, And Montaigne?S Essays Essay, Research Paper
I Know I Am But What Are You?
Cultural Differences in The Tempest, Montaigne?s Essays, and In Defense of the Indians
The Tempest, In Defense of the Indians, and Montaigne?s essays each illustrate what happens when two very different worlds collide. As Europe begins to saturate New World soil, the three authors offer their accounts of the dynamic between the European invader and native other. Though each work is unique in its details, they all share a common bond: Shakespeare, de Las Casas, and Montaigne show the reader how European colonialists use differences in appearance and language to justify theft and slavery.
The Tempest?s Caliban serves as an instrument to highlight the colonialist notion of the other. Caliban is the original inhabitant of the island; it is his native land. But Caliban is ugly. Prospero claims that he is “not honored with human shape” (p. 17), and so the new European inhabitants never think of him as a potential equal- they see him as their inferior. This initial incongruity between characters supports further dehumanization of the native for the remainder of the play.
Caliban?s appearance does not only contribute to the Europeans? poor estimation of him, but it also serves as the justification of his slavery. When Trinculo says, “Wilt thou tell a monstrous lie, being but half a fish and half a monster” (p. 55), he communicates two important concepts. First, Trinculo reinforces the idea that Caliban is more animal than man. Next, he assumes that Caliban?s exterior mirrors Caliban?s interior. Caliban?s physical deformities, according to Trinculo, also indicate deformity of character. Together, these faults aid Prospero?s justification of forcing Caliban to “serve in offices that profit us” (p. 18).
A second factor of Caliban?s oppression is language. The ability to communicate that ends man?s isolation from others and leads to civilization. When Prospero discovers Caliban, the native has no knowledge of Europe, much less its tongue. Miranda and Prospero take it upon themselves to educate Caliban in “civilized” language. Miranda says:
“I pitied thee, took pains to make thee speak, taught thee each hour one thing or other, When thou didst not, savage, know thine own meaning, but wouldst gabble, like a thing most brutish, I endowed thy purposes with words that made them known.” (p. 20)
Miranda believes that communication indicates that one is civilized. She does not for a moment consider that Caliban?s “gabble” was most likely his own language, the language he used to with Sycorax. Miranda believes that true communication (and true civilization) comes only in the words of her own language.
Prospero agrees with this notion. He believes that Caliban?s deformity and inability to communicate with foreigners make the native his subordinate. Caliban is only “?a lying slave, whom stripes may move, not kindness” (p. 54). Prospero refuses to hear Caliban?s exclamation that he was “first?mine own king” (p. 54). Once Caliban controlled his own life. With the arrival of Prospero, who sees no redeeming qualities but brute strength in Caliban, the native becomes a slave. Prospero believes that Caliban is not human and sees no reason to treat him as one.
Montaigne and de Las Casas also explore the humanity of natives. Though their portrayals of the Indians are very different, their aim is the same: to promote the humane treatment of the Indians. Both works oppose the colonialist mentality that appears in The Tempest. Montaigne and de Las Casas argue that differences in culture are not tantamount to inferiority.
De Las Casas? account of the Indians describes a race of people who are “completely innocent, meek, harmless, and temperate” (p.26). Like Caliban, de Las Casas? natives are very simple, even childlike. However, de Las Casas believes his child-natives are capable of “growing up.” He maintains that “they are quite ready and willing to receive and embrace the word of God” (p. 26). With this, he shows his confidence that the Indians have the potential to equal the Europeans.
Montaigne has a very different opinion of the natives. He shares the Shakespeare?s belief that language and culture are synonymous, but he differs in that he lauds the Indian tongue. Montaigne even goes so far as to compare Indian language with the most “civilized” language when he describes it as “a soft language, with an agreeable sound, somewhat like Greek in its endings” (Of Cannibals, p. 64). Montaigne also makes a point of describing the poetry and song of the Indians. The ability to create beautiful poetry certainly connotes civilization. Montaigne comments that “not only is there nothing barbarous in this fancy, but it is altogether Anacreontic” (Of Cannibals, p.64).
Though the primary focus of Montaigne?s essays and In Defense of the Indians is to vouch for the humanity of the Indians, the works also share a second purpose. As chronicles of European action in the New World they proof that Shakespeare was not unique in his belief of the inequality between European and native. Like Prospero and his peers, the Europeans in Montaigne and de Las Casas never consider the fact that the natives have the right to self-determination. The Europeans take over the land, imposing a new religion, a new language, and a new status on the natives. It is not even as if the Europeans choose to ignore indigenous society; they do not entertain the possibility that a society can exist. Much like Prospero?s treatment of Caliban, Montaigne and de Las Casas? Europeans believe that the Indians are no more intelligent than animals, and just about as capable of organizing a society. This perceived inferiority justifies the natives? enslavement.
Shakespeare, Montaigne, and de Las Casas all describe the usurpation of land from the Indians. De Las Casas discourages taking land with force, claiming that it is wrong to wage “war against men who are harmless?unarmed, and destitute of every human defense” (p. 26). Montaigne writes disapprovingly,
“He who had awarded their country to him must be a man fond of dissention, to go and give another person something that was not his and thus set him at strife with its ancient possessors.” (Of Coaches, p.67)
With this, Montaigne describes how the Europeans ignore the fact that the natives have any rights to property. Again, the Europeans ignore the humanity of the Indians.
Like the colonialists of de Las Casas and Montaigne?s essays, Shakespeare?s Europeans overlook Indian humanity when they seize the native land. Though Caliban defends his rights when he says, “this island?s mine by Sycorax my mother which thou tak?st from me” (p. 19) all Prospero hears are the words of an ugly, ignorant savage. Prospero pays no more heed to Caliban?s complaint than he would the lowing of a cow. To Prospero, both are animals meant for service.
In spite of their similarity, Shakespeare, de Las Casas, and Montaigne portray natives and colonialism in very different manners. De Las Casas insists that it is wrong to attack a childlike culture. Montaigne maintains that the natives are already a highly civilized people. In Shakespeare, the European actions that de Las Casas and Montaigne despise come to life. For Prospero, the native culture that Montaigne deems “evolved” and de Las Casas calls “gentle” is simply different and inferior. Montaigne says, “each man calls barbarism whatever is not his own practice” (Of Cannibals, p.58). Without understanding Montaigne?s true meaning, Prospero would wholeheartedly agree. Caliban certainly does not partake in the “practice” of Prospero. Like the natives in de Las Casas and Montaigne?s New World, Caliban has a different appearance and language. However, where Montaigne and de Las Casas are proponents of respecting differences, Shakespeare?s Europeans use those differences to defend robbery and subjugation.
Другие работы по теме:
The Tempest Is A Play About Th
Essay, Research Paper The Tempest is a play about the power and dangers of creativity. Discuss. “From beginning to end the play-write gives prominence to the problems of dominion, freedom, political failure and of repetition.”
Review Of Prospero
’s Books, Based On The Tempest Essay, Research Paper Review of Prospero?s Books When adapting a play for the screen, a director?s primary responsibility is to visualize an enactment that remains true to the original work?s perception. In addition to this task, the director must also build upon the foundations laid by the script; without this goal, (s)he would have no reason to have undertaken the project in the first place.
The Indians Contribution To Their Problems Essay
, Research Paper Oklahoma History The Indians contridbuted to there problem. When the Spanish came to America there was already an indigenous people here. When Christopher Columbus first came over on the Nina, Pinta and Santa Maria,He thought they were going to find a passage to India so when they saw the people they called them Indians.
War And Peace Of The Crow Indians
Essay, Research Paper Most of the Crow Indians reside in Southeastern Montana, while many others are scattered among the Northern Plains of the USA. The Crow Indians have lived in this area for at least 300 years. Many problems arouse whether they had to do with war, politics, or land ownership issues. The Crow Indians are not known as a war-going tribe, but as a peaceful group who tried to avoid war as much as possible.
The Long Death Of The Plains Indians
Essay, Research Paper “The long death? is an appropriate title for the book describing the slow death of the Plains Indian?s way of life. It took many years for the white man to alter and ruin the lives and homeland of the Plains Indians as the tribes suffered tremendously in the process. The Indians soon became warriors, to no avail, in hopes of defending their land against the settlers.
Tempest And Othello Essay Research Paper TOPIC
Tempest And Othello Essay, Research Paper TOPIC 3 The central issue depicted in both plays The Tempest and Othello is about money. Money in substantial amounts can represent great power and strength over the ruling nation. It plays a major role in our everyday society and one that is fully illustrated in both of Shakespeare’s play.
Nine Guardians Essay Research Paper Nine Guardians
Nine Guardians Essay, Research Paper Nine Guardians Throughout time man has oppressed his own kind. In The Nine Guardians man, in this case the Spanish man is oppressing the Mexican Indians. Just like history before the oppression of the Mexican Indians the oppressed revolt. In The Nine Guardians when the Indians revolt it causes death, degradation of a family, mental strain to the point of insanity and property damage, just as revolts before it.
Lennie Lenape Essay Research Paper he Lenape
Lennie Lenape Essay, Research Paper he Lenape Indians were the first people to live in what is now called New Jersey. The Lenape Indians lived in parts of Delaware, Pennsylvana, and New Jersey.
The Tempest Vs Brave New Worl Essay
, Research Paper Although these two English works exist many centuries apart and use two different forms, William Shakespeare in The Tempest and Aldous Huxley in Brave New World, use style to explore the theme of the nature of men and sleep . What is sleep? The dictionary definition states sleep as the natural periodic suspension of consciousness during which the powers of the body are restored.
Plains Indians Essay Research Paper During the
Plains Indians Essay, Research Paper During the 1800s, the Plains Indians were finally overcome by the white man. Several factors contributed to their downfall. In descending order, these included the near extinction of the buffalo, disease, tribal wars, and their naivete.
Indian Reservation Preservement Essay Research Paper Indian
Indian Reservation Preservement Essay, Research Paper Indian Project The Indians had every right to fight. Their land was being taken away by the whites. They were forcing them out by starving them and compressing them into small reservations. Many of the Indian leaders had felt safe before the whites began attacking and invading their territory.
Indian Movement Essay Research Paper Why were
Indian Movement Essay, Research Paper Why were the Indians forced off their land? a) Land Struggles b) Clash of Cultures Throughout the 1800s America was greatly expanding. As more settlers arrived, more were moving farther and farther west. At this time there were already natives living throughout the land that would one day make up all 50 states.
I Heard The Owl Call My NameMargaret
Craven Essay, Research Paper Margaret Craver?s novel, I Heard the Owl Call My Name, is the story of an ill, Mark Brian, who learns about life, death, and the power of love. His bishop sends him to Kingcome, an Indian village. There he learns enough of the meaning of life to be ready to die. In life people should give and share.
I Head The Own Call My Name
– Analytical Essay Essay, Research Paper Although the Indians in I Heard The Owl Call My Name, and in The Black Robe are primitive in the technological sense, they are neither simple or emotional people.
Removal Of Indians Essay Research Paper The
Removal Of Indians Essay, Research Paper The decision of the Jackson administration to remove the Cherokee Indians to land west of the Mississippi River in the 1830 s was more a reformulation of the national policy that
Iroquois Essay Research Paper The Iroquois
Iroquois Essay, Research Paper The Iroquois The Iroquois is a tribe of the Eastern Woodland indians. The Iroquois is one tribe that is seperated into five groups. These groups are called , Seneca ,
Master And Slave An Analysis Of The
Theme Of Bondage And Liberation In The Tempest Essay, Research Paper Each of the characters in The Tempest finds themselves in bondage. However, by the end of the story, the same characters are set free from whatever enslaves them. A few characters one can see enslaved are Prospero, Miranda, Ariel, and Caliban.
Daisy Cisneros
– Response Paper Essay, Research Paper Daisy Cisneros History 202 Response paper It was very hard to them to move from their own country were they grown up. It very difficult to leave something that you love like your relatives and all your memories, all your life its going to stay there then you have start a new life in a country that you are not familiarized with.
Tempest Essay Research Paper Slavery in The
Tempest Essay, Research Paper Slavery in The Tempest Slavery occurs on a widespread basis in The Tempest. Occurrence of slavery to many of the characters, all in different ways, helps to provide the atmosphere for the play. The obvious slaves are not the only slaves, as Prospero has basically got everybody entranced when he wants, to do whatever he wants with them.
Tempest Essay Research Paper The Tempest is
Tempest Essay, Research Paper The Tempest is a play that explores many themes, one of which is the theme of freedom versus control. This theme can be explored by examining the characters of the play.
Industrialization Essay Research Paper a Why were
Industrialization Essay, Research Paper a. Why were the Indians treated so unjustly? (12) The American settlers? greed was the basis for the injustice forced upon the Indians. At first the American?s simply wanted the land that could be used to grow or create products. Then the Indians were viewed as hostile enemies.
The Tempest Essay Research Paper Caliban
The Tempest Essay, Research Paper Caliban’s response to Trinculo and Stephano changes greatly throughout act two scene two. At first site Caliban intrepretates the the two as being spirits or Prospero’s, sent to torment him:
The Tempest Caliban
’s Ignorance Essay, Research Paper The Tempest: Caliban’s Ignorance Shakespeare portrays Stephano’s view of Caliban as an ignorant slave by taking advantage of the “monster”(Shakespeare, Act II, Scene II, line 31) while he is
The Tempest Essay Research Paper Prospero
The Tempest Essay, Research Paper Prospero’s philosopher lacking Shakespeake’s Tempest is a window into his idea of a utopia. The island serves as a place much like that of Plato’s Republic and Moore’s Utopia. But, Prospero, the leader of Shakespeare’s Tempest is not the same philosopher king that both Moore and Plato wished to rule their respective societies.
Pueblo Revolt Of 1680 Essay Research Paper
The Pueblo Revolt of 1680 was a very important part of New Mexico history. Because of the fact that there was 2 large groups, (Spaniards and Indians), fighting against each other there were 2 different accounts of what took place. These accounts told what took place and what led to this revolt.
Indian Essay Research Paper IndianTransformation of Native
Indian Essay, Research Paper Indian Transformation of Native American Cultures As the white man killed the buffalo, they also killed off the Indians. Indians needed buffalo to eat, defend, and stay warm. Horses helped both Indians and white man hunt, which killed off buffalo even faster. Guns that the white man brought over enabled the Indians to fight back.
Indians Of The United States Essay Research
Paper Indians of the United States There was a time long ago when there was no man in America, only animals. This was thousands of years before Columbus ever set eyes on America. What he saw was different; he saw a land populated from the north to the south. Due to the natural instinct of man to explore, the explorers just that to figure out the mysterious Indians.
Prospero
’s Role In The Tempest Essay, Research Paper Prospero s epilogue at the conclusion of The Tempest provides interesting parallels to its author s life. Written near the end of his career, numerous scholars suggest that it is Shakespeare s written farewell. Just as Shakespeare sculpts a world from nothing, Prospero authors the events on the island.
Defense Spending Essay Research Paper Defense SpendingDefense
Defense Spending Essay, Research Paper Defense Spending Defense spending is how much money the government uses to for our national defense. This year President Clinton?s budget includes 267 billion dollars for defense or around 15% of the budget. The budget only includes 18 billion dollars for foreign assistance, which accounts for about 1% of the budget.
The Tempest Essay Research Paper Tempest Character
The Tempest Essay, Research Paper Tempest Character Analysis William Shakespeare’s last play The Tempest is a story about Prospero (the rightful duke of Milan). He is betrayed by his brother Antonio and left on a ship with his daughter Miranda to die. Only things are not going according to plan and Prospero and Miranda arrive on an island.
California Indians Essay Research Paper The California
California Indians Essay, Research Paper The California Indians Location The California Indians we located in California. They settled in all areas of the state. California had the second-largest Native American population of any state. There was no empty land when the indians were there. The land had mountains, valleys, deserts, and the Pacific Ocean Coast all in California! A lot of them lived far down the coast north of Mexico.