, Research Paper
1. In what way was Australia involved in Vietnam in 1965 ?
In 1962 the Government of Australia decided in, response to a request from the South Vietnamese Government, to supply them with military aid. At that time, 30 instructors were sent to assist in the training of the South Vietnamese defense forces. Unofficially, in 1962, troops were sent in to train the South Vietnamese and act as a militia. The Australian public was not made aware of this until many years later after the conclusion of the war in 1972. In 1965, the war was officially declared and the public was made aware of this through the media. During this time (1965 to 1972) Australia supported the US and South Vietnam. However, Australia and the US were more concerned about the threat of a possible spread of communism rather than the well being of the South Vietnamese. In 1965, conscription was introduced to the Australian public in order to provide further assistance to the South Vietnamese. This was not widely supported by the public with many people refusing to attend the war and being putt in jail for a minimum of two years.
2. What were the reasons that Prime Minister Menzies gave that we should be fighting in Vietnam ?
Both Robert Menzies and Lyndon Johnson were willing to send in troops for one main reason. Both Menzies and Johnson feared or were concerned about a possible spread of communism within South-East Asia and even as far south as Australia. They were not too particularly concerned about the well being of the Southern Vietnamese. This is portrayed further in ?For Australia?s Sake? as a drawing of a communist man fighting in Vietnam with his shadow stretching down almost to northern Australia. Standing on the mainland of Australia is Menzies pointing at the threat. On top of this there is a comment in the drawing, ? A murky shadow has fallen over this part of the world, reaching to our very shores ?
3. List the reasons given by the Labor Party Leader, Arthur Calwell why we should not be fighting in Vietnam ?
Arthur Calwell believed that the decision to send troops to Vietnam was a mistake. Calwell thought that sending our troops to Vietnam would not help the fight against communism but actually harm the fight in the long term. He also believed that sending only a quarter of our small army (compared to the United States Army) was a waste of time and money. He stated that this process was not helping the South Vietnamese either. Calwell also said that the war was based on untimely assumptions on the US?s behalf concerning the threat of the North Vietnamese. Calwell concluded by saying, ? How long will it be before we are drawing upon our conscript youth to service these growing and endless requirements. ? 1
4. Who was later proved right ? Menzies or Calwell ? Why ?
In a sense both were proved right in a way but Menzies was more correct in his actions. The war effort was for the first time brought into the home via television, which disgusted many people. This turned many people to disapprove of the war, which was Calwell?s small victory. This was felt the most on the soldiers upon their return to Australia. They were spat on and jeered at for just being part of the war, when most of them had been conscripted and had no say in weather or not they went to war. Looking back on it now it seems rather immature. Despite this, Menzies efforts were noted and approved by many members of the Australian society. The Australian defense forces were of valuable assistance to the American troops that further secured the ANZUS treaty.
1. Calwell, A., cited in Simmelhaig and Spenceley, For Australia?s Sake
5. What was the attitude of the papers at the time to our decision to send troops to Vietnam ?
One of the articles featured in ?For Australia?s Sake? is by a writer for the Melbourne Herald on the 30th of April 1965. The article favors Menzies? decision to send troops to Vietnam. It also states that his (Menzies) motive was to protect the South Vietnamese, which was obviously not his main reason to send troops to Vietnam.
The Hobart Mercury was even more is agreement to Menzies decision. However, the difference between this article and the one in the Herald Sun was that the writer of that article in the Herald Sun was really aggressively agreeing with Menzies decision. The writer of the Hobart Mercury article however was focussing more on disagreeing with Calwell?s opinion.
6. What was the attitude of the National Times ten years later to our decision to send troops to Vietnam ? Explain why a change of view had occurred since 1965.
The writer of the article in the National Times concurs that Menzies plan was a disaster. He (the writer) uses many examples of faults committed by the Menzies government. Among these are the following facts :
- The Australian government was not asked by Lyndon Johnston to commit to the war. In fact, Menzies was the one to pressure Mr. Johnston into committing America to the war.
- The public was not made aware of secret troop involvement from 1962 to 1965.
- The US was conducting a secret war from 1954 onwards in an effort to stamp out communism in North Vietnam
There had been a massive change of view due to the obvious. Over ten years, many investigations would have been conducted to determine previously hidden / secret facts which had been hidden by the government. These would have surfaced and been published in various magazines. From here, the public would have developed an opinion and voiced it in many different ways.
7. Explain why our understanding of events in history changes over time.
Over time, events are recalled in many different ways. This can be combated by a larger amount of facts. The only way to get more accurate facts is to do more investigating. This takes an awful amount of time and manpower. This is the main reason why over time, more facts are uncovered concerning certain instances. This gives us a further insight, over time, into what really happened in a certain occurrence.
Другие работы по теме:
The US Involvement In Vietnam And The
Philippines Essay, Research Paper The US involvement in Vietnam and The Philippines Introduction Ever since the ?New Imperialist? era, the United States of America has become quite a large Neo-Imperialist power, particularly in The Philippines and also Vietnam. In order to understand this report the term Neo-Imperialism must be explained, this is when one country gives aid to another country in which the country that recieves aid becomes independent on the helping country.
Vietnam War Essay Research Paper The discussion
Vietnam War Essay, Research Paper The discussion of the Vietnam War and its affect on Americans. In this regard, the opinions and experiences of those who fought in the war, as well as those who stayed at
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Harold
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper Harold “Light Bulb” Bryant’s portrayals of life in the Vietnam War offend the human race. Not so much the actions Bryant displayed, but the demeanor of the U.S. armed forces. Through Bryant’s stories one comes to the conclusion that war made these people completely mad, and lost every bit of morality.
U.S.A Was Unable To Win The Vietnam
War Because… Essay, Research Paper The U.S.A was unable to win the Vietnam War because they realised too late that the real war in Vietnam was not a military one but a political one.
In 1969 The Plane Came Back Essay
, Research Paper In Kathryn L. Scott?s paper ?In 1969 The Plane Came Back? she addresses the issue of the affect of the Vietnam war on those who served in it.
Australia In The VIetnam War Essay Research
Paper The only time Australia has come under direct attack from another country, was when Japan bombed Darwin and sunk a number of ships in Sydney, during World War 2. The question then has
History Of Australia Essay Research Paper History
History Of Australia Essay, Research Paper History of Australia 1901 2000 Between the years of 1901-2000, much occurred in the history of the proud, independent nation. Over more than 100 years ago, Australia fought the battle for federation against England. Australia proposed to be an independent, self-governed nation of six states and territories.
Vietnam Essay Research Paper During 1954 to
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper During 1954 to 1965, America became more involved for several important reasons, the most important one is that America feared Vietnam would expand communism all over Asia. Throughout these years the USA could have retreat and stopped giving aid to South Vietnam, but didn’t, as the Presidents wanted to maintain there stature of strength and not let Russia think they were weaker.
Film Marketing In Australia Essay Research Paper
It seems Australia’s film success is not determined by its quality but by its box office returns. The national identity of Australia has become nothing but a market strategy. The future of the
How Important Was The My Lai Massacre
In Generating Support For The Peace Protest Movement? Essay, Research Paper The Peace Protest Movement was a time in the Vietnam war when people disagreed with it. This was because of a number of things. The amount of money it was costing, The amount of people killed, but it originated largely from the massacre at My Lai.
Australia
– Monarchy Or Republic Essay, Research Paper Australia – Monarchy or Republic Even before James Cook discovered this continent that later would be named Australia, there where people living on this continent. They are being called Aboriginal and are the origin population of Australia. In the year of 1788 the first convicts are being sent to Australia because of over crowded prisons in Britain.
Short Summary Of Vietnam Essay Research Paper
Vietnam was a struggle which, in all honesty, the United States should never have been involved in. North Vietnam was battling for ownership of South Vietnam, so that they would be a unified communist nation. To prevent the domino effect and the further spread of communism, the U.S. held on to the Truman Doctrine and stood behind the South Vietnamese leader, Diem.
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Vietnam should the
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper Vietnam: should the U.S. have been involved? The Vietnam War created a great deal of controversy in America. Did America really have to sacrifice thousands of lives and millions of dollars? Was it America s duty to be involved in Vietnams affairs? Questions such as these are what derived such a constant debate during the time of the Vietnam War.
Why Australia Joined World War I In
1914 Essay, Research Paper In 1914, Australia joined the First World War. Although it was seen as a European war, the Australia government decided that Australia should support its ‘Mother Country’, Britain. The prime-minister at the time, Joseph Cook, stated Australia’s position : “Whatever happens, Australia is a part of the Empire, right to the full.
How And Why Did Federation in Australia
) Occur? Essay, Research Paper Federation was the coming together in 1901 of the six separate Australian colonies to form what is now the Commonwealth of Australia. It occurred for many reasons including: to unite the defence of Australia; to make uniform bank laws; taxes and tariffs resulting in better trade and communication between states; and to put the ?White Australia? into practise.
American Dream Of The Soldiers Of The
Vietnam War Essay, Research Paper ?When we first got here–all of us–we were real young and innocent, full of romantic bullshit, but we learned pretty damn quick.? This quote was extracted from the
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Afflicting Vietnam Veterans
Essay, Research Paper Post Traumatic Stress Disorder afflicts a number of vietnam veterans who suffered extremely traumatic, and often consistent, experiences in the vietnam war. Many who do not understand the disorder at all view PTSD(post traumatic stress disorder) as an elaborate diagnosis for a vague set of symptoms that would otherwise be associated with other psycological problems.
Agent Orange Essay Research Paper Agent Orange
Agent Orange Essay, Research Paper Agent Orange Link Diabetes Strongly Associated With Vietnam Exposure to Pesticide U.S. Air Force planes spray the defoliant chemical Agent Orange over dense vegetation in South Vietnam in this 1966 photo. Dioxin is the component of Agent Orange linked to many health effects in laboratory animals. (AP Photo)
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Since during the
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper Since during the Vietnam War there has been debate on whether the United States was right to become involved in the conflict. Some say that we were wrong to become involved in what was an internal conflict among the people of Vietnam. Others feel that we followed the natural course and that involvement was not only wrong, but also justified.
How And Why Australia
’s International Relationships Have Changed Through Its Participation In Overseas Conflict. Essay, Research Paper In this essay I will answer the question- how and why have our(Australia’s) international relationships changed by our participation in overseas conflicts ? The answer to this is that we have had changed international relationships, more independence, it ended Australia’s isolation, it gave greater social rights to women, it affirmed Australia’s alliances with the world powers and most importantly it gave Australia an identity.
Platoon Truth Or Fiction Essay Research Paper
The Vietnam War was a military struggle fought in Vietnam from 1959 to 1975. It began as a determined attempt by Communist society (called Vietcong) in the South, backed by Communist North Vietnam, to overthrow the government of South Vietnam. The struggle widened into a war between South Vietnam and North Vietnam and eventually into an international conflict.
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Against the celebrated
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper -Against the celebrated and glorious backdrop of American history, the Vietnam War stands ghastly out of place. The war was an exercise in economic, military, and political futility. The greatest tragedy of the Vietnam War, however, stems from the unnecessary deaths of 58 000 young American boys and the installment of terror, mistrust, and sorrow in those who found a way to survive in an inferno where the laws of man were obsolete.
Australia Essay Research Paper Did you know
Australia Essay, Research Paper Did you know that Australia is its own country and continent? It is also the world s smallest continent and largest island with an area of 7, 671, 930 sq km. It is said to be the oldest country in the world, but it was discovered last. Australia is one of the most interesting places on the earth, because it has everything.
Antiwar Movment In Vietnam Essay Research Paper
The antiwar movement against Vietnam in the US from 1965-1971 was the most significant movement of its kind in the nation’s history. The United States first became directly involved in Vietnam in 1950 when President Harry Truman started to underwrite the costs of France’s war against the Viet Minh. Later, the presidencies of Dwight Eisenhower and John F.
Desert Storm Compare And Contrast To Vietnam
War Essay, Research Paper Desert Storm and Vietnam were portrayed in the media are similar because in each the American soldiers had confidence when fighting, both were on tv, journalists and reporters were with soldiers on the battlefield. They were different because Desert Storm lasted six weeks and Vietnam was ten years plus.
A Prolonged Civil Conflict Essay Research Paper
The reasons why the Vietnam War lasted so long is a very controversial subject among Americans. There is no simple answer to as why the war lasted so long. Many factors have to be considered when analyzing the war. The first factor that has to be considered is whether or not the U.S. really belonged in the Vietnam War in the first place.
Why Did The Usa Become Involved In
Vietnam In The 1950S And 1960S Essay, Research Paper Why did the USA become involved in Vietnam in the 1950s and 1960s? The USA became involved in Vietnam because of a cry for help from the Vietnamese president of that time, Ngo Dinh Diem, or at least, they used it as an excuse for what they did. The Americans saw it as a prime example to the rest of the world of how capitalism could conquer communism.
Australian Foreign Policy Essay Research Paper Australian
Australian Foreign Policy Essay, Research Paper Australian Foreign Policy Topic 2 Due Date: 26/5 Teacher: Br Smith Student: Luke O?Connor ?Australia was a good friend to the Indonesian independence movement in the years after World War 2, but Australia stood silently by as Dutch New Guinea was given to Indonesia.
Eucalyptus Trees Essay Research Paper The eucalypt
Eucalyptus Trees Essay, Research Paper The eucalypt is one of the tallest trees in the world. There are more then 600 species of eucalypts in Australia. Blackbutt, jarrah, karri, stringybark, ironbark are common names of eucalypts that grow in various parts of Australia. More than ninety per cent of Australia’s trees are eucalypts.
Welcome To Australia Essay Research Paper Welcome
Welcome To Australia Essay, Research Paper Welcome To Australia Australia is one of the most popular holiday destinations in the world. Thousands and thousands of foreign people come and visit Australia each year. This is due to our vast variety in our landscapes and animals. Also our weather is perfect in most places, especially on the coast.
Australian Report Essay Research Paper Essay Australian
Australian Report Essay, Research Paper Essay Australian Realm Why despite Australia?s visible advantages in natural resources, accessible ports and a huge educated population is Australia?s GNP growing at such a stunted
The Relationship Between Combat Journalist And Vie
Essay, Research Paper The combat jounalist in Vietnam gave Americans at home a different look, an honest look at the Vietnam experience. Though combat soldiers were often hesitant toward taking a civilian around, they became much more open and truthful as time went on. Their information from the grunts and observations in choppers and in field gave Americans a new respect for what was happening abroad.