Paper
In his The Miller’s Tale Chaucer presents a side of the courtly love tradition
never seen before. His characters are average middle class workers rather than
elite nobility. There is an interesting comparison between the Miller’s
characters and those in two of Marie de France’s lais that share very close plot
lines. Instead of being idealized Chaucer’s characters are gritty. Instead of
being involved in "courtly love" there is some evidence that the
relationship between Alison and Nicholas is one of lust. Chaucer’s use of the
lower class makes the absurdity of what they are doing stand out. In the lais of
Marie de France, Guigemare and Yonec, are built on the same archetype which is
the same as Chaucer’s Miller’s tale uses. Marie’s lais can give provide a set of
"ground rules" for this archetype. The two lais share several similar
elements. They both contain the same three central characters, who possesses
fundamental similarities, the same beginning plot line and several of the same
themes. The first character shared by the two lais is the story’s villain, the
aged husband. He is a powerful lord who is much older than his wife. Because he
is conscious of this fact, he worries constantly that his wife will betray him,
so he locks her up. He is both the least and most important figure in the story.
He’s important because without his presence and actions the story could never
take place. But he has very little actual interaction with the other two more
central characters. The husband in Yonec is never described as meeting either
his wife or her lover. In Guigemare the husband, wife and Guigemare are only
together when the two lovers are discovered. The figure of the beautiful,
imprisoned wife is the second central character. She is the quintessential
damsel in distress, beautiful, noble (and with the exception of her one true
love) chaste. The third character is the valiant lover who rescues the unhappy
and imprisoned damsel. In both Guigemare and Yonec this character is a knight,
and like his lover, the damsel in distress, he is the stereotypical "knight
in shining armor." He is described as being afflicted by love, and says he
will die without it. He will go to any extent for his true love. As with
characters both Guigemare and Yonec share a similar plot line. The young wife is
locked up by her jealous husband. Then by some magical means her lover is
transported to her. After some protestation from the woman, and some wooing from
the knight, the two become lovers, until they are discovered and separated.
After this point the two plots diverge. Also central to both stories is the idea
that these extra-marital affairs are not improper. In Guigemare, the lady’s maid
says to the knight: "The man who wishes to love my lady must keep her
constantly in his thoughts and, if you remain faithful to each other, the love
between you will be right and proper." (pg. 49) Obviously fidelity is
important, but not forced fidelity. Love is more important than marriage in
these lais. It’s also important to note the chastity of the lovers. There is no
mention of contact between the imprisoned wives and their husbands. In Yonec the
Lord of Caerwent takes his wife for the purpose of child bearing, but she is
imprisoned for seven years before meeting her lover and no children are
evidenced from the text. Guigemare has never been in love before he meets his
true love. This gives the love and actions between the pairs seem even more
pure, and also makes it seem to be less sinful. Love is a powerful force in both
these stories. It is not only the driving force behind the character’s actions,
but it also causes them physical affliction. Marie de France writes in Guigemare:
"But love had now pierced him to the quick and his heart was greatly
disturbed. For the lady wounded him so deeply he had completely forgotten his
homeland. . .The knight remained alone, mournful and downcast. He did not yet
realize the cause, but at least he knew that, if he were not cured by the lady
his death would be assured." (pg. 48) To Guigemare at least love is the
most important thing there is. This consideration is even more striking by the
fact that Guigemare either could not or would not fall in love while in his own
land. So those are the basic elements involved in the "imprisoned
wife" archetype used by Marie. In The Miller’s Tale Chaucer uses same basic
plot line, and similar characters. One of the largest differences between the
Chaucer’s characters and Marie’s characters is their level of wealth and their
position in society. This causes them to be portrayed in a different manner than
Marie’s rich, noble characters. The first of the three major characters is
present largely unchanged. He is not of course a king or lord, but John the
carpenter is obviously a man of at least some amount of wealth, evidenced by the
fact that he has a house that is big enough that he can rent rooms from. He is
also more present than the jealous husband of Marie. He does not lock his wife
up in a tower and stay far away from her. Unlike the husbands in Marie’s lais he
still has contact with his wife. The two sleep in the same bed (as we see when
Absalom tries to sing to Alison). John’s level of jealousy is not as great as
that of Marie’s husbands. When he awakens to hear Absalom singing to his wife he
does nothing. And as Absalom continues to try to woo John’s wife away from him
in his presence, he still does nothing. The king in Yonec kills his wife’s
lover, in Guigemare he at first attempts to do the same. He even allows a man,
Nicholas, to be near to his wife. The only man allowed close to Guigemare’s
lover is a priest who had "lost his lower members." Alison, Chaucer’s
imprisoned wife, is less of the ideal than her counterparts in Marie. Certainly
she is beautiful. But her is beauty is slightly flawed. She is "graceful
and slim like [a] weasel." By comparing her with a weasel Chaucer makes
Alison seem to be dirty and untrustworthy. Morally the comparison between Alison
and her counterparts in Marie is more confusing. Chaucer describes her as having
a "wanton eye." But her protestation seems to be more real, and
Nicholas seems to have gone to farther lengths to make her his lover. When
Nicholas professes his love to her Chaucer describes her reaction as such:
"[She] twisted her head away hard/ and said, ‘I won’t kiss you, on my
faith;/ why let me be,’ she said, ‘let be, Nicholas, or I’ll cry
"Help!" and "alas!"” (pg. 155) Alison seems quite adamantly
opposed to becoming Nicholas’ lover here, as opposed to the wife in Yonec, who
simply needs proof that her lover to be is Christian. Her refusals, and then
Nicholas only winning when he had "pushed her so hard" sounds, at
least to the modern reader, to be rape. But just lines later she swears a vow
with Nicholas. The shifts made by the women in Marie are not nearly so drastic.
At no point in Guigemare or Yonec do you get the feeling that the women will
refuse either of their lovers. Their protests are almost just for propriety
sake, the medieval version of playing hard to get. But in Alison’s refusal there
is no apparent support for her actions shortly thereafter. Possibly the reason
for Alison’s shifting actions is due to Chaucer’s image of women at the time, as
was argued against by Christine de Pisan. The figure of the rescuing lover is
divided into two parts by Chaucer. Pleasant Nicholas is the actual lover, but
Absalom is the stereotype of the courtly lover. Aside from the fact that he
actually becomes her lover Nicholas shares very little with the knights of Marie
de France. He is not especially handsome, being described as looking "as
meek as a maiden." Also unlike Guigemare certainly he is not chaste, nor is
this his first love. Chaucer writes: "he knew all about secret love and
pleasurable consolations." (pg. 151) This makes the love between Alison and
Nicholas seem to be less pure. Instead of Alison being the only woman for him,
as is Guigemare’s lover, she may just be another in a string of many. Absalom,
on the other hand, possesses many more of the qualities that one would expect
that a lover in a story about courtly love would have. He is described as being
handsome, or at least well groomed. He involves himself in what could be
described as "courtly" pursuits such as dancing (Chaucer says that he
knew twenty different steps) and can play two instruments. His attempts at
winning her love are more traditionally romantic. He sings under her window,
sends her gifts and even money to try to earn her love. Like Marie’s knights
Absalom is "afflicted" by love. Alison causes him to stay awake at
night. But he is also "a little squeamish/ about farting and prim in
speech." (pg. 157), not the most masculine of characters. The Miller views
John’s marriage to Alison as a mistake. He says: "People should marry
according to their condition,/ for youth and age are often at odds." (pg.
153) In considering what happens to the two lovers at the end of the story there
is no indication that Chaucer thought that what they were doing was wrong. It
would seem that if their actions where thought to be incorrect then they would
have been discovered, and some sort of misfortune would have resulted (to cite a
more extreme case, the Jews in the Prioresses Tale). But instead, of being
punished they get away with their affair. Absalom gets his revenge on Nicholas
with a hot poker, but John the carpenter seems to be the ultimate loser.
Nicholas and Alison get away with their night of passion, and he’s made to look
like a fool in front of the whole neighborhood. Class is the major difference
between the characters of Chaucer the Miller’s Tale and Marie’s lais. Marie’s
lovers are idealized, what each knight and lady should strive for. Chaucer’s
lovers are dirty, animal like and raucous. The Miller’s Tale is a parody of the
courtly love tradition. But the fact that Chaucer uses the lower classes as his
characters makes his story even more absurd. Instead of being wise they are
foolish.
Chaucer, Geoffrey The Canterbury Tales trans. Kent & Constance Hieatt;
Bantam 1964 de France, Marie The Lais of Marie de France trans. Glyn Burgess
& Keith Busby; Penguin 1986
Другие работы по теме:
Chaucer 2
Chaucer – The Canterbury Tales Essay, Research Paper By far Chaucer’s most popular work, although he might have preferred to have been remembered by Troilus and Criseyde, the Canterbury Tales was unfinished at his death. No less than fifty-six surviving manuscripts contain, or once contained, the full text.
Le Rossignol Essay Research Paper Le Rossignol
Le Rossignol Essay, Research Paper Le Rossignol est un lai de Marie de France qui s?etait traduire en vers romans de huit syllables entre les annee 1160 et 1180. Dans Le Rossignol, Marie de France examine l?amour courtois et l?amour de la court qui observe des regles. Un exemple de ses regles s?appele **Traite de l?amour ?courtois?** de Andre Le Chapelain qui nous avons deja lu en classe.
Chaucer And Feminism Essay Research Paper The
Chaucer And Feminism Essay, Research Paper The most potent form of criticism that a writer can use is satire. Satire is a form of irony wherein the speaker uses false praise in order to condemn an idea or event. Chaucer was a pioneer in the realms of English and criticism. He popularized the use of the satiric mask.
Corruption In The Church Essay Research Paper
Chaucer lived in a time dictated by religion and religious ideas in which he uses The Canterbury Tales to show some of his views. Religion played a significant role in fourteenth-century England and also in Chaucer’s writing. His ideas of the Church are first seen in “The Prologue,” and he uses seven religious persons to show the influence of the religion in his writing.
Use Of Satire In Chaucer
’s The Canterbury Tales Essay, Research Paper “The Canterbury Tales” was a novel written by Geoffery Chaucer in 1386. In the prologue to Chaucer’s work, he describes certain characters using the literary device known as satire. His descriptions of the characters do a few different things. First, they give the reader an accurate vision of the time period that the novel takes place, fourteenth-century England, through the context of the character descriptions such as their dress.
Guillaume De Mauchet Essay Research Paper handout
Guillaume De Mauchet Essay, Research Paper handout: Guillaume de Machaut Noelle Chamorro, September 19, 2000 Guillaume de Machaut (1300-1377) Born to commoners, Machaut came from humble origins in the Champagne -Ardenne region of Northern France.
Hitler Essay Research Paper VoltaireVoltaire was born
Hitler Essay, Research Paper Voltaire Voltaire was born in Paris, France in 1694 to the name of Fran ois Marie Arouet. Voltaire was the son of a notary and he was educated at the Jesuit College Louis-le-Grand. During his life Voltaire was unjustly imprisoned two times. One time from 1717 to 1718 he was sent to the Bastillle for insults to the regent, Philippe II d Orl ans, which were wrongly ascribed to him.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper Marie CurieMarie
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper Marie Curie Marie Curie was born in Warsaw on November 7, 1867. She was actually born to the name Marja Sklodowska. When she was 24, she went to Paris where she changed her name to Marie and started school in Sorbonne. In 1893, she received her degree in physics. When she needed a lab to experiment in, a Professor Kovalski said that there might be space in the School of Physics and Chemistry.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper Marie Curie
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper Marie Curie is the most famous woman of physics. She has been recognized for her work with Nobel Prize awards in both physics (1903) and chemistry (1911). She got a late start with her education obtaining her license in physics in 1893 and the corresponding degree in mathematics in 1894.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper Curie Mariephysicist
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper Curie, Marie physicist and twice Nobel laureate, best known for her Curie, Marie, nйe Maria Sklodowska (1867-1934), French work on radioactivity, with her husband Pierre. Maria Sklodowska was born in Warsaw, Poland, which was then part of the Russian Empire. Her father, an ardent Polish nationalist, taught mathematics and physics at a secondary school, but was denied promotion because of his political views, which he passed on to his daughter.
Richelieu Essay Research Paper RichelieuRichelieu was a
Richelieu Essay, Research Paper Richelieu Richelieu was a French cardinal and statesman, who more than anyone else promoted absolutism in France and laid the foundations of the country’s 17th-century grandness. He was born in Paris on September 9, 1585, and set out on a military career. In order to retain the bishopric of Lu on in the family, however, Richelieu switched to theology and at age 22 was ordained a bishop.
Love In Lanval Essay Research Paper Love
Love In Lanval Essay, Research Paper Love is the central theme of the two stories Lanval , by Marie De France, and The Prologue and Tale of the Wife of Bath in The Canterbury Tales, by Geoffery Chaucer. The authors have very similar opinions about the nature of love and how people react to being in love. One of the messages conveyed in both stories is the irresistible power that a woman has over a man who is in love with her.
Chaucer And Religion Essay Research Paper Chaucer
Chaucer And Religion Essay, Research Paper Chaucer and Religion It is very rare that a book is written without the opinions of the author being clearly expressed somewhere within that book. Geoffrey Chaucer’s The Canterbury Tales is one such book. In the General Prologue alone, by viewing Chaucer’s description of the Knight, the Prioress, and the Friar, the reader is able to pick up on Chaucer’s satirical humor toward the church of the 14th century.
Chaucer 2 Essay Research Paper The Effects
Chaucer 2 Essay, Research Paper The Effects of Geoffrey Chaucer’s Education on the Canterbury Tales The Medieval period was one of transformation. The great religious pilgrimages that occurred effected the course of history. Social set-ups were believed to be ordained by God and were not to be changed (www.aol/barrons 1).
Literary Criticism In Canterbury Tales Essay Research
Paper There are numerous sources of literary criticism of The Canterbury Tales, as well as specifically about “The Miller’s Tale.” “Telling stories of low sexual intrigue (fabliaux)…There is nothing like [these tales] in Middle English and nothing like [these tales] anywhere in English literature” (Life of Geoffrey Chaucer, 172).
The Cantebury Tails Essay Research Paper The
The Cantebury Tails? Essay, Research Paper The Cantebury Tails? What are those? A story? Perhaps a poem? Who really knows? If anyone is a book worm, likes British Literature, or just happens to be in the Junior English class at St. Bede Academy, all know what The Cantebury Tails is. The Cantebury Tails is a poem written by Chaucer.
The Voltaire Essay Research Paper Voltaire Francois
The Voltaire Essay, Research Paper Voltaire Francois Marie Arouet (pen name Voltaire) was born on November 21, 1694 in Paris. Voltaire’s style, wit, intelligence and keen sense of justice made him one of France’s greatest writers and philosophers. Young Francois Marie received an excellent education at a Jesuit school.
Canterbury Tales Essay Essay Research Paper Geoffrey
Canterbury Tales Essay Essay, Research Paper Geoffrey Chaucer presents a realistic portrayal of the medieval period in The Canterbury Tales. These details are especially accurate of the pilgrimages to Canterbury and the types of people who made them. Whether the character and its description are based on actual historic figures, then being called ?individuals,? or are more general portrayals, ?types,? they give the reader a genuine idea of the medieval society.
The Prioress Madame Eglantine Essay Research Paper
The Prioress, Madame Eglantine In the “General Prologue” of The Canterbury Tales, Chaucer introduces the readers to pilgrims he meets in the town of Southwerk as he begins his pilgrimage to Canterbury. The pilgrim I found to be most interesting was the Prioress. Chaucer tells the reader that she is a nun and her name is Madame Eglantine.
Canterbury Tales Prologue Essay Research Paper
In Geoffrey Chaucer s prologue to The Canterbury Tales, he introduces a character that he describes with very high esteem. Through direct and indirect characterization we learn Chaucer s feelings and facts that help us get to know his character, the knight.
Thw Wife Of Bath Chaucer
’s Feminist Character Sketch Essay, Research Paper In the medieval period when women were viewed as property, held to sexual double standards and considered to be little more than heir-makers, Chaucer wrote a rather biting piece that draws attention to the inequalities in standards for men and women that were supported by society.
Character Sketch Of Chaucer
’s Knight Essay, Research Paper Character Sketch of Chaucer’s Knight Geoffrey Chaucer s Canterbury Tales, written in approximately 1385, is a collection of twenty-four stories ostensibly told by various people who are going on a religious pilgrimage to Canterbury Cathedral from London, England. Prior to the actual tales, however, Chaucer offers the reader a glimpse of fourteenth century life by way of what he refers to as a General Prologue.
Rad Essay Research Paper
“The Wife of the Bath’s Tale” is the most affecting piece of literature studied this semester. The ranges of emotions displayed by the story’s characters are a function of Chaucer’s personal feelings. The reason the literature has been so affecting is because of the character development, and emotional differences from one character to the next.
The Time Period And People Of Geoffrey
Chaucer Essay, Research Paper The Time Period and People of Geoffrey Chaucer Geoffrey Chaucer is one of the greatest authors of his time. His distinctive use of characters in his literary works is one of a kind. Chaucer s works were accomplished during the Middle Ages. During this time period the whole community revolved around the church, the village and the surrounding farmland.
Geoffrey Chaucer Essay Research Paper Does Chaucer
Geoffrey Chaucer Essay, Research Paper Does Chaucer truly understand human nature? Geoffrey Chaucer, author of The Canterbury Tales, is known as the Father of English poetry. Some have said that Chaucer has the perfect understanding of human nature. All people identify with this piece of poetry in every time period, culture, and race.
Chaucer 2 Essay Research Paper Chaucer already
Chaucer 2 Essay, Research Paper Chaucer already summarizes the characteristics of the Knight as making up a perfect gentle-knight, and the many deeds of valor add more credence to Chaucer s summary. The modest bearing is contrary to the “lad of fire” and although the Squire had “wonderful strength and agility”, he did not use it to the full extent that his father used his own.
Chaucer Reaction Paper Essay Research Paper I
Chaucer Reaction Paper Essay, Research Paper I’m really not sure how a lot of things I took away from Cheryl Brown’s Lecture related to the Canterbury Tales, but they are worthy of reaction nonetheless. I wonder really if we are limited in the English Language with a word like “love” that can mean so many different things.
THE CANTERBURY TALES Essay Research Paper The
THE CANTERBURY TALES Essay, Research Paper The Canterbury Tales Chaucer uses satire in the Canterbury Tales to expose his attitude towards the Catholic Church of the Middle Ages. The first way in which he does this is by satirizing a common nun of the Middle Ages. Chaucer, in The Canterbury Tales, tells of a nun who is supposed to be married to the church.
Chaucer And Milton Essay Research Paper The
Chaucer And Milton Essay, Research Paper The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer, and Paradise Lost by John Milton both show how big the role was by women to contribute to the downfall of man. Each of these authors portrays women s actions in different ways. Chaucer, in his female pilgrimages thought of women has having an evil-like quality, which was that they always tempt and take from men.