Paper
In Issue 13 of Taking Sides, the controversial question Have Antidepressant Drugs Proven to be Effective is analyzed. Psychiatrist Peter D. Kramer argues in this issue that antidepressant drugs “can transform depressed patients into happy people with almost no side effects” (p.212). On the contrary, professors of psychology Seymour Fisher and Roger P. Greenburg “claim that the studies that demonstrate the effectiveness of antidepressants are seriously flawed” (p.212). Kramer’s agreement with the statement above is due mostly to the testing he did with his patient Tess and antidepressant drugs. However Fisher and Greenberg disagree with the statement mainly because of the bias drug studies that are done.
Psychiatrist Peter D. Kramer experienced with the antidepressant drug Prozac with one of his patients Tess. In doing this, Kramer learned many things about Prozac and it’s effects on people. The experience also leads him to ask many other questions about the drug. Tess was a patient who came from an abusive childhood and therefore as adult suffered from depression, which made Kramer feel she was a candidate for the antidepressant drug Prozac. In Tess taking the drug Kramer found out very quickly what remarkable changes it had on her. Kramer learned that the drug had a “quickly alteration in ordinary intractable problem of personality and social functioning” (p.218). Kramer also learned that Prozac enabled a person to understand what was important to them and who they were and wanted to be. Although Kramer saw the effects Prozac had on Tess, Tess also taught him to look at the border picture. Tess made Kramer think what if this “redefinition of self led to a culture in which this biologically driven sort of self understanding becomes widespread” (p.222). Kramer found it unbelievable what the drug Prozac could do to a patient, something that psychiatrists have always hoped to accomplish. The main thing though that Tess taught Kramer and what the drug itself taught him was that the effects of the drug would have to re examined and our sense of what is constant in the self to be revised.
As earlier stated, Fisher and Greenberg disagree with the effectiveness of antidepressant drugs which is mainly due to the bias studies. As Fisher and Greenberg state, “no one actually knows how effective antidepressants are. Confident declarations about their potency go well beyond the existing evidence” (p.223). One of the main biases on antidepressant drugs is that “patients learn to discriminate between drug and placebo largely from body sensations and symptoms” (p.225). Another point Fisher and Greenberg point out in their argument is that many doctor’s strong beliefs in the power of a drug has a strong affect on the power it really has on a patient. Many of the testing that are done with antidepressant drugs are a lot of the times used with bias sampling. For example when testing the effects on newer drugs and older drugs, researchers are more bias to see a greater effectiveness in the newer drugs. As Fisher and Greenberg say, “the present double-blind design for testing drug efficacy is exquisitely vulnerable to bias” (p.228).
In reading about the two sides of this controversial issue, my opinion on the subject became confused. On one hand I feel that if a person suffering from severe depression has tried everything accept for antidepressant drugs and nothing seems to help them, their doctor should prescribe Prozac. On the other hand I feel that there is too many instances that a person not necessary suffering from depression is prescribed this drug and changing themselves as a person. I guess, to sum it up, before I would prescribe Prozac to a patient they should under go many other treatments and a full evaluation on what the person is really suffering from and if it really is “clinical depression.”
Другие работы по теме:
Letter Essay Research Paper When examining an
Letter Essay, Research Paper When examining an issue it is essential that you look only at the facts and not let your opinion get in the way of what is known to be truth. Such is the case in the
The Argument Culture Essay Research Paper On
The Argument Culture Essay, Research Paper On any given night when watching the news, there are bound to be a number of stories involving arguments. Usually there are two sides to each point of contention, and both sides seem unable to compromise. But there are also a large number of times when the media examines stories which are not argumentative, sometimes regarding fact, possibly human interest.
Drugs Essay Research Paper An issue of
Drugs Essay, Research Paper An issue of personal, local, and national concern that I would like to focus in this paper is drugs. There are many reasons why I find drugs to be an issue of great importance to me.
The Computer Age Essay Research Paper Ben
The Computer Age Essay, Research Paper Ben Purdue 8/24/01 It is my prediction that the biggest issue we will face in the coming century not only as a nation but also as a planet is finding a blind between security of protected information and freedom of information. I say this because as a computer security consultant I understand the need for security of important information, however I as a programmer I understand such issues as the battle for open source code and freedom of information as a hole.
Legalization Of Marijuana Essay Research Paper The
Legalization Of Marijuana Essay, Research Paper The purpose of this paper is to discuss marijuana and compare the issue of legalizing it from both sides. We have two factions fighting each other, those who are pro-marijuana and those who are anti-marijuana. These two factions have been fighting on this issue in the halls of justice for years.
Taking On Responsibility Essay Research Paper Taking
Taking On Responsibility Essay, Research Paper Taking on Responsibility When I was diagnosed with diabetes I had to take on some responsibilities. Lately I had been feeling sick, drinking a lot, and going to the bathroom a lot. So my mom took me to the doctor to see what was wrong. I don?t remember much of it because I was only three years old.
Nuclear Power Plants Essay Research Paper Nuclear
Nuclear Power Plants Essay, Research Paper Nuclear Plants The question of whether the U.S. should have nuclear power plants is very controversial. There are two sides that one can take; however, both sides have their own share of problems. If you chose to not have nuclear plants, then eventually all natural resources will run out.
School Prayer Essay Research Paper The United
School Prayer Essay, Research Paper The United States Supreme court will once again address the issues of prayer in public schools. In the constitution, it guarantees freedom of religion, and separation between church and state. Should the government be allowed to base an opinion on social values versus social values? Just like any other controversy, there are two opposing sides.
Brown Vs The Board Of Education Essay
, Research Paper If I were to base my decision on the presentation of the opposite sides of the case, I would have to rule against Brown. Her argument lacked sufficient support and explanation. Furthermore, her proposed solution was very eluding for it would not solve the problem of segregation and racism.
Cloning Essay Research Paper A couple that
Cloning Essay, Research Paper A couple that had been married for only two years was in a terrible car accident. The husband, however, was unconscious when the paramedics arrived. He went into a coma shortly after arriving at the nearby hospital. He came out of the coma but never was the same again. It turns out that when he was in the accident, he had severe head trauma, and would be a vegetable the rest of his life.
Abortion Essay Research Paper The Moral Argument
Abortion Essay, Research Paper The Moral Argument Surrounding Abortion Arguments based on moral ideas tend to be polarized, but sometimes can be taken to extremes. When I was growing up in the late 1980 s my mother was, and still is, politically involved. I grew up in the state of Louisiana, and at that time in Louisiana the legislature introduced a bill that would make abortion illegal.
Wellness Inventory Essay Research Paper After taking
Wellness Inventory Essay, Research Paper After taking the wellness inventory I have found that I am possibly the most unhealthy person you could find. I am so tough mentally, meaning I am very mentally prepared for what the world will throw at me. When the physical factor comes in that?s where I find myself lacking.
Israel Essay Research Paper Looking Back and
Israel Essay, Research Paper Looking Back and Analyzing The United States is looking to help out Israel in as many ways as possible since it is one of the few Mid East nations that are democratic instead of monarch or a dictatorship. The United States?? best interest in helping Israel can be seen as a way of promoting democracy since Israel is a democratic state.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In today
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, if you ask five people who Jack Kevorkian is then three or more would know who he is. The issue of euthanasia has been on the media’s forefront for several years. There are several pros and cons to this issue. Some of these pros are as follows: it would help to end pain and suffering, it allows a person to die with dignity, and it also helps the grieving process because the person knows when they are gonna die.
Econ Essay Research Paper The federal progressive
Econ Essay, Research Paper The federal progressive income tax has been an issue that has been argued on the floors of Congress, in front of the United States Supreme Court, in front of television cameras, and around the dinner table. The tax served its purpose in supplementing revenue during the Civil War and World War I, but continued taking from Americans’ income in peacetime, allowing fewer dollars to be spent on goods and services.
Civil War By Edward Hagenlocher Essay Research
Paper Migration west brought South and North into conflict over slavery. Earlier compromises between the sections had succeeded because slavery had been a relatively minor issue; major differences usually revolved around culture, economics, and the balance of power. However, by the 1840s, slavery and its expansion became a central, pivotal issue.
Abortion Essay Research Paper AbortionI feel that
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion I feel that abortion is wrong. God says that he is the way, the truth, and the life. I am a Christian and I believe that God has a plan for everyone and everything. He has the whole world planned and He sees ahead. What happens is his will, no matter how harsh it may be or difficult to deal with.
Sex And Work Essay Research Paper Sex
Sex And Work Essay, Research Paper Sex and Work Women have made some strides in overcoming harassment and discrimination, but there is still a long way to go. When a corporate meeting is taking place, before the meeting, all the guys will be sitting around telling their little stories, until a woman walks in.
The False Promise Of Gun Control Essay
, Research Paper After the class debate, Tougher Gun Control on November 12, 1999: I gained a new understanding of the opposing sides views on the issue. They had some very strong arguments, including some very weak points. I’ll start with the stronger points and diminish to the weaker arguments throughout this paper.
Cherokee Removal Essay Research Paper Cherokee RemovalThese
Cherokee Removal Essay, Research Paper Cherokee Removal These articles, A Permanent Habitat for the American Indians and Memorial of the Cherokee Nation, enlighten the reader to both sides of a very controversial issue in the early 1830 s. The views of Andrew Jackson on removing the Cherokee Indians are very biased and very inconsiderate.
Abortion Essay Research Paper A womans right
Abortion Essay, Research Paper A woman?s right or murder? The topic I chose was abortion ~ a woman?s right or murder? I set out to interview a various range of citizens and professionals
Legalizing Marijuanna Essay Research Paper Legalizing MarijuanaThe
Legalizing Marijuanna Essay, Research Paper Legalizing Marijuana The purpose of this paper is to discuss marijuana and compare both sides of the issue of legalizing marijuana. We have two opposite opinions fighting each other, those who are pro marijuana and those who are anti-marijuana. These two sides have been fighting on this issue for years.
Changes In Writing Essay Research Paper Changes
Changes In Writing Essay, Research Paper Changes in Writing My last day of high school was January 21, which was my first day at UWM. I graduated early from high school and decided to jump right into college. I was not too worried because I figured that I would catch on. I came into English 102 and found out what an analysis paper was.
Personal Mission Statement Essay Research Paper I
Personal Mission Statement Essay, Research Paper I believe that the following statements are very true for my personal mission statement. Hear both sides before judging. This statement most people should remember. So often people judge and say what they are thinking at the spur of the moment before really thinking the situation over and hear other sides before speaking.
Abortion 4 Essay Research Paper The Issues
Abortion 4 Essay, Research Paper The Issues of Abortion Abortion has become one of the most controversial topics of the twentieth century. The act of ending a pregnancy before birth is abortion. It is hard to find someone who does not have an opinion on abortion today. About ninety percent of abortions occur during the women’s first trimester, which accounts for approximately 1.8 million abortions per year.
Miller Spring Essay Essay Research Paper Miller
Miller Spring Essay Essay, Research Paper Miller Springs Essay My science class and I went to Miller Springs to learn about sediments and nature a few days ago. The good and bad sides of the trip I will explain below.
Abortion Essay Research Paper AbortionThe value of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion The value of life cannot be questioned. Just as a murderer will pay for his crimes, so will anyone who kills another without just cause be punished by god and society. But, this issue of abortion extends far beyond the taking of life. Abortion requires consideration of what is just and does a pregnant woman have the right to decide.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Right To Choose
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Right To Choose Many people believe abortion is a moral issue, but it is also a constitutional issue. It is a woman’s right to choose what she does with her body, and it should not be altered or influenced by anyone else. This right is guaranteed by the ninth amendment, which contains the right to privacy.
The Bad Flag Essay Research Paper Some
The Bad Flag Essay, Research Paper Some people think the confederate flag is a symbol of hatred and slavery. Others think it represents the history of America. It’s up to ever person to decide where they stand. The old saying is, “If you don’t stand for something, you’ll fall for anything.” Ever person has a duty to respect the other person’s opinion.
Eutahnasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaEuthanasia is an
Eutahnasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Euthanasia is an issue that has been debated on many occasions. Both ethical and political questions have been raised. It is the one issue that can touch anyone, even politicians. Euthanasia is an issue that is controversial from all sides and is such a deeply felt issue across society.
Why It Should Be Legal Essay Research
Paper Why Marijuana Should be Legal For my final paper I am going to do it on why marijuana should be legal. I will provide factual information that will prove that there are more reasons that it should be legal than illegal. Using studies done by doctors and scientist that prove that it is used to cure many illnesses and medical conditions.
Medicare Essay Research Paper How To Fix
Medicare Essay, Research Paper How To Fix Medicare Is The Greatest Challenge. This Issue Is A Very Important One That Will Eventually Come Under Fire As We Approach That Year 2001 When Medicare Is Projected To Go Bankrupt. This Issue Might Not Be Resolved And We Could Be Seeing The End Of Medicare. I This Issue Will Get Solved Some How The Taxpayers Will Pay Medicare Out Of Trouble.
How To Writing A Research Essay Essay
, Research Paper How To Writing A Research Essay The toughest part of the essay, for me, was taking all the information I had gained and reduce it to a mere few pages essay. After all, quality is better