Paper
“The Health Risks of Secondhand Smoke Are Exaggerated,” according to an article written by W. Kip Viscusi, which is published in 1997 in Smoking, Opposing Viewpoints. The article, is not effective. Not only are the sources of the evidence not clearly identified, but also Viscusi uses logical fallacies, and the organization is confusing.
The first reason why Viscusi’s article is not effective is that the sources of the evidence Viscusi uses are not clearly identified. To begin with Viscusi talks about how the percentages of non-smokers in society have risen, then he says to consider the following “Gallup Poll results”, which are that the 16% believed that smoking in public places should be banned. But Viscusi fails to tell the reader what the “Gallup poll” is, when it was taken and who produced it. Equally important, in the seventh paragraph Viscusi states that “cancer researchers” generally note. Again he fails to let the reader know the credentials of the cancer researchers. Another example of poor credentials is when Viscusi states some percentages in “a 1991 survey of company smoking policies”. He again fails to let the reader know the credentials of the survey.
Another explanation as to why Viscusi’s article is not successful is because the organization is confusing. The thesis Viscusi is trying to prove is that the health risks of secondhand smoke are exaggerated. He fails to support his thesis because his main points in his story are all scattered and have no organization. Also, Viscusi’s main point is that
risks are exaggerated, but he fails to bring out the “risks” until after the he writes about insignificant topics that have nothing to do with the point he is trying to make. In addition to not supporting his thesis and scattering the main points, Viscusi also fails to stick to the point and he
often goes off topic. For example, Viscusi states in the second paragraph that the “debate over taxing cigarettes has intensified,” while taxation on cigarettes has nothing to do with the risks of secondhand smoke.
In addition to poor credentials and confusing organization, Viscusi often provides logical fallacies. The first way he does so is by using hasty generalizations. For example, Viscusi says that for many years non-smokers view secondhand smoke as a “smelly annoyance.” He generalizes that smokers annoy all non-smokers. Viscusi also uses shared assumptions to stand for
proof. One is he does so is when he stated that “one whiff is less likely to be risky than sustained exposures.” But goes on to say that the EDA and the OSHA hasn’t made those distinctions but that its instructive to use the estimates anyway. Another way Viscusi uses logical fallacies is by using circular reasoning. He “beats around the bush” by slipping in words like
“proposed” and “would have” to explain the laws about taxation of cigarettes.
Therefore, in conclusion, the susceptible credentials, confusing organization, and all the logical fallacies prove that this article is written unsuccessfully. This type of article should have been written with impressive credentials, better organization, and true statements. If
Viscusi had used those key topics, he would have been more successful in convincing the reader that secondhand smoke health risks are exaggerated.
Другие работы по теме:
Smoke Or Live Essay Research Paper Raj
Smoke Or Live Essay, Research Paper Raj Sagar Francisco Gil Yeon Sik Kim Tannenbaum Freedom to Live or Freedom to Smoke? What have cigarettes done for society?nothing but taken away millions of innocent lives. Each year thousands and thousands of people die from either smoking or second-hand smoke. Smoking has not benefited anyone but the tobacco companies.
Smoking 4 Essay Research Paper Tobacco is
Smoking 4 Essay, Research Paper Tobacco is used all over the world for centuries. It can be ingested many different ways: chewing, sniffing, and smoking. Today, cigarette smokers consume the most tobacco, Cigarettes account for nearly 17 percent of all deaths in the United States annually (Balch,485).
Solar Energy Essay Research Paper Smokers are
Solar Energy Essay, Research Paper Smokers are the Victims of Secondhand Smoke Smoking is a choice that everyone has to make. It is understood that smoking is bad for your health and nasty habit, but the rights of smokers have been taken away. Smoking and non-smoking sections were and exellent idea that is being slowly abolished.
Smoking Essay Research Paper In the seventh
Smoking Essay, Research Paper In the seventh grade I began to smoke cigarettes with my brother and a friend who introduced me to cigarettes. We smoke cigarettes in the morning before we get on the bus to go to school. I smoked cigarettes all through high school until my senior year, when I began to smoke black and milds (cigars).
Smokers Have Right Essay Research Paper In
Smokers Have Right Essay, Research Paper In 1998, Drew Carey held a sit-in because of the smoking ban in the California bars. Even though Drew is not a smoker, he smoked that night and called the ban ?stupid.? Three years ago, California enacted a state law that forbade smoking in bars and other work areas for the sake of the employees.
Summary On The Articles About Second Hand
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Secondhand Smoke, Is It a Hazard? In the 1950’s and 60’s scientists gave the people a lot of evidence on the deadly effects of smoking where the tobacco companies on the other hand tried to put the doubt in people?s minds through the campaigns to show that it is not all true. By the time people actually decided to take care of their health and finally saw how life-threatening smoking could be by real life examples, the tobacco companies already got rich from its sales.
Secondhand Smoke Is Bad For Your Health
Essay, Research Paper Reyes Freytes Phil 112 4-20-01 Secondhand Smoke I went on the Internet and started surfing around until I found this web-site called www.no-smoker. This site is About Americans for Nonsmoker’s Rights. The article I read was called “Things are changing”. The issue is secondhand smoke is bad for your health.
Effects Of Secondhand Smoke Essay Research Paper
Imagine your child wheezing, working hard for every breath he takes. You rush him to the Emergency Room. He is suffering from another severe asthma attack, which he developed when he was a baby. Why? Your child has been expose to secondhand smoke. This scenario may not be your community s worst problem, but I just want to address some concerns on the affects of secondhand smoke to children s health and their future.
Why Smoking Is Hazordous Essay Research Paper
In this report I will tell you the dangers of smoking. Smoking is one of the most preventable causes of death in our society. About one in five deaths in the US are results from using tobacco. More then half of all tobacco uses die much earlier then their normal life expectancy. Smokers could be losing an average of 20 to 25 years of their life.
Born To Smoke Essay Research Paper Bill
Born To Smoke Essay, Research Paper Bill Braskkey Born to Smoke: Prenatal Effects on Maternal Smoking on Daughters Smoking I suppose the real reason why I decided on this topic was because I find the capabilities of science amazing. The fact that it was proven that daughters are more likely to smoke if their mother did while they were in the womb is almost hard to swallow.
Clearing The Smoke Essay Research Paper Clearing
Clearing The Smoke Essay, Research Paper Clearing the Smoke Smoking has been an increasing trend among youth in America. This problem has been heavily stressed in the media and society. The major risks that usually surround smoking are strictly health risks. All of the warnings from the Surgeon General on the cigarette packages warn us of the health risks such as lung disease, cancer or problems with pregnancy and so on.
Health Effects Of Smoking Essay Research Paper
About 50 million people in the United States alone currently smoke a total of 570 billion cigarettes each year. In each one of these cigarettes there are around 4000 different chemicals, some of which are highly toxic. Nicotine, a main ingredient of tobacco smoke, is the most addictive drug known to man. Two main topics about smoking in general I would like to discuss are the various health effects of smoking and the anti-smoking actions which society has taken.
Smoking Us Bad Essay Research Paper The
Smoking Us Bad Essay, Research Paper The prohibition of smoking has become more and more wide spread in the Unite States today. Due to studies that smoking is related to many illnesses, people have made safe guards to prevent from acquiring them. One of those safe guard is prohibiting smoking in public places.
Smoking Essay Research Paper Smoking is the
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Smoking is the inhalation and exhalation of the fumes of burning tobacco. Tobacco leaves are dried and cured, then rolled into cigars or shredded for pipes or cigarettes, the most popular method of smoking. About 50 million people in the United States smoke a total of 570 billion cigarettes each year.
Smokers Rights Essay Research Paper Should smokers
Smokers Rights Essay, Research Paper Should smokers continue to have the right to smoke? This is a question that has been strongly debated over the last couple of years. Smokers believe that it is there right to smoke. While non-smokers say that smoking is a hazard to everyone s health and it should be restricted.
How Secondhand Smoking Affects Us Essay Research
Paper How Secondhand Smoking Affects Us As most of you know, smoking is bad for your health, but what some of you might not know is that you don t actually have to smoke to be harmed by smoking. Lung cancer, which is the leading cause of cancer deaths in men and women, is mainly caused by cigarette smoking. Secondhand smoking causes approximately 2 percent of lung cancer deaths each year.
Smoking Among Teenagers Essay Research Paper Young
Smoking Among Teenagers Essay, Research Paper Young Adults and Cigarette Smoking. Cigarette smoking is a major cause of lung cancer and many other illnesses. At least one out of five death in American society caused by disease directly related to cigarette smoking. The overall smoking prevalence in the United States has been reduced considerably over the past 20 years; however, there have been only minimal reductions in smoking prevalence among adolescents and young adults.
Tobacco Smoking And Its Risks Essay Research
Paper I am here to talk to you about smoking its risks and its consequences. First, to understand how smoking tobacco affects your body you have got to understand how smoking works inside your body
Why Smoking Is Hazardous Essay Research Paper
Hi I?m here today to tell you the dangers of smoking. Smoking is one of the most preventable causes of death in our society. About one in five deaths in the US are results from using tobacco. About half all of smokers between of 35 and 69 die ahead of time the new smokers replace them. Smokers could be losing an average of 20 to 25 years of their life.
Smoking Essay Research Paper Teen smoking and
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Teen smoking and drinking do not occur in a vacuum — both parents and peers may promote or discourage substance abuse among teens, according to a study of more than 4,500 students in the sixth, seventh and eighth grades.
Secondhand Smoke And Its Effects Essay Research
Paper Secondhand smoke and laws about smoking in public places “What the smoker does to himself may be his business, but what the smoker does to the non-smoker is quite a different matter This we see as the most dangerous development to the viability of the tobacco industry that has yet occurred The strategic and long run antidote to the passive smoking issue is, as we see it, developing and widely
Smoking Essay Research Paper Smoking in public
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Smoking in public places should be illegal, and today, we the affirmative team, will give you many reasons to prove why. People have been smoking cigarettes for hundreds of years, but it wasn’t
Jourrnal Essay Research Paper Journal AbstractPeople effect
Jourrnal Essay, Research Paper Journal Abstract People effect others without even knowing it when they choose to smoke. When someone lights up a cigarette and others inhale secondary smoke, you directly effect their health. Most smokers deny the fact that they are damaging others, or often don t even realize what they are doing.
Would You Please Smoke Outside Essay Research
Paper Jonathan Denney T. Huddleston English Comp. II 10-04-99 Would You Please Smoke Outside! While eating dinner at El Ranchito an acrid plume of smoke wafts over my table causing my eyes to
Effects Of Smoking Essay Research Paper The
Effects Of Smoking Essay, Research Paper The Harmful Effects of Smoking The Harmful Effects of Smoking Name: Adam Newell Teacher: Dr. Delos Santos Section: 57 Date December 8, 1999 Research Paper Words: 1901 Every year thousands of people die because of lung cancer or other tobacco related illnesses. Everyone in the world comes in contact with smoke from a cigarette at least once in their lifetime, whether it is at a restaurant or at work.
Passive Smoking Essay Research Paper What is
Passive Smoking Essay, Research Paper What is secondhand smoke? ? Secondhand smoke is a mixture of the smoke given off by the burning end of a cigarette, pipe, or cigar, and the smoke exhaled from the lungs of smokers.
Passive Smoking Essay Research Paper There is
Passive Smoking Essay, Research Paper There is nothing more annoying and sickening than sitting down for a meal at the local restaurant, or any place for that matter and having the poisonous haze of cigarette smoke drift towards you. It moves in an ever-expanding mass to all corners of the room, being inhaled by all.
Smoking
Smoking is a big social issue in many countries nowadays widely discussed in newspapers, radio and TV-shows. People start smoking for different reasons. Some say they smoke in order to relax, rest and distract from their daily stress.