Doctrine Of Creation Essay, Research Paper
Doctrine of creation
‘What do we mean by creation? How helpful are making, emanation and/or artistic work as analogies? Is it a doctrine about the world’s beginnings or origin, or about its present or future existence, or what?
Creation is often referred to as a ‘mystery’ and this is due to its perhaps ambiguous nature. Christian theology defines creation in many different ways, which differ greatly as viewpoints on the same theme. John Macquarrie tries to make the mystery clearer by using two analogies to try to describe what creation actually is.
The first of these is that of ‘making’. This is best understood alongside the literal understanding of creation, which can be found in the Bible, especially in the Old Testament (Genesis). The analogy is that of a craftsman producing an article that is to be used. It stresses the superiority of God; there is both differences and distance between the craftsman and his product – as there is transcendence between God and God’s creatures. It treats creation as an act of free will on the part of God, not as a process that is simply part of the Natural Law, which is more a view expressed by the second analogy.
One problem with the ‘making’ analogy is that it doesn’t embrace the traditional ‘creatio ex nihilo’ (creation out of nothing) view; if God has made the cosmos in the way in which a carpenter or a blacksmith would, out of what has he actually created it?
The second analogy is that of ‘emanation’. To understand this analogy it would be best to imagine God, the creator, as the sun, with the created, Gods creatures, as the rays emanating from it. This view stresses more affinity between the source (God) and what has sprung from it, thus making this the opposite of the ‘making’ analogy, with a
much stronger emphasis on immanence rather than transcendence.
As already mentioned, this theory of creation treats it more as a natural process that a spontaneous act, which is considered by some to be moving too far along the scale; a happy mean between nature and free will is the ideal view. Emanation is not a very biblical, traditionalist view of creation, and as such is often seen as opposed
to the view of making. However, Macquarrie would not wish this, and
says
‘It should not be regarded as a rival idea to the biblical one…It should indeed be regarded as secondary to the biblical idea, but as such it provides certain correctives and gives expression to insights which are not clearly presented in the image of making.’
A suggested ‘middle position between these two opposing images is sometimes put forward, that of the ‘work of art’ analogy. At first glance this seems to be a good balance between transcendence and immanence; in creating a work, an artist does put something of himself into it, while at the same time remaining external to the actual thing itself.
But does this do justice to the extent of the immanence of God in the creation of the cosmos? The artist analogy now looks to be too external; again there is the wrong balance. A way of creating the right balance would be to hold ’side by side in their tension with one another the models of making and emanation’.
All of these images do have something valuable in the search for the correct view of God and creation, however they all need to be given equal weight in the mind as they all have bad points and all have good. How you see the balance of transcendence and immanence in the creation mystery is a matter largely for the individual, however most Christian disciplines view God as both transcendent and immanent at the
same time in the creation of the cosmos.
Karl Barth claims that as we can not know empirically about creation, the whole doctrine of creation is in fact a doctrine of faith; the factual account of a world coming into being could be regarded as a creed of sorts, an expression of belief in God. Christian doctrine of creation is split into three sections; creatio originalis (the single act of creation in the beginning), creatio continua ( continuous involvement of creation) and creatio nova, the new creation still to come.
The obvious teaching in the doctrine of creation is the literal Old Testament view stated in the Bible; ‘In the beginning…’
But this creatio originalis view cannot be all there is to say about creation; if God is one who creates immanently, he must be there for us in the present- we can only know of the creation through the present after all.
E. Mascall defends the creatio continua view by putting a philosophical slant on things; he puts creation not only as the act of bringing the world into existence but also as something that ‘ would still have application to finite beings even if they had always existed and therefore had no beginning at all’ . A supporter of this view was St. Thomas Aquinas, though much earlier. He likened creation to the upkeep as well as the making; returning to our earlier analogy of the craftsman, God keeps us ‘well-oiled’. St. Thomas claimed that ‘if He [God] withdrew his action from them [things God has brought into being] they would return to non-existence’
Creation is therefore involved with both bringing things into being and maintaining them; it is a continual act, hence creatio continua.
Karl Barth provides us with a further inference regarding creatio continua when he says, drawing on Gods benevolence as a proof of creations continual state,
‘It would be a strange love that was satisfied with the mere existence and nature of the other, then withdrawing, leaving it to its own devices’
The three fold view of creation is and has been a popular one in the doctrine of creation, however it and the eschatological teaching of creation have been somewhat neglected with the advent of Darwinism and evolutionary theories. But surely we can dismiss the problem of evolution when we think of creation as a continual act;
‘…the act of creation gathers into one single divine moment the whole of existence, even though…extended in time…’
There is therefore no conflict between evolution and archaeological findings, and the traditional doctrine of creation provided that we think of the two as existing simultaneously in two separate realities. One way to look at it is an analogy, which is sometimes used in order to try and understand God’s omnipresence, a difficult concept to grasp for human beings.
Imagine a book that contains the world’s story from beginning to end, with the timescale in that book being that of Earth. God is the reader/writer/editor, and he is external to the book, both in terms of being able to edit it and in terms of time (if He is immutable and infinite so must He be outside the framework of our time).
So God can edit the book; he is something external (transcendence) but also involved as a reader, writer or editor (immanence). This present involvement we can see is creatio continua.
A story with a beginning and a middle usually has an end; we come now to the eschatological teachings of creation, creatio nova, the future involvement of God. Our destiny as human beings can be seen to be written in the book; the completion and end destination of creation, still to be fulfilled.
The three fold view of creation is one adopted by mot scholars; it is a sensible, balanced view of the doctrine as a teaching on more than just one act in time, i.e. creatio originalis.
Bibliography
Study pack, Doctrine of creation
Barth, K: The Openness of Being
Genesis 1
Bonhoeffer: Creation and Temptation
Mascall, E : The Openness of Being
St. Thomas Aquinas: Summa Theologica
Barth, K: Church Dogmatics
32f
Другие работы по теме:
Siddhartha Essay Research Paper had one single
Siddhartha Essay, Research Paper had one single goal–to become empty, to become empty of thirst, desire, dreams, pleasure and sorrow–to let the Self die. No longer to be Self, to experience the peace of an emptied heart, to experience pure thought… (Page 11, chapter 2)
Mcculloch V Maryland Essay Research Paper The
Mcculloch V. Maryland Essay, Research Paper The Supreme Court case of McCulloch v. Maryland set forth important principles in American government. The case itself dealt with whether or not the Congress had power from the Constitution to establish a national bank; also, it dealt with whether or not a state could tax or interfere with the national bank.
Unifying Themes Through World Religions Essay Research
Paper Not a single person likes to feel alone or lonely, making companionship key for a ?healthy? life. Whether through relationships with others, animals, or objects, most people are able to find the essential comfort. Millions of people have turned to one religion or another because there was some desirable idiosyncrasy inside that doctrine.
The Cold War Essay Research Paper In
The Cold War Essay, Research Paper In this paper I will discuss what actions and thoughts added up to cause the cold war. The cold war lasted from September 1, 1945 to about December 25, 1991. That is about forty-five years, which is an extremely long time. The cold war was a global competition basically between two sides, the Free World, which was led by the United States of America, and the Communist World led by the Soviet Union.
Christian Doctrine Concerning Humankind And Sin Essay
, Research Paper email: byrdd@mail.lakecity.cc.fl.usChristian Doctrine Concerning Humankind and SinThe Christian Doctrine of Mankind is Created, Free-willed, Image of God (Dr. Friend, 9/20/97). In this paper I will discuss the creation versus evolution aspect of the created portion of that doctrine.
Finnnney Essay Research Paper and after his
Finnnney Essay, Research Paper and after his conversion, Finney rejected the Calvinist doctrine of passive salvation available only to the elect. He believed that God offered Himself to everyone and, most
Socrates Final Speech Essay Research Paper Perhaps
Socrates Final Speech Essay, Research Paper Perhaps Socrates most important gift was the ability to stay timeless. However, his teachings were cut short when he was sentenced to death. In his speech “The Apology”, he claimed that a “good man cannot be harmed either in life or death”. If Socrates was right in this statement, then those righteous people on earth have nothing to fear, not even death.
American Imperialism Essay Research Paper The idea
American Imperialism Essay, Research Paper The idea of imperialism during the 19th century was mostly associated with European powers. The United States was not viewed, especially by itself, as an imperialist power. In fact the U S attacked imperialist views by way of the press. However, the US had criticized Europe and expressed their anti imperialism views in the media.
Karma And Varna Essay Research Paper What
Karma And Varna Essay, Research Paper What is the relation, if any, of the concept of varna to the concept of karma? Of karma to the doctrine of reincarnation? The concepts of varna and karma are
Monroe Doctrine Essay Research Paper The Monroe
Monroe Doctrine Essay, Research Paper The Monroe Doctrine was a cornerstone in American History because of the closure of the Western Hemisphere for future colonization, views that any attempts at controlling the Western Hemisphere were hostile, and prevention of the United States from interfering in internal affairs and the wars of European powers.
The Monroe Doctrine Essay Research Paper One
The Monroe Doctrine Essay, Research Paper One of James Monroe s most valuable asset to this country during his presidency would be the self titled Monroe Doctrine. This address set forth an American written policy on European intervention in the Western Hemisphere, and would soon become one of the foundations of United States policy in Latin America.
Truman Doctrine Essay Research Paper
“I believe that it must be the policy of the United States to support free people who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressure.” (Harry Truman mach 1947). This is part of the speech Harry S. Truman gave to congress on the behalf of small countries falling to the pressures of communism.
USA Essay Research Paper 4 American Civil
USA Essay, Research Paper 4. American Civil War The war between states, in the U. S. history, a four-year war (1861-65) between the federal government of the U. S. and eleven Southern states that asserted their right to secede from the Union. The secession of the Southern states in 1860-61 and the ensuing outbreak of armed hostilities were the culmination of decades of growing sectional friction over the related issues of slavery, trade, and tariffs, and the doctrine of state?s rights.
Positivism Essay Research Paper Positivism is a
Positivism Essay, Research Paper Positivism is a system of philosophy based on experience and experimental knowledge of natural sensation, in which metaphysics and theology are regarded as inadequate and imperfect systems of knowledge. (www.eb) The 19th-century French mathematician and philosopher Auguste Comte first called the doctrine positivism, but some of the positivist concepts may be traced to the British philosopher David Hume, the French philosopher Duc de Saint-Simon, and the German philosopher Immanuel Kant.
Indian Creation Myths Essay Research Paper In
Indian Creation Myths Essay, Research Paper In reading three different Indian creation myths, The Emergence, Lodge-Boy and Thrown-Away, and The Woman who Fell from the Sky, we are taught many things not only about creation myths themselves, but about the culture from which they originated. These creation myths contain many of the same universal elements that are found in nearly all creation myths and they demonstrate for us the degree to which the Indians felt we truly are one with nature.
Karma Essay Research Paper KARMAThe doctrine of
Karma Essay, Research Paper KARMA The doctrine of Karma is a spiritual doctrine based on the theory of cause and effect. Although Karma does not exactly fit the definition of supernatural phenomenon it is a spiritual doctrine based on the philosophy that God is not responsible for the happiness or failure of an individual, rather, we as individuals are solely responsible for the consequences of our own behavior.
Monroe Doctrine Essay Research Paper Monroe Doctrine
Monroe Doctrine Essay, Research Paper Monroe Doctrine A renewal of European interest in the hemisphere caused the administration to adopt a nationalist foreign policy. James Monroe declared the position of the United States on European interference in the America, which over time became known as the Monroe Doctrine.
Eisenhower Administration Essay Research Paper What role
Eisenhower Administration Essay, Research Paper What role did the Eisenhower administration play in Civil Rights? During the 1950 s race relations in the United States began to explode and the domestic tranquility caused years of injustice for African Americans. Eisenhower, the current president, entered office committed to Civil Rights in principle, and he pushed the issue in areas of federal authority.
Plato Vs Aristotle Essay Research Paper How
Plato Vs. Aristotle Essay, Research Paper How do we explain the world around us? How can we get to the truth? Plato and Aristotle began the quest to find the answers thousands of years ago. Amazingly, all of philosophy since that time can be described as only a rehashing of the original argument between Plato and Aristotle.
Greek Orthodox Church Essay Research Paper The
Greek Orthodox Church Essay, Research Paper The Greek Orthodox Church The Greek Orthodox Church is one of the three major branches of Christianity, which “stands in today’s society as one of the communities created
Resistance To Soviet Authority Essay Research Paper
Following WWII, The United States and Soviet Union were gripped in the clenches of a Cold War. Stalin felt the need to spread communism and add on to the Soviet Union by installing communist governments in the countries to the east, while the goal of the Truman Doctrine in America was to prevent the spread of communism.
Wife Of Bath Essay Research Paper Wife
Wife Of Bath Essay, Research Paper Wife Of Bath Feminism, or a doctrine advocating social, politcal, and economic rights for women equal to those of men, plays a large role in “The Wife of Bath’s
Expansionism Essay Research Paper In a sense
Expansionism Essay, Research Paper In a sense, The United States has been “expansionistic” from its very beginning. The 13 English colonies, clinging to the eastern seaboard, were determined to push westward despite all natural and political obstacles. Once established as a nation, the United States went about acquiring even more land, including Florida, the Louisiana Purchase, and the Mexican Cession.
The Doctrine Of Privity Of Contract Contract
Law. Private Or Public Essay, Research Paper Contract law- The Doctrine of privity. The law of contract is not about only private justice or public regulation; it is clearly concerned with a combination of both of these aspects of contract law in a number of ways. I will discuss this point in relation to the debate concerning privity of contract and whether a third party beneficiary of a contract should have a cause of action against the promisor.
The Incorporation Doctrine Essay Research Paper The
The Incorporation Doctrine Essay, Research Paper The Incorporation Doctrine The Incorporation Doctrine was devised by the Supreme Court to apply the state rights that are enumerated in the Bill of Rights. This is to ensure that the individual states are not by-passing the Bill of Rights in their decision making process.
Roosevelt Corollary Essay Research Paper In 1823
Roosevelt Corollary Essay, Research Paper In 1823, U.S. President James Monroe issued the Monroe Doctrine. It stated that no European nation should intervene in any situations in North or South America, and in return, the United States would not meddle in European affairs. It was originally intended to protect the newly freed South American countries, once Spanish colonies.
Civil Rights 2 Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Rights 2 Essay, Research Paper Civil Rights Several events in the history of America’s civil rights movement marked turning points that changed or illuminated aspects of the movement. For
Supporting Big Bang Essay Research Paper Science
Supporting Big Bang Essay, Research Paper Science has hypothesized that the universe was created by a big bang. By researching stars and fossil records scientists have claimed that the earth is much older than it is said to be in the creation theory. The creation theory says that the universe is only several thousand years old, but carbon dating has shown that fossils on earth are millions of years old thus disproving part of the creation theory with evidence.
Natural Law Essay Research Paper Ancient Greek
Natural Law Essay, Research Paper Ancient Greek philosophers were the first to elaborate a natural law doctrine. Heraclitus spoke in the 6th century BC of a common wisdom that pervades the whole universe, for all human laws are nourished by one, the divine. Aristotle distinguished between two kinds of justice: “A rule of justice is natural that has the same validity everywhere, and does not depend on our accepting it or not; a rule is legal [conventional] that in the first instance may be settled in one way or the other indifferently.” The Stoics, especially the philosopher Chrysippus of Soli, constructed a systematic natural law theory.