The Tutankhamen Mystery
Nebkheprune Tutankhamen is probably the most famous pharaoh in ancient Egyptian history, although not the most important. He lived a very short life, from 1503 to 1482 BCE to be exact. He was the ruler by the time he had turned nine years of age. Nobody really knows that much about him because he lived to only be around eighteen years old. Only because of an archaeologist by the name of Howard Carter who discovered Tutankhamen?s tomb on February 12, 1924 do we even have concrete proof that he even existed (Desroches-Noblecourt 7). One gigantic mystery about Tutankhamen?s life, is his death.
More than 3,000 years after the death of King Tutankhamen, questions are still being asked about how he died. Was it a natural death or was he murdered? The possibility that Tutankhamen did not die of natural causes was first raised 28 years ago when an X-ray analysis of his mummy was made by the anatomy department of the University of Liverpool. It revealed that the king might have died from a blow to the back of his head (Desroches-Noblecourt 18).
The suggestion caused a controversy among Egyptologists and scientists. If he were murdered, who did it? Was it Aye, Tutankhamen’s vizier who followed Tutankhamen as king and then married his wife, Ankhesenamon? Or was it Horemhab, the army officer who became king after Aye?s short four-year reign? Some archaeologists believed that Aye and Horemhab might have killed Tutankhamen together (Maugh).
A few years later, a new X-ray analysis was done only this time it suggested that Tutankhamen might have been murdered in his sleep. An unnamed trauma specialist at Long Island University conducted the examination. “The blow was to a protected area at the back of the head which you don’t injure in an accident. Someone had to sneak up from behind.? X-rays also show a thickening of a bone in the skull, which could occur only after a build-up of blood (Silverman 191). This would indicate that the king might have been left bleeding for a long time before he actually died. Scientists believe that the king was probably hit on the back of his head while asleep and that he was left there, maybe for as long as two months, before he died. According to Mohamed Saleh, Director-General of the Egyptian Museum, the original analysis of Tutankhamen’s mummy suggested that the boy king died of a lung disease or even a brain tumor, ?that would explain the lump on the head? (Silverman 195).
When the new analysis was carried out on the mummy, it was suggested that Tutankhamen was hit on the head and murdered by either Aye or Horemhab. Mohamed Saleh stated:
In my opinion this could not be the case. Because Tutankhamen had no
enemies; on the contrary, he was loved by the priests and the population because he re-established the stale religion of Amun-Re after the
religious revolution under Akhenaten, and re-opened all temples.
Moreover, Aye and Horemhab would have had no reason to kill
Tutankhamen because he was youth and did not hold authority
(Silverman 197).
Madelen El-Mallakh, Director-General of Luxor Museum, commented on the traces of a blow to the head: “Who is to say for certain how it was administered, whether it was foul play or accidental. There is certainly an element of mystery surrounding Tut’s death” (Silverman 199)
Bob Brier, an American Egyptologist, believes that Tutankhamen was indeed murdered, and claims he knows by whom:
It was either by his own personal attendant or by his cupbearer. No one
could easily approach the back of the pharaoh unless it was part of his
job to do so. The king’s attendant and his cupbearers would be the only
people allowed to enter his bedroom without arousing suspicion (Curse).
Brier added that he would back up his hypothesis with archaeological evidence, which will be shown, in his documentary, The Great Pharaohs. Such contradictions raised by Egyptologists prompted the Antiquities and Travel Lovers’ Committee (ATLC), an Egyptian non-profit organization, to re-examine Tutankhamen’s mummy and tomb and to carry out further research on the possible causes of his death (Curse).
The first step was a re-examination of the three tombs on the ban necropolis belonging to Aye, Horemhab and Tut. The tomb and the treasure of the latter have revealed two pieces of literary evidence suggesting that Aye and Horemhab were innocent of murder Desroches-Noblecourt 58).
The first is a papyrus document related to the ?opening of the mouth ceremony,? a ritual in which the dead man proclaims his innocence of any act be may have committed during his life-time, or mentions any subject he wants to shed light on in preparation for the day of judgment. Tutankhamen’s document indicated that Aye was innocent of his murder. Also, on the pedestal of one of Horemhab’s statues is a text in which he left a message to all Egyptians, indicating that he was not the man who committed the crime. He declared in writing that he was loyal to his king and carried out all his orders faithfully. He also warned any Egyptian who may read the text, against ‘normalizing’ relations with foreigners and told them never to trust them: “Egyptian brothers, don’t ever forget what foreigners did to our King Tutankhamen”, Horemhab wrote (Desroches-Noblecourt 62).
Forensic examination carried out by Egyptian experts on Tutankhamen?s mummy reveal that he was poisoned and it is now suggested that the blow to the back of the head might have happened after his death, during mummification. Experts say that his body might have been dropped on the floor and his head hit the flagstones; there is no trace of bleeding around the blow (Desroches-Noblecourt 68).
Now another person is being accused of the murder: Tutu or Dudu, described first as an official in the court of Amenhotep III, later that of his son Akhenaten, and then Tutankhamen. He was not an Egyptian and a person of a somewhat unruly character who caused friction in the royal household. One of the leaders of a vassal state in Tunib in Palestine repeatedly used this man to divert the messages of the Egyptian contingents in the area, so their calls for help failed to reach Egypt, and no help was given. When Akhenaton realized that he had been supplied with false evidence about the true situation of his troops, he apparently announced that an investigation would be carried out to discover its source (Desroches-Noblecourt 87).
Tutankhamen?s death in mysterious circumstances followed and members of the ATLC suggest that it was Tutu who was responsible for the deaths of Akhenaten and Tutankhamun “because in the tomb of the latter, an object like a trotter was found on which graffiti invokes, ‘go to the real killer and beat him and awake him from his death to confess and admit his crime so that the one who is now accused can be declared innocent.” Since trotters were not, ritual objects in Ancient Egypt, it is suggested that it belonged an outsider. ?Since Tutu was a foreigner, the priests used the trotter to indicate the nationality of the murderer,? Mohamed El-Saghir, head of Upper Egyptian Antiquities, added to the mystery. He claims that there is insufficient historical or archaeological evidence to suggest that either Aye or Horemhab were murderers, “but what is noteworthy is that Horemhab usurped some of Tutankhamen’s treasure and affixed his name to it.” El-Saghir referred to the two statues on display in Luxor Museum which were found in the open court of Amenhotep III in Luxor Temple in 1989. These feature the king seated before the god Atum and the goddess Isis respectively (Silverman 176).
Beneath each are texts stating: ‘Horemhab with gods’ El-Saghir points out that studies on both these statues reveal that they have the same features as Tutankhamen as well as evidence that the original texts were erased to inscribe the new ones. Analysis on the traces of the old inscription shows some parts of Tutankhamen’s titles. “And as for Aye, there is insufficient evidence that he is guilty. He was the high priest and was, moreover, the one who wrote Tutankhamen’s negative confession and performed the ?opening of the mouth? ceremony,? El-Saghir stated (Secrets).
While Tutankhamen’s murder was so much in the news, it must not be forgotten that his wife, Ankhespaton, must not been entirely ruled out as a suspect. She was the one who dispatched a message to the Syrian monarch asking him to send one of his sons to marry her following the death of her husband because she was without a son to take care of her; Ankhespaton, must not been entirely ruled out as a suspect neither. This proves that Tutankhamen?s death, to this day, is still an unsolved mystery and will most likely stay that way forever…. unless someone comes forth and admits it. Not likely anytime soon.
Другие работы по теме:
Mystification Essay Research Paper Mystification
Mystification Essay, Research Paper Mystification According to McNeil, mystification is a technique used by teachers who are not fully informed on the topic in which they are instructed to teach. Teachers
Titanic The Unsinkable Essay Research Paper The
Titanic The Unsinkable Essay, Research Paper The Titanic was and still is considered one of the biggest disasters of the century. The ship that was proclaimed to be “unsinkable” proved that
King Tutankhamon Essay Research Paper Tutankhamon the
King Tutankhamon Essay, Research Paper Tutankhamon ,the 12th king of the 18th Dynasty, was only eight or nine years old at his succession. His father, Smenkhare, died at the age of 25, the cause remains a mystery.
Romantics Vs Realists Essay Research Paper Views
Romantics Vs Realists Essay, Research Paper Views of Nature Romantics verse Realists and Naturalists have different views of nature. In this essay I will portray how Romantics see nature, and then how Realists and Naturalists together see nature. It will show how Romantics had a deepened appreciation of the beauties of nature.
Cable Guy Essay Research Paper 1
Cable Guy Essay, Research Paper 1. Grey, Harriet. The Cable Guy. USA, St. Martin’s Paperback’s, 1996. 247 p. 2. I could say that this is a mystery and suspense novel. There is mystery because the main character tries to discover who his new friend really is. Also there is suspense at the end of the novel because his friend tries to steal his girlfriend.
Poem My Dream And Stage Essay Research
Paper A moment of silence. They announce The Dancer. Polite applause. The music stirs. The pulse of the drum quickens. My everyday world fades away as I approach the Gate.
Maigret And Then Toy Village Essay Research
Paper I read the book Maigret And Then Toy Village. I really liked this book. The Hound of the Baskervilles and Maigret And The Toy Village were very different. I liked Maigret And
Emily Jane Bronte Essay Research Paper Emily
Emily Jane Bronte Essay, Research Paper Emily Jane Bronte Emily Jane Bronte remains a mystery. Very little is known about her. There is little information, and much of what we have is contradictory. She is the author
Pilot
’s Wife, By Anita Shreve Essay, Research Paper In the past years, one of my favorite books was The Pilot’s Wife, by Anita Shreve. It has action, suspension, and mystery. It has my vote for a great book for two reasons. First, it has the type of mystery
Love In Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Love In Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet is, without any doubt, one of William Shakespeare’s most puzzling plays. Often times, the reader becomes engulfed in the mystery, trickery and deceit in this tragedy. People become perplexed while reading Hamlet when they ask themselves the question, “Does Hamlet truly love Ophelia?”.
Monsters Essay Research Paper 1 Pike Christopher
Monsters Essay, Research Paper 1. Pike, Christopher. Monster. New York, Archway Paperbacks, 1992. 229 p. 2. This book is both a mystery novel and a suspense novel. It is a mystery novel because Angela tries to find out the big mystery about the monsters while, at the same time, it is a suspense novel because of all the adventures that happen throughout the book.
Black Holes Essay Research Paper Our universe
Black Holes Essay, Research Paper Our universe is a vast abyss, always expanding without any end. Many objects in space are exciting and interesting. One great mystery is the black hole. Ever
No OneS A Mystery By Elizabeth Tallent
? Essay, Research Paper Literary analysis on “No One’s a Mystery” Elizabeth Tallent’s short story “No One’s a Mystery” is about Jack and how he uses his 18 year-old admirer as an excuse to make himself think he is still young. It is a way to keep him in the frame of mind that he doesn’t need a wife, he can do what he wants and get what he wants without her.
Third Eye Blind Essay Research Paper Dr
Third Eye Blind Essay, Research Paper Dr. Ernest Everett Just, was born in 1883 and he died in 1941. He spent most of his life trying to understand the mystery of biology, being a biologist himself. He has many contributions to the branches of science, for instance the facts about fertilization and pointed the way toward a better knowledge of the way all cells work.
Attention Keepers In
“The Most Dangerous Game” Essay, Research Paper Attention keepers in “The Most Dangerous Game” In Richard Connell’s “The Most Dangerous Game”, he uses several literary devices to keep the reader interested. During Rainsfords journey to and through the island of General Zaroff he partakes in an adventurous journey filled with mystery, suspense, and dilemma.
Romanticism 2 Essay Research Paper Romantics often
Romanticism 2 Essay, Research Paper Romantics often emphasized the beauty, strangeness, and mystery of nature. Romantic writers expressed their intuition of nature that came from within. The key to this inner world was the imagination of the writer; this frequently reflected their expressions of their inner essence and their attitude towards various aspects of nature.
Iron In Drinking Water Essay Research Paper
Purpose: The purpose of this lab was to gain the quantitative measure of the color difference between Transmitance and absorbance in 8 different samples of water containing varying amounts of iron in a range between 5-100ppm, so that we know which samples where exceptable for drinking.
No One
’s A Mystery Essay, Research Paper Career choice, for many individuals in our society, is a sociological issue. (Brooks-Gunn & Schempp-Matthews, 1979). We tend to imitate what we see that we
Edgar Allan Poe Essay Research Paper Poe
Edgar Allan Poe Essay, Research Paper Poe’s Never Ending Loneliness “From childhood’s hour I have not been/as others were; I have not seen/ as others say I could not bring/ my passions from a common spring. From the same source I have not taken/ my sorrow; I could not awaken/ my heart to joy at the same tone;/ and all I loved, I loved alone.”
Agatha Christie Essay Research Paper In the
Agatha Christie Essay, Research Paper In the murder mystery by Agatha Christie, Murder on the Orient Express, her style of writing can be described as one of Christie s best works, having an international trend, and being a genius with detective fiction. Murder on the Orient Express was a great book and should be read by all.
And Then There Were None By Agatha
Christie Essay, Research Paper I recently read a mystery book by the name of “And Then There Were None” by Agatha Christie. I read this book because I have read other books by Agatha Christie that were pretty well written. Ten people are invited to an island, called “Indian Island”,by letters that were signed by people they had met before.
The Earth Essay Research Paper THE EARTH
The Earth Essay, Research Paper THE EARTH The Earth’s Place In Space: Despite its own special conditions,the Earth is in some ways similar to the other inner planets the group of planets
Mr Murder Essay Essay Research Paper MR
Mr Murder Essay Essay, Research Paper MR. MURDER ESSAY For everyone life is filled with mystery, suspense and facing the unknown. In Dean Koontz s book Mr. Murder he does just those things for the main character in the book. He helps us understand that those kinds if things can happen to us.
Mother Nature Essay Research Paper Nature has
Mother Nature Essay, Research Paper Nature has a certain presence or spirit. It s an almost indescribable feeling just to go out to the middle of the sea or into a forest and just sit there in awe of its beauty. Nature has a certain mystique and mystery to it that draws people to it. Nature, described as mysterious and secretive, is a recurrent theme throughout many stories.
Heart Of Darkness Mystery And Suspense Essay
, Research Paper Heart of Darkness: Mystery and Suspense It seems like everywhere there is something in life that seems to be left behind. In the books I read about mystery or suspense, this always seems
Everglade Dilemma Essay Research Paper Everglade DilemmaThe
Everglade Dilemma Essay, Research Paper Everglade Dilemma The worlds systems of life are of such complexity that even modern man can’t fully understand and predict it. The common word for this is Mother Nature and the question is the mystery of life. Life was created by a specific set of environmental and geologic features present at the same time.
What Is The Question That Is A
Question And Will Always Be A Question? Essay, Research Paper In this life, the number of questions is almost endless. There are so many answers we are in search for, some of which we will never find. Is
IN THE LAKE OF THE WOODS A
MYSTERY? Essay, Research Paper IN THE LAKE OF THE WOODS: A MYSTERY? Almost from this novel?s first page we know that Kathy Wade will vanish, and it is not long before we discover that her disappearance will remain unsolved. We then ask ourselves, ?how is this novel considered a mystery if we never even find out what happened to Kathy?? In the Lake of the Woods, by Tim O?Brien, still has undeniable suspense.
Dave Garret Essay Research Paper ConflictThe conflict
Dave Garret Essay, Research Paper Conflict The conflict in the story begins when Kate McMahan is kidnapped. Her boyfriend Dave must find her. The conflict is person vs. person. Dave must go through many people in order to find Kate. There are people who try to kill Dave, and kill anyone who may be trying to help him.