Tiberius Gracchus? Proposal Essay, Research Paper
By Tiberius Gracchus? proposal of the law stated in the lex agaria, I speculate that he is trying to help the poor citizens of Rome, and at the same time, benefit the overall condition of the city. The law stated that those holding more than the legal limit of public land must give that land up, and that this land would be redistributed to ?Roman citizens in small allotments…? That Gracchus is trying to help the poorer citizens is shown through the small size of the plot of land given, the provision that a small rent must be paid, and that the land could not be sold. Handing out this land also would benefit the state because, by giving some of these plots to those who had no land, these people could now join the army. As well, this would de-crowd the actual city of Rome. Finally, he could not make this law by himself; it had to be approved by the aristocrats, so he had to benefit them too or they would not comply.
The plots of land that were to be split up and redistributed were said to each have a maximum size of 30 iugera. This allotment is not a large amount of land in comparison to the 500 or more iugera that other citizens are said to hold. The difference between the sizes of land seems to imply that those receiving these small plots would be of a lesser income, because there would not be much of a point in giving land plots of 30 iugera away to those who would consider it insignificant. Those Roman citizens that did not have a large quantity of money or land, however, would find 30 iugera to be a large allotment of land and would be able to find good use for it.
The law makes the statement that the new holders of the land must pay a small rent. This could be just instated so that the land is not just a hand-out. If land was handed out for free, that would most likely anger the rich that the land was taken from. As well, this alludes to simple principles. It would most likely not be acceptable in these days to hand out land for free, however, if a fee was added to it, no matter how nominal, it would give the idea that it was in fact fair for this to be done. Another possible reason for the rent being required could also be so that if the people given the land had to pay for it, they would put it to good use. If the land was given out for free, it might be taken advantage of and not treated properly. The fact that it was paid for makes it all the more valuable. Additionally, the fact that the rent is stated to be a small also insinuates that
this land will be given to the poor, and probably the poor that had not owned land before. If this land was to be given to the middle class or rich, almost certainly a larger rent would be asked for, since these people could afford it.
It is stated that ?the new holders were not allowed to alienate [the small allotments]?? This says that once they were given the land, the citizens could not sell it back for money. This implies two things. One, that the people the land was ?taken away? from could not get this land back by bribe or anything of that sort. And two, that this prevents serfdom in a way also because the original owners cannot try to get the land back and assert control over the new holders. Because the new holders have paid a small rent and could not sell their land, instead of working other citizens? land at the mercy of those they worked for, they were working their own land and were subject only to the government, whom they paid the rent to.
There are also possible additional benefits to giving these plots of 30 iugera to the poorer citizens. In the time when this law was made, any citizen who owned land had to be in the army. If some of these citizens who had just gained the new 30 iugera of land had previously possessed no land, then they had not been able to be in the army. Therefore, feasibly, by giving these previously landless citizens these plots, they could then join the army. Also, the holding of land and the ability to produce crops to make a living would permit these people to furnish themselves with the equipment necessary to join the army. If it is so that the small plots of land were given to citizens previously holding no land, then this could, in turn, add more people to the army. This would obviously benefit the state of Rome, because a larger army can be more effective, as well as act as a way of unifying the state. With the addition of lower class citizens into the army, more citizens would be brought together as a people.
Rome was a crowded city, and the area in which the poorer people resided was most likely not a very nice part of town. The city and the individuals would therefore benefit a great deal from the relocation of some of these poorer citizens. This 30 iugera of land would not likely be in the heart of the city, therefore, it was probably in a rural area. If this is so, the distribution of land would move people out of the city, which would benefit the actual city, in that crowding causes all sorts of sanitary problems, and
problems of safety, and crime. As well, living in an area without these problems is an obvious improvement for those citizens. So, if this is all true, the quality of living has increased greatly for those that leave the city, as well as those who remain in it.
Gracchus cannot make this law without the approval of the aristocrats. He has to go through a group vote to pass this. Therefore, he must benefit these aristocrats that vote with him in some way so that they will have some reason to vote in favor of the law. The 500 iugera spoken of as a maximum amount of land is public land. This amount is a great quantity of land, and the law even provides more land possible for each son of these holders. People who have this much land would most probably have to be very wealthy. This land was not previously owned and here, Gracchus is giving this land to the holders. Although he is taking the land away that exceeds this amount, he is taking away land that did not even belong to these citizens. Further, there is nothing in the law that mentions any price for this land that they are receiving. Besides this, the law states that the ?fertile ager Campanus was not included in the scheme.? This implies that these citizens with 500 iugera or more of land had even more land that was included in a different type of terrain. If any citizens were holding this type of land, they didn?t even have to include this in their maximum amount of land that they could own. Also, that the law says anything more than 500 iugera exceeds the legal limit tells us that there was a law already made concerning this issue, and that these people holding more than this legal limit are breaking that law. Instead of getting punished for breaking this law, they are, in a way, being rewarded. All of this definitely should be gain enough for the aristocrats to agree to this law.
In conclusion, by passing this law, Tiberius Gracchus is accomplishing multiple tasks. He helps the poor by giving them land to hold for a small amount of rent. Whether this land is given to those previously holding no land or those who only had a little plot before, it is beneficial. This will presumably take them out of the ?slums? of the city and allow them to be part of the army, and therefore, a more integral part of Rome. This benefits the state as a whole because it de-crowds the actual city, and it unifies and consolidates more citizens through a common ground. In doing this, Gracchus also gratifies the aristocrats that must be in favor of the law to pass it, by giving
them the land they were previously only allowed to hold, as well as not including any ager Campanus land they might hold in addition to the public land. Therefore, individuals, as well as the state as a whole, are aided through this proposal.
Другие работы по теме:
Kansas
& Nebraska Act Resolved Essay, Research Paper Kansas & Nebraska Act Resolved Essay submitted by Unknown The Kansas-Nebraska act was a proposal by Sen. Stephen A. Douglas which said that
Road Systems Of The Roman Empire Essay
, Research Paper Within this section of our report I would like to address which emperors had major contributions in the building of Rome’s road system, and why these roads were important. Herein we will be looking at the emperors Gaius Octavius (Augustus), Tiberius Claudius Drusus Nero Germanius (Claudius I), and Marcus Ulpius Trajanus (Trajan), for these emperors seemed to vastly expand the empire which in turn leads to the building of new road systems.
Julian Emperors Essay Research Paper The Julian
Julian Emperors Essay, Research Paper The Julian Emperors were the emperors of Rome that were related to Julius Caesar, hence the name. There were four of them that ruled from A.D.14 to A.D.68. Some of them were
Hard Times Essay Research Paper
“A Modest Proposal”Jonathan Swift wrote this essay as a satirical proposal for the purpose of exploiting social and economic issues in a sophisticated and comic way. Its main purpose is to prevent the poor people of Ireland, particularly the children, not to be burdens on their parents and to their country and for making them useful to society.
Terms And Conditions Essay Research Paper TERMS
Terms And Conditions Essay, Research Paper TERMS AND CONDITIONS The conditions for the design price quote are as follows: 1) This quote is for the above stated AppleWax Music, Inc. proposal only. Any changes will require a new proposal and price quote.
News Essay Research Paper n an effort
News Essay, Research Paper n an effort to become the nation’s largest cable operator, AOL Time Warner (news/quote) proposed late last week to merge its cable operations with AT&T (news/quote)’s, executives close to the negotiations said yesterday.
Modest Proposal Essay Research Paper Jonathan Swift
Modest Proposal Essay, Research Paper Jonathan Swift s “A Modest Proposal” was written in a time when Ireland was in great need of help due to poverty and over population. Swift wrote this proposal to the English to complain of its horrible treatment and to give some way to try to help Ireland out of being over populated and out of poverty.
Teen Curfews Essay Research Paper William Plemons
Teen Curfews Essay, Research Paper William Plemons III New curfew for teens It was a very tragic moment last week when two teens died in driving accidents. One of the events happened to a student of a fellow G.I.S.A school. Now the main focus is on the future of teen driving. It is a very serious issue, which needs very serious reform.
Johnathan Swift Essay Research Paper A Modest
Johnathan Swift Essay, Research Paper A Modest Proposal In Swift s A Modest Proposal he discusses how he wanted to prevent the poor children to no longer remain a burden to their parents or to the country, but instead to make them more beneficial to the public. Swift also wanted to expose the economic restrictions that the British had imposed upon them.
Bush Tax Proposal Essay Research Paper IPI
Bush Tax Proposal Essay, Research Paper IPI adresses the tax cut proposal that President Bush is presenting before Congress. IPI feels that althouh Al Gore had a good plan for the national tax cut by decreasing the national income tax, George Bush’s proposal was much better because it not only lowers income tax, but also eliminates estate and death tax (accounting for almost 66% of the 1,437.8 billion dollar cut).
High School Cuts Essay Research Paper Our
High School Cuts Essay, Research Paper Our principal recently asked for the student?s opinions on the ?school cuts? proposal. This proposition proposes that all extra curricular activities be cut until the money
Mali Essay Research Paper Developing a CountryThe
Mali Essay, Research Paper Developing a Country The country of Mali is considered an under developed country. Our group had to think of a proposal that would help a town in Mali stay well off on their own. The
Tiberius Claudius Nero Caesar Essay Research Paper
Tiberius Claudius Nero CaesarTiberius Claudius Nero Caesar was born in 42B.C. and was the second emperor of Rome. Tiberius took over the throne after his step-father Augustus died. He ruled from AD 14 to AD 37 during the first part of the rise of the Roman Empire. Even though his parents were divorced when Tiberius was four years old, Augustus saw that he was well educated and at an early age obtained intellectual power and military skill.
Treatment Of The Prisoners In The Concentration
Camps Essay, Research Paper Interdisciplinary Research Research Proposal The Treatment of the Prisoners in the Concentration Camps The topic that I plan to focus on in my research paper is treatment inside different concentration camps during the Holocaust. I plan to focus on three different camps, but I have not narrowed down my choices yet.
Caligula Essay Research Paper As most of
Caligula Essay, Research Paper As most of the emperors of ancient Rome were given different names then the names they had at birth Caligula was no different. Caligula’s real name was Gaius Caesar Augustus Germanicus and he was born at Antium, 25 miles from Rome, in 12 AD Gaius was a turning point in the history of the Principate, but he also was the one emperor from the Julio-Claudian dynasty who was very poorly documented. (Bibliography # 2).
Literary Analysis Of Jonathon Swift S Modest
Proposal Essay, Research Paper Literary Analysis of Jonathon Swift s Modest Proposal Jonathon Swift writes an enthralling essay full of sarcasm and bitterness. He rips apart the upper class and his concern for the common people of his nation spills forth from his written words. He writes sarcastically of how Ireland could recover if they eat their very own children.
Jonathon Swift
’s A Modest Proposal Essay, Research Paper Jonathon Swift’s A Modest Proposal Jonathon Swift assumes a few key ideas throughout A Modest Proposal. It is unquestionably assumed through the essay that anyone would be willing to give up and sell his child as nourishment. It is presumed that the reader would not hesitate to accept the ideas of cannibalism and barbarism.
Jonathan SwiftS A Modest Proposal Essay Research
Paper Jonathan Swift- ?A modest Proposal? Confusing, misleading, intriguing, and yet to the point. What do all these words have in common? They are what come together to make the essay ?A modest proposal? so good. When I first began to read this essay I found my self very confused and even after two or three times of re-reading I still could not make out many different parts of the essay.
Literary Critique Of A Modest Proposal Essay
, Research Paper A Modest Proposal Jonathan Swift In very simple terms, A Modest Proposal is a satire of the social and economic events in Ireland. It was written in the early eighteenth century in an attempt to shame England and to shock Ireland. Jonathan Swift lived in an Ireland which was a colony, politically, militarily, and economically dependent on England.
Three Excerts From Jonathan Swift
’s A Modest Proposal Essay, Research Paper Through Jonathan Swift’s mastery of satire, his pen continually stings the wealthy class of Ireland and England. The idea of the wealthier oppressing the poor is shown by the following passage from “A Modest Proposal.” “I grant this food will be somewhat dear, and therefore very proper for landlords, who, as they have already devoured most of the parents, seem to have the best title to the children.” In this passage, Swift satirically implies that the children should be quite useful since the landlords have already “devoured”, or used up the parents.
Breakdown Roman Republic Essay Research Paper The
Breakdown Roman Republic Essay, Research Paper The Breakdown of the Republic by Thomas Humphrey The Romans built one of the most extensive empires in the history of the world. The fall of a republican system to a dictatorship was gradual and was brought about by many different factors. One major aspect which was vital to the breakdown was the advent of physical force into the political arena.
The Decline And Fall Of The Re
Essay, Research Paper Overview In all of Rome s conquests, Rome grew so large so quickly that crises in society, government and morals began to develop beyond control. The final result ended in the fall of the Republic and the beginning of the Empire. There are many reasons as the final fall, and I will elaborate on a few that I think are most pertinent.
The Decline Of The Roman Empire Essay
, Research Paper To this day historians debate the reasons for the decline and fall of the Roman Republic; some arguing that conquests by Roman generals allowed them to overpower Republican institutions. To say that these powerful military leaders and their influence over Rome were solely responsible for the fall of the Republic would be nearsighted at best.
Diabetes Mellentus Essay Research Paper Project ProposalMy
Diabetes Mellentus Essay, Research Paper Project Proposal My Independent Project is on Diabetes Mellitus, type1 Diabetes, or juvenile-onset diabetes. No matter what you call it, its all the same. Your pancreas has died and you have no other way to survive other than to inject insulin multiple times a day.
Our Life Is Effected By Music Essay
, Research Paper Research Proposal: Our everyday lives are effected by music. People listen to it in the car, while grocery shopping, in the movies, at home, and practically anywhere else possible. There are many different types and styles of music such as: rock and roll, classical, rap, hardcore, Christian, jazz, reggae, country, and the list goes on.
Modest Proposal Essay Research Paper Not So
Modest Proposal Essay, Research Paper Not So Modest Proposal In 1729, with A Modest Proposal , Jonathan Swift raised the argument that, For preventing the children of poor people in Ireland from being a burden to their parents or country, and for making them beneficial to the public (44), we should rid ourselves of them by our own consumption.
Writing Techniques Essay Research Paper Writing TechniquesAfter
Writing Techniques Essay, Research Paper Writing Techniques After reading Katha Pollitt?s essay ?It Takes Two: A Modest Proposal for Holding Fathers Equally Accountable? and Patricia Mainardi?s essay ?The Politics of Housework?, several writing techniques become apparent in both essays.
Aristotle 3 Essay Research Paper Aristotle s
Aristotle 3 Essay, Research Paper Aristotle s Successful Attack on Socrates Proposal: Should Women and Children Be Held in Common? In Aristotle s Politics, Aristotle successfully criticizes Socrates proposal of having wives and children in common (Plato 449d) by pointing out a number of flaws in Socrates proposal.
Project Proposal Essay Research Paper INTRODUCTIONTopic and
Project Proposal Essay, Research Paper INTRODUCTION Topic and Purpose This proposal identifies the need for a document, which will propose and develop reasons why a for-profit transportation service for Kent should be perused. This service should be considered because of the recent parking and commuting problems both on and off campus.
Practical Proposal Essay Research Paper Practical ProposalFor
Practical Proposal Essay, Research Paper Practical Proposal For my practical I will be the stage manager for the Finningley Interhouse play. This, I think will help me greatly in discovering what happens behind the scenes. I haven t really been involved with the plays before, except a for backstage and a small part as a fireman, so this will give me a chance to do something for the plays and for my drama class.
Mary Astell Extreme Solutions Essay Research Paper
Discussion Question: Why did Mary Astell suggest such extreme solutions as a learning environment for woman, and is it necessary? In Mary Astell s From A Serious Proposal to the Ladies is a plea for intellectual equality among the sexes. The author was tired of the oppressive nature of man, which kept her and her sisters from developing their minds.
Oscar Wilde Essay Research Paper This statement
Oscar Wilde Essay, Research Paper This statement is pronounced by Gwendolen Fairfax, when Jack Worthing proposes to her by standing on his knee. Oscar Wilde tries to demonstrate in this phrase the young woman?s obsession with social acceptance. The mere fact that she is getting a marriage proposal from a good man that adores her is not satisfying enough.
Girl Interrupted Essay Research Paper Both the
Girl Interrupted Essay, Research Paper Both the book and the movie titled “Girl, Interrupted” tell the story of a young girl who is declared mentally ill in the late nineteen-sixties.