– Stories From Many Cultures Essay, Research Paper
Compare and contrast the two stories by R.K. Narayan. Which story do you prefer and why?
In all the stories and authors featured in "Global Tales", R.K. Narayan is the most respected and well-known author. From the short description of him at the end of the book, he created a space for himself called "Malgudi" and developed his own characters, like a puppet master making his own puppets from cloth and giving them life when he does the show. His stories are universal, probably because the themes and characters of the stories are easy to identify with. He should be ninety-seven this year (year 2000). From what I know, his other books include " Malgudi Days", where " An Astrologer?s Day" is taken from.
Narayan is a very observant man, sharp and sarcastic at the same time. His sarcasm become humour and it is not very obvious sometimes. We have to read between the lines to catch the joke. He is very descriptive in his writing and his world comes alive with the mood through the informative and colourful description, the characteristics and the internal thinkings of the characters, the suspense and the dialogues used. I especially admire the way he brings the story to a close, not too dramatic, yet satisfactory. Some writers often leave an unfinished ending where it is up to the reader to decide, treating this as their style and adding a sense of mystery to the story. However, these are sometimes the most horrible kind of ending, not only irritating, but also annoying. The ending is the element that wraps up the whole story, yet the writer left it out, like a jigsaw piece went missing. It is not a complete piece of writing. Lastly, I find R.K. Narayan to be naughty at times, from the way he phrased his sentence, and the sarcasm, but we like it.
In " An Astrologer?s Day", an astrologer meets a stranger and tells his fortune. Surprisingly, the "fake" astrologer managed to tell what was true for the stranger. Then, it is only when the astrologer reveals his secret, did we know how his "magic" worked.
We are brought into the world of the streets of India where there is little lighting but "a bewildering cris-cross of light rays and moving shadows". The in-depth description gives us the setting, which can be seen in our minds. Not only using the sense of sight and sound, Narayan also gives us the face of the astrologer with a forehead "resplendent with sacred ash and vermilion", having eyes that " sparkled with a sharp abnormal gleam" and a "painted forehead" and "dark whiskers", topping it off with a "saffron-coloured turban". The ?colourful? astrologer contrasts with its semi-dark surroundings, attracting the customers like "bees are attracted to cosmos or dahlia stalks". We should not only focus on plot, we should also focus on the setting too.
On the other hand, the introduction to "Crime and Punishment" did not have the variety of colours as seen in "An Astrologer?s Day". "Crime and Punishment", a story about an impatient teacher who slapped his student on impulse, then was exploited by the child, resulting in an unexpected ending later.
In "Crime and Punishment", we do not get a detailed description, only a brief description about the boy as " all dimples, smiles and sweetness—-only wings lacking". The nursery is mentioned but not in detail as compared to "An Astrologer?s Day". "Crime and Punishment" focus more on character, in contrast to the focus on setting in "An Astrologer?s Day".
The moods are different in these two stories. In " An Astrologer?s Day", it is ?heavy? with mystery and amazement while in "Crime and Punishment"; it is more relaxing and light. On similarities, humour and language of the two are evident.
For style, R.K. Narayan used humour and old language to bring out the unique element of the story. The story is mostly sarcastic and subtle, sometimes added with a pinch of irony, like "when he told the person before him, ? In many ways, you are not getting the fullest results of your efforts,? nine out of ten were disposed to agree with him. Or he gave an analysis of character: ?Most of your troubles are due to your nature. How can you be otherwise with Saturn where he is? You have an impetuous nature and a rough exterior. This endeared him to their hearts immediately, for even the mildest of us loves to think that he has a forbidding exterior". Narayan is mocking at people?s naivety and stupidity, especially the fortune about Saturn, as it is nothing but rubbish. In " Crime and Punishment", the boy is described to be "a little angel, all dimples, smiles and sweetness—only wings lacking", which is very sarcastic as the boy is not a little angel but a boy who blackmailed his teacher.
The old language that Narayan used sometimes makes the readers confused. Words like "contrariness", "wholesome (slap)" and "dull desperation" are not commonly used in modern stories. This can be quite difficult, as we are not used to the language.
Despite its similarities and differences, they are two stories which readers will enjoy. The plot, climax and the role reversal are important elements of the stories. Role reversal is an interesting element as one character becomes another, their actions are different from their usual selves, giving the readers a good laugh and add on to the irony of the story. Most of the characters have no names, thus it can be any teacher or boy, making Narayan?s stories universal and popular. Another special element is that we pick up clues along the way, like how the astrologer came to know of Guru Nayak?s past and why the boy is not a little angel or a healthy citizen as thought by the parents. In all, both are unique in their own way and its endings are memorable.
Choosing between the two, I prefer "An Astrologer?s Day" due to its exciting plot, building up climax and the clues along the story. The plot is like a jigsaw puzzle, giving us pieces of ?jigsaws? (clues) like the astrologer "had left his village without any previous thought or plan" and "caught a glimpse of his face (stranger) by the match light". They all seemed to refer to the astrologer?s past and his looking at the stranger, all so normal and not so obvious. This adds to the excitement of deciphering and reading between the lines. I especially admire the astrologer?s intelligence and sharpness for his "working analysis of mankind?s troubles" and his "matter of study, practice and shrewd guess work" as he was not only calm in hiding his initial panic when seeing the person he killed years ago to be alive, he managed to use his wits to con Guru Nayak of his money using the advantage that Guru Nayak does not recognize him due to the lack of lighting and the astrologer?s ?make-up?. This is the irony: Guru Nayak is paying money to the enemy he is looking for when he is supposed to take revenge by beating him to a pulp.
By picking up clues along the way, it builds up the curiosity and climax of the story. This element is not easily found in "Crime and Punishment". This, thus, keeps us in suspense and excitement.
There is also an elaborate description of the place and the astrologer to give us the picture of the setting in our mind. This is not easy as not every story/writer is capable of, yet the details made us feel as if we are looking and following the story at the astrologer?s stall, like watching a movie.
The author skillfully ?misleads? us to ?believe? that the astrologer?s action of killing the man to be justified calling the astrologer "our friend" and describing the stranger to be grumpy ("grumbled some vague reply), rude ("you call yourself an astrologer?") and violent ("Answer this and go. Otherwise I will not let you go till you disgorge all your coins"), making the astrologer look like the good guy and the stranger to be the big bad wolf. However, the astrologer?s action of murder cannot be justified or taken lightly as he nearly killed a man, it is only natural for the victim to seek revenge as he was left for dead. Murder is murder, committing murder when drunk is still a crime, thus I detest the astrologer for being a coward, running away and ?killing? the man. However, I believe the astrologer had been regretful and guilty for ?killing? the man ("Do you know a great load is gone from me today?"), thus I sympathesized and pitied the astrologer for this.
Using the clues, I did some guess-work and was not surprised by the astrologer?s revelation, but what surprised me is the irony that the man had cheated the astrologer by giving less annas while the astrologer cheated Guru Nayak by telling him that his enemy "was crushed under a lorry" and to "never travel southward again". Both of them resorted to cheating, a common characteristic, probably the reason why both had a bad quarrel while gambling.
Другие работы по теме:
Do Fairy Tales Loes There Mean Essay
, Research Paper Comparison Paper One chilly night you decide to pull out your old book of fairytales. As you dust off the cover you start reading along, and as you finish the tale. You re struck with a large volt of curiosity, you realize that it was not the same as the tale you were told when you were little. You reread the authors name and see it is the Charles Perrualt.
Chaucer 2
Chaucer – The Canterbury Tales Essay, Research Paper By far Chaucer’s most popular work, although he might have preferred to have been remembered by Troilus and Criseyde, the Canterbury Tales was unfinished at his death. No less than fifty-six surviving manuscripts contain, or once contained, the full text.
The Golden Apples Of The Sun Essay
, Research Paper Twenty two stories, each as enchanting as the last. From tales of small towns, spaceships, and even sea serpents, Bradbury conjures up a wealth of images with which to astound us. Some tales have a twist, some don’t, but each and every one has charm. From the opening story the reader is hooked, drawn into Ray Bradbury’s universe.
Global Warming Essay Research Paper Like the
Global Warming Essay, Research Paper Like the glass in a greenhouse, certain gases that occur naturally in the atmosphere tend to trap the sun’s heat. This natural "greenhouse
The Pardoner And The Knight Essay Research
Paper ?The Canterbury Tales? is a collection of stories, which are told by different characters to serve as entertainment on their journey to Canterbury. The characters who arise during the different tales, and those who tell the tales, play a vital role in understanding the story, and the mind frame of the English people living in the 15th century.
Two Warriors A Comparison And Contrast
Of Beowulf And The Knight From The Canterbury Tales Essay, Research Paper The Canterbury Tales CharacterKnightBeowulf Quest- fights religious wars - fights for god
Global Warming Essay Research Paper My position
Global Warming Essay, Research Paper My position on global warming is that despite the media’s claim of a rising climate, in reality there is no cause for concern. Inane reports regarding global warming are yuppie-tree-hugger propaganda. The information defending their case is misleading and inaccurate.
Canterbury Tales Essay Research Paper Throughout an
Canterbury Tales Essay, Research Paper Throughout an author’s literature, many times we find common themes; this is definitely true in Geoffrey Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales. In the literary work, the reader can find common themes through many of the tales. In the Wife of Bath tale, The Miller’s tale, and the Pardoner’s tale, it is easy to see that one of the main themes through the book is that women are the downfall of men.
Industrial Revolution Essay Research Paper How Global
Industrial Revolution Essay, Research Paper How Global Warming Relates to the Industrial Revolution Global Warming relates back to the Industrial Revolution in many ways. During the Industrial Revolution many new inventions were made that would make life easier for people back then and also in the future.
The Pardoner And The
“Brothers” Essay, Research Paper The Pardoner and The “Brothers” Throughout literature, relationships can often be found between the author of a story and the story that he writes. In Geoffrey Chaucer’s frame story, Canterbury Tales, many of the characters make this idea evident with the tales that they tell.
Critical Lens Essay Research Paper In life
Critical Lens Essay, Research Paper In life we come to many conflicts. Some are easy some are hard. The quote, “The harder the conflict, the more glorious the triumph” by
Pardoners Tale Essay Research Paper The Pardoner
Pardoners Tale Essay, Research Paper The Pardoner’s Tale vs. Sir Gawain and the Green Knight Throughout literature, relationships can often be found between the author of a story and the story that he writes. In Geoffrey Chaucer’s frame story, Canterbury Tales, many of the characters make this idea evident with the tales that they tell.
Literary Criticism In Canterbury Tales Essay Research
Paper There are numerous sources of literary criticism of The Canterbury Tales, as well as specifically about “The Miller’s Tale.” “Telling stories of low sexual intrigue (fabliaux)…There is nothing like [these tales] in Middle English and nothing like [these tales] anywhere in English literature” (Life of Geoffrey Chaucer, 172).
Global Problems Essay Research Paper Global problems
Global Problems Essay, Research Paper Global problems affect the modern world. Today?s rapid changes have made countries more interdependent than ever before, shrinking the world into a global village. As the world grows smaller, events in any one area have a greater impact on other parts of the world. National borders do not limit the effects of pollution or environmental destruction.
Arabian Nights Essay Research Paper Throughout history
Arabian Nights Essay, Research Paper Throughout history there have been many tales passed down from generation to generation. Arabian Nights has been one of them. Arabian Nights contains an outer and inner framework. The outer consists of Scherazade telling stories to the Sultan each night to stay alive.
Fairy Tales Essay Research Paper Fairy Tales
Fairy Tales Essay, Research Paper Fairy Tales were composed to express eternal joys, sorrows, hopes, and dreams of human kind. Although these folk tales may be aimed at children, but they surely reflect the values, assumptions, and concerns of our cultural traditions. They always portrayed one moral that obedience, good manners, beauty, and hard work always lead to rewards while opposing characteristics are consistently punished.
Global Warming Effects Essay Research Paper How
Global Warming Effects Essay, Research Paper How the World is changing due to the effects caused by Global Warming The reason for this topic is our increasingly changing climate. Every year our climate
The Miller And The Reeve- As Corrupt
As They’ll Ever Be Essay, Research Paper “The Miller?s Tale” and “The Reve?s Tale” from The Canterbury Tales are very closely related. They both deal with the relationship between a jealous man, his wife, and a young scholar(s), and they both are immoral stories that contain sex and violence. This proves that the Miller and the Reeve are two very corrupt individuals.
Deciet And Trickery In The Canterbury Tales
Essay, Research Paper Deceit and Trickery in the Canterbury Tales In Geoffrey Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales, the reader is introduced to the tales of the miller and the reeve, which are both written in the fabliau genre. Both the Miller’s Tale and the Reeve’s Tale demonstrate quick, snappy endings that entertain the audience.
Global Crisis Essay Research Paper In times
Global Crisis Essay, Research Paper In times of global crisis, is it reasonable to expect that nation-states will put aside rivalries and join together to deal with the crisis?
Beauty And The Beast Essay Research Paper
The message that fairy tales send readers about female virtues has been debated time and time again. Some people, like Karen Rowe, believe that fairy tales exhibit “passivity, dependency, and self sacrifice”. While many fairy stories embody self-sacrifice, passivity and dependency are two virtues not widely portrayed in fairy tales.
Education And The Global Economy Essay Research
Paper The idea of “getting rich quick” do to the global economy is very common these days. It is easy to see throughout the articles that many people have built multi-million dollar fortunes because of technology and global based business. It seems that ordinary people who had a vision of a global economy tailored their ideas to fit this new way of life.
The Problem Of Global Warming Essay Research
Paper The Problem of Global Warming The problem of global warming, an increase in the average temperature on Earth, is getting worse. The Earth has warmed 0.3 to 0.6 degrees Celsius since
Canterbury Tales Prologue Essay Research Paper
In Geoffrey Chaucer s prologue to The Canterbury Tales, he introduces a character that he describes with very high esteem. Through direct and indirect characterization we learn Chaucer s feelings and facts that help us get to know his character, the knight.
George Sorors Essay Research Paper Many economists
George Sorors Essay, Research Paper Many economists agree that there is a significant imbalance between the growth of global economy and the development of a free society. One of these economists who agrees with this point is George Soros. Soros bases his dilemma mainly on the Thai crisis that hastened the currency meltdown in Asia.
Cantebury Tales Vs The Decameron Essay Research
Paper There are many different roles for women shown in “The Canterbury Tales” and “The Decameron”. Both books take place around the same time frame, 1300AD. “The Canterbury Tales”, takes place in London, England and “The Decameron” takes place in Florence, Italy. It would be just to think that since both books take place in a western civilization, both books would reflect the same morals and daily life styles.
Cantebury Tales Essay Research Paper Canterbury Tales
Cantebury Tales Essay, Research Paper Canterbury Tales tells many stories from medieval literature and provides a great variety of comic tales. Geoffrey Chaucer injects many tales of humor into the novel. Chaucer provides the reader with many light-hearted tales as a form of comic relief between many serious tales.
THE CANTERBURY TALES Essay Research Paper The
THE CANTERBURY TALES Essay, Research Paper The Canterbury Tales Chaucer uses satire in the Canterbury Tales to expose his attitude towards the Catholic Church of the Middle Ages. The first way in which he does this is by satirizing a common nun of the Middle Ages. Chaucer, in The Canterbury Tales, tells of a nun who is supposed to be married to the church.
Canterbury Tales Wife Of Bath 3
Essay, Research Paper Canterbury Tales: Wife of Bath Chaucer portrays the Wife of Bath as if she is a hypocrite, although, beneath the words, there is a great deal of wisdom involved.