the time comes to move out,
The Dorm Room Essay Research Paper A
The Dorm Room Essay, Research Paper A room that can be described so much by scent and sight. A room that when approached can give you the fresh smell of charred cigarettes and as you came in a little closer you get the smell of dirty clothes. But this was due to the people who inhibited this room. Comforted with two extravagant, old model bunk beds and a pair of genuine high-class desk and chair.
Your Late Essay Research Paper Your late
Your Late Essay, Research Paper Your late, what’s your excuse this time? No, no I don’t want to hear it you can tell me later in detention, sound familiar? Well to half the students in my school it does. That was the usual answer that teachers distribute when students are late to class, which is permissible, but what about what about when your late to home room? Well before you answer that let me explain to you what home room is.
Asian Exclusion Laws Essay Research Paper There
Asian Exclusion Laws Essay, Research Paper There were a very large number of local, state, and federal laws that were specifically aimed at disrupting the flow of Chinese and Japanese immigrants to the United States. Two of the major laws were the 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act and the 1907-1908 Gentleman s Agreement.
The Safety Inspector Essay Research Paper The
The Safety Inspector Essay, Research Paper The Safety Inspector Mr. Redos, I am an inspector for the OSHA. I have noticed the following safety objects missing in the room F 203, chemistry room. These are sprinklers,
Cheap Decorating Essay Research Paper With today
Cheap Decorating Essay, Research Paper With today’s inflation how can anybody find the money to decorated their ugly boring living room? Well, I have the solution for you, decorate with little money. Just follow these three easy steps and you’ll be on your way to a beautiful room.
The Turing Test Essay Research Paper The
The Turing Test Essay, Research Paper The Turing Test was designed by a man named Alan Turing in 1950. It was initially called the “imitation game.” Originally, the test was designed to differentiate between males and females. It was played with three people?a man, a woman, and an interrogator. The interrogator would go into a separate room and try to determine who was the man and who was a woman by asking various questions such as “How long is your hair?” or “Do you have an Adam’s apple?” Based on the answers to the participants’ replies, the interrogator would decide who was the man and who was the woman.
My Bedroom Essay Research Paper My favourite
My Bedroom Essay, Research Paper My favourite place in the entire world is my bedroom. My bedroom and I are one. My bedroom personifies me. It is the only place that allows me to be me. My bedroom is mine. I have complete control over it and everything in it. The only regulations in my bedroom are those I decide on.
Chester A Arthur Essay Research Paper Chet
Chester A. Arthur Essay, Research Paper Chet Arthur, President of the United States? Good God! That is what many of us were saying when former President Garfield died and
Barbie Girl Essay Research Paper Sing it
Barbie Girl Essay, Research Paper Sing it to the Barbie song… Hi ya lang niu! Hi lang jai! Want to ride in my Honda? Sure lang jai! Jump in! * I’m a Chinese girl, in a Chinese world,