Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper
It is said that there are two views about the use of the atomic bomb, orthodox and revisionist. The orthodox view is one of solely winning the war, while the revisionist view is one of intimidating the Soviet Union. While I do not believe that the atomic bomb was a necessary weapon in this war, I do think it helped the US kill two birds with one stone . I think it both won the war and scared the USSR in the process.
An important argument for the use of the atomic bomb was the distrust of the Soviet Union by the British and eventually the Americans. The British distrust is demonstrated in a memo of a meeting between the US and the UK on July 22,1943 where Winston Churchill states that “it would never do to have Germany or Russia win the race for something that might be used for international blackmail” [Document 12, pg. 42]. Both of these countries were afraid that the USSR might try to expand its influence after the war, and neither of them wanted to see the USSR with atomic power or wanted to lose their advantage in postwar negotiations. The US and UK were right about the USSR’s aims at expansion. Concern over Russian expansion was mentioned in Stimson’s diary entry on July 23, 1945 where he writes about Russian concerns for influence in the Pacific and present expanding influence in Eastern European countries [Document 73, pg. 209]. This fact really made the US want to keep the USSR from entering the Pacific and be able to influence the postwar outcome there. Again, this was another factor that meant the atomic bomb would have to be dropped if it would result in shortening the war and keeping the USSR out of the Pacific. These fears could be seen as part of the revisionist view.
By 1945, the US had the Japanese forces on the run. The planned invasion of Japan is discussed in the President’s meeting on June 18, 1945 with the Joint Chiefs of Staff [Document 52, pg.151]. In this meeting, the fanatical resistance of the Japanese is discussed along with the decision to continue with the “operation” before the planned assault on November 1 and to wait for the Japanese response. US leaders were uncertain when the Japanese would surrender, but they all agreed that eventually they would have no choice. The US knew of the “Japanese maneuverings for peace” on July 16, 1945 but wanted an unconditional surrender from the Japanese and presented them with the terms of surrender in the Proclamation of the Potsdam Conference [Document 74, pg. 215]. The Japanese did not want to lose their emperor and wanted it instilled as a condition of their surrender. In fact, many Japanese leaders had made the decision to end the war by May 1945 but were trying to convince the Japanese military leaders and to hold out for their condition for surrender. Unfortunately, Radio Tokyo broadcasted that Japan would not surrender and continue to fight on July 28, 1945, and had not responded to the Allies terms for surrender. This is part of the reason for the orthodox view.
This did not help curb the decision to drop the bomb since the US seemed to want to end the war as fast as possible, for political reasons. President Truman ordered two atomic bombs to be used during World War II. On August 6, 1945, “Little Boy” exploded about 1,750 to 1,900 feet above the city of Hiroshima. Instantly, 66,000 people were killed and over 69,000 people were injured. On August 9, 1945, “Fat Man” exploded about 1,650 feet above the city of Nagasaki. Instantly, 39,000 people were killed and over 25,000 people were injured. On August 11, 1945, Japan surrendered but only because they were allowed to keep their emperor [Document 87, pg. 246]. Japan had entered their surrender through the Swiss Government, which relayed the message to the US Government. Because of the third party involvement and negotiations, Japan officially surrendered on August 15, 1945. This helps reinforce the orthodox idea that the bomb ended the war.
In the end, I believe that the use of the atomic bomb and the decisions made during its development were like a double-edged sword. I agree with the comment that the Japanese would have surrendered before November 1, 1945 that was made in The Manhattan Project, page 272. This means that the Soviet Union would most likely not have had much influence in the Pacific after the war. Japan is an island with limited resources, and the naval blockades were strangling the nation. The atomic bomb might have prevented the immediate and extensive Soviet influence in the postwar Pacific, but we still witnessed several nations turn to communism and come under the umbrella of the Soviet Union. The research into the atomic bomb was necessary because Germany was doing the same. But you must remember that Germany, the major atomic threat, surrendered in May 1945. Because Japan did not have any atomic weapons, I do not believe it was necessary to use the bomb. This is possibly why the revisionists think it was used to scare the Soviets.
Many, but not all scientists were against the use of the bomb. In a report by A. H. Compton, E. O. Lawrence, J. R. Oppenheimer, and E. Fermi titled “Recommendations on the immediate use of nuclear weapons”, Oppenheimer wrote for the panel, “we can purpose no technical demonstration likely to bring an end to the war; we see no acceptable alternative to direct military use” [Document 51, pg. 149]. Many scientists felt that the US was not attacking Japan, but it was defending itself from a country that attacked the US first, at Pearl Harbor. However, many of these scientists did oppose the use of the second bomb so quickly. They felt the US should have waited longer for Japan to surrender.
The loss of innocent lives at Hiroshima and Nagasaki is inexcusable. President Truman agrees with this idea as seen in his comment made on August 10, 1945 where it is written about his order to halt all other plans for use of atomic weapons on Japan because “he didn’t like the idea of killing,” as he said, “[especially] all those kids” [Document 86, pg. 245]. These murders stained America’s image. Peace efforts were already underway with Japan and should have received full attention and given a chance before the bombs were dropped. This could also be why the revisionists think it was used as a scare tactic. In Stimson’s memo and letter to the President on July 2, 1945, he states the current situation of Japan and that “Japan is susceptible to reason in such a crisis to a much greater extent than is indicated by our current press and other current comment” [Document 58, pg. 167]. When the bombs were dropped, so were the morals of the United States.
While it is obvious that the bomb did indeed end the war as orthodox views dictate, it was not needed to end the war. Japan was likely to surrender, and they posed no threat of atomic warfare. But there were definite fears by US officials of soviet expansion that needed to be resolved. I think that the revisionist views of Soviet expansion fueled the decision to build the bomb, but the orthodox view of ending the war is what sparked the decision to drop it.
Другие работы по теме:
Niels Hendrik David Bohr Essay Research Paper
Niels Hendrik David Bohr Niels Hendrik David Bohr was one of the foremost scientists of the 20th century. The Nobel prizewinning physicist was known for his development of the theory of atomic fission that led to the development of the atomic bomb. He was born on Oct. 7, 1885, in Copenhagen, Denmark. His father, Christian, was a professor at the University of Copenhagen and his brother, Harold, was a great mathematician.
Atomic Bomb Essay Research Paper Through the
Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper Through the centuries, man has tried many attempts in inventing a mass killing mechanism. Alas, in 1945, such a mechanism was created. The atomic bomb was created after many years of the study of atoms. Finally, a way to split the atoms was born. Germany was the first to try, using uranium-235 to make a bomb.
Hiroshima Essay Research Paper The stories and
Hiroshima Essay, Research Paper The stories and events that unfold in John Hersey’s, Hiroshima, have certainly been eye-openers for me. As a child in middle school and high school I, we have all heard of the atomic bomb and of course of Hiroshima, but never in as much detail or on such a personal level as these stories.
Drop The Bomb Better Version Essay Research
Paper Atomic Bombs Dropped on Japan, Justified? On August 6th and 9th of 1945 U.S. bombers dropped atomic bombs on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, causing utter destruction and many deaths.
Hiroshima And Nagasaki Essay Research Paper TO
Hiroshima And Nagasaki Essay, Research Paper TO BOMB OR NOT TO BOMB This report is to discuss the dropping of the nuclear bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki to end World War II. Many people believe that this was the only way to get Emperor Hirohito of Japan to surrender to the United States. Some believe that there were other reasons for dropping the bombs.
The US Went Too Far Essay Research
Paper In order to end WW2 President Truman believed it was necessary to destroy an entire residential Japanese city with what was the most horrific weapon of its time, the atomic bomb. Near the end of WW2 almost all countries had stopped fighting and the allies were in victory, but the war between Japan and the U.S. was yet to be finished.
HiroshimaA Essay Research Paper HiroshimaThe first most
Hiroshima(A) Essay, Research Paper HiroshimaThe first most powerful bomb, which is called the atom bomb, was droppedon August 6 , 1945. In a city located in Japan, called Hiroshima. Withthese facts and the information i ve read from this one book called Hiroshima I have a very strong opinion which I will speak of now.
Atom Bomb Essay Research Paper World War
Atom Bomb Essay, Research Paper World War II was the most costly and the most deadly war towards Americans in its short existence. The plan was for the allies, the united States , France, Russia, and Britain to defeat Germany and then defeat the empire of Japan. After the defeat of Germany it was crucial for the Americans to end the war quickly because if the Soviet Union enterd the war against Japan and learned about the secrets of the atomic bomb it too could become a world power and dominate as Germany tried to do.
Hiroshima Essay Essay Research Paper The bomb
Hiroshima Essay Essay, Research Paper The bomb was dropped for many reasons and President Truman was faced with a hard decision to drop the bomb. During World War II, the first atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima. If he dropped the bomb he would surely have killed an estimated 200,000 Japanese and the city of Hiroshima.
The Atomic Bomb Essay Research Paper Were
The Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper Were the atomic bombings in Hiroshima and Nagasaki necessary to save allied livesand to end Japan s threat to world peace? Did the resulting loss of life cost more than a deadlyinvasion of the Japanese mainland? In August 1945, the first dropping of atomic bombs incivilian areas of Japan killed hundreds of thousands of innocent people.
Pushcart War Essay Research Paper Harry S
Pushcart War Essay, Research Paper Harry S. Truman Harry S. Truman was sworn into office on April 12, 1945 as the thirty-third President of the United States of America. He did not win an election, but he was the Vice President under President Franklin Roosevelt who had died so Harry Truman became President.
Harry S Truman Essay Research Paper The
Harry S. Truman Essay, Research Paper The 33rd president was Harry S. Truman. He took over office after Roosevelt died, during this time period of WWII. He had to make the decision of the atomic bomb and how to take care of getting peace in Europe and with the other countries. He dealt with these difficulties in correct and appropriate manner and in a respectful way.
Should We Have Dropped The Bomb Essay
, Research Paper The Decision to Drop the Bomb Our century has been dominated by a continuing expansion of military knowledge, but perhaps the weapon which had the most impact was the atomic bomb. It ended a world war, and inspired many to search of the secret of atomic weaponry. The A-bomb has inspired much controversy.
Atomic Bomb 12 Essay Research Paper Atomic
Atomic Bomb 12 Essay, Research Paper Atomic Bomb Now imagine yourself for a while being in one of the following Japanese cities, Hiroshima or Nagasaki. You are having a normal day like always when suddenly you look up at the sky and see an airplane drop millions of papers warning you to get out of your city. The paper fliers tell you to leave your city because you are about to be bombed by a single bomb capable of destroying the entire city.
The Atomic Bomb In World War 2
Essay, Research Paper Atomic Bombing: America s Only Choice It was discovered at the University of Chicago that neutrons striking the element uranium caused the atoms to split apart. The discovery, based on Einstein s E=mc2 theory that mass has the potential to unleash great amounts of raw energy, showed that among the pieces of a split atom were newly produced neutrons.
How The Atomic Bomb Affected World War
II Essay, Research Paper Many different innovations in military strategy and weaponry effected the outcome of World War II, but none so much as the development of the Atomic Bomb. The law of supply and demand has determined
Atom Bomb Essay Research Paper The United
Atom Bomb Essay, Research Paper The United States’ decision to drop the atomic bomb was intended to intimidate and keep the Soviet Union from invading Japan, but was also to end the war. Even without the atomic bomb, the Japanese empire would have collapsed. The United States, however, did not want to let the Soviet Union enter the war and invade Japan in order to spread communism.
Opposing Views Of The Atomic Bomb Essay
, Research Paper The United States? decision to drop an atomic bomb on Hiroshima was more of a diplomatic measure calculated to intimidate the Soviet Union in the post-Second-World-War era rather than a strictly military measure designed to force Japan?s unconditional surrender.
Decision To Drop The Atomic Bomb Essay
, Research Paper The atomic bomb controversy started on August 6, 1945. The Atomic bomb was first used in combat as it was dropped on Hiroshima, Japan. The explosive power of the weapon was finally displayed. Within a few days, another bomb was dropped on Nagasaki, Japan. The atomic bomb was one of the most destructive weapons of war used in combat.
Hiroshima Essay Research Paper Hiroshima The first
Hiroshima Essay, Research Paper Hiroshima The first most powerful bomb, which is called the atom bomb, was dropped on August 6 , 1945. In a city located in Japan, called Hiroshima. With these facts and the information i’ve read from this one book called Hiroshima I have a very strong opinion which I will speak of now.
Atomic Bomb Essay Research Paper The Right
Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper The Right Choice On August 6, 1945, at 8:15 the American plane The Enola Gay changed history forever. The plane dropped the first atomic bomb over the city of Hiroshima, Japan in a successful effort to ended World War II. The question on whether or not such a powerful attack was necessary to end the war has often been asked.
Atomic Bomb Essay Research Paper The history
Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper The history of the atomic bomb dates back to the early 1900 s when Einstein s theory of relativity proved a basis for understanding nuclear energy and showed that the atom contained vast energy. This energy seemed beyond men s grasp until the late 1930 s.
Atomic Bomb Controversy Essay Research Paper The
Atomic Bomb Controversy Essay, Research Paper The Atomic Bomb Controversy August 6, 1945- the atomic bomb was first used in combat as it was dropped on Hiroshima, Japan. The raw explosive power of the weapon was displayed. Within a few days, another bomb was dropped on Nagasaki, Japan. The atomic bomb was one of the most destructive weapons of war ever used in combat.
Atomic Bomb Essay Research Paper Was Atomic
Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper Was Atomic Bomb Necessary? August 6th, 1945, 70,000 lives were ended in a matter of seconds. The United States had dropped an atomic bomb on the city of Hiroshima. Today many argue over whether or not the US
Atomic Bomb Essay Research Paper This was
Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper This was the basis for the atomic bomb. Throughout this research paper, I will trace the history of the atomic bomb. In addition, who was involved and why, what happened in this event, and explain the impact that it had on the world. After Einstein predicted, that mass could be converted into energy.
Atomic Bomb Essay Research Paper In this
Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper In this paper, it will be discussed why the Atomic Bomb is the biggest method of destruction known to man. The paper will be discussing the results of the Atomic Bombs, along with the effects years after the initial explosion. People always wonder how many people actually died in the two Atomic Bombs which were dropped in Japan.
The A Bomb Essay Research Paper The
The A Bomb Essay, Research Paper The A-Bomb The effects of the atomic bomb were terrible. There’s no doubt in my mind that the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki was a costly mistake. Atomic bombs produce heat millions of degrees high and visible ultraviolet rays. Everyone and everything exposed to their blast is affected.
The Dropping Of The Atomic Bomb Essay
, Research Paper The dropping of the A-bomb was a direct result of world conflict, at the fault of everyone involved. The blame has been placed on many people, from Oppenheimer making the bomb to the pilots dropping it. However, the blame of the disastrous A-bomb cannot be placed solely on one person. There were many people who were involved in the dropping of the bomb and the making of the bomb.
Why Did We Drop The First Atomic
Bomb Essay, Research Paper Why Did We Drop the First Atomic Bomb Ever since the historical event occurred on August 6 of 1945, when the United States dropped the first atomic bomb on a city, people have asked why. There are different explanations of why the bomb was dropped from historians, from the individuals who made the decision to drop the bomb, and from general populations alike.
Atomic Question Essay Research Paper The Atomic
Atomic Question Essay, Research Paper The Atomic Question On August 6, 1945 the world was changed forever. On that day the United States of America dropped an atomic bomb over the city of Hiroshima. Never before has the world seen anything like it. Hiroshima had almost been decimated with an estimated 70-80,000 people were killed.
Nuclear Energy Essay Research Paper Nuclear Energy
Nuclear Energy Essay, Research Paper Nuclear Energy should be produced because it is an alternative to fossil fuel. Nuclear energy helps to conserve our national resources that we use as fuel such as coil, oil, and natural gas. Another pro of nuclear energy is that radiation that is given off by nuclear energy is mostly thought of a very dangerous thing but it can be used in positive ways too.
Untitled Essay Research Paper There has been
Untitled Essay, Research Paper There has been a long standing debate on why the atomic bomb was used to defeat Japan. The threat of Russian advancement in Europe and in Asia was enough