Paper
Abortion is one of the most controversial issues today. It has become a question of not only ethics, but morals. In the 1973 case of Roe v Wade the Supreme Court ruled that a woman has the right to terminate a pregnancy by abortion within the first six months of the pregnancy. However, conservative Presidents have changed the legislation enough to allow states to restrict abortion in various ways (Practical Ethics, Peter Singer). In the following paper, I will summarize the views on abortion of Pope John Paul II and philosopher, Peter Singer. These two men have very conflicting opinions about abortion.
Pope John Paul II s Argument:
This argument is very adamantly against abortion. It is also a religiously based argument. He uses exerts from the Bible and other religious documents and quotes many different clergymen and priests to help defend his position.
He starts by explaining how you must follow the ten commandments to live a good life and have eternal life. Jesus replied, If you would enter life, keep the commandments (Mt 19:17). The first of these ten commandments is You shall not kill . On the contrary, you should love respect and promote life (The Gospel of Life, Paul II). In order to do this, one must carry out God s plan of procreation with love and intentions to multiply. By having an abortion, one is doing the exact opposite. Not only are they killing an innocent human being, but they are killing a child of God. Also, man is not the final judge in matters such as life and death, he is only a minister of God s plan (Humanae Vitae, Paul VI).
Paul II goes on to explain how human life is sacred and inviolable . Life is sacred because it is a gift from God and man was created in the image of God. God overlooks our lives from birth to death, and no one else has the right to destroy an innocent human being, especially one as innocent as an unborn child. Man is suppose to be the defender of the innocent, not the destroyer. He explains how the man who kills the innocent is one who has been deceived by the Devil, because only Satan delights in
the death of the living.
You shall not kill represents the extreme limit which cannot be exceeded. It is meant to encourage man to see life with respect and lead to the promotion of life with love. Along with the teaching that one shall not kill another, is this, as stated in the Didache, the most ancient non-biblical Christian writing: you shall not put a child to death by abortion nor kill it once it is born … The way of death is this: … they kill their children and by abortion cause God s creatures to parish … they are filled with sin. As time goes on, the Church will continue to teach the undeniable value on the first commandment. Even in the first centuries, murder was considered one of the three most serious sins. This should not come as a surprise. To kill something that was created by, and in the image of, God should be considered a serious sin.
The most important case involving the first commandment of You shall not kill is when it refers to innocent human beings. This is especially so when it refers to defenseless, weak, human beings such as an unborn child or infant. The taking of an innocent life, especially at it s beginning or end, is gravely immoral. This direct and voluntary action will always be regarded as morally evil and can never be considered as necessary, either as an end, or as means to a good end. Nothing and no none can in any way permit the killing of an innocent human being, whether a fetus or an embryo, and infant of an adult … no one is permitted to ask for this act of killing, either for him/herself or for another person entrusted to his or her care … Nor can any authority legitimately recommend or permit such an action (Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith).
Every innocent human being has a right to life. Every man, woman and child is a person worth protecting, not just an object to be used. Of all crimes possible, abortion and infanticide are defined as unspeakable crimes by the Second Vatican Council. When such crimes are accepted by much of the population and permitted by lawmaking
bodies, it is a dangerous sign that the moral line between good and evil is getting obscured. This is especially dangerous because the right to life is at stake.
The decision to have an abortion is often painful and tragic to the mother. Not only is she ridding herself of the fruit of life, but a part of herself, too. It may be that the mother s health, or the child s welfare after birth is a factor in this decision. However, these reasons and others like them, however serious and tragic, can never justify the deliberate killing of an innocent human being (The Gospel of Life, Paul II). This decision is, in the end, completely up to the mother. But she may be influenced by many others on the way. The father of the child, either by coercing her or by leaving her alone, can lead her to such a decision. Also, the family and friends of the mother may be to blame. The blame is also put on the legislation which allows the abortion, foundations which encourage the legalization of abortion, and those who promote sexual behaviors in those who cannot care for a child.
No circumstance, no purpose, no law whatsoever can ever make licit an act which is intrinsically illicit, since it is contrary to the Law of God which is written in every heart, knowable by reason itself, and proclaimed by the Church (The Gospel of Life, Paul II)
Singer s Response to this Argument:
Throughout Pope John Paul II s whole argument, he refers to a fetus as an innocent human being. Singer, however, does not agree that a fetus is a human being. He explains how there are stages to determine when a fetus becomes a human being. The earliest of these stages is the onset of consciousness, then comes quickening,
viability, and finally, birth.
Quickening is when the mother first feels the baby kick. Traditionally, this was a religious sign that the baby had a soul. Without such religious doctrines, quickening is not a strong dividing line to determine that the fetus is a human. Ultrasounds have shown
that a baby makes movements not felt by the mother as early as six weeks after conception (Practical Ethics, Peter Singer). If movement constitutes life, then when are paralyzed fetuses human beings?
Viability is the stage of the pregnancy when the fetus can survive outside the womb. In most cases, this is at the beginning of the third trimester. But, in other cases, this may not be until the fetus is born, depending on the medical facilities available. Therefor, viability cannot distinguish between a fetus and a human being, because viability happens at a different time for each woman.
Birth, obviously, is when the baby is born. This means that a fetus is not a human until it leaves the mother s womb. But should the location of the fetus really matter? Do those few seconds, or in some cases, hours, while the baby moves down the birth canal make the distinction between a fetus and a human?
Since none of these stages can determine when the fetus becomes a human being, there is no dividing line. Therefor, one cannot say whether a fetus is to be considered a human being, or just a fetus, and what rights to life this fetus has, if it is not a human
being.
Singer also believes that there is a difference between being a human being as a member of the homosapien race and being a person . People are self-conscious, they have feelings about themselves and others. They have the ability to be rational and to
make decisions. A person has interests and a desire to live. People are valuable. Is a fetus a person, or just a member of the homosapien race? If they don t have these characteristics, in Singer s view, they are not people. Since no fetus is a person, no fetus has the same claim to life as a person (Practical Ethics, Singer).
This brings up the question of immoral actions. To commit an immoral action, you must be harming others. Harm to others is either physical or emotional. Emotion, or psychological harm is harm to one s personhood. If a fetus has no personhood, and cannot feel pain, it cannot be harmed. Therefor, the act of killing a fetus, or having an abortion is not immoral. However, an abortion does take away the fetus potential for life. But this potential life is different from the actual life.
Paul II s argument against abortion is based completely on religious morals and writings. The first commandment You shall not kill has no religious meaning to Singer. His whole argument shows the answer to the question of abortion within the bounds of non-religious ethics (Practical Ethics, Singer). Therefor, the arguments of the two men are hard to compare.
Другие работы по теме:
Abortion Essay Research Paper ABORTION 1
Abortion Essay, Research Paper ABORTION 1. What are the issues? Abortion has been a major subject in the eyes of Americans for the past thirty years. It is something that Political Parties (ex. Right To Life) are chosen by and it is an issue that people are very passionate about. People feel that having an abortion should be considered murder while other people think its a very acceptable practice.
Abortion Is It Murder Essay Research Paper
Abortion: Is it Murder? A mother kills her baby because it is unwanted, yet she is not charged with murder. Is this right? Believe it or not, this has happened more than
Milton To Pope Essay Research Paper In
Milton To Pope Essay, Research Paper In this essay I will attempt to contrast the type of society that would create a Milton to a society that would create a Pope. Although you may be able to
Abortion Kills Essay Research Paper Abortion Kills
Abortion Kills Essay, Research Paper Abortion Kills Children Do you consider something with a beating heart a living creature? A baby s heart forms and starts beating in the fifth week of pregnancy, therefore that would make abortion a form of murder. Murder is classified as taking another human life. The baby that is growing inside of a woman is depending on her, so when she makes the choice to end the baby s life, she is making the choice to murder another human.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 6 of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 6 of 7 I recently interviewed a woman who had an abortion. She was twenty years of age when she had the abortion She did so because she felt she had no choice. She was away at college and she did not want to tell her parents and the guy was a jerk (Interview). I do not think I would be able to tell my parents I am pregnant if I was away at college.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Many have pondered
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Many have pondered upon the meaning of abortion. The argument being that every child that is born should be wanted and others who believe that every child that is conceived should be born. The choice of a woman whether or not she wants to conceive a child is called abortion. Abortion preserves a woman?s constitutional right, relieves the undesired child of future distress, and establishes a peaceful society.
Explain How Christian Teachings May Be Used
In A Discussion About Abortion Essay, Research Paper Christians are taught about their religion through teachings from the Bible. They also follow what the Pope and other religious teachers tell them. These teachings help guide
Anti Abortion Pill Essay Research Paper I
Anti Abortion Pill Essay, Research Paper I wish I would have said something about abortion and the new pill that came out. I wish that that pill would have never came out and I wish that none of the abortion methods ever came about. I believe no one in this world has the right to take the life of another human being no matter how old they are.
What Is Abortion Essay Research Paper What
What Is Abortion? Essay, Research Paper What Is Abortion? What is abortion? Is it the killing of a defense less child or is it the freedom of a woman. In the case of the latter, it is easy to see how
The Choice Essay Research Paper Abortion the
The Choice Essay, Research Paper Abortion the most personal choice a woman may ever have to make. To choose abortion would mean to terminate a fetus . To clarify the word fetus is in the Meriiam-Webester Dictionary as:”an unborn or unhatched vertabrate esp. especially after its basic structure has been laid down est. especially a developing human being in the uterus from usu. three months after pregancyoccurs”
Nazi Essay Research Paper John Mendes 83000Critical
Nazi Essay, Research Paper John Mendes 8/30/00 Critical Thinking Philosophy 100 Singer?s Final solution Singer and the Nazis both took away the rights of other human beings. Both men took away rights because of physical ability, self-awareness, or intelligence.
Abortion Pill Essay Research Paper The Abortion
Abortion Pill Essay, Research Paper The Abortion Pill There have always been strong disagreements as to whether abortion should be legal or not. A new medical breakthrough, the abortion pill, will only make these arguments stronger. Whether you are a pro-choice person or a pro-life person, there are still benefits to this recent discovery.
My Thought On Abortion Essay Research Paper
My thoughts on abortion Abortion is one of the toughest controversial issues. On the side of feminist and pro-abortionists, abortion is women’s right to choose and best healing for raped woman.For the religious group and pro-lifers, abortion is a kind of murder because unborn babies and even fetus are life.
Abortion In America Essay Research Paper Abortion
Abortion In America Essay, Research Paper Abortion in America One of the most debated issues in America is abortion: Pro-life or pro-choice. This is a decision that each person has to make for him or herself. Many people say that abortion is the woman’s choice. I firmly believe, however, that if the woman is willing to have sex, she should be willing to suffer the consequences.
Hungrey Essay Research Paper Global hunger is
Hungrey? Essay, Research Paper Global hunger is a major concern that effects the whole world. According to Peter Singer ?the whole way we look at moral issues-our moral conceptual scheme
Interpretations Of Hills Like White Elephants
Essay, Research Paper Interpretations of Hills Like White Elephants The woman in the story realizes a lot about her husband in the story. He got her pregnant and they were deciding on having an abortion or not to have an abortion. Ernest Hemingway sort of hid this in his story. He does not say in his story that they are talking about an abortion and if the reader does not catch this the story does not make much sense.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Abortion has been
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion has been around in our country for decades. It may be one of the most debated human rights topics in the whole world. I can remember the first time I really learned what abortion was. I was about 14, and I was sitting on a couch in my house, reading through a magazine. As I flipped through the magazine, I stopped on an article that caught my attention.
Abortion Essay Research Paper AbortionI feel that
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion I feel that abortion is wrong. God says that he is the way, the truth, and the life. I am a Christian and I believe that God has a plan for everyone and everything. He has the whole world planned and He sees ahead. What happens is his will, no matter how harsh it may be or difficult to deal with.
Canto Of Pope Essay Research Paper In
Canto Of Pope Essay, Research Paper In this Canto, Pope describes the satirical decent of Umbriel into “underworld” as the last literary convention of epic poetry that Pope uses.
Abortion Essay Research Paper There are many
Abortion Essay, Research Paper There are many women who have choices to make in life that can be difficult or easy. One very difficult decision is whether or not to terminate a pregnancy. Most people should think before they act. If a woman has to terminate a pregnancy, it is because she wasn’t planning to get pregnant or because she did not use birth control.
Abortion Essay Research Paper wwwpottersschoolcomabortionIs it right
Abortion Essay, Research Paper www.pottersschool/abortion/ Is it right or is it wrong? Is it murder or is it a woman’s choice. There are so many conflicting views, but who is right? The debate over abortion will probably never be settled in my life time. As with many computer literate people, the author of this site gives us an objective view on abortion.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Abortion I think
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion I think is very bad. Abortion is the killing of an unborn child. The abortion clinics use many cruel and discusting techniques to kill the unborn baby. On way is they take a vaccuum and suck the child out break it into pieces. Another way is they take a sharp knife or something and they scrape the baby out while cutting it into pieces.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Abortion is the
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion is the termination of an unborn fetus. In today’s society there is a lot of controversy over this issie. Many people have views that say abortion is both right and wrong, while others are primarily focused on it either being right, or wrong. I for one am completely against the whole abortion issue.
Abortion Essay Research Paper My personal opinion
Abortion Essay, Research Paper My personal opinion about abortion is that it should stay legal. I believe that it is the woman’s choice because it’s her body, and no one else should be allowed to tell her what she can, and can’t do with it.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 2 of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 2 of 7 Throughout the Middle Ages and Renaissance, abortion was legal until the moment of quickening. In 1588 Pope Sixtus V called abortion the same as murder and thus subject to the same penalties. Within three years Pope Gregory XVI eliminated any penalties until ensoulment- which was then determined to be about 40 days after conception (5).
Abortion ProChoice Essay Research Paper An abortion
Abortion: Pro-Choice Essay, Research Paper An abortion is a medical procedure that should be offered in every Hospital. I myself am pro-choice, there are several reasons that contribute to that and those will be discussed in this essay. My first reason, is that it is the woman?s body, and she can do with it what she pleases.
Key Differences Which Separate Pope From Wordsworth
Essay, Research Paper Key Differences Which Separate Pope from Wordsworth In comparing excerpts from Pope’s “An Essay on Man” and Wordsworth’s “Prospectus”, I found many similarities and some key differences. Pope’s lean toward the more structured and confined, and Wordsworth’s lean towards the informal and original.
Dfferences In Pope
& Wordswort Essay, Research Paper Key Differences Which Separate Pope from Wordsworth In comparing excerpts from Pope s An Essay on Man and Wordsworth s Prospectus , I found many similarities and some key differences. Pope s lean toward the more structured and confined, and Wordsworth s lean towards the informal and original.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 7 of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 7 of 7 The last question was asking the females if abortions should be banned. 24% said they think abortion should be banned in Pennsylvania
Abortion ProChoice Essay Research Paper Abortion ProChoiceIt
Abortion: Pro-Choice Essay, Research Paper Abortion: Pro-Choice It should be strictly between a doctor and his/her patient whether or not an abortion should be performed. Many Anti-Choicers give us their speeches about how immoral abortions are, but different people have different morals. I personally would not have an abortion, but I think that whoever wants an abortion should be given the option.
Abortion Essay Research Paper My view on
Abortion Essay, Research Paper My view on the abortion is pro-choice so I will debate the issue from the pro-life point of view. Abortion is in a word: murder. There is no way around it , people that have abortions are committing a crime. If one was killing a person who could defend themselves they would go to jail but the people who have abortions just get continue on with their sinful lives.
Abortion Essay Research Paper IntroductionThis piece of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Introduction: This piece of coursework is about the issue of abortion, the Catholic Churchs view point to abortion, the pro and anti abortionists and the implications it has on modern day society and individuals. The Catholic churchs view is that all human life is sacred and that includes the baby in the womb.