Book Review on Jared Diamond?s
Guns, Germs and Steel
Why is it that Europeans ended up conquering so much of the world? Or as Yali puts it in the far beginning of the book, ?Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo and brought it to New Guinea, but we black people had little cargo of our own?? Despite all the contrary evidence from anthropology and human biology, many persist in attributing the differing political and economic successes of the world?s peoples to historical contingency. On the other hand though, the author sees the fundamental causes as environmental, resting ultimately on ecological differences between the continents and as he well puts it on page 25: ?Authors are regularly asked by journalists to summarize a long book in one sentence. For this book, here is such a sentence: ?History followed different courses for different peoples because of differences among peoples? environments, not because of biological difference among peoples themselves.?
The complex and integrated argument unfolds in four parts, strategically constructed by questions: why have different continents and regions developed so differently like the Maori killing the Moriori, and why did Pizzaro capture Inca emperor Atahuallpa. The first part, ?from Eden to Cajamarca,? sketches developments on all the continents before 11000 BC. In the second part, the author gives approximate dates on the early production of food and explains why certain peoples developed food production whereas others did not. Followed by the studies of why some peoples chose not to farm, why some did not domesticate animals, and why production spread on different rates at different continents. In part three the author argues that the settled communities made possible by production of plant and animal food allowed diseases to leap from domesticated animals to humans. He also links success in food production to the inventions of writing and of technology. These he relates also to government and religion, which he characterizes as ?kleptocracy?. After all this research and explanation the author returns to reconsider the course of human development on each continent. Starting first with Australia and New Guinea, then with China, Polynesia, Eurasia and the Americas and finally Africa.
Jared Diamond sees food production, or the domestication of plants and animals, as the central key to human history. In a relatively short display (part two), the author outlines the origins of agriculture. He describes when and where food production originated, how it spread from the Fertile Crescent to other parts of the world and why. There is a deep explanation about the types of crops around the world, and a thorough description why the large seeded wild plants in Eurasia were easy to domesticate. Eurasia had the same climate over its long east-west axis whereas the Americas and Africa had a huge variation and thus could not grow those kinds of plants. The characteristics of these crops are extensively discussed, driving us, the readers, to the conclusion that food production indeed played a major role in a material sense, mental sense, as an agent of civilization and as a source of power.
Firstly, the author argues that ancient farmers had to develop more advanced tools for producing more amounts of food and had the opportunity to support people that did not work in the fields, such as politicians, warriors, priests and so on. As a result of that, farmers became materialistically richer than hunter-gatherers who stayed in relatively small groups, because hunters could not support people that were not able to hunt and kill wild animals. More food available meant, and still does, more people. More people to feed requires better technology and also soldiers to guard, politicians to make laws, priests to have as spiritual leaders and so on. Through this argument we can see that new techniques were being invented and new levels of hierarchy as well. So, in a nutshell, with food as basis the farmers were able to first build the materials, then establish some sort of a hierarchical system, which led to the invention of the alphabet and the rise of major civilizations.
A similar analysis is carried out for the domestication of large mammals. Here, again, Eurasia was favored with almost all the suitable species. The author in this particular section gives modern examples of modern animal breeders that were not able to domesticate some wild large mammals of Africa and justifies why ancient Africans and other peoples could not domesticate them either. Then, he continues on to demonstrate that when large animals such as horses became available to some of those peoples, such as the Native Americans, they adopted them and made use of them.
Guns, Germs and Steel is a fascinating synthesis that brings together history, archaeology, agriculture, linguistics, medicine, evolution and many other fields. We can see that the writer starts off the book with a notable amount of frustration about the mistaken ideas our society has come to believe: ? ? objection to such racist explanations is not just that they are loathsome, but also that they are wrong. ?evidence for the existence of human differences in intelligence? is lacking. ?modern ?Stone Age? people are probably more intelligent ? than industrial peoples? (page 19). Through these strong words we can see that he will try to convince people that there was something else holding people back and there is not such a thing as a superior race.
There are a lot of rock solid clever arguments in this book about writing, language and how people came about to where we stand today. Studying extensively the history of World War II, I?ve attained the belief of cause and effect and the writer describes almost all of his arguments giving out a strong case. The only thing that I did not quite grasp, was the quick description of the Spaniards? conquest of Mesoamerica; what exactly caused the Spaniards to capture the natives, since the natives were not a thread to them?
Besides that, I believe Guns, Germs and Steel was a very well structured, extensively researched and superbly presented book. Reading this was actually a different experience, because it covers and explains in a nutshell how, when and why we are here today.
Другие работы по теме:
Gun Control 6 Essay Research Paper The
Gun Control 6 Essay, Research Paper The issue of gun control is a very hot topic in today s society. Many believe there should be no guns. They believe that all guns should be taken away and that all Americans, regardless of age, race, sex, or religion, should be stripped of our second amendment right to keep and bear arms.
Obessive Compulsive Disorder Essay Research Paper EnglishObesessive
Obessive Compulsive Disorder Essay, Research Paper English Obesessive Compulsive Disorder 1. People with obsessive compulsive disorder freaks about everyday germs or forgetting something. Compulsive are things that people do or act they perform in their head. They are repetitive and senseless just like obsessions.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun ControlThe
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Control The National Rifle Association (NRA) is a very powerful organization with huge financial backing; it wants laws already in placed to be used more forcefully to control the use of guns in committing crimes. However, people are still dying; something more must be done to take guns out of the hands of those who plan and execute criminal behavior.
Handguns Essay Research Paper All handguns must
Handguns Essay, Research Paper All handguns must be banned because they are the cause (s) of many deaths amongst the people of the world today. Gun violence result in fifty percent of today?s tragedies. Handguns causes too many deaths, the government need to make gun less accessible, and the law/law enforcement need to really enforce the laws they make.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Guns have
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Guns have many functions. Some people use them for many different sports, some use them for protection, and some use them for murder.
Steel Pier Essay Research Paper When I
Steel Pier Essay, Research Paper When I walked into the Leary Theatre I was skeptical about the production of Steel Pier because of its past failure on Broadway. Although, under the direction of Brother Augustine Towey, C.M. I knew that the possibilities were endless. I understand that a remarkable production comes from the imagination and hard work of the director.
Rock And Roll Essay Research Paper At
Rock And Roll Essay, Research Paper At the beginning at Enemy at the Gates, it showed the new Russian recruits being loaded onto trains to fight at Stalingrad. There was little organization, just a mob of young men
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Before we
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Before we discussed gun control in class, I thought that gun control was the perfect solution to crime. But is it? After spending many days in class debating gun control, I realized that there is much more to the subject than I thought. Many new questions arose in my head like: Does the government have the right to take away the freedom of owning a gun? Does gun control really decrease crime like I thought it would? Are we safer if we all have guns? These are all questions that I still do not have the final answer for, but it has made me more open minded about this topic.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Are you
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Are you ready to die? What?s more, are you ready to kill? When you hold a gun anywhere but the firing range you?d better be ready and able to use it or die. Don?t get me wrong; just because you carry a gun doesn?t mean people automatically start being violent towards you but if you get in a fight and someone realizes you have a gun it?s more than likely that they will pull one and shoot you if they have it.
Respiratory System Essay Research Paper EmphysemaEmphysema is
Respiratory System Essay, Research Paper Emphysema-Emphysema is a disease that causes the alveoli (the tiny air sacs where the air meets the blood in your lungs) not to work properly. This means not as much oxygen can get into the blood of the person, and it makes breathing difficult. Because the blood isn’t getting as much oxygen as it is supposed to, the body cells aren’t getting the oxygen they need to release the energy in food.
Andrew Carnegie Essay Research Paper Carnegie Andrew
Andrew Carnegie Essay, Research Paper Carnegie, Andrew (1835-1919), American industrialist and philanthropist, who, at the age of 33, when he had an annual income of $50,000, said, Beyond this never earn, make no effort to increase fortune, but spend the surplus each year for benevolent purposes.
Gun Control Legislation Essay Research Paper The
Gun Control Legislation Essay, Research Paper The question of weather or not to have tougher gun control laws is a major issue for the American society. Violence with guns in the United States seems to be ever growing. Gun violence claims the lives of an estimated 34,000 Americans each year. It is evident that some people should just not have the right, or privilege to own a gun.
Bla Bla Essay Research Paper 1 Id
Bla Bla Essay, Research Paper 1. I?d like to begin by saying that everything that you just heard about the success of gun control is FALSE. Case and point: Washington D.C. Since 1976, the District of Columbia has had the country?s most extreme gun control laws. NO civilian may BUY or CARRY a handgun, nor may ANY gun be kept loaded or assembled in a home for self-defense.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Controlling sales
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Controlling sales and the registration of guns and owners is necessary because of the homicide rate involving guns and the violence caused by criminals using guns. Since the early days of the United States, firearms have been part of the American tradition as protection and as a means of hunting or sport.
Gun Violence Essay Research Paper I believe
Gun Violence Essay, Research Paper I believe that it is time for laws that govern guns to be tightened and a compromise to be made between gun banning and complete gun freedom.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Why is
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Why is it that the government wants to take away our guns? It is a growing issue these days with murders, gun fights, and recent school shootings. Are guns that important for people to have them in the first place? The National Rifle Association (NRA) sure thinks so; that is why they are fighting to protect our gun rights.
Tape Measure Essay Research Paper MEMORANDUMDate June
Tape Measure Essay, Research Paper MEMORANDUM Date: June 20, 2000 From: TAPE MEASURE The tape measure is an instrument used to measure objects. Tape measures are found in most households and are fairly simple to use. Standard tape measures measure in feet and inches.
Life Goes On Essay Research Paper Steel
Life Goes On Essay, Research Paper ?Steel Magnolias? We all have problems in our life, but some how life goes on. If you were to lose your closest friend, family member, or a loved one would
NonLethal Weapons VS Lethal Weapons Essay Research
Paper Resolved that non-lethal weapons, such as tasers, could be used instead of lethal weapons, such as guns. Every year over 10,000 people are killed by guns in the United States. This kind of violence does not need to happen, and won?t happen if weapons such as tasers are used in everyday life. Another problem in our society is violence such as riots and fights.
HyPlex Essay Research Paper James McKay George
Hy-Plex Essay, Research Paper James McKay, George Buchanan and Arthur Dalzell founded the company in 1965. Initially the company started with a small production of golf clubs with fiberglass shafts but thanks to the great demand that their products encountered, in 1972 Hi-Plex expanded its manufacturing facilities that resulted in a turnover of over ?3 million and a pretax profit of ?600,000.
Book Review New Worlds For All Essay
, Research Paper Themes: New Worlds for All, by Colin G. Calloway has several themes. The first theme is the failure of the settlers to acknowledge the fact that the Indians had a whole society set up before they got there. Many settlers came to the New World, not wanting to blend in with the culture that was already there, but to recreate what they had in their homeland.
Earthquake Proof Building Essay Research Paper Our
Earthquake Proof Building Essay, Research Paper Our company name is CNN Incorporated. The first thing we did was dig up all the soft soil and filled it with cement. After that we stuck big steel poles into the cement to hold the building in place and keep it on the ground. The garage is made out of brick and it has 9 cement pillars to make the structure stronger.
Guns Problem Essay Research Paper These activists
Guns Problem Essay, Research Paper These activists are also taking the guns out of the wrong peoples hands. They work to pass laws that would take the guns from the law-abiding citizens. When we give people the right to defend themselves, criminals start looking for victims who are unable to do so. For this reason we must work to reduce crime in America and look at the problem realistically. develop plans that would address the real problem of crime.
His Bright Light Danille Steel Essay Research
Paper In Danielle Steel’s His Guiding Light, Steel expressed that its better to try, and then fail, then to have never have tried at all. Steel’s son Nick Traina was a good person; ” He was not a bad kid he was a sick kid.” He tried to do his best and wanted people to love him for whom he was. “I want people to know they can believe in me and trust me.” Steel said, “All I wanted to do was to help him.” Nick was sick and needed help and her heart was filled with love and hope for him.
California Law Essay Research Paper Caleb FairleyJudicial
California Law Essay, Research Paper Caleb Fairley Judicial Proc. 9/03/00 1. California law restricts the use of guns by seeing to it that the guns are safer, and by being safer they are registered by the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice tests the guns to make sure that they meet all safety needs and that the guns are not faulty.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Dear Mr
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Dear Mr. President: The issue of gun control in the United States has formed a public debate for quite a while now. Many are struggling to find a solution to the problem. The U.S. needs your help to stop guns from being misused. Guns are getting into the hands of people who shouldn t have them and these people are abusing the privilege of having the weapon they have.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun EssayShould
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Essay Should we really just keep adding gun control laws? Well, I don’t think so. I think that Senator Larry E. Craig said it best “the criminal that wasn’t stopped by 20,000 laws won’t stop at 20,001.“ My viewpoint is that we should have better law enforcemnt.
Gun Control Laws 2
Gun Control Laws – Should They Be Altered? Essay, Research Paper While many people believe there should be more gun control and the possibility of banning guns all together, I believe the gun control laws should not be changed. Although there are many reasons that may persuade people to choose to ban guns, I believe that there are several other reasons that lead to all the tragedies with guns in America.
Guns In Texas Essay Research Paper GUNS
Guns In Texas Essay, Research Paper GUNS IN TEXAS Gun control consists of the government restricting the ability of individual citizens to purchase weapons. In recent years many laws have been passed to assist with keeping guns under control, and this has become a topic of significant interest among politicians and US citizens.
Gun Laws Essay Research Paper Dear LegislatorI
Gun Laws Essay, Research Paper Dear Legislator, I am writing on behalf of my thoughts and myself about gun control laws. My position on this topic is neutral leaning towards the “No Gun” law. The idea of a federal law to ban these guns is a good idea, but it could be better. I believe strongly that guns should be banned from our country in some kind of way, but there are exceptions like for law enforcement and hunters.