Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper
Assisted Suicide
In thousands of homes across the nation victims of terminal illnesses
sit in pain due to their sicknesses. Should these people have to go through all
of that pain and suffering just for the end result of death? Should these
people have the right to assisted death, to rid themselves of unbearable pain?
This topic has been one of the great controversies over the last several years.
Not too long ago if someone was found assisting in suicide, it was seen
as a felony crime. But recently there have been court cases taken up in two
federal appellate courts that ruled terminally ill patients have the right to
seek doctor assisted suicide (Carter 1). These cases took place in New York and
Washington. This added two more to the list of states that legalized this means
of ending life. However, doctor assisted is still seen as a criminal act in
thirty four states(Rosen 1). In my opinion, doctor assisted suicide should be
made legal throughout the nation. If a terminally ill patient wants to take his
or her life due to excruciating pain, he or she should have the ability to
utilize euthanasia. Ultimately, the decision should be that of the terminally
ill individual.
The main controversy over this issue, is the question of morality. Is
it morally right for a doctor to assist in suicide? Many individuals feel that
it is not. It is thought if assisted suicide is legalized throughout the states,
it will encourage families with terminally ill relatives to push them
prematurely to their demise(Carter 2). This is an outlandish assumption. A
family that truly loves one another would not urge a family member to rush any
decision as momentous as ending one’s life. If there is caring among the family,
the suicide would not take place until is was utterly necessary.
Two other important moral questions also arise from this issue. First,
do our mortal lives belong to us alone, are we sovereign over our bodies, or do
they belong to the communities of families in which we are embedded? Second,
will this right give the terminally ill a greater sense of control over their
circumstances, or will it weaken respect for life?(Carter 2)
The first question is ridiculous. It seems as though Carter is trying
to say we will no longer be in charge of ourselves, and we will be living in a
socialistic society. There is no reason why we should not be able to control
the destiny of our lives. We, as human beings, are solely sovereign over our
own bodies. Therefore, it is the terminally ill patient who should have the
ability to choose death over life. It is this person who is experiencing the
pain and suffering of their disease, not a relative or close friend, much less
the government. The legalization of doctor assisted suicide is no reason to
change anything with people who are not terminally ill.
The second question, on the other hand, has some validity and logic to
it. Doctor assisted suicide would give the dying a certain sense of control.
It would enable the patient to have a certain feeling of power, knowing that he
or she has the ability to complete his or her life upon request. This may sound
somewhat awkward; however, it is quite possible that it would give the patients
a sense of well being. Furthermore, it gives them a chance to end their lives on
their terms, instead of letting a disease determine their course in life. As
for the second half of this question, it should in no way weaken the respect for
life. Losing respect for life is for the weak minded. If anything it
strengthens the patient’s respect; a person in the last stages of a terminal
illness has endured some of the worst life has to offer. It takes away many of
his capabilities to perform what would normally be commonplace activities; in
short it has overtaken his life and dignity. The ability to perform legal
assisted suicide would help to replace some of the dignity which the illness has
extracted from a person’s life. It would give the person the capability to end
matters on his own terms.
John Stuart Mill, one of the great philosophers of the nineteenth
century, derived a theory which is an excellent example as an argument for the
legalization of doctor assisted suicide, or all moral crimes for that matter.
This theory was deemed the “Harm Principle”: a person is wholly sovereign over
his body. It is no one else’s right to invade a person’s body. Therefore,
since one is fully autonomous over his physical body, one should have the
ability to do as he pleases with it. This holds true up until the point where
his actions bring harm to another human. Doctor assisted suicide is a perfect
example, one’s body is his own and only his; therefore, if one chooses not to
suffer needlessly for months or even years who is to stop him from utilizing the
procedure? Some would argue that this does cause harm to others in an emotional
sense, yet this is not the issue, and not how Mill thought it should be
interpreted.
Now that the moral issues have been discussed, what about the rights
which the Constitution of the United Stated guarantees its citizens? Under the
provisions of the fourteenth amendment, the same amendment the right to abortion
is found under, we are provided the right to due process(Carter 1). The
argument set forth here, is the fact that not all states abide by this
amendment, thirty four to be exact. The reason for this is, they do not feel
the “right to die” means allowing a doctor to assist terminally ill patients in
prematurely ending their lives. Another reason is the assumption that, if
doctor assisted suicide were legalized, it could possibly be used as an excuse
for murder(America 1). It is possible that it could occur; however, self
defense is also an excuse that is used from time to time. But this excuse does
not always work. If a murder case was taken to court for “assisted suicide”, it
would be justly proven whether it was an act of murder, or, rather, whether it
was an act of mercy.
The federal rulings state, “we see no real difference between allowing
terminally ill patients to die naturally and taking direct measures to kill
them.”(America 1) I am in total agreement with their statement. However, I am
against what happened to a man by the name of Aaron McGuinn. In 1990 this man
tested positive for the HIV virus, and in 1996 he passed away by the means of
assisted suicide(Macleans). However, he was not yet suffering, for he had not
yet developed full blown AIDS, and was in no pain at all. This decision goes
against my personal morals for doctor assisted suicide.
Finally, I support doctor assisted suicide, but only within certain
limitations. First, the patient must be within close proximity to a natural
death, and this should be documented by a licensed physician. If a patient is
in unbearable pain, then it is also understandable to follow through with the
procedure. This decision should not be taken lightly in any way, and if it were
to become decriminalized, there should be some type of counseling service
established for those who are weighing their options with doctor assisted
suicide. A person’s body is his own and his alone; therefore, when it is all
said and done, it should be he who is in full control of his own destiny.
Другие работы по теме:
Should Assisted Suicide Be Legalized Essay Research
Paper Should assisted suicide be legalized? As the society has been developed, the needs of its people’s freedom and right have also increase. People even touch the domain of death which many other are scare of. The question about legalizing assisted suicide is one the most argumentative topic. Lots of people support the legalization of assisted suicide, but many of them have wrong assumptions about suicide.
Case Queen Versus Dudley And Stephens Essay
, Research Paper In the case Queen versus Dudley and Stephens the criticism that is most applicable is the third one about moral inconsistencies in the law. In this case the law teaches us that, in a situation such as the one Dudley and Stephens found themselves in, it is more moral to sacrifice our lives than to preserve it.
Physician Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Scott
Physician Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Scott DeBoer DeBoer 1 9-26-2001 Physician Assisted Suicide How could someone wake up every day sick, in constant pain and feeling horrible every minute of existence? This is not a good way to live from anybodies point of view. The time may come when suffering, just is not worth living.
Physican Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Physicianassisted
Physican Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Physician-assisted suicide occurs when a physician helps a person take his or her own life by giving advice, writing a prescription for lethal medication, or assisting the individual with some device which allows the person to take his or her own life. The physician lends expertise, but the person does the act.
Assisted Suicides Essay Research Paper The background
Assisted Suicides Essay, Research Paper The background for this work is that the existing conflict over legalizing assisted suicides and euthanasia could bring our values down and society apart. The problem is not legalizing or opposing to it, the real problem is to find a way to care for the terminally ill.
Assisted Suicide Cannot Be A Right Essay
, Research Paper Everyone who is born will die. All humans face death sooner or laterin their lifetime. It is the wish of many, especially sufferingindividuals, to die peacefully and without pain. Death is beyond ourcontrol, but should we be allowed to decide the time of our death?There are proponents on both sides of this controversial issue, butwith all the complications and dangers associated with legalizingassisted suicide, it should not become an option available toanyone.Many believe that individuals suffering immensely physically deservethe right to end their pain.
Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Imagine you
Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Imagine you have just found out you are going to die within three months. Recently the questions have been changed from, |What am I going to do with the rest of my life?X to |When should I kill myself?X With painful and crippling diseases such as AIDS and cancer, and Alzheimers along with doctors such as Dr.
Right To Die 2 Essay Research Paper
Right to Die Physician-assisted suicide presents one of the greatest dilemmas to families across the nation today. There are many who are suffering unnecessarily everyday, who want to partake in physician -assisted suicide. Should someone who is mentally competent, but labeled terminally ill, be allowed to engage in physician -assisted suicide? According to society, the terminally ill do not have the right to take their own life or be assisted.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Assisted SuicideA great
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Assisted Suicide A great deal of debate surrounds the practice of assisted suicide. Lately, laws against voluntary euthanasia have been eased, although serious moral and legal questions still exist. Most opposition of assisted suicide comes from religious groups, including Christianity, Judaism, and Islam.
Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper People are
Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper People are probaly confused at the fact that society approving people to be euthanized. Obviously, if it was stated in a letter to the editor in the Detroit Free Press entitled, “Death, Dignity.” The writer is simply saying it’s okay to end lives. It also states that John Engler, our state government, is supporting two important projects that assist in these suicides.
Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Questions concerning
Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Questions concerning the right to end one’s life have long generated storms of controversy. These questions, involving intensely personal views on issues no less profound than the meaning of life and liberty, are unlikely to disappear any time soon. The conservative nature of the medical profession, and the organized opposition of the “right to life” movement, along with disagreement among disabilities rights organizations, perpetuate the controversy.
Death With Dignity Essay Research Paper Death
Death With Dignity Essay, Research Paper Death With Dignity Euthanasia is a controversial subject that has been a longstanding and multifaceted debate. The argument over patient rights and physicians responsibilities has been on going since the 1950’s. Suicide is a legal act that is theoretically available to all, however many people think that euthanasia is far worse than suicide.
Assisted Suicide 2 Essay Research Paper An
Assisted Suicide 2 Essay, Research Paper An advocate of assisted-suicide, Dr. Kevorkian, has recently been convicted of 2nd degree murder for an assisted-suicide and faces up to 25 years. Kevorkian claims to have assisted in over 130 suicides since 1990. Three earlier juries have acquitted him, and a mistrial was declared in his fourth case.
An Easier Way Out Essay Research Paper
An Easier Way Out Doctor Kevorkian and other so-called “death doctors” should be permitted to assist in the premature deaths of the terminally ill. Although many states outlaw assisted suicides, nevertheless, they should by made legal for terminally ill patients. These patients may not want to suffer a long, painful death.
Dr Jack Kevorkian Disrupting The Universe Essay
, Research Paper Dr Jack Kevorkian: Disrupting the Universe Mike Cunningham 12-27-96 Social Studies 2, Mr. Johnson Dr. Jack Kevorkian did something that most people would never even think
Assisted Suicide 4 Essay Research Paper ASSISTED
Assisted Suicide 4 Essay, Research Paper ASSISTED SUICIDE I feel that assisted suicide is a practice that should not only be legally acceptable, but socially acceptable as well. No one should be forced to live a life of pain and suffering. After all, aren’t we all guaranteed the rights of life, liberty, and happiness? If happiness means freedom from pain and suffering, then assisted suicide should be legalized.
DoctorAssisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Doctor Assisted
Doctor-Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Doctor Assisted Suicide An issue of great controversy boomed in the United States approximately ten years ago. Doctor-assisted suicide was brought to the attention of Americans in the mid-1980s, but did not become the issue it is today until the nineties.
Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper DAS
Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper D.A.S Murder, death, suffering. All these horrific terms are related to an extremely important and devastating issue. Doctor assisted suicide is a very important subject that many people know little about. We need to finally shut this murdering out of Oregon for good.
Euthanasia And Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper
EUTHANASIA AND ASSISTED SUICIDE In today’s society, euthanasia and assisted suicide is a major discussion. People, who are terminally ill or are depressed, are sometimes looking for a way out. They feel that their only hope is to kill themselves. Other people in the world feel that euthanasia and assisted suicide are morally wrong.
Assisted Suicide 3 Essay Research Paper Is
Assisted Suicide 3 Essay, Research Paper Is Physician-Assisted Suicide A Solution ? Physician assisted suicide (PAS) is a very important issue. It is also important tounderstand the terms and distinction between the varying degrees to which a person can be involved in hastening the death of a terminally ill individual.
38 Assisted Suicides Essay Research Paper The
38 Assisted Suicides Essay, Research Paper The Washington Post 38 Assisted Suicides September 2-8, 1996 Picture yourself in this situation. You go to the doctor for a routine physical. You
The Controversial Issue Of DoctorAssisted Suicide Essay
, Research Paper The Controversial Issue of Doctor-Assisted Suicide Imagine youu have just found out you are going to die within three months. Recently the questions have been changed form, “What am I going to do with the
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Retired professor and
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Retired professor and psychoanalyst Ernest Van den Haag, by defending the right to commit suicide, made an appeal to J.S. Mill?s principle. Van den Haag said that people should have the right to choose as they please, as long as no one else is hurt (Hallock 13). According to the constitution, people have the right to decide death, not the government (Dority 8).
Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Should assisted
Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Should assisted suicide become totally legal in the U.S.? Well, that is the question that Mr. Stephen Carter seems to brutally review in his article ?Rush to a Lethal Judgement,? where it appears that he takes a stance against assisted suicide. He makes a very week argument though, and I feel he would fail at convincing most anyone.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Euthanasia and Physician
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia and Physician Assisted Suicide Should it be legalized? Whose life is it, anyway? Euthanasia is a word that means good death. Euthanasia normally implies that the act must be initiated by the person who wishes to commit suicide. But, some people define euthanasia to include both voluntary and involuntary termination of life.
Dr Kevorkian Essay Research Paper History and
Dr. Kevorkian Essay, Research Paper History and BackgroundDr Jack Kevorkian, a 70-year-old retired pathologist, has devoted most of his life to the campaign for assisted suicide. He has admitted helping more than 130 people to end their lives. To date only 48 have cases been documented, including the assisted suicide documented on 60 MinutesDr Kevorkian was born in 1928 in Pontiac, Michigan, to a family of Armenian immigrants.
Is Phyiscian Assisted Suicide Ethical Essay Research
Paper Physician-Assisted Suicide is Ethical Jack Kevorkian addresses many aspects of physician-assisted suicide. First, he addresses the Hippocratic oath, stating that there is no oath concerning a doctor?s moral codes. Next, he addresses the slippery slope argument. Kevorkian states that the only way the slippery slope argument will take place, is if everyone is insecure and cannot control their individual actions.
Assited Suicide Essay Research Paper If you
Assited Suicide Essay, Research Paper If you had incurable disease that gave you six months to live and you were in incredible pain and were suffering, would you want to hang on for those last moments of torture? Assisted suicide is a very controversial topic. There are many people supporting it and many people opposing it.
The Controversy Over Euthanasia Essay Research Paper
The controversy over euthanasia is based on the same ethical and social platform from which the debates for abortion and capitol punishment stem. These social dilemmas all revolve around the sanctity of life and how far government can go in making choices involving individual rights. Although the debate over euthanasia is just heating up in the American judicial system, the practice of assisted suicide has been around for centuries, Modern advances in medicine and technology have helped doctors in prolonging life.
Assited Suicide Essay Research Paper The man
Assited Suicide Essay, Research Paper ?The man who, in a fit of melancholy, kills himself today would have wanted to live had he a week.?(Voltaire) In the U.S. assisted suicide has become all too common. Mr. Jack Kevorkian, otherwise known as Dr. Death, might be the reason for this unethical uprising. Assisted suicide in those who fear they are too old, mentally unstable, or suffering from an incurable illness, doesn?t solve any problems.
Euthenasia In Australia Essay Research Paper Euthenasia
Euthenasia In Australia Essay, Research Paper Euthenasia In Australia Euthanasia Sometimes, life can deteriorate to the point where a person loses their dignity and self-respect, and are unable to communicate; life like this is longer worth living, as the most enjoyable of things are no-longer enjoyable.