? Capitalism? Essay, Research Paper
Max Weber?s original theory on the rise of Capitalism in Western Europe has been an often studied theory. In its relationship to Protestantism, specifically Calvinism, Weber?s theory has been in scholarly debate since it?s release in 1904. ?The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism? puts forth not capitalism as an institute, but as the precursor to the historical origins of capitalism. Weber?s attempts to use statistical data, as well as church doctrine to prove his theory, has been the foundation for the main arena of debate amongst his peers.
Weber, although touching on other religions and countries, specifically focuses on the Reformation and its correlation to the dominance of capitalism in Western civilizations. He centers his work on the thesis ?that the chances of overcoming traditionalism are greatest on account of the religious upbringing?, thus ?it is worthwhile to ask how this connection of adaptability to capitalism with religious factors occurred in the early days of capitalism(1).? This break with tradition could be attributed to the ?calling? as depicted in the Protestant faith. Weber believes Protestants saw the ?calling? as finally sanctifying the earning of a profit and as a sign of salvation. In this, he saw a breaking of the ?backward-sloping supply curve? for labor by instilling a new work ethic and the bringing forth of capitalistic values.
Amintore Fanfani in his critical work ?Catholicism, Protestantism, and Capitalism? disagrees with Weber on the role Protestantism played in the development of capitalism. He argues that ?Europe was acquainted with capitalism before the Protestant revolt? and thus ??we have ruled out that Protestantism could have produced a phenomenon that already existed(2).? He does agree that capitalism acquired prominence after the Reformation; however, he attributes the success to Italian merchants who operated under Catholicism decades earlier. Fanfani believes this discredits the influential aspects of religion on capitalism, and instead credits ?that general revolution of thought that characterizes the period of the Renaissance and the Reformation, by which in art, philosophy, morals, and economy, the individual emancipates?himself from the bonds imposed on him during the Middle Ages(2).? Arguments could be made on Weber?s behalf that it was the Reformation that ?emancipated? Protestants from the bonds of Catholic ritual. The removal of the Catholic priest necessitated Protestants to acquire a higher degree of learning for their own salvation. An education combined with divine sanction towards profit and a sinful attitude towards idleness would only lead towards a diligent work ethic. It can be inferred, in this rebuttal, that the Reformation may have been a guiding factor in the Renaissance and therefore Fanfani?s argument would be inclusive of Weber?s theory.
The argument that capitalism existed before the Reformation is valid, but Fanfani is discussing it as a definition where as Weber discusses it as driving force.
Weber?s thoughts, that rationality being a basis for capitalism, inspired him to use several quotes from Ben Franklin early in his work. In where, even before there was a strong capitalistic foundation formed in the colonies, Weber found Franklin?s writings to be infused with the prudence of rationality. From Franklin?s work ?Necessary Hints to Those That Would be Rich? Weber quotes:
For six pounds a year you may have the use of one hundred pounds, provided you are a man of known prudence and honesty?
He that loses five shillings, not only loses that sum, but all the advantages that might be made by turning it in dealing, which by the time that a young man becomes old, will amount of a considerable amount of money(3).
Weber?s critiques Dickson and McLachlan deny that Franklin is preaching a Protestant work ethic, and suggest that by the title of Franklin?s work he is merely suggesting prudent advise. Yet, it is that prudent advise that fits neatly into Weber?s definition of capitalism in where he states that ?one which rests on the expectation of profit by the utilization of opportunities for exchange, that is on peaceful chances of profit? and pursuit of profit and forever renewed profits through continuous, rational, capitalistic enterprise(1).? Dickson and McLachlan, like many other critiques, don?t take into account that although Weber attempts to prove a statistical and specific point as to the origin of capitalism, it?s a generalization he refers to. ?The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism? must be taken as a whole work, additions and explanations of this work given at a later date by Weber must also be included.
Weber?s work is theoretical. It is based on one man?s view of the evidence, and must be taken as a whole, and as a theory. Whether or not the Protestant ideal was the complete basis for capitalist domination can never be fully proven. Weber?s discussion of Protestantism, as a factor in capitalism, cannot be discredited either. Even though statistical and historical facts may prove it somewhat inconsistent, there will always be an idea before a movement, and until one man can be proven to be the founder of capitalism Weber?s thesis still stands.
Bibliography
(1)Anderson, Hughes, and Sharrock: Classic Disputes in Sociology. London: Unwin and Hyman, 1987.
(2)Green,Robert W.Protestantism and Capitalism: The Weber Thesis and Its Critiques. Boston: D.C. Heath and Company, 1959.
(3)Dickson, Tony and McLachlan, ?In Search of ?The Spirit of Capitalism?: Weber?s Misinterpretation of Franklin,? Sociology, Vol.23, No.1 (81-89).
(4)Weber, Max: General Economic History. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction, Inc., 1979.
(5)Weber, Max: The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. New York: Charles Scribner?s Sons, 1958.
(6)Algazi, Gadi: Max Weber on Market Relations, Freedom and Coercion. Dept. of History, Tel Aviv University: WWW.Criticism.Com.
Другие работы по теме:
Work Ethic Essay Research Paper In todays
Work Ethic Essay, Research Paper In today?s society I believe we have lost the traditional work ethic of long ago. Being brought up in a traditional family and around a population mainly comprised of Amish, I have come to understand the work ethic that America has lost. Amish are people who lead a simple religious life unaffected by automobiles, electricity, modern appliances, or other modern convinces.
The Land Ethic Essay Research Paper To
The Land Ethic Essay, Research Paper To answer the question, was Aldo Leopold right in saying we need to adopt a land ethic? First we need to identify what a land ethic is.
Catholic Apologetics Essay Research Paper The Apocrypha
Catholic Apologetics Essay, Research Paper The Apocrypha: Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Ecclesiasticus, Baruch, 1 and 2 Maccabees The Protestant argument is that the Catholic Church added the 7 books known as the Apocrypha to the Canon Bible at the Council of Trent in the mid-16th century (after the reformation) to back up things the Church taught
Weber Capitalism Religion And Social Control Essay
, Research Paper The analysis of the relationship between religion and social change can usually be seen as a debate between those who believe that religion can be change promoting, such as Weber, and those who believe religion to be change inhibiting, such as Marx and Durkheim. Marx’s view fro example, would be that religion would inhibit social change at it legitimises and justifies the status quo, whereas this is usually contrasted with Weber, who suggests that religion can cause social change, in that it helped in the development of capitalism. 1905 saw the publication of The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, which was possibly the most influential of Weber’s works, and also one of the most important theories on religion and its effect on the wider economic structure.
Patriachy In Colonial America Essay Research Paper
Colonial America began as an offspring of the English patriarchal government. The first settlers could not imagine a society that could be both self sufficient and independent from English control. The colonists simply accepted its role on the bottom of the social and political hierarchy. They relied on their intense work ethic and their desire to practice their own religion without interference.
Independent Spirit Essay Essay Research Paper There
Independent Spirit Essay Essay, Research Paper There can be a difference between a dependent and independent spirits. Independent spirits can be found in everyone and how your independent spirit can help others.
Baroque Art Essay Research Paper The baroque
Baroque Art Essay, Research Paper The baroque has been called a theatrical style, one that deals in spectacle, grandeur, and dramatic contrast. Test these concepts in an essay that discusses the baroque as an expression of the Catholic Reformation, Protestant devotionalism, the Scientific Revolution, and the Age of Absolutism.
The Protestant Reformation Essay Research Paper During
The Protestant Reformation Essay, Research Paper During the late 1400’s, England became a country plagued by changes, both good and bad. Knights, who were once prominent in England faded away and became less popular. Soon after that, the Renaissance swept into and changed England dramatically. The Renaissance, which started in France and many other western European nations, was a time of prospering for literature, art, science and learning.
Nkohma Essay Research Paper Acts Summary xThe
Nkohma Essay, Research Paper .Acts Summary x The book of Acts is written by the author Luke the Apostle who also wrote the book Luke that is one of the four books in the Gospel of the New Testament. The book of Acts is a linking book that shows and describes the transition of Jesus final ministry by sending the Holy Spirit after His ascention into Heaven.
A Salesmans Death Essay Research Paper An
A Salesmans Death Essay, Research Paper An Analysis of Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman When people accept an ideal to live by it can be a glorious and noble thing unless they become so obsessed with the ideal that it becomes a yolk and they are unable to realize their dream. This is especially true for Arthur Miller’s play Death of a Salesman.
The Protestant Reformation Essay Research Paper I
The Protestant Reformation Essay, Research Paper I walked around town thinking about the Reformation that would make great impacts on the history of my village in Germany and other lands. Most people in Europe are prayer people who accept all aspects of the church, whether or not they personally believed in the idea or not.
Christian Reformation Essay Research Paper The Protestant
Christian Reformation Essay, Research Paper The Protestant Reformation Many ideas of the Renaissance like humanism, individualism and secularism stimulated a strong critique of the church+s policy and the clergy+s behaviour. Many people regarded it as a scandal that the catholic church sold indulgences.
The Protestant Reformation Essay Research Paper AP
The Protestant Reformation Essay, Research Paper _______________ AP European History Period 4 The Protestant Reformation The Protestant Reformation changed the course of European history very strongly, and rapidly. This paper will talk about what exactly the reformation did to Europe, in terms of social, political, and philosophical impacts.
Fake Myth Essay Research Paper Many centuries
Fake Myth Essay, Research Paper Many centuries ago, before you, before me. Before water existed. There was a god, who roamed the earth in search of something, anything. He roamed the barren landscapes and searched under all rocks. Until one day he found something. It was a hole, a hole that seemed bottomless.
Novel Mean Spirit Essay Research Paper Mean
Novel: Mean Spirit Essay, Research Paper Mean Spirit With oil being discovered on Native American property in Oklahoma during the early 1920 s, it was a chance for whites to get rich and it was the start of the demise of a stable Native American civilization. As a result of the Dawes Act of 1887, reservations were divided into plots given among the Indians.
The Land Ethic Holistic View Essay Research
Paper The land ethic is a holistic view of ecosystems. It entails an entire view of a biotic community to include all of nature, not the individualistic components which incorporate our environment. Great efforts would be taken by supporters of the land ethic to support an ecosystem that was threatened. The individual components that comprise the ecosystem are not of great concern to supporters of this theory; they would argue that a threat to an individual organism, even protected or endangered, should be evaluated on whether or not the protected or endangered species does endanger the integrity of the whole system.
Blithe Spirit Essay Research Paper Anthony J
Blithe Spirit Essay, Research Paper Anthony J. Perrotta October 3, 1999 Blithe Spirit Frankly, I was amazed by the set of Blithe Spirit. I am not sure whether it was because I had a hand in building it and all of the skills I acquired in doing so or just the fact that it was a great set. Either way I was extremely impressed.
Spirit Of Mountains Essay Research Paper Spirit
Spirit Of Mountains Essay, Research Paper Spirit of the Mountains Grace, Beauty, tranquillity, man conquering majestic mountains, mammoth in size. Thus describes the experience, of a mountain. Like
Protestant Reformation Essay Research Paper 3A2 Florian
Protestant Reformation Essay, Research Paper 3A2 Florian Boyce Euro pd. 6 November 2000 Protestant Reformation The Protestant Reformation was period of revolt. It was an uprising of the Roman Catholic Church. Though it has been proven that the main reason of rebellion was the grievances many people had of the church.
Kindred Essay Essay Research Paper Throughout the
Kindred Essay Essay, Research Paper Throughout the novel Kindred, Butler compared and contrasted modern African Americans with African Americans that were slaves in the novel. Some of the many ways she compares them are through education, work ethic, and their personal feelings about and/or how they handle their own slavery.
Franklin Book Report Essay Research Paper Amanda
Franklin Book Report Essay, Research Paper Amanda Culver HIST 328 Book Review 1 Benjamin Franklin lived a highly productive life as a printer (as well as becoming an honored statesman) and he practiced living modestly, honestly and diligently. In his autobiography, written as a letter to his son, Franklin describes how he lived his life with a strong work ethic and moral character.
Julius Caesar A Dead Man
’s Party Essay, Research Paper JULIUS CAESAR: A Dead Man?s Party In Shakespeare?s Julius Caesar, the character of Caesar remains a active force throughout the play, even after his assassination. Caesar is
Calvinism Essay Research Paper Since John Calvin
Calvinism Essay, Research Paper Since John Calvin first introduced the belief of election, it has caused debate among theologians in many Protestant churches. John Calvin?s beliefs consisted of five general themes.
The Holy Spirit Essay Research Paper The
The Holy Spirit Essay, Research Paper The Holy Spirit Paul talks lot about the Holy Spirit and the role that He plays in peoples lives in Romans 8:3-17. His main point though, is that there is a very distinct difference between people of the flesh and people of the Spirit. If the Spirit of God is alive in a person, then that person is alive because they died to sin.
Personal Communication Ethic Essay Research Paper Part
Personal Communication Ethic Essay, Research Paper Part I – Personal Communication Ethic I feel that that the best way to persuade people is with your ears — by listening to them. Feeling this way, I based my personal communication ethic on listening.
Propsero
’s Relationship With Caliban Essay, Research Paper Prospero generally greets Caliban and Ariel with the words ’slave’ and ’servant’. Prospero calls Ariel the servant and rarely uses Ariel’s name. Prospero also calls Ariel ’spirit’. It is quite apparent that Prospero feels that he owns Ariel, always calling Ariel ‘My brave spirit’ and ‘Why that’s my spirit’ using ‘my’ in these sentences when he speaks to Ariel, showing possesion.
A View Of Young Goodman Brown Essay
, Research Paper A view of Young Goodman Brown The story Young Goodman Brown is about a man and his faith in himself, his wife, and the community they reside in. Goodman Brown must venture on a journey into the local forest refuse the temptations of the devil and return to the village before sunrise. The time era is approximately a generation after the time of the witch trials.
Marx And Weber Essay Research Paper Erik
Marx And Weber Essay, Research Paper Erik NicholsonMarx and Weber essayComparative Politics Max Weber’s book The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism is basically a counter argument to Karl Marx and Fredrick Engels s publication The Communist Manifesto. Both books deal with the progression and rise of capitalism, yet the authors discuss very different paths to explain how we achieved capitalism as it is today.
Comedy And The Power Of The Human
Spirit Essay, Research Paper Paving the way, comedy traditionally deals with the efforts of individuals to survive and create a new and better world ? or at least one that is better than the reality the character find themselves in if only for a short period of time. In this way this genre seems to be a means of dealing with both human suffering and failure.
Aldo Leopold Ecocentrism Essay Research Paper Environmental
Aldo Leopold- Ecocentrism Essay, Research Paper Environmental Ethics 1) Leopold strongly suggests the need for land ethic because he sees a great lack for it. Humans see land as an economical resource. Land is used for our needs and enjoyment with the belief that we are the ruler and conqueror of the land. Humans feel superior to the land and all that live on it and therefore lack the sense of being a part of land.