Physicians, including cosmetic surgeons, have many responsibilities that are inherent with their professions. Included in these are the decisions that the surgeon must make when deciding if and how to do a certain medical procedure. They must first of all make certain to ensure the health and safety of their patient while performing a procedure successfully. But should cosmetic surgeons also be handed the responsibility to decide if a certain surgery is morally suspect or an immoral request to change ones appearance? Margaret Olivia Little, author of Cosmetic Surgery, Suspect Norms, and the Ethics of Complicity, argues that cosmetic surgeons should be responsible for filtering out morally suspect cases and refusing to do surgeries that may not be moral. She has come up with a post modernist view on this subject. I, however, agree with the more modernist mainstream model. I feel that it should not be the responsibility of the surgeon to decide what is moral and what isn t when approached by a patient who may request a surgery.
The surgeon has a certain amount of responsibility when asked to perform a surgery. Their primary concern should be whether or not this surgery is going to have an adverse effect on the patient s health. Why should the surgeon be bothered with whether or not the procedure is going to have an adverse effect on society? It would disrupt the concentration of the physician if they had to spend time thinking about whether or not the surgery is morally right. When a surgeon is preparing to do a surgery their focus should be on how they are going to do it and what precautions are necessary to ensure the safety of the patient and not is this the moral thing to do? Similarly when a surgeon is performing a surgery their attention should be focused on the task at hand and not did I make the right decision about whether or not to do this? Putting the responsibility of shaping societies morals on the surgeon is not right.
The surgeons who perform these operations are not in the wrong. Little argues that the surgeons are out to turn women into Barbie dolls (Little 171, 172) and rake in the money while they are at it. First of all the surgeons are not the ones who created the demand for cosmetic surgery. Rather the demand for surgery created a demand for surgeons. The surgeons do not trick the patients into opting for a surgery that they don t want; rather they offer it to people who are already actively looking for it.
Who is to say anyway that it is immoral to want to change one s appearance? Further who is supposed to make the decisions as to which cases are considered morally suspect? Many people have many different moral beliefs. What is immoral to one person may not be to another. So the decisions made by one person that sets the guidelines for these types of morally questionable surgeries may be too strict for some or not strict enough for others. Even if there were specific guidelines set up they would be almost impossible to follow because of the vast number of different cases that come up in these types of surgeries. It would be impossible to come up with rules that everyone would agree with.
Little herself, seems to have trouble drawing the line between the morally suspect cases and the ones that are reasonable requests. She lists four different examples that would all resemble typical requests for surgeries. She uses her post-modernist models to make the decisions for these people. The first is a man who lives in a society in which a double chin is what makes one attractive. This man however does not have a double chin so he would like to have a surgical implant to give him one. The second is a child whose ears stick out from his head. Because of this he is subject to relentless taunting by other children. He is looking to surgery to tuck his ears in closer to his head. The third case is a black man who believes that he could be more successful if he had a more European look so he is pursuing surgery to make himself look whiter. The fourth and final case that Little talks about is a size 8 woman who would like surgery to make herself have a more super-model like appearance. Now given these four cases, which ones should be considered morally suspect and which are reasonable requests for cosmetic surgery? Little believes that the man with the single chin should be granted his surgery because he is suffering because he doesn t fit with societies ideals. She also believes that the child should be able to have an ear tuck since he is suffering from being different looking than everyone else. Little says that the black man and the woman should be denied their surgeries though. She says that they should NOT be granted their surgeries because they only want them to fit in with their societies preferences. This seems contradictory to the first or second case though. There, Little said, that the man and the boy SHOULD be able to have surgery because they doesn t fit societies ideals. Little is clearly just as confused as anyone else would be in trying to decide whom to grant cosmetic surgery. Why should we put such difficult decisions on the surgeons? The surgeons need to spend their time concentrating on the health and safety of the patient.
It is clear that morally suspect cases are hard to discern from morally acceptable ones. It is also clear that the cosmetic surgeons should not be held responsible for filtering the two or for shaping societies morals. They are responsible for helping the patient make an educated decision on what they want done to their body and make sure they understand the risks involved. Most importantly the surgeon should be concerned with the health and safety of the patient. The last thing on their mind should be how is this surgery going to affect society? The modernistic standard practice that cosmetic surgeons follow today should be the way that they continue to practice. They should not be burdened with the post-modernists moral issues or be responsible for shaping societies standards or norms.
Другие работы по теме:
Quotation Speech Essay Research Paper Quotation SpeechHarvey
Quotation Speech Essay, Research Paper Quotation Speech Harvey Fierstein once said ?Never be bullied into silence. Never allow yourself to be made a victim. Accept no one?s definition of your life; define yourself.? Only you can define yourself . . . there?s something so special about that concept; something so intimate about the fact that only you can control your destiny.
Jefferson Essay Research Paper I feel that
Jefferson Essay, Research Paper I feel that I would be considered a Jeffertonian because I think the common man should run the federal government, like Jefferson thought. I think the federal government
Advice Essay Research Paper A piece of
Advice Essay, Research Paper A piece of advice that I often receive is “as long as you do your best.” This refers to success in everything from school to careers. I believe that this is good advice because
Decisions Essay Research Paper It s amazing
Decisions Essay, Research Paper It s amazing that every decision people make, no matter how unimportant it may seem, can change the outcome of their day or even, on a larger scale, their lives. From asking someone out on a date to buying a watch; decisions can start a chain reaction of events that can take one on a journey to the unknown.
Twelve Angry Men Essay Research Paper In
Twelve Angry Men Essay, Research Paper In the story “Twelve Angry Men”, Reginald Rose shows how making one’s own decisions is one very important aspect in life. He also showed that one’s decisions should
Democracy Essay Research Paper DemocracyThesis Is democracy
Democracy Essay, Research Paper Democracy Thesis: Is democracy a possible form of government? With out it the world would be full of chaos and injustice. Democracy is the form of government that America has today. We are able to vote on whom we want to run our government. We have a say in what goes on in our lives and our future.
Elizabeth Arden Essay Research Paper Elizabeth ArdenElizabeth
Elizabeth Arden Essay, Research Paper Elizabeth Arden Elizabeth Arden, formally known as Florence Nightingale, changed her name in 1909 with the introduction of her first shop selling facial creams. She began as a normal working girl, taking different odd jobs here and there. Then she was introduced into the cosmetic world by Eleanor Adair, who hired Arden on as a clerical consultant at her London firm in Saks Fifth Ave.
Seregas Essay Essay Research Paper The life
Seregas Essay Essay, Research Paper The life stories of many today s New Yorkers are amazingly similar and different at the same time. For those of us who can call New York our new home, the choice to move to this city has certainly been one of the most important decisions of our lives. Whether or not we came from fifty or five thousand miles away, the hopes for success and brighter future were the sources of our motivation.
Commercials Essay Research Paper In every young
Commercials Essay, Research Paper In every young person life there are certain critical decisions that must be made. One of the more important of the many is the choice to resume education after high school. After that decision is made the choice of which college to go to comes into play. In making this decision you must first do research on schools that interest you, you must visit these campuses, and last you must apply to the schools of your choice.
Why Do People Get Cosmetic Surgery Essay
, Research Paper Why do people Get Cosmetic Surgery? It might be giving you a sense of uniqueness or even adds character to your whole physical appearance, but what if you just can t stand it? What if you have a physical attribute that just drives you mad? Well, you re certainly not alone. According to the American Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons, thousands of people in all age groups, from children to seniors perform cosmetic surgery each year.
Decisions Essay Research Paper Decisions Decisions DecisionsPeople
Decisions Essay, Research Paper Decisions, Decisions, Decisions People make decisions every single day, even if they know it or not. Whether it is an important decision as in buying the right car, or a little decision as in deciding what to eat for lunch. No matter what the decision maybe, one has to make choices everyday.
Harry S Truman Essay Research Paper The
Harry S. Truman Essay, Research Paper The 33rd president was Harry S. Truman. He took over office after Roosevelt died, during this time period of WWII. He had to make the decision of the atomic bomb and how to take care of getting peace in Europe and with the other countries. He dealt with these difficulties in correct and appropriate manner and in a respectful way.
Things They Carried Essay Research Paper In
Things They Carried Essay, Research Paper In the story ?Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong? in The Things they Carried by Tim O? Brian Mary Ann Bell goes from one end of the spectrum to the other.
Capitalism And Communism Essay Research Paper Capitalism
Capitalism And Communism Essay, Research Paper Capitalism and Communism are two totally different economic systems. Capitalism is a much better economic system than Communism. Capitalism is an economic system characterized by freedom of the market and is the economic system where you do not have freedom because the government will make most of your decisions for you.
Oliver Cromwell Essay Research Paper LondonToday in
Oliver Cromwell Essay, Research Paper London- Today in 1654, Oliver Cromwell proclaimed himself as Lord Protector of England. This came after he dissolved the Parliament, because of their inability to make decisions, a few months earlier. What this means to English citizens is that they will now be ruled by a dictator with a puritan background and the loyalty of the army.
Accepting Responsibility Essay Research Paper As a
Accepting Responsibility Essay, Research Paper As a parent with a young child, your main goal is to teach him responsibility. When children are growing up, especially your own children, you only want what is best for them. You want them to make good decisions and the right choices. But as we all know, sometimes that is not always what happens; that is why not only children but people must accept responsibility for their actions.
Altruism Essay Research Paper AltruismRational choice theorists
Altruism Essay, Research Paper Altruism Rational choice theorists believe that decisions are based on rational thought. For the most part, rational decisions are made with the intention of receiving some type of benefit or reward. However, people sometimes make decisions that have no obvious remuneration.
Independance Essay Research Paper IndependenceIt is frightening
Independance Essay, Research Paper Independence It is frightening to be alone and to have to fend for yourself and make your own choices. Sometimes though it is a good thing to think for yourself and to not let other people tell you what to do with your life. When you are independent you do what you really want to do and stop letting others influence your decisions.
What Does It Mean To Be Moral
Essay, Research Paper What does it mean to be moral? Our morality is used every day in every situation and decision we make. Morality is very much a part of who you are. To be a person who is moral you know what is right and wrong on your own.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John MarshallIn
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall In early American history, the powers of the executive and legislative branches of the government were already well defined. However, the judicial branch needed to establish its position as an equal of the other two branches. John Marshall was crucial in making this happen.
12 Angry Men Essay Research Paper English12
12 Angry Men Essay, Research Paper English: 12 angery men essay 2000-07-15 12 Angry Men Paper The jury member I chose to do my paper on was Mr. Davis (the member who voted not guilty first), because he used many task messages, did not allow physical factors to affect his decisions, and was a successful emergent leader at some points in the case.These three points made Mr.
Personal Experience Essay Research Paper A piece
Personal Experience Essay, Research Paper A piece of advice that I often receive is “as long as you do your best.”This refers to success in everything from school to careers. I believethat this is good advice because it tells me that they trust my judgmentand will respect my decisions, even if they are the wrong ones.
Commercialism In Schools Essay Research Paper Commercialism
Commercialism In Schools Essay, Research Paper Commercialism affects children everyday. Children are targeted by companies to become life-long buyers of their products. When commercialism is brought into schools it is harder for children to learn to make educated decisions about their purchases. Kids need to be educated and given proper instructions about how to be objective towards advertisements.
Mind And Body Essay Research Paper The
Mind And Body Essay, Research Paper The mind and body are said to be two different entities that have different characteristics. Many have argued that each holds its own properties and can be without the other. In my opinion, the mind and body are distinguishable in there properties but are derived from the other.
Prom Speech Essay Research Paper 2000 SpeechWhen
Prom Speech Essay, Research Paper 2000 Speech When we were younger, we couldn t wait to graduate from high school and be done with school. Well, now it s here and we are still pretty exited to be finished, but graduation has taken on a whole new meaning for us.
Developing A Procedurally Essay Research Paper Developing
Developing A Procedurally Essay, Research Paper Developing a procedurally Just performance appraisal process When organizations make decisions about people, such as whom to hire or promote, appraisal ratings or merit raise to give, or how important that the decisions are seen as fair and just. Research has shown that at least two aspects of justice influence employees?? job satisfaction and organizational commitment and both must be considered in organization decisions.
Counselors Essay Research Paper Counselors
Counselors Essay, Research Paper Counselors Clients often come to counselors to change their lives in some way, such as to become more assertive. As likely, clients seek counseling as a result of
The Giver Essay Research Paper The GiverSome
The Giver Essay, Research Paper The Giver Some say when you have the freedom to chose you really have no freedom at all. Many countries don t give their citizens the right to make their own decisions. In the
Jane Eyre Passion Vs Reason Essay Research
Paper Many of Jane s values are based on reason but ultimately many of her actions and decisions are driven by the heart. Discuss The character of Jane in Charlotte Bronte s novel Jane Eyre, was entirely revolutionary for the Victorian era. Whilst her values were shaped by her environs, her actions and decisions were often driven by an intense passion often contrary to societies norms.
Effects Of Smoking 2 Essay Research Paper
Smoking has many side effects many of these effects being serious life altering side effects and not simply cosmetic. The cosmetic effects are all well known from the smell of cigarette smoke, to yellowing teeth. But also are the effects of lung cancer to not only the smoker but to anyone who is near them or being exposed to the second hand smoke of the smoker.
The Change Essay Research Paper EssayIn this
The Change Essay, Research Paper Essay In this essay I am supposed to discuss a project or activity that best represents me. I thought about this for a while, and I decided I would talk about my piano lessons. My parents didn?t make me take them, and I didn?t take them because it was “just something to do.” There is a lot behind the story.
After January Essay Research Paper There are
After January Essay, Research Paper There are critical periods or turning points in everyone s life. Discuss the way Alex s Coloundra vacation affects his life. This is the topic question asked for this essay. This topic is a key theme of the novel After January because it is a time of change or a turning point in Alex s life and highlights the decisions we all have to make.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Antigone and The
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Antigone and The Mother Death surrounds us all. It is a common reminder of the life we have around us. Death is seen in people, nature, and animal’s everyday. It brings us sadness and pain. It is something that is not easily dealt with and sometimes may seem unjust. It helps us become better people by accepting death and learning from it.
Decision Making Essay Research Paper Any decisionaffecting
Decision Making Essay, Research Paper Any decision-affecting people has ethical ramifications and virtually all-important decisions reflect the decision-maker s mindfulness and resolution to ethical behavior. This is why it is important to know for yourself how you go about making ethical decisions, or making decisions of any kind.
Reaction Essay Research Paper REACTION PAPERThe first
Reaction Essay, Research Paper REACTION PAPER The first section of the packet explained the meaning of personality and how decisions and actions are based on your personalities. It also goes on about how various religions contribute to the forming of a positive personality. At the end of the section, it brings up God s involvement in the construction personality, which appears frequently throughout the packet.