Both France and the United States have
a Bill of Rights. Both documents list rights of the individual.
The United States Constitution Bill of Rights, the French Rights of Man,
and the U.N. Universal Declaration of Human Rights all share one set purpose.
They all were created in the best interest of the citizens to ensure freedom
and equality throughout a nation. In this essay, I will compare the
similarities between three important U.S. Bill of Rights Amendments with
others written in the French Rights of Man and the U.N. Universal Declaration
of Human Rights.
For over 200 years, the Constitution has
served as the cornerstone of our Nation?s democracy. It has guaranteed
us freedom in our decisions and equality in our lives. The twenty-four
Amendments to the Constitution bind us together to form a nation and help
unite us with our government.
The first Amendment I would like to expand
upon is Amendment I. The first Amendment states, ?Congress shall
make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the
free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or the press;
or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government
for a redress of grievances.? This Amendment is basically stating
that all American citizens have the right to say and write what they wish,
the right to meet together peaceably, and the right to complain to the
government. It also states that Congress cannot set up an official
religion or keep people from worshiping as they wish. This Amendment
ensures the freedom of speech, press, assembly, and free exercise of religion.
This amendment is extremely significant
in my life. My family and I are Roman Catholics and worship our God
every Sunday in church. If that freedom of worship was taken away
from me or never instilled throughout my childhood, I am positive that
I would be leading a different type of lifestyle today. I am proud
of who I am and who my country allows me to be. The right to choose
your own religion is often taken for granted in our diversely filled country.
I discovered some interesting similarities
while comparing Amendment I from the U.S. Constitution Bill of Rights with
others written in the French Rights of Man. Article number 10 of
the French Rights states,? No one shall be disquieted on account of his
opinions, including his religious views, provided their manifestation does
not disturb the public order established by law.? This simply means
that the citizens of France have the freedom of speech as well as religion.
The rights depicted in the first Amendment can also be compared with the
rights in Article number 11 of the same doctrine, ?The free communication
of ideas and opinions is one of the most precious of the rights of man.
Every citizen may, accordingly, speak, write, and print with freedom, but
shall be responsible for such abuses of this freedom as shall be defined
by law.? In other words, this article is stating that the people
of France have the freedom of press as well as speech.
Another similarity I found to Amendment
I of the Bill of Rights came from the U.N. Universal Declaration of Human
Rights. In Articles 18 through Article 21, the doctrine states everyone
is entitled to freedom of thought, religion, opinion, speech, peaceful
assembly, and government action. These articles from both the French
Rights of Man and the UDHR are generally summarizing the concepts stated
in First Amendment of the Bill of Rights.
The second Amendment of the Bill of Rights
I selected for my comparison is the Fourth Amendment. Amendment VI
states, ?The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses,
papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall
not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause,
supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place
searched, and the persons or things to be seized.? In simpler terms,
this Amendment is stating that an official cannot search a person or his
home or seize his property without a warrant. A judge can issue a
warrant only if it is necessary to catch a criminal or prevent a crime.
This right?s primary purpose is to protect citizens against unwarranted
search.
A slightly similar right was written in
the U.N. Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Article 12 states,
? No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy,
family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honor and reputation.
Everyone has the right to the protection of the law against interference
or attack.? This statement is not completely the same as the one
explained above from the Bill of Rights. This Article only means that everyone
is allowed a sense of privacy in their lives. The law was made to
protect the nation?s people against attacks.
After reading the seventeen Articles of
the French Rights of Man, I learned that the doctrine does not supply a
similar right. The only Article which mentioned a citizens? property
was Article 17. It states, ?Since property is an inviolable and sacred
right, no one shall be deprived thereof except where public necessity,
legally determined, shall clearly demand it, and then only?? This
is only saying that the government can not take away someone?s land or
property unless legally permitted or it is a public necessity. There
is no guarantee of privacy in ones? property. A search is allowed
without a judge appointed warrant.
Amendment VI is another essential part
of the Bill of Rights Doctrine. It sates, ?In all criminal prosecutions,
the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial
jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed,
which?and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to
be confronted with the witnesses against him; ? and to have the assistance
of counsel for his defense.? This Amendment means that a person accused
of a crime must be tried quickly. He cannot be held in jail while
the police look for evidence. The trial must be held in public.
The Amendment also states that the accused has a right to have his case
heard by a jury in the state the crime was committed. He must be
told of what he is accused and must be able to see and hear witnesses against
him. If he cannot pay for a lawyer, the court has to appoint one.
Other articles that protect rights to a
fair trial and council cannot be found in both the French Rights of Man
and in the UDHR. The right of a fair trial is not mentioned in the
French Rights of Man. It does state although, ?As all persons are
held innocent until they shall have been declared guilty, if the arrest
shall be deemed indispensable, all harshness not essential to the securing
of the prisoner?s person shall be severely repressed by law,? in Article
9. This means everyone arrested is thought to be innocent until declared
or labeled guilty. In the Universal Declaration rather, Articles
10 and 11 state that everyone is entitled to a fair and public trial.
It also says that all men charged with crimes are innocent until proven
guilty. Even though this sounds similar to the U.S. doctrine, I found
one difference. The 6th Amendment guarantees the supply of defense.
A public assistance lawyer is appointed if the accused has no representation
in court.
There are a few rights listed in the U.N.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights which are not included in both the
French Rights of Man and the U.S. Bill of Rights. One right mentioned
in the UDHR is Article 4. ?No one shall be held in slavery or servitude;
slavery and the slave trade shall be prohibited in all their forms.?
This right is stating that slavery, in any form, is illegal. The
use of slaves and the trading of slaves is not permitted by law.
Another human right that wasn?t written of in the other two doctrines is
Article 16. This article of the UDHR states that any men and women
over the legal age have the right to marry. This gives a person the
right to start a family without any limitation due to race, religion or
nationality. Article 13 is another right that was only included in
this doctrine. It states, ?Everyone has the right to freedom of movement
and residence within the borders of each state. Everyone has the
right to leave any country, including his own, and return to his country.?
This article gives a citizen freedom to come and go as they please.
Travel and choice of residence is a legal option.
In closing, this comparison proved that
the U.S. Constitution Bill of Rights, the French Rights of Man, and the
UDHR hold many similarities, as well as differences. These three
doctrines were great accomplishments that united people together to form
strong world powers.
Другие работы по теме:
French Revolution 2 Essay Research Paper Have
French Revolution 2 Essay, Research Paper Have you ever thought, “Did the world just become the way it is gradually over time, or was there an actual turning point that can be referred to?” The answer is yes there was an actual turning point, the French Revolution. The French Revolution was a turning point in European political and social history, and was a period that changed the outcome of world history dramatically.
Arc De Triomph Essay Research Paper Jeremy
Arc De Triomph Essay, Research Paper Jeremy Crowe Arch de Triomphe The famous Arch de Triomphe was a monument of all the battles Napoleon won during his rein in France. The Arch was dedicated to Paris in 1836. The designer of the Arch was a man named named Jean Francois-Therese Chalgrin. The designer wanted it to be an impresive Arch so he made the arch 165 feet high and 145 feet long.
Pearl Harbor 3 Essay Research Paper Position
Pearl Harbor 3 Essay, Research Paper Position Paper Although the bombing of Pearl Harbor and events of World War II are far behind us and still in our minds, the United States under any and all circumstances would have gotten involved in the war eventually no matter what. Sure Pearl Harbor was the obvious reason why the United States decided to join the war, but there are some other less obvious clues that point towards our involvement no matter what the situation.
Napolean Bonaparte Essay Research Paper Napoleon Bonaparte
Napolean Bonaparte Essay, Research Paper Napoleon Bonaparte ? French Revolution Napoleon was the cure of the French Revolution when he came to power. It would be impossible to put them together. From what was chaos throughout France during the Revolution, came a new government that Napoleon created. He was able to balance the government?s budgets and setting up national banks thus helping and supporting the economy of France.
Napolean Essay Research Paper The qualities of
Napolean Essay, Research Paper The qualities of a Romantic hero are clearly displayed through the ambitions and actions of Napoleon Bonaparte. Napoleon’s triumphs and ideas for France’s future truly made him a Romantic hero.
War Essay Research Paper The war between
War Essay, Research Paper The war between Japan and the United States did not have to happen. It could have been prevented by diplomacy in 1941. The United States was Japan?s principle supplier of scrap metal and oil. In 1940 Japan signed a treaty with the government of France for the establishment of airbases in French Indochina.
Western Front Essay Research Paper On 3rd
Western Front Essay, Research Paper On 3rd August, 1914, German troops crossed the Belgian border in the narrow gap between Holland and France. The German First and Second Armies swept aside the small Belgian Army and by 20th August had occupied Brussels.
Robespierre 1794 Essay Research Paper 1794 Paris
Robespierre 1794 Essay, Research Paper 1794 Paris, France At the expense of thousands of lives, the recent terror that has struck France has helped to rescue France from the brink of total collapse. The leadership of Robespierre and the
Cities On France Essay Research Paper Toulose
Cities On France Essay, Research Paper Toulose is a city in southern France, Capital of Haute -Garonne Department, on the Garonne River and the Canal du Midi. Its major Commercial , Transportation and Manufacturing
World War II Essay Research Paper On
World War II Essay, Research Paper On September 1, 1939, a wave of German planes roared over Poland. A huge mass of smoke covered the sky with dive-bombers and disintegrated Polish planes still on the ground. Then, tracks of German tanks and footsteps of troops marched into Polish territory to clean up any unfinished business.
Archudukes
… Wars In Europe Got A + Essay, Research Paper -Archduke Francis Ferdinardo of Austia Hungarywas killed in Sarajero,bosnia -The blackhand-wanted bosnia to be part of Serbia-not Austria Hungary. Serbia
Three Musketeers Essay Research Paper THE THREE
Three Musketeers Essay, Research Paper THE THREE MUSKETEERS The Three Musketeers is a wonderful story mixed with romance and action. It is about one young man’s journey from boyhood to manhood. On this quest he ironically befriends three of the former musketeers. D’Artagnan , starts his voyage in the provinces of France hoping to make his way to Paris.
Europe Essay Research Paper EuropeFrom June 31
Europe Essay, Research Paper Europe From June 31 to July 31 1997, my family went to Europe. We went on 4 airplanes the whole trip. We went to 7 countries. Now I will tell you about my trip.
Paris Essay Research Paper L
Paris Essay, Research Paper L’Annйe Derniиre j’ai travel des vacances а l’espagne avec mes parents et il n’йtait pas trиs bon. Cette annйe je suis allй а Paris en france avec mes Amis. Nous sommes allйs lа-bas par eurotunel. Nous sommes arrivйs а Calais а 2:00. Le temps йtait trиs chaud lа-bas. Nous avons voyagй а Paris en voiture sur le N1.
Twenty And Ten Essay Research Paper The
Twenty And Ten Essay, Research Paper The name of the book: TWENTY AND TEN THE AUTHOR: CLAIRE HUCHET BISHOP THE PUBLISHER: SCHOLASTIC INC. COPYRIGHT DATE: 1980
Hitler Essay Research Paper VoltaireVoltaire was born
Hitler Essay, Research Paper Voltaire Voltaire was born in Paris, France in 1694 to the name of Fran ois Marie Arouet. Voltaire was the son of a notary and he was educated at the Jesuit College Louis-le-Grand. During his life Voltaire was unjustly imprisoned two times. One time from 1717 to 1718 he was sent to the Bastillle for insults to the regent, Philippe II d Orl ans, which were wrongly ascribed to him.
Richelieu Essay Research Paper RichelieuRichelieu was a
Richelieu Essay, Research Paper Richelieu Richelieu was a French cardinal and statesman, who more than anyone else promoted absolutism in France and laid the foundations of the country’s 17th-century grandness. He was born in Paris on September 9, 1585, and set out on a military career. In order to retain the bishopric of Lu on in the family, however, Richelieu switched to theology and at age 22 was ordained a bishop.
Euro Essay Research Paper Tax breaks promised
Euro Essay, Research Paper Tax breaks promised by France and Italy to lorry drivers who mounted fuel price protest blockades in the summer looked to set to cause controversy among EU finance ministers meeting in Brussels today (19 January). The concessions are illegal under EU competition law and upset some of the countries? EU partners who were angry that the French and Italian governments gave in to the protesters.
European Union Essay Research Paper EUROPE ESSAYThe
European Union Essay, Research Paper EUROPE ESSAY The European Union is a movement that will let Europe trade easier. Europeans are removing the borders to let it be easier to enter into a different country. They figured that the U.S. had few problems with it, they are going to try.
Britain And France Essay Research Paper Britain
Britain And France Essay, Research Paper Britain and France remained leading powers in Western Europe as Spain and the United Netherlands declined because these two countries gained so much power and economic strength. France possessed the largest European population during this time. It also had wiser political leadership, economic recovery and consolidation, and a less ambitious foreign policy.
French Government Essay Research Paper The modern
French Government Essay, Research Paper The modern French government is run very much like the government of the United States. France is a democratic republic that is divided into three branches,
Pablo Picasso Essay Research Paper No artist
Pablo Picasso Essay, Research Paper No artist has dominated the 20th century in the way Pablo Picasso has. This extraordinarily gifted Spanish artist, working most of his life in France, produced a voluminous body of work in a variety of styles that influenced nearly every major trend of the first half of this century.
The Characters From A Tale Of Two
Cities Essay, Research Paper List of Characters For A Tale of Two Cities Lucie Manette – A young woman from France who grew up in England. She was raised as a child of Tellson’s Bank when her parents were thought to be
Louis X1V Outline Essay Research Paper I
Louis X1V Outline Essay, Research Paper I. Introduction II. Political Crisis A. Religious Disputes 1.Development of science (the new philosphy) a. Undermining of church authority and Kings in Rule
The Cost Of Change Essay Research Paper
What is change? Defined in the Webster Dictionary as a Shift from one to another , change seems for the better. But is it? What is the cost of change? What must go wrong, for something to go right? How many people must die for a certain cause or change in history? It seems that the cost of change is always greater than the change itself.
Monet Essay Research Paper Several years ago
Monet Essay, Research Paper Several years ago when I was ten I had an opportunity to travel to France. I went to a few museums which I liked including Yhe Louvre and The Pompidou Center. The museum I found
Impression Sunrise Essay Research Paper Impression SunriseTowards
Impression, Sunrise Essay, Research Paper Impression, Sunrise Towards the later half of the nineteenth century, many artists were pursuing new avenues in their artistic representations. They were perturbed at the rigid and constricting regulations of the Salon, and some artists decided to form and independent exhibition.
Les Miserables 23 Essay Research Paper Les
Les Miserables 23 Essay, Research Paper Les Miserables, written by Victor Hugo in 1862 is a wonderful story of life in France in the nineteenth century. This novel shows how people have to struggle to be a part of the society. Les Miserables reveals the cruelty in France society’s pressure on the poor, the outcast, and the criminal.
Metric System Essay Research Paper Metric SystemThe
Metric System Essay, Research Paper Metric System The Metric System, also known as the System Internationale (SI) was developed in France in 1799. The Metric System was created because the French and English were not in agreement politically, therefore the French did not want anything to do with the English including their system of measurements.
France Society Essay Research Paper Luis LereboursFrench
France Society Essay, Research Paper Luis Lerebours French II 5/19/99 French Culture Introduction Not large by North American standards (about the size of Texas), France is nonetheless extremely diverse: it concentrates a wealth of scenery, regional identities each with their own particular flavor defined by cultural and historic differences.
Calvin John Biography Essay Research Paper CALVIN
Calvin John Biography Essay, Research Paper CALVIN JOHN (1509-64). When John Calvin was a boy in France, Martin Luther launched the Protestant Reformation in Germany. Two decades later Calvin became the second of the great 16th-century reformers. His work and teachings had a profound impact on the development of Christianity.
French Presentation Essay Research Paper L
French Presentation Essay, Research Paper Lґanee derniere jґai ete en france, je suis reste dans un vieil hotel pendant trois semaines. Lґhotel etait tres confortable et grand. Je suis arrive a lґhotel a six heures. Lґhotel etait situe a paris.
Tour De France Essay Research Paper Tour
Tour De France Essay, Research Paper Tour De FranceThe tour de france is the most popular bike race in the world. It is held in July Of every year. In France.More than 200 competitors race for about 3200km in 25-30 days. This race was started back in 1903 by an ex-biker named Henri Desgranges. Who at the time was the owner of a struggling french newspaper.