In 1987, the power of the 21st Amendment of the Constitution was in question by South Dakota and the State Secretary of Transportation (1983-87),1 Elizabeth Dole. The 21st Amendment declares that states have complete control over production, sale, and transportation of alcohol and that liquor importation and sale are no longer prohibited among states of the US (since the prohibition law of the 18th Amendment). However, a federal law states that in order for a portion of federal highway funds to be given by the federal government to an individual state, that state must adopt a minimum drinking age of 21 years of age. Michigan is an example of this law, for because our minimum drinking age is 21, we receive highway funds from the federal government.
Therefore, this law directs Dole to withhold a percentage of highway funds from states who refuse to set their drinking age law at 21 or over. South Dakota was one such state, with a minimum age of 19 required to buy beer up to 3.2% alcohol content. They claimed that the federal law violated constitutional limitations on Congress spending power (Article I) and also violated the 21st Amendment. South Dakota believed that the power of setting a drinking age is and should be reserved to the state, and their power was weakened by this federal law.
The main issue confronted in this case was whether or not the 21st Amendment was violated by this federal law on state drinking age. The case was heard by a US District Court (dismissed case, South Dakota appealed), then the Court of Appeals affirmed the case and it was then heard by the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court decision was a 7:2 vote that the federal government’s law did not violate the 21st Amendment in any way, and that the law was a valid use of congressional spending power.
The Supreme Court agreed that the Congress did not have the power to impose a national drinking age by direct legislation. Congress did, however, have the power to set conditions on receipt of federal funds, therefore mostly controlling those funds. It was said that “Congress encourages uniformity in drinking ages.”2 This means that Congress is regulating the drinking age indirectly but does not violate any constitutional Amendment. “Congress can tempt, not coerce.”2 There is a difference between tempting and coercing, and between forcing compliance and buying compliance, the Congress executing the latter action. They stressed only mild encouragement to US states to change the drinking age.
Another factor affecting the Supreme Court’s decision on the case was the fact that only a mere 5% of federal highway funds was at stake, so a decision either way would not change money matters severely. Also, the decision satisfies the requirement for congressional spending for the “general welfare” of the states, not for personal advancement but for the improvement of the US as a whole.
One point that the federal government was trying to stress with their highway fund/ drinking age law was that the lack of uniformity among US state drinking age laws was an interstate problem, and a dangerous one as well. The Congress wished to find uniformity within a drinking age law, or regulate the sale and commerce of liquor in another way. However they could only do this by indirect means.
The case of South Dakota vs. Dole ended with the decision that the federal law backed by Dole was not a violation of the 21st Amendment used by South Dakota. Therefore, in order to receive federal highway funds, South Dakota must comply with the federal law and raise their minimum drinking age to 21 years of age.
Works Cited
“Dole, Elizabeth.” Compton’s Interactive Encyclopedia. Copyright 1996. Softkey Multimedia Inc. (computer)
United States Government: Democracy in Action. Glencoe, pp. 103-4.
Другие работы по теме:
Линейные корабли типа Саут Дакота
Тип «Южная Дакота» или «Саут Дакота» (англ. South Dakota class) — серия линейных кораблей США. Последние корабли, спроектированные в рамках ограничений Вашингтонского договора, они также оцениваются многими специалистами как одни из наиболее удачных кораблей, созданных в этих рамках. В 1939—1942 годах были построены четыре корабля этого типа.
Fort Sumter Essay Research Paper Fort Sumter
Fort Sumter Essay, Research Paper Fort Sumter was a turning point in determining the outcome of the Civil War. Fort Sumter was built on a man-made island of seashells and granite. It was a pentagon shape that was fifty feet high and the walls were eight to twelve feet thick. Fort Sumter is located in South Carolina.
War On Poverty Project South Essay Research
Paper War On Poverty: Project South Another project that is trying to make lead way in the poverty war. Is the Project South(PS) is a program that is felt strongly felt though out the
South Atlantic Eddies Essay Research Paper The
South Atlantic Eddies Essay, Research Paper The article I chose to do my assignment on was Giant Eddies of South Atlantic Water Invade the North. The eddies that the article discusses are thought to originated from sharp changes of the direction of the currents, which are called North Brazil Current retroflection eddies.
Aparteid Essay Research Paper ApartheidThe idea of
Aparteid Essay, Research Paper Apartheid The idea of apartheid started in South Africa around the year 1910. This all came about when Britain took over South Africa. The British thought that whites should be
Reconstruction Era Essay Research Paper Reconstruction EraThe
Reconstruction Era Essay, Research Paper Reconstruction Era The Reconstruction period can be defined as the time after the Civil War when states were debating on what to do with a partially seceded nation. The Union, known as the North, wanted to come to agreements with the Confederacy, or the south, on how to successfully bring the states together again as one nation.
Gandi Essay Research Paper Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi
Gandi Essay, Research Paper Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi was an Indian nationalist leader, who established his country’s freedom through a nonviolent revolution. Gandhi is also known as Mahatma a nickname given to him meaning great soul. This name was given to him by his followers who felt he was God’s messenger on Earth.
Why The South Could Not Win The
Civil War Essay, Research Paper Ever since the day the South surrendered to the North in May of 1865, Americans have argued on why the South lost. Others argued that the South never had chance to win the war, yet more than half a million people were killed, homes were lost and destroyed and families were torn apart.
Case Study Of A Market Town Monmouth
SW Wales Essay, Research Paper Situation: it is situated at the confluence of the rivers Wye, Monnow and Trothy. In the county of Monmouthshire, Gwent South West Wales.Site:
Losing The Black Hills Essay Research Paper
10/14/99 Losing the Black Hills In the early 1860s the Oglala Sioux leader Chief Red Cloud fought to keep the U. S. Army from opening the Bozeman Trail, which led to the Montana gold fields through Sioux hunting areas in the Dakota Territory. Between 1866 and 1868 Red Cloud and his allies besieged forts along the trail until in 1868 the U.S. government agreed to abandon it.
The Beet Queen Essay Research Paper On
The Beet Queen Essay, Research Paper On a spring morning in 1932, young children Mary and Karl Adare arrive by boxcar in Argus, North Dakota. Having parted and going separate ways Mary having gone to live with her aunt, while Karl goes on to explore and live on the wilder side. These children were orphaned in a most peculiar way; their mother took off in a plane with an airplane stuntman.
Bob Dole Essay Research Paper How Dole
Bob Dole Essay, Research Paper How Dole Could Have Used The Issues To His Advantage In a more or less conservative country, the more or less conservative candidate, Bob Dole, should have been a lock for the presidency; the only
Apartheid Essay Research Paper What Is ApartheidThe
Apartheid Essay, Research Paper What Is Apartheid? The word Apartheid means separation. Apartheid was a form of living in South Africa. It was the process of segregating different races. Not only did it separate the Afrikaans, and other tribes in South Africa, but it also separated the whites from the non-whites.
The South Essay Research Paper The South
The South Essay, Research Paper The South The South has many objects associated with it, to where it is considered either a beautiful place or very disturbing. In The South , Langston Hughes describes his feelings of the south from the point of view of a black man who
Waterlily By Ella Cara Deloria Essay Research
Paper Waterlily by Ella Cara Deloria Mn. History 2-3-97 Waterlily is a book based on the events that happen within a particular Dakota Indian family’s life. Not only does it depict the affairs of blue Bird’s
BIGHORN SHEEP Essay Research Paper The bighorn
BIGHORN SHEEP Essay, Research Paper The bighorn or the bighorn sheep, ovis candensis, is the family bovidae in the order Artiodactyla. It is a wild sheep with a silky coat similar to that of a deer, varying from brown to buff. The male bighorn, or ram, may be as much as 150 cm long, about 100 cm at the shoulders, and weigh 157kg; females are the smaller.
Overview Of The Socialist Party And Bob
Dole Abort Essay, Research Paper overview of the Socialist Party and Bob Dole AbortionI. Socialist Party… The Socialist Party is based on the idea that the working class are fully capable of running their own bussinesses and magnaging their own lives. The party strives to make a classless system, all people living in the country are equal in status income and future.
Various Bios Of Western Settlers Essay Research
Paper Bill was born in Troy Grove, IL. He moved to the Kansas territory at age 18. He served as a Union spy during the Civil War. He was extremely brave. He died in South Dakota while playing poker.
Korean War Essay Research Paper Causes of
Korean War Essay, Research Paper Causes of the Korean War Essay # 2 By: Dylan Foreman After the Japanese gained control of Korea in and made it part of Japan. The Allies defeated Japan in World War II (1939-1945) and U.S. and Soviet forces moved into Korea. Soviet troops occupied North Korea and American troops occupied South Korea.
Trouble With Bill Clinton
’s Character Essay, Research Paper Trouble With Bill Clinton’s Character In the article, “The Trouble With Character” from Time magazine , writer Richard Stengel describes Bob Dole’s attacks on President Bill Clinton’s
Bill Clinton President Essay Research Paper A
Bill Clinton, President Essay, Research Paper A Victory For Clinton Another four years, another new president? The election of 1996 for president moves closer everyday as the republican Robert Dole, and the president
Mandella Essay Research Paper Nelson Mandela has
Mandella Essay, Research Paper Nelson Mandela has played an important and controversial role in the history of South Africa and establishing South Africa as a Democratic country. Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela was
Presidential Debates 96 Essay Research Paper Philip
Presidential Debates 96 Essay, Research Paper Philip Rubacha October 22, 1996 American Politics-Essay #1 Essay-Debate The presidential debates between democratic President William Clinton and Republican Senator Robert Dole proved to be a game of “dodge-ball”. Bob Dole fired criticism and attacks while Clinton tried to “dodge” them.
Minnesota Essay Research Paper Hi Im Amanda
Minnesota Essay, Research Paper Hi! I?m Amanda. I chose to do my report on Minnesota because that’s where I?m from. In fact, my whole family is from Minneapolis. I thought it would be
Sue The Dinosaur Essay Research Paper Sue
Sue The Dinosaur Essay, Research Paper Sue is the largest, most complete, and best-preserved Tyrannosaurus rex. Fossil hunter Sue Hendrickson discovered her in 1990, in the badlands of South Dakota. The Field Museum purchased Sue at public auction in 1997 with generous financial support from McDonald s Corporation, Walt Disney World Resort, and private individuals.
Argentina Essay Research Paper ArgentinaBy Chris OjedaArgentina
Argentina Essay, Research Paper Argentina By: Chris Ojeda Argentina is a South American country with a population of thirty one million people. Argentina?s capital is Buenos Aires, which is one of the largest cities in South America. Buenos Aires is situated on the coast of Argentina, which makes Buenos Aires a major trade route in Argentina and in South America.
Civil War Causes Essay Research Paper Causes
Civil War Causes Essay, Research Paper Causes of the Civil War Although some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political blunders and that the issue of slavery
Korean Conflict Essay Research Paper North Korea
Korean Conflict Essay, Research Paper North Korea and South Korea was once one country combined. That changed soon after World War II. Since the Soviet Union controlled North Korea it was mainly