Hawthorne Comparison Essay, Research Paper
Nathaniel Hawthorne has written many short stories that have common themes. One of these common themes is science versus nature and God. Hawthorne was writing during a time when many people were trying to use science to explain phenomenon that had always been attributed to a divine power. In Hawthorne s Rappaccini s Daughter , The Birthmark and Dr. Heidegger s Experiment science has a negative effect on those who meddle with it, and sometimes innocents suffer too. Hawthorne uses these works to denounce science as a substitute for faith and love.
In The Birthmark Aylmer becomes so obsessed with making Georgina perfect that it causes both their downfalls. He becomes so confident is his ability to mold and change nature that he acquires a God complex. Although the idea of religion is not a main idea in the plot, Hawthorne brilliantly uses language to convey his point:
language which may be either literal or figurative but in either case has influential overtones. What we find recurrently in The Birthmark, and therefore insistently asking to be taken into account, is the terminology and imagery of religion. Specifically religious problems are not overtly introduced into the story, but the language of religion is there for so unfailingly that, like iterative imagery in drama and poetry, it must be closely inspected if a final reading of the story is to be complete. (Heilman, p. 189)
As the story continues, we see that Georgina also considers Aylmer to be God-like in his science. Science has been substituted as religion in this relationship;
Georgina thinks of Aylmer s devotion to her-to the perfect her- as holy love. What is made clear by such terms, which function precisely like poetic images, is that science itself has become religion, able to provide an ultimate account of reality and therefore to exact complete human dedication. (Heilman, p. 189)
Instead of believing in God and the natural beauty she was blessed with, she focuses her faith on her husband and his plight to remove her birthmark. He has now become her God, controller of nature. Further evidence of Georgina s faith in Aylmer as God, comes when she is talking about Aylmer s sorcerer s book:
(Aylmer s) sorcerer s book, Georgina insists to him, has made me worship you more than ever. Aylmer s own confusion is shown further in his paradoxical inclination to adore as well as create: the spectral hand wrote mortality where we would fain have worshipped. (Heilman, p. 191)
Aylmer and Georgina have shifted the focus from God and religion to science, including all aspects of what religion used to encompass. To stress the theme, Hawthorne even uses the same words we associate with religion to show how confused the characters are and how misplaced their faith is.
Aylmer confuses science and religion again when he attempts to improve inner beauty with outer beauty:
Hawthorne brilliantly summarizes the metaphysics of the scientific religion in Aylmer s explication of the series of steps in his rehabilitation of Georgina. He tells her, I have already administered agents powerful enough to change your entire physical system is, in this cosmology, the equivalent of regeneration or conversion. Aylmer s faith becomes, in effect: improve the body, and you save the soul. (Heilman, p.191)
The idea of improving inner beauty with outer beauty is also a prevalent theme in Dr. Heidegger s Experiment . As Dr. Heidegger describes his guests, none of them strike the reader as particularly nice people. They are all decrepit, miserable and old. Dr. Heidegger is also elderly, but he does not share the negativity and cynicism of his peers. Compared to the scientists from The Birthmark and Rappaccini s Daughter , Dr. Heidegger is much smarter and less fanatical. He offers his friends the water from the fountain of youth and they greedily lunge for it. Dr. Heidegger even warns them to consider the consequences, but they drink the water as fast as they can consume it. As their bodies become more beautiful, the subjects of the experiment start acting younger. They get up and dance and rejoice in their new found youthfulness. They seem to have forgotten about the disparity of old age in a matter of seconds. Even though the guests are more beautiful on the outside, their inner beauty seems to be unaffected. In the most disgusting and disgraceful moment of the story, the new young people mock Dr. Heidegger s old age and feebleness even though they were of similar condition only moments ago. He is responsible for their happiness, and they laugh in his face in return. This display proves what Aylmer discovered in The Birthmark ; outer beauty cannot beautify your soul.
In Rappaccini s Daughter the allusions to religion are much more obvious than either of the previous two stories. The setting is a beautiful garden that matches the likes of the garden of Eden. This garden, however, is filled with poisonous plants that will kill you if you come into contact with them. This creates a very strong Heaven /Hell contrast. As Giovanni becomes infatuated with Beatrice, it is again, his lack of faith in religion that causes both of them emotional pain and death:
Giovanni, in short, lacks the depth of heart necessary to tender to Beatrice the love to which her spirit could respond. He vacillates between faith and doubt, between the promptings of the heart and those of the fancy, which blurs any profounder vision and makes it impossible for him to believe in Beatrice s spiritual beauty even though he has perceived its manifestation. Had he trusted in the heart rather than in the fancy he would have been reassured that all this ugly mystery was but an earthly illusion, that despite the mist of evil surrounding her, the real Beatrice was a heavenly angel. But Giovanni is incapable of such high faith. When Beatrice says she had been lonely until heaven sent him, he turns angrily upon her, burying her with invective, calling her a world s wonder of hideous monstrosity. And when she sadly explains the truth of her situation, a contrite Giovanni betrays the poverty of his heart one final time. Perhaps, he thinks, he can yet lead the redeemed Beatrice from the garden; putting his faith not in the heart but in a scientific antidote, he ministers the potion given him by Baglioni, and-compounding his emotional blindness-promises that it is almost divine in its efficacy. (Martin, p. 89-90)
If Giovanni had chosen to trust in God instead of science, Beatrice would not have died.
Beatrice is the most victimized of all the characters in these three short stories. Her father, Rappaccini had created a garden so unnatural and his daughter was born that way too. Although he never seemed bothered in the beginning of the story, he clearly sees what terrible consequences his actions have caused when his daughter dies. Rappaccini is perhaps the most evil of the three scientists. He makes natural beautiful things evil and ugly, and when it backfires and affects his daughter, it doesn t bring about an epiphany:
Rappaccini, a grotesque figure of the mad scientist as overly protective father, has thus rendered his daughter poisonous to defend her against the evils of the world. He had poisoned Giovanni to give her a companion in this inverted paradise, this Eden of the present world. And just as Baglioni has precipitated Beatrice s death by his concern to outmaneuver Rappaccini, just as Giovanni has failed to evince the potent magic of love that could have been the true antidote to Rappaccini s scientific skill, so Rappaccini, warped apostle of the head that he is has never seen that Beatrice would fain have been loved, not feared. She is, we recall from his boast, the daughter of his pride and triumph, not the daughter of his heart. (Martin, p. 92)
Only in death when it is too late does Rappaccini learn the consequences of his actions. Unfortunately, it is Beatrice who pays the price.
In these three short stories, it is clear that science is the cause for the death and destruction of the characters. This is Hawthorne s way of warning against the acceptance of science as religion and the rejection of faith in God. These characters put their faith in the twisted religion of science and they paid the price for it. All of the irreparable damage could have been avoided had the characters maintained their faith in God and not looked elsewhere for a substitute for happiness.
330
Другие работы по теме:
The Hollow Of The Three Hills Essay
, Research Paper The Hollow of the Three Hills is a story of dishonor, deceit, and death. The author, Nathaniel Hawthorn portrays the main character as a beautiful woman with a shameful and
The Scarlet Letter Essay Research Paper
“The Scarlet Letter” was written by Nathaniel Hawthorne in 1828. “The Scarlet Letter” portrayed the punishment suffered by two individuals who committed adultery in a Puritan society and their struggle to deal with their sins. Throughout the novel Hawthorne uses Pearl to serve as a constant reminder to Hester and Dimmesdale of their sin.
Scarlet Letter Themes Essay Research Paper Nathaniel
Scarlet Letter Themes Essay, Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne was a truly outstanding author. His detailed descriptions and imagery will surely keep people interested in reading The Scarlet Letter for years to come. In writing this book he used themes evident throughout the entirety of the novel. These themes are illustrated in what happens to the characters and how they react.
A Tale Of Evil Essay Research Paper
Nathaniel Hawthorne is considered by many a great writer. Hawthorne’s use of imagery captures the reader’s attention and holds it throughout the story, such as the reader will experience in the tale of Young Goodman Brown. In the fable of Young Goodman Brown the reader is thrown into a twist of good versus evil.
One More Thing With An Underlying Meaning
…When I Essay, Research Paper Hathorne. Hawthorne. Visibly names are of importance to Nathaniel Hawthorne as evident in the “w” placed within his own to disassociate himself from his great great grandfather, a Salem judge. So, it would be logical to say that he took the naming of characters in his literary piece, The Scarlet Letter, into serious consideration: Chillingworth.
Choices Essay Research Paper ChoicesIn Nathaniel Hawthorne
Choices Essay, Research Paper ChoicesIn Nathaniel Hawthorne’s novel The Scarlet Letter, the young and vulnerable Hester Prynne had a choice…a choice of right or wrong…a choice of either being faithful to her dreams and the commitments she had made to her husband or giving in to thoughtless temptations of lust and passion; similarly, today’s teenagers-turned-parents are making the same thoughtless choices and thus reaping the consequences.
Changing Views Of The Letter A Essay
, Research Paper The perception of Hester’s A has changed throughout the novel. In the beginning, the scarlet letter on her chest was a symbol of her sin. It was intended to be part of her punishment by providing her
Reoccurring Themes And Symbols In Different Works
By Nathaniel Hawthorne Essay, Research Paper Reoccurring Themes and Symbols in Different Works by Nathaniel Hawthorne It is no secret that Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Minister’s Black Veil” is a parable. Hawthorne intended it as such and even gave the story the subtitle “a parable.” “The Minister’s Black Veil,” however, was not Hawthorne’s only parable.
Scarlet Letter Essay Essay Research Paper
“To be fully human is to balance the heart, the mind, and the spirit. One could suggest the novel The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, that one should not violate the sanctity of the human heart. Hester was well ahead of her time, and believed that love was more important than living in a lie. Dimmesdale s theology and his inclinations render him almost incapable of action; Chillingsworth dammed himself, along with Dimmesdale.
Scarlet Letter Essay Research Paper Since early
Scarlet Letter Essay, Research Paper Since early times, Puritans have been known for their morality in discipline, religious intolerance, and harsh punishments for those defying their beliefs. These Puritan influences had a great impact on early American literature. Nathaniel Hawthorne provides an illustrated look into the Puritans and their community in his classic The Scarlet Letter.
Hawthorne Essay Research Paper There never surely
Hawthorne Essay, Research Paper There never surely was a powerful, active, continually effective mind less round, more lop-sided, than that of NATHANIEL HAWTHORNE. If there were aught of dispraise in this, it would not be said by me,–by an Englishman of an American whom I knew, by an Englishman of letters of a brother on the other side of the water, much less by me, an English novelist, of an American novelist.
Nathaniel Hawthorne Essay Research Paper Author Profile
Nathaniel Hawthorne Essay, Research Paper Author Profile: Nathaniel Hawthorne Nathaniel Hawthorne, named after his father, was born on July 4, 1804 in Salem, Massachusetts. Four years after Hawthorne?s birth, his father died. This left his mother to take care of him and his two siblings. A very important event occurred to him at age nine when he injured himself severely, leaving him bed ridden.
The Affects Of Sin On Man In
The Scarlett Letter Essay, Research Paper The Affects of Sin on the Individual in The Scarlet Letter In the novel, The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, there is a
Trans Essay Research Paper The Minister
Trans Essay, Research Paper The Minister’s Black Veil By Nathaniel Hawthorne Anti-Transcendentalists believed that everything has a good or evil side, and that the truths about these matters would be terrifying and
Nath Essay Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthornes short
Nath Essay, Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne?s short stories ?The Birthmark? and Rappaccinni?s Daughter are both tragic tales of women being taken advantage of. In each account a young woman is skillfully led to her downfall by a loved one she trusts. In each case Hawthorne includes an inconceivable innocence about the woman.
Hester Prynne In
‘the Scarlet Letter’ Essay, Research Paper In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter Hester Prynne and her daughter Pearl are isolated from society; this is shown by where they live, the action from people toward
Th Scarlet Letter Essay Research Paper The
Th Scarlet Letter Essay, Research Paper The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, the heroine is admired becuase of her strong will, and disregard for other’s views of her.
Scatlet Essay Research Paper The Scarlet Letter
Scatlet Essay, Research Paper The Scarlet Letter Argumentative Essay Nathaniel Hawthorne found a scarlet letter in an old custom house. This is where he came up with the idea for The Scarlet Letter. The Scarlet Letter caused much greif for each of the three Characters: Hester Prynne, Author Dimmesdale, and Roger Chillingworth.
The House Of Seven Gables Essay Research
Paper An ancient tale of the dreaded curse. The story written by Nathaniel Hawthorne The House of the Seven Gables is a typical example of this story. The story takes place in a simple time during the Puritan settlement in the New England area.
Changes Of A Scarlet Letter Essay Research
Paper In the first true American novel, The Scarlet Letter, written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, there is an inspiring young women named Hester Prynne. This character changes from the beginning of the novel to chapter thirteen.
Analysis Of Nathaniel Hawthorne
’s Young Goodman Brown Essay, Research Paper ld be at my very elbow” symbolizes that the forest is a mysterious and frightful place (244). With the words, “staff, which bore the likeness of a great black snake” (244) and “The moment his fingers touched them, they became strangely withered and dried up as with a week s sunshine” symbolizes the devil (246).
Untitled Essay Research Paper Young Goodman Brownby
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Young Goodman Brown by Nathaniel HawthorneIn short stories, I have learned that there is much more than what at first meets the eye. Almost everything in the story has meaning. All I
The Birthmark Essay Research Paper In Nathaniel
The Birthmark Essay, Research Paper In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark,” Hawthorne focuses on the single imperfection of Georgina, the bride of Aylmer. Alymer insists that with the removal of the hand shaped birthmark from her cheek, she will be flawless. Aylmer was “a man of science” (qtd. in 100).
The Birthmark And Rappaccinis Daughter
– Sophecles Essay, Research Paper Sophocles once said that ?The greatest griefs are those we cause ourselves.? That is to say that the source of most human turmoil lies within the beholder. This concept is true and is clearly proven in Nathaniel Hathorne?s short stories ?The Birthmark? and ?Rappaccini?s Daughter.? Hawthorne?s works both support Sophocles quotation by using irony and characterization to show that men are the source of their own turmoil.
Hawthorne And Symbolism Essay Research Paper Hawthorne
Hawthorne And Symbolism Essay, Research Paper Hawthorne and Symbolism Symbolism is a key in all or most writings. Symbolism is what the reader needs in order to use his imagination. In “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne, through different symbolism, Hawthorne writes about a man who in his coming of age.
Symbollism In The Scarlett Letter Essay Research
Paper British Literature Matt Gordon 9-22-96 Symbolism In The Scarlet Letter Symbolism in literature is the deepness and hidden meaning in a piece of work. It is often used to represent a moral or religious belief or value. Without symbolism literature is just a bunch of meaningless words on paper. The most symbolic piece of work in American Literature is Nathaniel Hawthorne?s The Scarlet Letter.
Scarlett Letter Essay Research Paper In
Scarlett Letter Essay, Research Paper In “The Scarlet Letter” , Nathaniel Hawthorne presents this novel in a dramatic point of view, starting with the scene of the prison. Hester is displayed as an adulterous woman in a Puritan society, where sin is harshly accounted for. She is forced to wear her badge of shame throughout life along side her daughter Pearl, yet the irony of it all is that she becomes one of the most helpful, phenomenal, virtuous people in her society.
Scarlet Letter Essay Research Paper OutcastsThe Scarlet
Scarlet Letter Essay, Research Paper Outcasts The Scarlet Letter, written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, was a book of many meanings. The novel paralleled to Hawthorne’s life, particularly his childhood. He used The Scarlet Letter as a
Scarlet Letter By Nathaniel Hawthorne Essay Research
Paper The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne is, on many levels, a struggle between good and evil. Each character falls on the spectrum of good and evi. Arthur Dimmesdale, an agent of God, is the town’s most respected reverend. He is a deeply moral man who regrets the sins he has committed. He practices self-mutilation to punish himself for an affair with a married woman, Hester Prynne.
Color Symbolism In The Scarlet Letter Essay
, Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter is story about Hestor Prynne, a woman who commits a sin and is filled with many feelings, including pride, surrounding that sin. Many of those around Hestor’s sin reflect similar emotions and feelings. Hawthorne employs many symbols throughout The Scarlet Letter.
The Faith Of Young Goodman Brown Essay
, Research Paper Timothy Wenk Bailey Engl. 1302 16 Feb. 2000 The Faith of Young Goodman Brown Faith, and the struggle to keep it, is the theme of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown.” In this story, Hawthorne gives Goodman Brown’s wife the name of Faith for the obvious symbolism and irony it creates.