Galileo And Newton Essay, Research Paper
Galileo and Newton
2/4/97
Galileo believed the physical world to be bounded. He says that all
material things have “this or that shape” and are small or large in relation to
other things. He also says that material objects are either in motion or at
rest, touching or not touching some other body, and are either one in number,
or many. The central properties of the material world are mathematical and
strengthened through experimentation. Galileo excludes the properties of tastes,
odors, colors, and so on when describing the material world. He states that
these properties “reside only in the consciousness.” These latter properties
would cease to exist without the living creature so the mathematically defined
properties are the most accurate in describing the material world. Galileo
seems to test his beliefs through experimentation and mathematical reasoning.
He sites examples in life that support his hypothesis. His argument is of a
scientific nature because he is making a hypothesis on a distinctive type of
concept. The conclusions that Galileo made relate directly to the work in
physics for which he is so well known. His conclusions put emphasis on shapes,
numbers, and motion which are all properties that lend themselves to support
through “reasoning back and forth between theory and experiment.” I feel that
Galileo’s argument is a valid one because it explains relations in nature and
the physical world through mathematical analysis. This allows him to define a
world outside of human existence that can be logically calculated and explained.
His view describes the world in which living creatures live and not contrasts it
to the world within living creatures. The problem with Galileo’s view is that
it pioneers a scientific outlook but never actually fulfills it.
Newton believes the world is ultimately made up of hard particles that
can retain different properties. The central properties are solid, massy,
impenetrable, and movable particles. He believes God created matter in the
beginning in such a way to allow the particles to take on mathematical forms.
His approach is a scientific one because he practices the continual interaction
of experiment and theory. It is the hard particles that move in such a way that
can be assigned certain mathematical principles that clearly explain the
interaction of bodies. Newton’s conclusion seems to be a strong one because it
deals with the world being made up of particles and shows how these particles
act with each other in a way that can be explained scientifically. I like the
idea of organized flow in the world and God being the creator of it all. The
mathematical/scientific approach offers explanation to how the particles are
moving. Galileo and Newton differ in certain aspects of their understanding of
the physical world. Galileo doesn’t put much emphasis on the role of creativity
in science. Newton believes in the mathematical and experimentation outlook of
science pioneered by Galileo but he believed that new concepts are the product
of creative imagination. He felt that math should explain the concepts imagined.
Newton extended ideas pioneered by Galileo on issues of forces, masses, shapes,
and forms. Newton didn’t feel that the scientific theory needed to answer every
question asked about a phenomenon in order to be useful.
Galileo and Newton make a strong argument for the lack of purposes or
values in nature. Their scientific minds sought answers on a logical scale.
They could analyze the material world through calculations and in this math was
suitable explanation. In the study of physics, purposes are irrelevant.
Physics looks for the mathematical explanation of concepts and doesn’t need to
analyze the purpose behind such. It is concerned simply with what happens and
how it is happening. The philosophy of physics could extend the concepts to
incorporate purpose. The world is the product of the chance concourse of atoms.
Everything is comprised of atoms and it makes up the known world to which
mathematical principles analyze. If there are no purposes in the universe and
this fact is supported through scientific study, then there is purpose in that
science works to break down the material world to series of facts that are
constantly adapting to one another.
The world view introduced by seventeenth century mechanists is science.
Science became the answer or way to the answer. Aristotelian view is concerned
with the final state whereas as the scientists thought the important information
was the entire process, or efficient causes. It is also concerned with the
purposes and values that are at work in nature while mechanists see nature as a
mechanism that operates blindly, and the forces of nature are in themselves
entirely indifferent to purposes or values. Newton, in opposition to Aristotle,
didn’t believe in unknown causes. He wanted answers that were or could be
proven. I feel that Newton has the stronger view because his deals with
observable facts and not just concepts. Newton’s ideas about the world extend
the concepts of Democritus. Newton strengthens the mechanistic view by
providing it with mathematical reasoning. Aristotle’s argument of Democritus
weakens when dealing with Newton. He had scientific evidence that backed up his
claims. However, Newton still doesn’t concern mechanism with the answer of
“why” but rather looked to understand the immediate “how.” Newton would agree
that Democritus didn’t support his arguments with fact and that they are mostly
conceptual views. Newton would have to support Democritus for initiating the
atomic theory and would probably say that his ideas are relevant and not over
simplified. Form in the world is the effect of other causes in a long,
scientific chain of efficient causes by the interactions of atoms.
In a way Newton’s cosmological ideas are better because he was able to
support interactions within the universe with mathematical reasoning. He
eventually came to the belief that “there is no scientific explanation for the
pattern of the planets,” holding that coplanar orbits with velocities in the
same direction cannot be accounted for by natural causes. This lead him to the
answer that God prevents the universe from collapsing. I feel this is better
than Timaeus’s view of patterns in the cosmos because he has to discard certain
information because he himself can’t find mathematical proof for these theories.
Later, Laplace will be able to account for the coplanar character of the solar
system by showing inadequacies in Newton’s science. This is a credit to Newton
in that if he couldn’t back a theory with mathematical reason and experiment, he
wasn’t just going to assume it to be true. Galileo and Newton along with Plato
believed in atoms or particles as the material of which all things are made of.
I also infer that they would somewhat agree on how truth can be perceived
differently in the same manner that opinion is different from knowledge (this
idea was illustrated by Plato in his divided line analogy). For the mechanists,
opinion is a perception of truth but an incorrect one because it is not
supported with mathematical reasoning and experimentation, which would then make
it knowledge.
Другие работы по теме:
Sir Isaac Newtonscience Essay Research Paper Describe
Sir Isaac Newton(science) Essay, Research Paper Describe Social and Economical conditions of this time. During the time period of 1643 – 1727 there were many things happening. One thing, which was happening, was the plague. 1/3 of the world died in that terrible time. Newton was very lucky that he was sent to his aunts to live.
Galileo Essay Research Paper Born Galileo Galilei
Galileo Essay, Research Paper Born Galileo Galilei, his main contributions were, in astronomy, the use of the telescope in observation and the discovery of sunspots, lunar mountains and valleys, the four largest satellites of Jupiter, and the phases of Venus. In physics, he discovered the laws of falling bodies.
Galile Vs The Bible Essay Research Paper
Galileo vs. The Bible Religion and science have always been conflicting studies. Religion, being based on faith, relies on the supernatural to explain life and being. Science, on the other hand, cannot do this. Scientists need to eliminate the possibility of the unexplainable in order to maintain and control group by which to measure other groups.
Galieo A Look At The Math In
His Life Essay, Research Paper Galileo was born in the city of Pisa, on the day Michelangelo died. His parents determined the first, significant, event in his life. At the age of seventeen he was sent to the University of Pisa to study medicine. It is reported that Galileo’s interest in science and mathematics was roused by this problem and then further stimulated by the chance attendance at a lecture on geometry at the university.
My Ass Essay Research Paper v A
My Ass Essay, Research Paper v A Florentine philosopher, physicist, and inventor. This is a lot of work to do in one life time. Galileo Galilei did all that and even more. He is most commonly remembered for his condemnation by the Holy Office as a result of his attempting to prove the Copernican theory of the universe.
Enlightenment The Light Bulb Of The 1700
’s Essay, Research Paper Enlightenment: The Light Bulb of the 1700’s Throughout history many people have changed society with their ideas and actions. Two philosophers whose ideas and actions changed society are Voltaire
Evangelista Torricelli Essay Research Paper I chose
Evangelista Torricelli Essay, Research Paper I chose to do my report on Evangelista Torricelli. The reason I chose to do him is because he is both Italian and male. I am also both Italian and male which would be my connection to him.
Galileo Essay Research Paper Galileo GalileeGalileo Galilee
Galileo Essay, Research Paper Galileo GalileeGalileo Galilee was a pioneer of the modern physics and astronomy who was born on February 15, 1564 near Pisa, Italy. An Italian astronomer, he was the one who invented the telescope and discovered many undiscovered realms of the space. He was one of the few that challenge the idea of the earth not being at the center of the galaxy.
Newton Essay Research Paper Mediaeval understanding of
Newton Essay, Research Paper Mediaeval understanding of ?science? had mostly based Aristotle; Aristotle?s ideas held for thousands of years until the scientific revolution begin breaking them off. It is Newton helped the transformation of natural philosophy into modern science.
The Telescope Essay Research Paper The TelescopeIn
The Telescope Essay, Research Paper The Telescope In 1609 Galileo Galilee Constructed his first telescope. Little did he know that this would be one of the greatest inventions the world would ever see. This fairly simple creation enhanced our ability to see things that are very far away and that can?t be seen with the naked eye.
Galileo And The Telescope Essay Research Paper
Galileo was not the person who invented the telescope, but he was the first one to use the telescope to study the heavens. He made many observations using the telescope that shocked the religious world. In this short essay, I will only focus on three observations and how an Aristotlean reacts to it. These observations played a very important role on the development of astronomy.
The Scientific Revolution A New View Of
The World Essay, Research Paper Herbert Butterfield stated that, ?Since the Scientific Revolution overturned the authority in science not only of the middle ages but of the ancient world?it outshines everything since the rise of Christianity.? During the scientific revolution Nicholas Copernicus, Galileo Galilei and Isaac Newton all voiced their opinions that contradicted the views of the church.
Galileo Essay Research Paper After reading this
Galileo Essay, Research Paper After reading this letter I feel that Galileo had a very opinionated outlook on life and was heavily involved in a struggle for freedom of inquiry. Galileo was a person who had many strong beliefs and would not let people or a document have a say in what he believes.
Issac Newton Essay Research Paper Isaac Newton
Issac Newton Essay, Research Paper Isaac Newton was born in 1642 and died in in 1727. He was an english scientist and mathematician who was born into a poor farming family. Newton was not a good
The Scientific Revolution Essay Research Paper During
The Scientific Revolution Essay, Research Paper During the Scientific Revolution scientists such as Galileo, Copernicus, Descartes and Bacon wrestled with questions about God, human aptitude, and the possibilities of understanding the world. Eventually, the implications of the new scientific findings began to affect the way people thought and behaved throughout Europe.
Motion Galileo And Newton Essay Research Paper
Sir Isaac Newton- Newton’s fascination for gravitation started was when he was sitting underneath an apple tree alone in the countryside observing the scenery. While he was sitting down,
Marxism Through Galileo Essay Research Paper Marxism
Marxism Through Galileo Essay, Research Paper Marxism Through Galileo Marxism is a form of communism in which one day the common people, or the proletariats, would overthrow the power of the upper class, or capitalists. Bertolt Brecht, the author of the play Galileo, was a strong believer in this kind of communism.
What Drives History Essay Research Paper
“History is the Essence of Innumerable Biographies” -Thomas CarlyleWhat drives history? Before we answer this question, we must go deeper and answer a more important question: What is history? History is, simply, all of the events, ideas, people, and occurrences that have existed in the past. These things have been driven by one common factor: individuals.
Galileo Galilei Essay Research Paper Galileo Galilei1564
Galileo Galilei Essay, Research Paper Galileo Galilei 1564 -1642 Galileo Galilei was born on February 15, 1564 in Pisa, Italy. Galileo pioneered “experimental scientific method,” and was the first to use a refracting telescope to make important astronomical discoveries.
Galileo Galilei Essay Research Paper Galileo was
Galileo Galilei Essay, Research Paper Galileo was an Italian mathematician, astronomer, and physicist. He was born in Pisa, Italy on February 15, 1564. In the mid 1570?s, he and his family moved to Florence and he started his formal education in a local monastery. He was sent to the University of Pisa in 1581.
Galileo Galilei
“founder Of Modern Experimental Science” Essay, Research Paper Galileo Galilei “founder of modern experimental science” Galileo Galilei was one of the most remarkable scientists ever. He
Galileo 2 Essay Research Paper Galileo s
Galileo 2 Essay, Research Paper Galileo s Scientific Revolution Against the Church The scientific revolution was not only a challenge to a government but was also a challenge to a deeply rooted religion. The Church, having been influenced by Greek philosophers, viewed the world as a creation by God, complete with lawfulness, regularity and beauty.
Life Of Galileo Essay Research Paper Betrolt
Life Of Galileo Essay, Research Paper Betrolt Brecht s Life of Galileo , depicts key episodes in the life of the great Italian physicist, Galileo Galilei. The central concern of the play is the essential conflict between Galileo and the Catholic Church. The scientist s heretical discoveries about the solar system brought him to the attention of the Inquisition and led ultimately to his theories being silenced by the Church.
Galileo Essay Research Paper Galileo
Galileo Essay, Research Paper Galileo “Whereas Galileo spent his last days under house arrest and was formally condemned by the Church for his scientific views, the elder Darwin was widely
The Supreme Sir Isaac Newton Essay Research
Paper The Supreme Sir Isaac Newton Sir Isaac Newton (1642-1727) was the greatest and most prominent physicist to ever walk upon the Earth?s surface, yet we have the Anti-Newtonians who say that Sir Isaac Newton should not be considered the greatest/most influential physicist of the past or present. However, in Dr.
Galileo Essay Research Paper Galileo was an
Galileo Essay, Research Paper Galileo was an Italian physicist and astronomer who with the German astronomer Johannes kelper initiated the scientific revolution that began the work of Sir Isaac Newton. Galileos main interest was astronomy he used the telescope which he invented using optic lenses to see sunspots on the sun loonier mountains and valleys the four largest satellites of Jupiter and the phases of Venus.
Galileo 2 Essay Research Paper GalileoGalileo 15641642
Galileo 2 Essay, Research Paper Galileo Galileo (1564-1642), was an Italian physicist and astronomer, who, with the German astronomer Johannes Kepler, initiated the scientific revolution that flowered in the work of the English physicist Sir Isaac Newton. Born Galileo Galilei, his main contributions were, in astronomy, the use of the telescope in observation and the discovery of sunspots, lunar mountains and valleys, the four largest satellites of Jupiter, and the phases of Venus.
Ancient Astronomy Essay Research Paper Astronomy has
Ancient Astronomy Essay, Research Paper Astronomy has been a source for myriad ideas influencing every subject. The stars have existed since the dawn of man. People have looked to the universe to determine physical location, gain spiritual direction and to track time. Many early scientists used astronomy to make careers for themselves and print their names in all the history books of time.
Galileo
& His Impact On Society Essay, Research Paper Known to some people as the father of modern science, Galileo impacted this field in such a way that he was put on trial for going against the Catholic Church?s beliefs, because he supported the Copernican theory that the Earth revolved around the sun. The Church?s belief was that the Earth was in the center of the universe and all heavenly bodies went around the Earth (geocentric theory or Ptolemaic theory, followers of Aristotle believed this too).
Galileo Science And The Church Essay Research
Paper Wanting people to know that there was a double fault in the conflict between Galileo and the Church Father Langford writes an account of the facts in Galileo, Science and the Church.
Galileo And Church Essay Research Paper Galileo
Galileo And Church Essay, Research Paper Galileo, Science and the Church, by Jerome J. Langford, are about the trials and tribulations of Galileo with the Roman Catholic Church in the 1600?s. The
Galileo Essay Research Paper GALILEOGalileo 1564 1642
Galileo Essay, Research Paper GALILEO Galileo (1564- 1642) was an Italian astronomer and physicist whose discoveries in mechanics and astronomy contribute greatly to the progression of Science. He started his Science career at the University of Pisa where he studied to be a physician. Galileo made his first important discovery while still studying in Pisa when he was only 19, it was when he was in the cathedral observing the swinging action of the hanging lamps, he wondered if the duration of their swings was always the same regardless of the distance they traveled.
The Science Of Galileo Essay Research Paper
THE SCIENCE OF GALILEO The play Life of Galileo is considered a masterpiece and one of the most relevant plays of the 20th century. It addresses the social and political problems of the late 16th and early 17th centuries.