Don Qui Essay, Research Paper
Comparison of “Beloved” by Toni Morrison and “Don Quixote” by Kathy AckerOn reading Beloved by Toni Morrison and Don Quixote by Kathy Acker, there seem to be quite a few similarities in themes and characters contained in these texts, the most prevalent of which seems to be of love and language as a path to freedom. We see in Acker s Don Quixote the abortion she must have before she embarks on a quest for true freedom, which is to love. Similarly, in Morrison s Beloved, there is a kind abortion, the killing of Beloved by Sethe, which results in and from the freedom that real love provides. And in both texts, the characters are looking for answers and solutions in these “word-shapes” called language. In Acker s Don Quixote, the abortion with which the novel opens is a precondition for surrendering the “constructed self.” For Acker, the woman in position on the abortion table over whom a team of doctors and nurses work represents, in an ultimate sense, woman as a constructed object. The only hope is somehow to take control, to subvert the constructed identity on order to name oneself: “She had to name herself. When a doctor sticks a steel catheter into you while you re lying on your back and you to; finally, blessedly, you let go of your mind. Letting go of your mind is dying. She needed a new life. She had to be named” (Don Quixote 9-10). And she must name herself for a man become a man before the nobility and the dangers of her ordeals will be esteemed. She is to be a knight on a noble quest to love “someone other than herself” and thus to right all wrongs and to be truly free. In another of Acker s works she writes: “Having an abortion was obviously just like getting fucked. If we closed our eyes and spread our legs, we d be taken care of. They stripped us of our clothes. Gave us white sheets to cover our nakedness. Let us back to the pale green room. I love it when men take care of me (Blood and Guts in High School 33). In Morrison s Beloved, Sethe has two “abortions.” The first and most obvious is the act of infanticide in killing Beloved. The second “abortion” is Sethe “getting fucked” by the grave-digger. This abortion, like Acker s protagonist, creates a name. The name is Beloved a “word-shape” representing true love, or freedom. For Sethe, to love also becomes a testament of freedom. For having been owned by others (like Acker s patriarchy) meant that her claim to love was not her own. She could not love her children, “love em proper in Kentucky because they wasn t [hers] to love” (Beloved 162). Paul D understands that “to get a place where you could love anything you choose well now that was freedom” (Beloved 162), but he is also bound to his slave mentality to overcome his fear. He considers Sethe s unconditional love “risky”: “For a used-to-be-slave woman to love anything that much was dangerous, especially if it was her children she had settled on to love” (Beloved 45). The far safer way was “to love just a little bit, so when they broke its back, or shoved it in a croaker sack, well, maybe you d have a little love left over for the next one” (Beloved 45). It is this compromised love that even Baby Suggs accepted despite her magnificent sermon in the Clearing on loving one s self knowing that her slave master would take her children away. And it is this “weak love” that Paul D tells Sethe she must accept (a patriarchal love, as Acker might say). When Paul D tells her love is “too thick,” however, Sethe insists that “Love is or it ain t. Thin love ain t no love at all” (Beloved 164). She believes in this pure love, the kind perhaps Acker s protagonist is looking for. Also, like Acker s Don Quixote, Morrison shows, through the relationship between Sethe and Beloved, the dangerous potential of “free” love. Another similarity shown in Beloved is that freedom is always perilous it has the potential to be self-consuming. This love allows Sethe to commit infanticide as well as compelling Beloved to claim possession of Sethe s self. Despite her efforts to earn Beloved s understanding of her action, Sethe never retreats from her insistence that the murder was justified. She wills Beloved to return in order to hear her say “I forgive you,” yet she acknowledges no guilt. In her “unspeakable things, unspoken” narrative, she claims that though she does not “have to explain a thing,” she will: “Why I did it. How if I hadn t killed her she would have died ” (Beloved 200). The more Beloved demands of her, the more “Sethe plead[s] for forgiveness, counting, listing again and again the reasons: that Beloved was more important, meant more to her than her own live” (Beloved 241-242), “that what she had done was right because it came from true love” (Beloved 251). But it seems to be a confession without a crime: “Sethe didn t really want forgiveness given, she wanted it refused. And Beloved helped her out” (Beloved 252). For Sethe, forgiveness must not cancel out the justification of her act, the very love that generated it transforms infanticide into the profoundest testimony of love, signifying the reverse of what it seems. Sethe is “luxuriating” in not being forgiven, more proud than repentant, paradoxically seeking forgiveness irrespective of a crime.
The acquisition of a new life and name, and love and language are henceforth erratically and erotically pursued in both texts. The means of acquisition are outside, unavailable in a culture locked in patriarchy, or slavery. In order to constitute the self differently, the quester is required to find a different site for enunciating that self. Acker moves her protagonist toward this site through the appropriation of male texts. As the epigraph to Part II of Don Quixote reads: “BEING BORN INTO AND PART OF A MALE WORLD, SHE HAD NO SPEECH OF HER OWN. ALL SHE COULD DO WAS READ MALE TEXTS WHICH WEREN T HERS” (Don Quixote 39). These texts represent the limits of language and culture within which the female quester attempts to acquire identity. Once inside the male text, the quester, by her very posture, subverts it: “By repeating the past, I m molding and transforming it.” In the text, Acker explains the subversive effects of plagiarism through Arabs, who in incarnating an “other” of Western culture are comparable to women:Unlike American and Western culture (generally), the Arabs (in their culture) have no (concept of) originality. That is, culture. They write new stories paint new pictures et cetera only by embellishing old stories pictures They write by cutting chunks out of all-ready written texts and in other ways defacing traditions: changing important names into silly ones, making dirty jokes out of matters that should be of the utmost importance to us such as nuclear warfare. (Don Quixote 25). It seems also in Morrison s Beloved, with subversion of words and language is apparent when the townsfolk get together at 124. At first they try the prayers that “weren t theirs,” but when the women s singing prayer does not have the ability affect the “roaring” around 124, they must go all the way back to the first page of the text in their collective memory: “In the beginning was the sound, and they all knew what the sound sounded like” (Beloved 259). This familiar, original sound revitalizes Sethe s body and allowing her to break the lock Beloved has had upon her. “For Sethe it was as though the Clearing had come to her with all its heat and simmering leaves, where the voices of women searched for the right combination, the key, the code, the sound that broke the back of words. Building voice upon voice until they found it, and when they did it was a wave of sound wide enough to sound deep water and knock the pods off chestnut trees. It broke over Sethe and she trembled like the baptized in its wash” (Beloved 261). Unleashed, Sethe rushes toward Bodwin (mistaking him for the schoolteacher) with ice pick raised, her body partially transformed into the shape of the weapon she is holding: “The ice pick is not in her hand; it is her hand” (Beloved 262). But the reconstituted community intervenes, pulling her into what Beloved sees as a “hill of black people falling” (Beloved 262). Now that Sethe and Denver have reentered the community, Beloved thinks that she has been left behind, “Alone. Again” (Beloved 262), and the “devil-child” (Beloved 261) vanishes. Thus Sethe s freedom. She has loved completely. All this raises a question: Is Acker s protagonist similar to Sethe or to Beloved? Like Sethe, the “knight-night” believes in a pure love, not excluding taboo. They both also believe that to love one must be freed from their respective slavery, and to be free is the ability to love. However Sethe, and the whole of Morrison s work, seems to be the incarnation of what Don Quixote is trying to reach. Sethe sees her love a true and pure, while this is the quest of Don Quixote. However, Sethe is “saved” at the end of the text by a community getting in touch with a “language of their own,” while Acker s protagonist is subverting texts to find or create something this “primal.”Don Quixote is far more easily paired with the ghost of Beloved. They both are searching for a language they can use and understand and know with the “word-shapes” that they are given. They are both on quests to find love and freedom that are not a product of “slavery.” They both are in search of a name, an identity, that is not a product of an “abortion.” They are both childlike yet adult, trying to understand. And neither of them are asking for, or offering, forgiveness.
Другие работы по теме:
Critique Of Recitatif Essay Research Paper Critique
Critique Of Recitatif Essay, Research Paper Critique of Recitatif Sometimes, the mere fact of being from a different race can influence people’s way of thinking or attitude toward other people with different color skin. That is the theme of Toni Morrison’s short story Recitatif. In the story, two eight year old girls, Roberta and Twyla, from different races (black and white) meet in an orphanage called St.
Toni MorrisonS The Bluest Eye Essay Research
Paper Black Beauty and The Ugly Duckling Some people will argue with you that there is always an ugly duckling somewhere in a family. I see it different, I see these people as unique. In Toni Morrison’s book, The Bluest Eye there is the issue of being beautiful and ugly. In this essay I will discuss how Toni Morrison book The Bluest Eye initiates that during 1941 white was beautiful and black was ugly in the surrounding of two families.
How Far Essay Research Paper Toni Morrison
How Far Essay, Research Paper Toni Morrison’s Beloved (1987) was her fifth novel, and consequently the most controversial work she had ever written. Morrison was working as a senior editor at the publishing firm Random House when she was editing a nineteenth century article which was in a historical book and found the basis for this story.
Beloved Essay Research Paper BelovedElements of the
Beloved Essay, Research Paper Beloved Elements of the supernatural pervade Toni Morrison’s novel, Beloved. These elements include evidence of African-American folklore and tradition in the everyday lives of the inhabitants of 124 Bluestone Road. Beloved’s character is another obvious use of the supernatural: she is a ghost for part of the novel and a “ghost-in-the-flesh” for the major part of the book.
The Bluest Eyes Essay Research Paper 2
The Bluest Eyes Essay, Research Paper “The Bluest Eyes” Toni Morrison was an African American woman that had gone through almost forty years of suppression. In an excerpt from her novel The Bluest Eyes, she tells the story of a young girl named Claudia who receives a white baby doll every Christmas. Claudia does not like the doll so she decided to tear it apart like every other “white baby doll” that she has received.
BelovedWater Motif Essay Research Paper BelovedIn her
Beloved-Water Motif Essay, Research Paper Beloved In her novel Beloved, Toni Morrison writes about the life of former slaves of Sweet Home. Sethe, one of the main characters, was once a slave to a man and his wife, Mr. and Mrs. Garner. After Garner’s sudden death, schoolteacher comes to Sweet Home and takes control of the slaves.
Beloved 2 Essay Research Paper BelovedIn regards
Beloved 2 Essay, Research Paper Beloved In regards to the novel Beloved Toni Morrison says, [The novel] can t be driven by slavery. It has to be the interior life of some people, a small group of people, and everything that they do is impacted on by the horror of slavery, but they are also people. Critics argue that the novel is driven by slavery and that the interior life of the protagonists is secondary.
Bluest Eye Essay Research Paper The Bluest
Bluest Eye Essay, Research Paper The Bluest Eye, by Toni Morrison, was written during the Black Revolt of the 1960?s. At a time when Negroes were not going to allow themselves to be segregated
Beloved Essay Research Paper Critical AnalysisBeloved in
Beloved Essay, Research Paper {Critical Analysis} Beloved in Light of Flannery O Connor s Essay Flannery O Connor lectures, in her essay on the virtues and vices of writing a novel. In her essay, she describes those certain characteristics in good literature. Toni Morrison s novel, Beloved can be examined in light of Flannery O Connor s ideas on the characteristics of good literature.
Racism Related To The Novel Jazz Essay
, Research Paper Racism Related to the Novel Jazz In the novel Jazz, written by Toni Morrison, racism was a strong issue that was presented in the novel. The novel relayed the issue of racism to its beginnings and to how it is today. Although, at that time black males regaurded jazz as the essence of the Harlem Renaissance, the age of the New Negro, for many black women it represented the disenchantment of urban life.
Beloved Essay Research Paper BelovedIn the Novel
Beloved Essay, Research Paper Beloved In the Novel Beloved, by Toni Morrison unmasks the horrors of slavery, and depicts its aftermath on African Americans. The story is perfect for all who did
Beloved The Human Condition Essay Research Paper
Toni Morrison’s novel, Beloved, reveals the effects of human emotion and its power to cast an individual into a struggle against him or herself. In the beginning of the novel, the reader sees the main character, Sethe, as a woman who is resigned to her desolate life and isolates herself from all those around her.
Beloved By Toni Morisson Essay Research Paper
Beloved is actually a quintessentially American story. Its topic slavery however may not seem to be a traditional one in American literature. The novel written by Toni Morrison is an American survivor?s tale, which depicts the collective experience of slavery defined by the identity of the black community in America for years.
Toni Morrison Essay Research Paper Toni MorrisonToni
Toni Morrison Essay, Research Paper Toni Morrison Toni Morrison?s cultural heritage continues to shape her life and writing. On February 18th, 1931 (Shockley 112), baby Chloe Anthony Wofford was born in Lorain,
Essay On Toni Morrison
’s Beloved Essay, Research Paper Throughout the book Beloved by Toni Morrison and the slave narrative of Aunt Betty s story, the significance of the roles of the main characters as women, their strive for their freedom from the era of slavery, the memorys and rememorys that serve as a reminder to Aunt Betty and a haunting past to Sethe help to shape their character and further their generations by coming to grips with the past in order to move forward.
The Bluest Eye Analysis Essay Research Paper
The Bluest Eye In a film interview, Morrison has stated, “I suppose The Bluest Eye is about one’s dependency on the world for identification,self-value, feelings of worth.” Toni Morrison has been consistently insightful and helpful critic of her work. With regard to herfirst novel, she has indicated that her plan was to take love and the effects of its scarcity in the world as her major themes,concentrating on the interior lives of her characters, especially those of an enclosed community.
Like Father Like Son Essay Research Paper
The book called Song of Solomon, by Toni Morrison, deals with many real life issues, most of which are illustrated by the relationships between different family members. One archetypal relationship that Morrison includes in her book is the father:son relationship. Although it is obvious that Morrison does talk about this topic, it is not so obvious what she is trying to say about it.
Theme Of Healing In Beloved Essay Research
Paper Theme of healing in Beloved November 02, 1998 Healing in Beloved The theme of “healing” is ever present in the novel, Beloved by Toni Morrison. Many forms of “healing”
Name And Naming In Beloved Essay
, Research Paper It is rarely the case for an author to select the names of his or her characters arbitrarily. Often the names of the characters will be used to express an idea or concept significant to the author. For example, in 1984 George Orwell named his hero after Winston Churchill, England’s great leader during World War II and added a common last name: Smith.
Beloved Essay Research Paper BelovedBy Toni Morrison
Beloved Essay, Research Paper Beloved By Toni Morrison Dear Toni, Your novel Beloved evokes a tremendous amount of emotion from its readers. The various stylistic techniques enable the reader to see beyond the twisted story. Your use of stream of conscientiousness, symbolism, and characterization bring forth a well-written novel containing strong emotion.
Beloved Essay Research Paper In the novel
Beloved Essay, Research Paper In the novel Beloved, by Toni Morrison, Sethe?s killing of Beloved to save her from her future and raising of Denver to save her from her past are both done with the goal of saving them from having to live the past and present that she has yet to overcome.
Beloved Essay Research Paper BELOVEDToni Morrison was
Beloved Essay, Research Paper BELOVED Toni Morrison was born in Loraine, Ohio on February 18, 1931. She has accomplished many things from then until now. From writing several books to being a trustee of the National Humanities Center, she finds the time to remain grounded and stable. She has written many books, one namely Beloved which focuses on one woman?s trials and tribulations.
Beloved Essay Research Paper BELOVEDToni Morrison depicts
Beloved Essay, Research Paper BELOVED Toni Morrison depicts the physical and psychological effects slavery has on an African American woman and her family following the civil war in her famous book, Beloved. Throughout the novel, Morrison uses various themes to capture the impact of slavery had on the various characters portrayed in Beloved.
Misnaming Motifs Essay Research Paper Misnaming Motifs
Misnaming Motifs Essay, Research Paper Misnaming Motifs in Song of Solomon by: Toni Morrison Song of Solomon by Toni Morrison is a brilliantly written novel that accurately depicts racial and social tensions between blacks and whites. Morrison chooses the setting of Shalimar, Virginia and Danville, Pennsylvania, during the late 1930 s through the 1960 s, where she covey s her story through the third person as an omniscient author.
Comparison Essay Of Memoirs Of A Geisha
And The Bluest Eye Essay, Research Paper Memoirs of a Geisha by Aurthor Golden and The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison are two thought provoking books with a unique style of writing. Memoirs of a Geisha has a beautiful poetic grammar which captures readers imagination and brings the story to life. Morrison on the other hand uses combined voices to give varied perspectives with out resorting to authorial intrusion or preaching.
Slave To Pain An Essay On Beloved
Essay, Research Paper Slave to Pain Sethe, now free from slavery has become a slave again, but this time instead of being a slave to a white master she is a, slave to her own pain. The sources of her pain are numerous, including the stealing of her milk, the murdering of her child, Beloved, attempting to kill the rest of her children, and two of her children leaving her because of it.
Beloved Essay Research Paper Beloved by Toni
Beloved Essay, Research Paper Beloved by Toni Morrison In Toni Morrisons novel, Beloved, the main character Sethe, is a former slave who chooses to kill her baby girl rather than allowing her to be exposed to the
Beloved Essay Research Paper Beloved Essay FlashbacksRevisit
Beloved Essay, Research Paper Beloved Essay: Flashbacks Revisit the Dry Well, Find a New Spring Toni Morrison?s novel Beloved swims like a garden pond full of minnows with thoughts and memories of days gone by. Each memory is like a drop of water, and when one person brings up enough drops, a trickle of a stream is formed.
Who Is Beloved Essay Research Paper After
Who Is Beloved Essay, Research Paper After reading the novel Beloved by Toni Morrison, many readers may find them selves asking who Beloved really was. There are basically three
Beloved Essay Research Paper BelovedToni Morrison
Beloved Essay, Research Paper Beloved Toni Morrison’s, Beloved, is a complex narrative about the love between mothers and daughters, and the agony of guilt. “ It is the ultimate gesture of a loving mother. It is
A Mothers Love Essay Research Paper A
A Mothers Love Essay, Research Paper A Mothers Love The idea of a ghost story or horror story has long since been introduced into the world of American literature starting in the late 18th
Song Of Solomon Essay Research Paper The
Song Of Solomon Essay, Research Paper The Icarus Myth in Toni Morrison’s Song of Solomon Throughout literature it has been common for authors to use allusions to complement recurrent motifs in their work. In Toni Morrison’s Song Of Solomon, Milkman learns that his desire to fly has been passed down to him from his ancestor Solomon.
Playing In The Dark Essay Research Paper
Playing in the Dark by Toni Morrison allowed me to begin to understand how African Americans are portrayed though white based literature. I was able to begin to see that our society has struggled with the notion of grasping the Aficanism concept. However I became entangled within her arguments and facts. I became clear what her view as a general idea but I found it difficult to break through and really delve into the heart.
COMPARISON OF WEST SIDE STORY AND ROMEO
AND JULIET Essay, Research Paper A Comparison of Romeo and Juliet West Side Story. There is a lot in common between the two plays Romeo And Juliet and West Side Story. The main male characters have many things in common. In fact, Toni and Romeo both miss the beginning fight at the beginning of the plays, they both fall in love and end up getting killed.