’ Legal Rights Essay, Research Paper
Adoptive v. Birth Parents’ Rights
This issue hits home with me, I am adopted. I believe that a child’s parents are the people who raise them and take care of them. I do not believe that birth parents have any rights to their children after the child has been adopted and living with their adoptive parents. The biological parents made a decision when they put the child up for adoption, for whatever the reason may have been. Just because they feel that their lives are more “stable” and “together” does not give them the right to rip a child from the only parents that child knows. By doing this the biological parents destroy not only the life of the child but also the lives of the adoptive parents who have worked so hard to have a child to call their own. I feel that biological parents should not have this right because it is based purely on selfish reasons and it destroys all the lives involved. In the next few paragraphs, I
Gaffney 2
intend to discuss some famous rulings of recent adoption cases, and the horrible outcomes that followed.
In these days adoption has become extremely hard for couples looking to adopt children for fear that the adoptions can come undone. Two of the most recent, highly publicized and heart-wrenching cases in this country that have spurred this fear in perspective adoptive parents are the cases of “Baby Jessica” of Michigan, and “Baby Richard” of Illinois. In both of these cases, a child was adopted and then ordered by the courts to be given back to the biological parents.
The widely publicized “Baby Jessica case gripped the emotions of the nation as the natural parents (Dan and Cara Schmidt) of Iowa sought to regain custody of their daughter from the adoptive parents (Jan and Robert DeBoer) of Michigan. The adoptive parents had been ordered to return the child to the Schmidt’s by the Iowa courts. Confronted with this decision, The DeBoers successfully persuaded a Michigan state trial judge to enter a custody order in their favor, only to have the Michigan court of Appeals declare that the court in Michigan was without jurisdiction to act. The publicity abruptly halted when the Michigan Supreme Court entered its
Gaffney 3
order on July 2, 1993, requiring that “Baby Jessica” be returned to her biological parents. (Baron, 72)
In the Baby Jessica case, the birthmother intentionally identified the wrong man as the birth father. The adoptive parents took custody believing they had the consent of the birthfather, only to find out later that the real birthfather objected to the adoption. As a result of this case, state courts are recognizing that even when there is consent from a man who pretends to be a child’s father, greater efforts must be made to identify others that may claim to be the father and steps must be taken to terminate their rights. (Gray, 18)
Baby Richard’s Case was riddled with even more deception than Baby Jessica’s was. When Daniela Kirchner gave up her newborn son in March of 1991, she was angry that her then boyfriend (and now husband), Otakar, had left her two weeks before the baby was born and returned to Czechoslovakia. She believed rumors that he had run off with an old girlfriend. He believed her story that the baby was dead, even though Oto and Daniela had lived together for the first eight and a half months of her pregnancy. She refused to disclose that he was the father. He failed to search
Gaffney 4
for his son as thoroughly as some thought he should have. Then, in May 1991, the couple reconciled in Chicago. And 80 days after Baby Richard’s birth, Oto challenged the adoption. Although Illinois requires a father to demonstrate an “interest” within 30 days of the birth, Oto argued he couldn’t stake a claim to a son he didn’t know he had.
Two lower courts ruled that Oto had abandoned his rights to his son. In the summer of 1994, though, the Illinois Supreme Court not only overturned the adoption but also told the adoptive parents that they didn’t look hard enough for the birth father. Unlike Baby Jessica’s case, Baby Richard’s case raised the chilling prospect that even a completed, legal adoption could be upended. ( Ingrassia, 44)
The social workers of our time have initiated a program called
“Family Reunification,” where their primary goal is to take children away from the loving homes of adoptive parents and put them with blood relatives, even when these people have beaten, burned, or sexually abused their blood children.
Gaffney 5
Our court systems think that they protect traditional values by believing that blood-parents, not adoptive parents, are the “real” parents and they are simply mistaken.
Today it seems as if we live in a society where the court systems are more interested in the selfishness of originally un-wanting parents than the well-being of our future; our children.
Gaffney 6
1) Baron, Roger M. “Child Custody Suits: Litigating Heartbreak.” USA
Today MagazineJan. 95: p72.
2) Blum, Andrew. “Digging deep.” Adoptive Families Nov./Dec. 96:p21.
3) Gray, Alec. “Birthfathers and Legal Risks.” Adoptive Families Mar./Apr.
96: p18.
4) Grogan, David, and Fannie Weinstein. “Life after Jessica.” People 5 Sept.
94: p46.
5) Ingrassia, Michele, and John McCormick. “Ordered to Surrender.”
Newsweek 6 Feb. 95: p44.
6) “Legislative Update.” Adoptive Families Mar./Apr. 96:p7.
7) Miller-Havens, Susan. “Nature Over Nurture.” World & I Dec 93:p102.
8) Shapiro, Joseph P. “Bonds that Blood and Birth Cannot Assure.” U.S.
News & World Report 9 Aug. 93:p12.
9) Wilson, Pat A. “Sunflower Birthmoms seek to change Adoption laws.”
The News-Journal 25 Mar. 98 www.aol 11 Nov. 99
members.aol/idodc/newspaper.html.
Другие работы по теме:
Single Adoption Essay Research Paper Should Single
Single Adoption Essay, Research Paper Should Single Individuals be Allowed to Adopt There are some conflicts concerning whether or not single individuals are capable to adopt. This paper discusses why singles have the need to adopt. It also discusses some issues they may encounter when considering adoption.
The Birth Narrative Through The Gospels Of
Matthew Luke And John (Comparison) Essay, Research Paper The birth narratives of the gospels of Matthew, Luke and John are versions of the stories of the Messiah’s birth. They are not exactly the same. John’s gospel doesn’t even give word of the virgin birth. In Biblical Theology class, we remembered each birth narrative as “the one with the shepherds,” or “the one with the wise men.” Matthew’s gospel starts with the Messiah’s genealogy.
What Is In A Name Essay Research
Paper What is in a name? Does a name serve any importance in representing a person? Three letters and one syllable make up my name. Which part of me does that represent? I believe that a person?s name does not partake in their identity or character. It is just a form of reference, given to a person at the time of their birth.
Opening Adoption Records Essay Research Paper Opening
Opening Adoption Records Essay, Research Paper Opening Adoption Records When a child is adopted, it is standard procedure for a new birth certificate to be issued. On this new certificate the adoptee s new name appears, along with the names of the adoptive parents. All references to the adoptee s birth name, the name of the adoptee s birth parents and the fact of the adoption, are omitted.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 6 of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 6 of 7 I recently interviewed a woman who had an abortion. She was twenty years of age when she had the abortion She did so because she felt she had no choice. She was away at college and she did not want to tell her parents and the guy was a jerk (Interview). I do not think I would be able to tell my parents I am pregnant if I was away at college.
Adoption Essay Research Paper Did you know
Adoption Essay, Research Paper Did you know that it is estimated that approximately one million children in the United States live with adoptive parents, and that between 2-4% of U. S. families include an adopted child (Stolley, 3)? Well, its true! It is estimated that there are approximately 120,000 children adopted each year (Flango and Flango, 1).
Adoption
& Measure 58 In Orego Essay, Research Paper Adoption & Measure 58 in Oregon Oregon adoptees won a nineteen month court battle to see their birth certificates, which have been sealed since 1957. U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Conner refused to continue a hold on Measure 58, an adoption rights law approved by voters in Oregon in 1998.
Parenting Styles Essay Research Paper There are
Parenting Styles Essay, Research Paper There are 4 parenting styles based on parental responsiveness and demandiveness. These styles are Authoritative, Authoritarian, Indulgent parents, and Indifferent.
Elizabeth Cady Stanton Essay Research Paper Elizabeth
Elizabeth Cady Stanton Essay, Research Paper Elizabeth Cady Stanton Elizabeth Cady Stanton was born in 1815 to the affluent parents Daniel and Mary Livingston Cady in Jamestown, NY. Cady’s parents made it obvious that they preferred sons to daughters when they showed their mutual displeasure of the birth of the Elizabeth’s younger sister.
Should Adopted Children Be Allowed To Locate
Their Biological Parents? Essay, Research Paper Should Adopted Children Be Allowed To Locate Their Biological Parents? A touchy topic these days is whether or not the option should be open
Adoption Essay Research Paper Biracial adoptions have
Adoption Essay, Research Paper Biracial adoptions have been the topic of debate for many years but not only for it s effects on the children and their parents but also for it s effect on society and the effect it has on the child s ability to function in society. With this in mind the Federal Government has decided to step in.
Adoption Essay Research Paper Adoption is an
Adoption Essay, Research Paper Adoption is an alternative way to have a family; it is a lifetime decision that should be made very cautiously. Adoption is a process where parents are supplied for children whose biological parents are deceased, or for those children whose biological parents are unable or unwilling to provide for their care. ?Adoption creates a parent-child relationship recognized for all purposes including: child support obligations, inheritance rights and custody?(Aigner p 10).
Your Parents Raise You To Live Their
Lives Essay, Research Paper Your Parents Raise You To Live Their Lives Well, I don’t think that, that is true but there are always exceptions. For the most part I just think that one’s parents raise them according to the mistakes which they have made through out the course of their life. The only answer for my reasoning is that through out my life I have made graver mistakes more often than most.
Obesity Essay Research Paper OBESITY
Obesity Essay, Research Paper OBESITY – NATURE OR NURTURE? Obesity is a disease or condition that is caused by both Nature and Nurture. In this essay you will read examples and facts that show that obesity is the result of family genes, and through your own personal satisfaction, or decisions. So you will understand that people who you see that are huge, aren’t always that way because they are pigs.
Do Parents Expect Too Much From Their
Kids Essay, Research Paper Do parents expect too much from their children? or Do parents expect too little from their children? Well there are many ways to look at this. In this persuasive
Types Of Parents Essay Research Paper Protective
Types Of Parents Essay, Research Paper Protective parents are the easiest category of parents to spot. Most parents in this category illustrate an extreme sense of strictness through the use of several rules and harsh punishments. For instance, Mr. and Mrs. Gallop ground Jennifer from riding in a car because she was ten minutes late without notifying her parents first.
Intelligence Essay Research Paper Intelligence hereditary
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Intelligence: hereditary or acquired? Is intelligence determined primary by heredity or by the environment? This issue has aroused intense debates because many believe it has a little bit of both, but to what extent? The ones that believe that believe that every person is born with a fixed amount of intelligence argue that there is little one can do to improve intelligence, so special education programs should not be expected to produce an increase in the children?s IQ.
A Parents Appearance Essay Research Paper The
A Parents Appearance Essay, Research Paper The relationship between a child and his parents will never change no matter if they do go through a divorce. Parents should always love their kids all the time, even if they don t live with them. Don t get me wrong there are many advantages with living with both the living with one, I know.
Parental Consent Essay Research Paper Does Parental
Parental Consent Essay, Research Paper Does Parental Consent Work? Abortion is a controversial issue that can cause uproar for many families. When a young girl is thinking about having an abortion, she is making the choice on whether or not to go through with a pregnancy. One of the biggest controversies right now, about abortion is parental consent.
Interracial Adoption Essay Research Paper Interracial AdoptionAdoption
Interracial Adoption Essay, Research Paper Interracial Adoption Adoption is the complete and permanent transfer of parental rights and obligations, usually from one set of legal parents to adoptive parents(Ademec 27). Not until the late 19th century did the U.S. legislative body grant legal status to adoptive parents.
Nature Vs Nature Essay Research Paper Nature
Nature Vs Nature Essay, Research Paper Nature vs. Nurture Psychologists have often questioned whether personality traits are inherited, and therefore a result of genetics, or if they are caused by the environment,
Adoption Discrimination Essay Research Paper Adoption Discrimination
Adoption Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Adoption Discrimination In a world today, where nothing is no longer black and white people still view it as that and make ignorant decisions. Discrimination doesn t just lurk around dark corners, it thrives in the every day lives of all human beings. Adoption discrimination is just one of the injustices trapping innocent people.
Parents
’ Role Essay, Research Paper ?Roles of Parents? All parents love their children. They sometimes even sacrifice their lives for their children. But is only love enough for a child to grow up with? Why do parents need a child? This is the first question parents should ask themselves before anything else. Lots of parents think they have enough reasons for having a child but do parents need children to satisfy themselves, to dedicate their love to him/her, or to train a good, useful person for the society they?re living in.
Teen Pregnancy Essay Research Paper Teen PregnancyThesis
Teen Pregnancy Essay, Research Paper Teen Pregnancy Thesis statement: Teenage pregnancy is a major concern in today’s society; there are many ways to prevent teen pregnancy, many people to get advice from, and many decisions that a teen parent must make.
Abortion Essay Research Paper For every two
Abortion Essay, Research Paper For every two babies born, one dies because of abortion. Abortion is the most disruptive bio-ethical issue of our time (Levine 2). Abortion has two different viewpoints. One view, known as pro-life, sees abortion as the immoral slaughter of innocent life. The other view, pro-choice, considers abortion as an option that must be available to women if they are to control their own reproductive lives (2).
Opinion Essay On Abortion Essay Research Paper
In America alone, approximately 1.5 million abortions are performed every year. That is about one abortion every twenty seconds, yet nothing is being done to reduce these numbers. Why does the law allow the murders of so many innocent babies to continue? The answer is simple, it shouldn?t. Abortion is wrong and should be stopped.
Parent Essay Research Paper What does the
Parent Essay, Research Paper What does the word parent mean to you? The definition of this word is, one who begets, gives birth to, or nurtures and raises a child; a father or a mother. Yet, one interprets this word difrently depending on what life has had to offer us.
Interracial Adoption Essay Research Paper Interracial AdoptionToday
Interracial Adoption Essay, Research Paper Interracial Adoption Today, the United States has become more racially and ethnically diverse than it has been in the last few decades. Although there is basic equality among people of different cultural backgrounds, racial bigotry still lies beneath the surface.
What Does The Word Parent Mean To
You? Essay, Research Paper What does the word parent mean to you? The definition of this word is, one who begets, gives birth to, or nurtures and raises a child; a father or a mother.
Adoption Nature Or Nurture Essay Research Paper
Adoption: Nature or Nurture? Clay Cooper 12/2/00 Are parents those who give birth to a child or those who care for a child? Does nature or nurture make a woman a mother? As more and more heartbreaking tugs-of-war