, Research Paper
Comparison of Adam Smith and Karl Marx on the Ideas of Individual Work and Production.
The task of political economy, Karl Marx argued, was to understand all the presumptions within productive and social relations, which made social life in a given form possible at a particular time. The aim of political economy is to understand the processes that produce these differences. The two historical figures that analyzed capitalism were Adam Smith and Karl Marx. Their philosophy differs in the way each viewed the human conditions and the role of the individual. It could be argued that history has shown Smith to be right and Marx to be wrong but the fact is that each of these men understood capitalism on different terms although both had similar material ideas.
The main difference between Marx’s and Smith’s thoughts is found in the values that each were concerned with. Smith suggested that the economic process could be forever unchangeable in its natural stage as individuals seek their own advantages. If people are left free they will try to improve the quality of their lives. This can be achieved in two ways: by individual effort, or at someone else’s expense. Most individuals will search for or make something that others will pay for rather than live at someone else’s expense. On the other hand, Marx noticed a growing consciousness among the working class of society which he believed was formed by economic development and that would create a transformation of the whole social system. He asserts that it is not the consciousness of men that determines their existence, but rather the opposite. Marx is talking about consciousness and the development of the society. He believes that the wealth produced by the industrial system develops the personal thought in all people, more importantly among working class. The individual comes to a self-realization through creative labor and develops a self-identity through relations with other members of the society. He considers the potential for intellectual growth as a way to take society to a new level of equality. For Marx the most basic human needs have to do with recognition of oneself in the products of labor. Through material labor and the labor that involves them in social relations, humans create their environments. Through their activities, the world becomes a place where humans can live and feel secure. Since one can have a place through activities, his individuality based upon how creative he is.
Marx believes that in his society labor activity is not a pain since one class isn’t forced to work for the other. Thus, for Marx the needs and capacities of labor are universal. Activities of people determine how they develop their capacities and the society determines the result of these activities. For Marx, human nature is changeable and that new social conditions create new kinds of individuals. So, Marx disagrees with the fact that capitalism is inevitable because it is formed of basic human desires. Marx would argue that capitalist society itself creates those desires. Because humans create the social and natural environment and as a result improve themselves during this process, they become historical beings. They have the power to decide their future and change things. In fact, the ability to control one’s future and develop in the process is how Marx describes freedom. His freedom is positive on one hand and social on the other. It focuses on the capability of activity, many of which is social and therefore can be appreciated without other individuals.
In order to understand Marx’s human nature, we have to take a close look at alienation. The basis of his argument is that capitalism alienates humans from their essence in labor. Capitalist society is undesirable since it doesn’t allow individuals utilize their natural potentials, which is, for Marx, to express and develop oneself through labor in one’s environment. This system of labor is made up of four relations: The worker is alienated from his or her productive activity, playing no part in deciding what to do or how to do it. The worker is alienated from the product of that activity, having no control over what is made. The worker is alienated from other human beings, with competition and mutual indifference replacing most form of cooperation. Finally, the worker is alienated from the distinctive potential found in the notion of human beings. Marx argues that alienation and capitalism come hand in hand. To get rid of alienation, one has to abolish capitalism. In capitalism, labor power of a certain group/class of people is exploited. This result in alienation in both sides, exploiter and exploited.
Besides all these explanations, it is necessary to examine Adam Smith s perspective. He simply states the reasons why all men naturally follow self-interest, and that this process leads to the greatest production of wealth in society. He asserts that it is only for the sake of profit that any man employs a capital in the support of industry. As we can see, Smith was not so much concerned with the development of consciousness among men, he never directly mentions the two classes- the bourgeois and the proletariats- Smith makes, because according to him all men do decisions based on self-interest. Since he defines the individual as sovereign (within the laws of justice), and he defines liberty as freedom from constraint, his argument begins with the individual, defining a man’s labor as the foundation of all other property. He uses his economic theory to support his belief that this limitation on government action creates the most overall good for society. He believes that the economic order should be independent from the political order.
Smith s Wealth of Nations was a critique of the existing system of state controls that he called mercantilism. He argued that the state intervention not only restricted freedom but also was economically inefficient. In contrast to Marx, Smith doesn’t see laborers as slaves: rather as free men with something to sell-their labor. According to Smith’s view all men are laborers since all must use effort to create their industry, thus final profit for themselves. He believes that all men are capitalists in a free economic society. Smith suggests that those who possess wealth have an interest in increasing it and giving society free exercise of all individual interests could never motivate such increase. He states that the sum of individual private fortunes makes up the wealth of the nation; there is no wealthy person who does work to become richer.
Each of these philosophers had valid points to make but they are focused on different targets. They in fact, agree that the production of wealth in society is good but they would not agree on the conditions of the workers. If Smith possibly asks who stops the workers from leaving their profession and joining another, Marx response would be the social conditioning of another job. People need to believe that if they had made right choices, or worked hard enough, they would have gone to the top of society. They would have also achieved the amount of wealth that they desired.
Другие работы по теме:
Writing Process Essay Research Paper Writing a
Writing Process Essay, Research Paper Writing a paper on the writing process is pretty hard. The writing process is different from one person to another. You come across questions like, What exactly is the writing process? and Must you follow one persons writing process if yours is different? This is where I came across the answer to my questions, write however you wish to write.
Writing A Poem Essay Research Paper Writing
Writing A Poem Essay, Research Paper Writing a Poem It is beyond reason; there is no motive, no explanation Why it is, I do not know because there is cause, no clarification.
Writing
– It’s Not Jst For Fun Anymore! Essay, Research Paper Writing…….It’s Not Just For Fun Anymore! I am writing to support the new writing class being discussed for the Junors’
An Unforgettable Trip Essay Research Paper
I still remember my 10 days trip to Calcutta, which is largest and fascinating city in India, with my school staff and students when I was ten years old. Moreover, it was 24 hours journey from my city Hyderabad to the city Calcutta. I can never forget this trip because whenever I get free time, the first thing I think is about the friends that I made, the places which I saw, and the way that I lived on this trip.
The Trip Journey To The Center Of
Terence McKenna’s Inner Self. Essay, Research Paper The Trip: Journey to The Center of Terence McKenna’s Inner Self. Terence McKenna has become one of the most (in)famous figures in the exploration
Physics Lab Paper Essay Research Paper In
Physics Lab Paper Essay, Research Paper In physics MC 503, we are required to write a paper twice a semester summarizing the previous four to six labs. In this, the first paper, I am writing about the previous four labs. As each lab comes around each week I start to get excited. I know that the lab is going to help me understand or comprehend some form of formula I am learning in the chapters.
Europe Essay Research Paper EuropeFrom June 31
Europe Essay, Research Paper Europe From June 31 to July 31 1997, my family went to Europe. We went on 4 airplanes the whole trip. We went to 7 countries. Now I will tell you about my trip.
Writing Drafts Essay Research Paper In his
Writing Drafts Essay, Research Paper In his essay, Writing Drafts , Richard Marias explains how to begin writing the first draft and get to final draft of the writing. He says when you first begin writing your first draft you should list the points you want to cover and list the main points. This process can have any writer hours of starting and stopping time.
My Trip Essay Research Paper The role
My Trip Essay, Research Paper The role of the visit to Pemberley by Elizabeth and the Gardiners would most closely resemble a modern visit to a museum or a tourist attraction.
Ecuador Essay Research Paper Ecuador South America
Ecuador Essay, Research Paper Ecuador, South America s second smallest country, is regarded as one of the most geographically and ethnically diverse countries on the continent. This culture-rich country is largely uncharted, making it an exciting and adventurous place to visit. Simply learning about this country is a remarkable experience.
Ecuador Essay Research Paper EcuadorI picked this
Ecuador Essay, Research Paper Ecuador I picked this country because when we saw the video on Ecuador it made me want to learn more about the country. Ecuador has a population approximately 10,500,000 and is a little bit smaller than Nevada. 85% of the people aged 15 or older are literate. The Galapagos Islands are also part of Ecuador and the total population is about 10,000 people.
Ecuador Essay Research Paper EcuadorEcuador is the
Ecuador Essay, Research Paper Ecuador Ecuador is the small country in Latin America. The conditions in Ecuador are not anywhere near what we expect and get everyday. There are numerous active volcanoes and many earthquakes that cause much damage. The economic situation is not good and health problems are many.
Ecuador Essay Research Paper Ecuador a country
Ecuador Essay, Research Paper Ecuador, a country smaller than the size of Nevada, is located in western South America. It borders the Pacific Ocean at the Equator and is a tropical region. The capital of Ecuador is Quito. Quito is located in Northern Central Ecuador. One interesting fact about Ecuador is that it contains the highest active volcano in the world, Cotopaxi.
Writing From Recall Essay Research Paper Having
Writing From Recall Essay, Research Paper Having a car accident may soundnormal in most people lives; however, this particular event was not as normal for my life. This car accident was a remarkable lesson for me because it changed me a great deal. It changed my personality, behavior, and philosophy. In addition, I came to realize later what I did make a lot of people, especially, my parents upset and disappointed in me.
Essay Writing Essay Research Paper email 7cdgqlinkqueensucaEssay
Essay Writing Essay, Research Paper email: 7cdg@qlink.queensu.caEssay Writing An essay is a literary composition. The purpose of a good formal essay is to try out an idea, thesis, or opinion, within the confines of a proper literary composition. To do this successfully one must know their topic, formulate a thesis, and finally write the essay.
An Example Of Good Writing Zinsser
’s “Simplicity” Essay, Research Paper An Example Of Good Writing: Zinsser’s “Simplicity” Zinsser’s essay on Simplicity is an example of good writing for many
Writer
’s Block Essay, Research Paper Writer’s BlockIt’s 1:27 on a Sunday morning and I’ve been sitting in front of my computer for about forty minutes. The screen is still blank and I don’t understand why words aren’t flowing from my mind. I’ve completed an outline, scribbled several notes, collected various reference books and yet, I haven’t typed one word.
Slanguage Essay Research Paper Slang when used
Slanguage Essay, Research Paper Slang, when used as a noun, refers to nonstandard terms or nonstandard usage of standard terms. Slang provides different symbols from which communication messages can be constructed. Slang is more than a noun though. Slang is a process. This means slang is also a verb. We slang as well as speak slang.
Comparison Essay Of Isadora And Art And
Isadora Essay, Research Paper Isadora Duncan It is always amazing to see how two different writers can use different techniques and writing styles to write about the same subject. Janet Flanner and John Dos Passo both
Miller Spring Essay Essay Research Paper Miller
Miller Spring Essay Essay, Research Paper Miller Springs Essay My science class and I went to Miller Springs to learn about sediments and nature a few days ago. The good and bad sides of the trip I will explain below.
Trip To Hospital Essay Research Paper Trip
Trip To Hospital Essay, Research Paper Trip to the hospital My trip to the hospital was ok it was required but I still went and I found out that when you go to the hospital. It isn?t just some place that when you go ijn you sign papers it a place that saves live.
Writing Techniques Essay Research Paper Writing TechniquesAfter
Writing Techniques Essay, Research Paper Writing Techniques After reading Katha Pollitt?s essay ?It Takes Two: A Modest Proposal for Holding Fathers Equally Accountable? and Patricia Mainardi?s essay ?The Politics of Housework?, several writing techniques become apparent in both essays.
InClass Writing Essay Research Paper Inclass Writing
In-Class Writing Essay, Research Paper In-class Writing or Homework Desks and paper rattle while time slowly tics away from the clock. This time these distractions do not bother you because you are finishing one of your most well written papers. In-class writings are great because they include many positive opportunities.
Growth In Writing Essay Research Paper Emily
Growth In Writing Essay, Research Paper Emily Gillette DVWR 101.004 Professor Bull September 22,2000 Growth in Writing Writing is one of my favorite things to do. Expressing yourself is so much easier when given time to think about what needs to be said. I would like to believe that I have a very rich writing history.
Writing Life Essay Research Paper Writing Life
Writing Life Essay, Research Paper Writing Life The book we had to read by Annie Dillard, The Writing Life, talks about a woman who has gone though various times in her life when she would be inspired by something, and she would write it down. This book wasn?t really appealing to me. I thought that Annie was going to explain how she went about writing, and what were her struggles.
Journal Writing Essay Research Paper Journal Writing
Journal Writing Essay, Research Paper Journal Writing I write a lot in class but I don’t like writing one bit it gets on my nerves cause my hands are very sensitive and my hands get so tired that don’t even want to type anymore and that messes me up a lot cause in my English class you are required to write a lot. Now if it were typing that a whole other story but that’s not going to help me in life to come cause when you go get a job you are required to have punctuality.
Pat Conroy Essay Research Paper Pat Conroy
Pat Conroy Essay, Research Paper Pat Conroy was an author who grew up in South Carolina.His works were influenced by his life and experiences which occurred from when he was young to
ProblemSolution Essay Essay Research Paper Have you
Problem-Solution Essay Essay, Research Paper Have you ever received a problem-solution essay where you cannot think of anything to write? Although many of the forty million students in America go through this at one time or another, don?t despair! There are several systematic ways to find a writing topic.
Writing Creatively Essay Research Paper Writing CreativelyCreative
Writing Creatively Essay, Research Paper Writing Creatively Creative writing is used to help regular expository writing become more interesting. You can use creative writing to do many tasks to help compose your paper. For instance, use this technique to select and narrow down your chose of topic. You can also generate and ideas, research ideas, and organize the ideas into a thesis.
How To Writing A Research Essay Essay
, Research Paper How To Writing A Research Essay The toughest part of the essay, for me, was taking all the information I had gained and reduce it to a mere few pages essay. After all, quality is better
Florida Essay Research Paper FloridaThere are many
Florida Essay, Research Paper Florida There are many different places to go and to see in this great country. Are you looking for fun in the sun? Then Florida is your vacation paradise. The whole family will enjoy a trip to Florida because of many different attractions, water activities and sports.