“Carpe Diem” Theme Essay, Research Paper
Coleman 1
Katherine Anne Porter: Master of the “Carpe Diem” Theme
Katherine Anne Porter’s writings demonstrate several predominant themes that occur throughout many of her stories. Porter’s writings all encompass her personal ideas regarding death and dying, mourning, loss and loneliness, injustice and rejection. Katherine Porter explores the lives of her characters, who seem drawn into disillusionment and despair. Through her stories, readers get a strong sense of the characters’ personal guilt, isolation and sadness. The main recurring theme in her work coincides with the “Carpe Diem” philosophy, meaning to “seize the day” and to act in and enjoy the present. Porter conveys to the reader that people should live for each day and not dwell on the past, as doing so will only lead to a life of unhappiness and regret.
Katherine Anne Porter excels at showing peoples personal rejections. In “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall”, she shows how people can go through their entire lives feeling rejected and inadequate. Ellen “Granny” Weatherall is jilted at the altar over sixty years
Coleman 2
earlier, and never truly recovers from this rejection of love. After the jilting, she forces herself to give some order to her life, but by doing so Granny is trying to reconcile herself to being left at the altar. Granny Weatherall lives her entire life comparing her life with John to the life she could have had with George, had he not left her at the altar. Porter demonstrates here that Granny’s life, which was filled with mourning, loss and rejection was wholly due to her jilting sixty years earlier. Because of her jilting sixty years earlier, Granny never actually loved anyone. “Love was denied Granny the day she was jilted and she herself never again dared to love. But without love, Granny’s radically human hurt was never healed” (Wiesenfarth 108). Granny Weatherall spent her life simply going through the daily motions, but she was never satisfied for what she had achieved during her lifetime.
Porter conveys this very well in the story through her stream-of-consciousness perspective on Granny’s deathbed. “The next world enters the story to give meaning to this world. The boundary situation is here for the sake of the land of the living, not of the dead” (Wiesenfarth 108). At the end of the story Granny reasons that she has had an
Coleman 3
unfulfilling life due solely to her jilting all those years ago; but in reality, through perseverance and hard work, Granny has surmounted life’s obstacles and endured into old age with children who love her. However, buried in Granny’s most secret self, there is the vivid memory of her rejection. She has not been able to share this deep hurt with her loved ones, and it has cut off a central and tender part of herself from everyone. Porter has drawn Granny’s character so well, her story becomes an example for readers to see: an example to show people that they should not waste today for disappointments of yesterday.
Porter also shows this rejection theme in “Flowering Judas.” Laura, the main character, is in love with Eugenio, who is a political prisoner. Braggioni, the leader of the revolution and suitor of Laura, frightens her because she is not in love with him and he is known for his cruelty and vanity. Laura has been trying to resist his advances without appearing to do so. She is living in Mexico and teaching and does not know why, as she is beginning to disagree with revolutionary theories. The struggle for Laura is that she frequently finds herself being unhappy and depressed with her life. “In Laura, the principle rejection is exposed as having over-extended
Coleman 4
itself. Through its operation she has become, for all her youth and femininity, a strong, detached, self-sufficient woman; but she has also become almost completely isolated from humanity” (Nance 23).
Katherine Porter implies through Laura’s characterization that simply going through the motions of life does not guarantee one’s happiness. Laura’s love for Eugenio is the source of her unhappiness. “The principal plot element employed to expose the bitterness of Laura’s isolationism is her imputed love for Eugenio; the principal means of revealing the presence of her rejection theme in the story will be the demonstration of the unreality of that love” (Nance 24). Laura is consumed with guilt to the extent of suffering from moral depression. She merely goes through the motions of being a teacher and rebel without comprehension of the reasons behind her actions. While Braggioni will betray anyone, Laura betrays herself. She is unable to differentiate between her concepts of life as it should be and life as it actually is.
Porter’s works also embody many concepts of justice. “Many of her best stories are, in fact, about the efforts of individuals to maintain, attain, or regain justice in their dealings with others” (Moddelmog 64). In “Granny
Coleman 5
Weatherall,” Granny did not achieve justice until the day she died. She spent her life unhappy, unsatisfied and unfulfilled. In death, Granny Weatherall finally receives the justice she deserves- realization that something is missing in her life, true happiness. Ultimately, on her deathbed Granny comprehends that she has lived her life never fully recovering from her jilting sixty years earlier. Thus, this enlightenment is Granny’s “justice.”
Porter’s justice concept is also prevalent in “Flowering Judas.” Laura has lived her life in isolation and sadness. She never understands the reasons why she is still living in Mexico under false pretenses. Finally, at the end of the story, Laura awakes from her nightmare to realize she was wrong living her life the way she has. It took this epiphany for Laura to come to terms with the fact that there were major problems with her life. This nightmare holds as an example to show that Laura is at a point of great unhappiness in her life, and it took this dream to make her realize this unhappiness. “The desire to right personal wrongs sometimes drives Porter’s characters to extremes” (Moddelmog 64).
Coleman 6
Porter’s most dominant concept in her works is the emphasis of people’s imperfections. She does this to reinforce the idea that bad things happen in life, but one should learn, grow and move on. For example, Granny in “Granny Weatherall” is “one of those women who are respected exactly in proportion as they have escaped from the spiritual limitations of their surroundings by dominating them” (Nance 42). Granny Weatherall could not control the fact that George left her at the altar, so she in turn gave some order to her life. But, by doing so, she never actually got over George. “Granny Weatherall believes that her prayers and her exemplary life will ensure that she will never again feel like she did on the day she was jilted” (Piedmont-Marton 2). This false hope demonstrates another example of Granny Weatherall’s imperfections.
In “Flowering Judas,” Porter vividly points out Laura’s imperfections. Laura is insecure and feels unhappy about virtually everything in her life. She does not love Braggioni, who constantly makes advances to her, and the man she does love is in jail. In the end of the story her lover dies because of the drugs she had smuggled to him and she experiences extreme anxiety over his death.
[Flowering Judas] is a paralysis of the will,
Coleman 7
induced through a refusal on the part of the
soul to make a resolute choice between good and
evil. Unwilling to risk the loss of either
world..trying to hold on to the advantages of
both without making a declaration for either
(Bride 2).
Laura cannot decide what direction she wants her life to go, so she continues in a state of unhappiness, which is her most dominant imperfection.
Katherine Anne Porter is a master of showing that people should live for today and not be tied to disappointments of the past, incorporating her “Carpe Diem” theme. Her stories allow readers to reflect on the positive events in their own lives. Through her writings, Porter sends readers an important moral message; although we have no control over some of the disappointments life deals us, we do have control over how we react to these events. Life can at times be painful and difficult, however our responses to these negative events will often determine the degree of our future happiness.
Bibliography
Williams, Joseph. “Katherine Anne Porter: Literary Genius.” Doubleday books. New York. 1998
Garside, Carrie. “Katherine Anne Porter’s Writings.” Doubleday books. 1979. Boston.
Другие работы по теме:
Anne Frank Essay Research Paper What do
Anne Frank Essay, Research Paper What do you know about Anne Frank? If you don?t know a lot about her I will help you. Anne Frank lived from 1929-1945. She was a young adult who kept an account of everything that went on from 1943-1945 when she was in hiding. Her diary was later published a year after her death, the name of the book was Diary of a Young Girl.
A New Day
– Book Review Essay, Research Paper A New Day written by Margaret Johnson-Hodge was the first book I have read by a female black author. She became serious about writing when she attended a workshop with another writer Brenda Conno-Bey. She lives in the northeastern United States.
Narrator Description Essay Research Paper What is
Narrator Description Essay, Research Paper What is narrator? Narrator is the voice the author creates to tell the story. The possible ways of telling a story are many, and more than one way can be
Narrator Essay Research Paper What is narrator
Narrator Essay, Research Paper What is narrator? Narrator is the voice the author creates to tell the story. The possible ways of telling a story are many, and more than one way can be worked into a single story. Conventionally, the various narrators that storytellers draw upon can be grouped into four broad groups: the third-person narrator, the first-person narrator, the omniscient narrator and the witness narrator.
Anne Hutchinson Essay Research Paper Andrew D
Anne Hutchinson Essay, Research Paper Andrew D. Dugan Anne Hutchinson Although Anne Hutchinson is historically documented to have been banished as a religious dissenter, the real motive for her persecution was that she challenged the traditional subordinate role of women in Puritan society by expressing her own religious convictions.
Bronte Poem Essay Research Paper
‘Night’ (by Anne Bronte) The Bronte sisters had a very agonizing life, which is beautifully portrayed through their poetry. One of the main reasons why their poetry is so effective is because
Huckelberry And Finn Essay Research Paper Anne
Huckelberry And Finn Essay, Research Paper Anne Sullivan: A Great Teacher A teacher effects eternity (Henry B. Adams). A teacher does many things that affect her students. Even though at the time, the student does not understand the wisdom of the teachings. Anne Sullivan is one of those remarkable teachers.
Life In The 20Th Century As Shown
In The Storm A Clean,Well-Lighted Place And Magic Essay, Research Paper Life in the twentieth century is different through each decade but also much different than life in a century before. The short story Magic , written by Katherine Anne Porter in 1930, shows how people think they have choices in life but their future is actually already planned out for them.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Lisa WilsonEnglish 101Story
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Lisa Wilson English 101 Story Outline 1 December 2000 1. Intro A.The story of ?The Jilting of Granny Weatherall? by Katherine Ann Porter is portrayed in two different ways by the video and story version.
The Jilting Of Granny Weatherall And Worn
Path: Compare And Contrast Essay, Research Paper The short stories, ?The Jilting of Granny Weatherall? by Catherine Anne Porter and ?A Worn Path? by Eudora Welty, have many similarities as well as differences. Both stories have a simple plot with a theme that is symbolic of their lives. These stories include great characterization, description of elements in the stories, and the point of view.
Porter Essay Research Paper I Organizational Pattern
Porter Essay, Research Paper I: Organizational Pattern: Rogerian Christa Porter examines what a true friend is. She does this by establishing a presentation with a Rogerian pattern as it?s basis. This pattern is seen in several aspects mentioned by Porter, the more obvious aspect is when she invites the audience to give their opinion of what a true friend is.
Katherine Anne Porter Essay Research Paper Rejection
Katherine Anne Porter Essay, Research Paper Rejection in Life Katherine Anne Porter is regarded as one of the leading modern writers of short stories. Born on May 5, 1890 in Indian Creek, Texas as the great-great-great- granddaughter of the famous American frontiersman Daniel Boone, Porter was educated at various schools.
O Henry Essay Research Paper O Henry
O. Henry Essay, Research Paper O. Henry was the pen name for William Sydney Porter an American short story writer. Porter was born on September 11, 1862, in Greensboro, North Carolina, the son of Dr. Algernon Sidney and Mary Jane Virginia Porter. When Porter was three, his mother died, and his father, his brother, and he moved into the house of his grandmother and his Aunt.
Anne Rice Essay Research Paper Anne RiceAnne
Anne Rice Essay, Research Paper Anne Rice Anne Rice s life experiences and intellectual inquisitiveness provide her with constant inspiration for her writing. She was brought up in New Orleans, Louisiana. She was the second of four daughters in her family. She was born Howard Ellen O Brien. Her mother thought that Howard was a suiting name that would bring her good fortune.
Anne Sullivan Macy Essay Research Paper TeacherAnne
Anne Sullivan Macy Essay, Research Paper Teacher Anne Sullivan Macy By: Helen Keller Year of Publication: 1955 Anne Sullivan Macy Anne Sullivan Macy was born on April 4, 1866 in Feeding Hills, Massachusetts. Her parents were poor Irish immigrants. Anne had trouble with her eyes her whole life. When Anne was eight years old her mother died and two years later her father left.
Bio Of Anne Frank Essay Research Paper
The Diary of Anne Frank Anne Frank s Diary is sometimes considered by most people to be a novel. Frank s diary is not a novel, but a true diary kept by a young Jewish girl for two years that she was forced to be in hiding by the Nazi persecution of the Jews of Europe. The event recounted in Anne Frank s diary take place during World War II.
Diary Of Ann Frank Essay Research Paper
Books related to Diary of Anne Frank 2 Diary of Anne Frank 1.The Diary of Anne Frank by Anne Frank 2.The setting of this book is an attic of a building in Amsterdam during the time period of 1942 to 1944.
Anne Frank 3 Essay Research Paper Anne
Anne Frank 3 Essay, Research Paper Anne Frank Anne Frank, a young Jewish girl going through hard times during World War II, writes in her diary about her thoughts and feelings relating to her life from her own prospective. Anne writes from an attic where she is hiding from the Nazi s. This is a book report on Anne Frank, Diary of A Young Girl by Anne Frank.
Anne Frank Essay Research Paper In 1942
Anne Frank Essay, Research Paper In 1942, when the Nazi?s began to invade their country, the Frank family went into hiding in an attic of a warehouse. The Franks? daughter, Anne,
The Jilting Of Granny Weatherall Vs A
Worn Path Essay, Research Paper Death is not something to be feared, but faced with awe. Although, by nature, aging and death are merely facts of life; a loss of hope, the frustration of all aspirations, a leap into a great darkness, and the feelings of fear and anguish. Phoneix Jackson of Eudora Welty’s “A Worn Path” and Granny of Katherine Anne Porter’s “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” face these inevitable signs of aging and death.
The Jilting Of Granny Weatherall By Katherine
Porter Essay, Research Paper In the story, “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall”, written by Katherine Porter, Granny Weatherall is a character of depth. Her name is synomonous with her character. Three main qualities of her character are her strength, her endurance, and her vulnerability.
The Jilting Of Granny Weatherall Essay Research
Paper Having read “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” by Katherine Anne Porter once before, I thought it would be a good idea to revisit the short story. With more understanding of the story now, it is much easier to consider the how Granny’s actions are acceptable rather than rash at times. Granny’s character is one where everyone can relate to because each one of us manages to feel sorry for her through the problems she must face along her long road to death.
Scene Analysis Essay Research Paper Scene AnalysisThe
Scene Analysis Essay, Research Paper Scene Analysis The intent of this paper is to analyze a few points in Shakespeare’s Play, “The Taming of the Shrew.” During scenes i and iii of Act IV, Petruchio has taken Katherine to his country estate. It is here that Petruchio will manage to transform and conform Katherine to playing the role of a benevolent wife.
About The Witch Of Blackbird Pond Essay
, Research Paper The Witch of Blackbird Pond The book, The Witch of Blackbird Pond, is about a young girl named Katherine who is forced to leave her elegant home in Barbados to live with relatives in puritan New England after her grandfather s death. Katherine has a hard time accepting the dramatic difference between the two cultures.
The Grave Essay Research Paper The short
The Grave Essay, Research Paper The short story, ” The Grave,” by Katherine Anne Porter began in a secluded area that had once been the family cemetery. The cemetery was owned by the grandmother who had just passed away. In her will she had requested the land be sold and this required the family cemetery to be moved.
Anne Bradstreet Vs Anne Saxto Essay Research
Paper Anne Bradstreet vs. Anne Sexton When one thinks about women in literature, the names Anne Bradstreet and Anne Sexton come to mind. They are two very passionate women who wrote about everyday life while making it seem extraordinary. However, they didn t quite express themselves in the same way. These women were different in the way they wrote about family life and the pattern in which they wrote their poetry.
The Taming Of The Shrew Katherine Essay
, Research Paper The Taming of the Shrew: Katherine In William Shakespeare’s play, The Taming of the Shrew, the shrew played by Katherine, had a terrible outlook on life and just about everything else. Her
Helen Keller Essay Research Paper Helen Keller
Helen Keller Essay, Research Paper Helen Keller This novel is about the amazing accomplishments Helen Keller has achieved. Her appearance was not much different from others even though she was blind and deaf. Helen had long light brown hair that was always tied up in a bun, with very thin lips. When Helen was a little girl she was very smart, greedy, and stubborn.
Funny Story Essay Research Paper
There I was, enjoying my holiday in our families holiday flat. Things couldn t get better until 2 girls moved into the flat above ours. I soon introduced myself find out their names were Julie
Anne Frank Essay Research Paper The Diary
Anne Frank Essay, Research Paper The Diary of Anne Frank Anne Frank lived with her family in a pleasant house. For Anne and her sister, Margot, their early childhood was a sucure place inhabited by loving parents, relatives and nurses.
The Taiming Of The ShrewCharacter Analisis Essay
, Research Paper The Taming Of The Shrew Character Analyses: Katherine: She is called the shrew, even by her father. She is always put second in her fathers eyes, next to her sister. She alters dramatically from an ill mannered shrew to a obedient and happy wife when she discovers her husband cares enough to try to change her for her own good, as well as his own.
Anne Frank Journal Essay Research Paper Journal
Anne Frank Journal Essay, Research Paper Journal #1 I think that when Mr. Frank, Mrs. Frank, Anne, and Margot needed to hide from the Nazis in Mr. Kraler loft in his factory the living conditions were so appalling. They only had two rooms and one space for Peter to sleep in. I feel it is amazing how two families, the Franks and the Van Daans, and one dentist, Mr.