? Hare-brained Schemes, Brezhnev?s Offered Nothing Essay, Research Paper
?Khrushchev?s rule was characterised by foolish and
hare-brained schemes, Brezhnev?s offered nothing but stagnation.? Analyse the
domestic history of the USSR in the period 1953-1980 in the light of this
assertion.In 1953 the ruthless and powerful ruler of the USSR Josef
Stalin died thus ending a period of Russian history which saw the world?s first
communist state grow from a country crippled by civil war to one of the world?s
two superpowers. As with Lenin before him Stalin left no clear successor and it
wasn?t until 1956 that Nikita Khrushchev became the first notable leader of the
party (after Malenkov and Bulganin). Leonid Brezhnev then followed him as
leader. The rule of Khrushchev has been described, as being characterised by
hare-brained and foolish policies and the rule of Brezhnev has been described
as a time of stagnation. This essay will evaluate each of the leaders? domestic
policies and attempt to conclude whether these assertions are correct. One of Khrushchev?s first domestic policies once he had come
to power was the process of de-Stalinisation. This involved dismantling the
system that Stalin had created, and ending his reign of terror. It also tied in
with a number of his other domestic polices including harbouring the growth of
consumerism, and aiming to overtake the USA in consumerism. It all began in 1956 at the Twentieth Party Congress where
Khrushchev denounced Stalin in a bitter attack on his polices and his rule of
the USSR. The policy of de-Stalinisation involved releasing and pardoning tens
of thousands of the gulag inmates across the USSR, and turning the USSR away
from the ways of Stalin. This also involved talking of peaceful co-existence
with the west and re-patching a relationship with the Yugoslavian leader Tito
who Stalin had attempted to undermine in previous years. Khrushchev also changed the focus of the five-year plans
away from heavy industry, which Stalin had kept them focused on since their
creation, to consumer goods in an attempt to raise the standard of living within
the USSR. Khrushchev even boasted on a trip to the USA that the USSR would
overtake them within a few years. The policy of de-Stalinisation was a good idea on
Khrushchev?s part as the Soviet people had come to hate Stalin due to his reign
of terror and therefore changing that part of the country was a good move. It
was however unwise of Khrushchev to believe that he could completely remove
everything which Stalin had setup and had had influence over. The assertion
claims that Khrushchev?s rule was characterised by foolish hare-brained
schemes. This policy was neither hare-brained nor foolish in its implementation
but it was foolish in its belief that everything could be changed and that
people would forget Stalin?s regime. Again changing the focus of the five-year plans away from
heavy industry was a good idea yet had some problems. The five-year plans had
been shown to be flawed. They were inefficient and due to a lack of incentives
or punishments on the completion or failure of the five-year plan respectively,
the population were not compelled to meet the targets set. Khrushchev?s most ambitious policy was that of the Virgin
Lands, which he first implemented before he came to power in 1954. At the time
of Khrushchev?s rule it had been generally admitted that Stalin?s policy of
collectivisation was a failure and therefore Khrushchev being of a peasantry
background decided to change agricultural policy. He ended centralised
decision-making changing it to a local level. The Virgin Lands policy involved
using previously unfarmed or virgin areas of land for agriculture. Khrushchev
hoped to exploit these areas for agriculture. Some examples of virgin areas of
land included Siberia and Kazakhstan. Volunteers, primarily komosot or young communists were sent
along with 120,000 tractors to farm these areas. There were a number of problems with the Virgin Lands policy
which included a lack of enthusiasm within the groups of komosot, a lack of local knowledge, a lack of storage facilities
for crops produced and finally and most importantly the land chosen was
unsuitable for farming. These problems led to the failure of the Virgin Lands
policy and to a severe food shortage within the USSR. Their problem was so bad
Khrushchev was forced to import grain from the USSR?s arch enemy in the cold
war, the USA. This was a major humiliation for the USSR, which lost a lot of
prestige due to this failure. Overall the Virgin Lands scheme was a hare-brained idea on
Khrushchev?s part. The idea of being able to grow crops in areas not suitable
for doing so was absurd and therefore led to one of the most humiliating
incidents to occur to the USSR during the whole of the cold war. In October 1964 after a power struggle within the party
Khrushchev was removed from his position and it was one of those involved with
his sacking, Leonid Brezhnev, that became the new party leader. Brezhnev was
more like Stalin than Khrushchev and therefore slowed down the policy of
de-Stalinisation, which had been begun by Khrushchev. Brezhnev took time to consolidate his control of the Soviet
leadership only gaining supreme power in 1977 after being made head of state.
Brezhnev believed that Khrushchev had made too many changes of personnel during
his time as the party leader. This led to him not wanting to gain ultimate
power through the removal of people, then replacing them with people loyal to
him. He decided that he would gain his support by promoting his allies when the
position became vacant, usually via the death of the predecessor. The major job
Brezhnev had to make sure he had an ally at the head of was the KGB and he
secured this by appointing Yuri Andropov, quite early into his rule. (Who
happened to become the next leader of the USSR after Brezhnev.) Brezhnev?s unwillingness to promote quickly led to an
overall age increase. Within the politburo between 1960 and 1978 the average
age of members rose by ten years. This policy did lead to a stagnation of the
USSR, as there were no new ideas being circulated through the politburo, as the
personnel were not being replaced. Brezhnev also was unwilling, like Khrushchev before him, to
adapt or change the five-year plans. So the lack of incentives being offered to
workers and managers succeeded in keeping productivity levels low. The average
Soviet worker during his rule was half as productive as the average American
worker. This low productivity level led to the failure to complete the Ninth
five-year plans targets between 1971 and 1975 in certain areas, notably
agriculture and industry, although the production of consumer goods did
increase. This failure did lead to an increased stagnation of the Soviet Union
particularly its economy throughout the 1970?s and the 1980?s, even though
there were a number of huge industrial projects including the opening of gas and
oil fields in Siberia during the 1970?s. Brezhnev, again like Khrushchev before him, realised that
the USSR?s agriculture needed a major overhaul. This was especially necessary
after the failure of Khrushchev?s Virgin Lands policy to produce any extra food.
Brezhnev decided to allow increased ownership of private land to the peasants.
This meant that they could have their own plot of land and they could grow
their own food. The requirement of this policy was that any excess grown by the
peasants would be bought by the state. This policy led to peasants growing only
enough food to support themselves leading to Brezhnev having to again buy grain
from the USA. This was because the peasants chose to not sell any excess food
to the state but to use it for blat a
bartering system which operated across the whole of the Soviet Union. This
policy did not lead to the stagnation of Soviet agriculture it merely succeeded
in continuing the stagnation that had started under Khrushchev?s rule. The communist system was very rigid and allowed very few
opportunities for individual expression of one?s belief or thoughts. This lack
of expression led to a slow development of the economic and social structure,
as people were not allowed to put across their ideas and thoughts. This also
had some social consequences including a massive increase in alcoholism rates
then giving the USSR the highest rate in the world. This was along with one of
the highest rates of divorce and abortion in the world. This problem although
not created under the Brezhnev rule, was not solved and probably did worsen
throughout his rule and led to the increased stagnation of the Soviet Union. Overall it can be concluded that the assertion that
Khrushchev?s rule was filled with hare-brained schemes and that Brezhnev?s rule
was a period of stagnation is partially correct. Khrushchev?s rule was
characterised by a number of different policies most of which failed. These
however were not hare-brained or foolish when they were implemented, with the
exception of the Virgin Lands policy they were just not successful. However the
assertion about Brezhnev?s rule is correct, there was stagnation in the USSR
during his rule in the three main areas of the country the economy, the
agriculture and the social wellbeing of the people. This meant that by 1980 the
USSR had failed to prove that communism was better than capitalism and was a
weak country with an unproductive economy. It wasn?t until the appointment of
Mikhail Gorbachev in 1985 that the USSR began a whole scale restructuring of
the Soviet system.
3ce
Другие работы по теме:
Гомруль 1914 года
Гомруль (Home Rule Act, Irish Third Home Rule Bill, Government of Ireland Act 1914) — законопроект, обсуждавшийся в парламенте Соединённого Королевства в 1914 году, согласно которому Ирландия получила собственный парламент.
Gimples Foolishness Essay Research Paper Adam KayProfessor
Gimples Foolishness Essay, Research Paper Adam Kay Professor deall English 220 March 16, 2001 Gimpel’s Foolishness In many stories there are series of conflicts with an individual and his society. In “Gimpel the Fool,” written by Isaac Bashevis Singer, there is conflict between Gimpel and the society in which he lives in.
Mr Bennet
’s Catharsis Essay, Research Paper Most people realize that they can help either themselves or others by analyzing situations they have found themselves in, in the past and preventing themselves or others from repeating those same mistakes. The novel, Pride and Prejudice written by Jane Austen describes the events in the lives of a family composed of an irresponsible father and a foolish mother whose only concern consists of getting her daughters married off and having a place to live once her husband passes away.
A Wise King Or Essay Research Paper
A Wise King Or A Foolish Hero? Gilgamesh is a character that evolves throughout the epic of Gilgamesh. Throughout the first half of the epic, Gilgamesh is depicted as courageous and heroic on a quest of terror with his great companion Enkidu. In the end after accepting that he too will have to die and be subject to fate, Gilgamesh settles back into his city setting, only this time to be a wise king rather than the foolish hero he once was.
Baseball
’s New Rules Essay, Research Paper Baseball’s New Rules I started to watch baseball again since the World Series is starting but I have noticed that there are a couple of new rules in
Tale Of Two Cities Sydney Carton Fool
Or Hero Essay, Research Paper Many people want to be remembered as martyrs or heroes; to have proven their devotion to a person or cause, and many people have and do die for this. Some of their deaths may have been in vain; foolish, impetuous sacrifices of themselves that had no true effect, or some of the deaths may have furthered just causes and strengthened beliefs or saved the day.
Santa Anna Perez De Lebron Essay Research
Paper Antonio de Lopez de Santa Anna Perez de Lebron was a great man. He was strong, humble, smart, and clever. But he was also a weak, arrogant, stupid, foolish, and these are what most people remember about him. That is not how he really was. In the following paragraphs I will tell about the life and times of Santa Anna, and of his mistakes and achievements, I will tell of the age of Santa Anna.
Ivan Iv Essay Research Paper Ivan IV
Ivan Iv Essay, Research Paper Ivan IV: The First TsarIvan the Terrible was only 3 years old when he became the tsar of Russia. Obviously too young to actually rule, his mother Elena and her lover, Ivan Obolensky, ruled the country for him. In 1538, Elena died and Ivan Obolensky killed for the chance to rule the country.
Blah Essay Research Paper Beowulf and His
Blah Essay, Research Paper Beowulf and His Great Qualities The story of Beowulf describes a man who has many great qualities. He is known as a true hero, having risked his own life to save those in danger. He has superior physical strength and is highly moral. However, at times, he is a bit foolish.
Antony Speech Analysis Essay Research Paper Emotional
Antony Speech Analysis Essay, Research Paper Emotional Speech Analysis William Shakespeare?s ?Julius Caesar? is a well-written stage play. Shakespeare included many good speeches in his plays; one of the best was the one delivered by Antony. Antony?s speech came very shortly after Julius Caesar?s death, and the city was in much chaos.
Andy Is Unsympathetic I
’m A Fool Essay, Research Paper In the video “I’m A Fool,” By Sherwood Anderson, there sare many events that occur that cause the main character, Andy, to prove his true personality. In the story Andy cotridicts himselfand shows how easy it is to make insipid mistakes. In the story Andy proves himself to be an unsympathetic character because he acs foolish, timid, unremorsful and as a masquerader.
Stalin Essay Research Paper Rule Under StalinIn
Stalin Essay, Research Paper Rule Under Stalin In one point in Russia a man with the name John Stalin ruled. He was supposed to be a great ruler. He had many ideas for the country, which before his rule was run in the worst of ways.
Macbeth Deserves No Pity Essay Research Paper
The tragedy of Macbeth tells of how a noble and respected man, turned into a tyrant by ambition and greed. There were outside influences which contributed to this transformation such as the prophecies told by the witches, and lady Macbeth. However Macbeth deserves no pity as it was he who decided upon the actions he took, which left many innocent people dead including himself.
AdAs Model Of A Boom Essay Research
Paper Explaining a ?BOOM? using the AD-AS model The Business Cycle or Trade Cycle is characterised by a regular cyclical pattern with four distinctive phases: the expansion, the peak, the contraction, and the trough.
Zero Tolerance Essay Research Paper Zero ToleranceTo
Zero Tolerance Essay, Research Paper Zero Tolerance To the best of my knowledge on the subject the zero tolerance rule is a very good rule, because there is no room for error on the part of the criminal justice systemand there is no room for a misleading excuse. So the zero tolerance policy is good. For example, say a person pulls a fire alarm just to get out of a class.
Ireland Essay Research Paper IRELAND 19091914 Ireland
Ireland Essay, Research Paper IRELAND 1909-1914 Ireland has been in conflict for over seven centuries, in this essay I will attempt to describe the events which occurred in Ireland and what is now Northern Ireland between 1909 and 1914. Tension between the Irish people had always been existent but with the advent of the Home Rule bill the people had an excuse to fight.
Oedipus Essay Research Paper Just as it
Oedipus Essay, Research Paper Just as it was with Oedipus, Creon is also a victim of his own arrogance. To say he is a victim is somewhat gracious, but he is after all, human. Arrogance being a chief
European Colonization On Africa Essay Research Paper
Back in early African history, Europeans colonized and infiltrated African civilizations in order to make a profit and to be known as a superior nation. By doing this, European colonists ?messed up? the traditional African lifestyle. African?s were willing to let the colonists join them, but the Europeans went too far when they took over governments and tried to rule over the Africans.
Open Campus Or Bust Essay Research Paper
OPEN CAMPUS OR BUST Michael Parker is a teacher from a high school who has closed campus and doesn?t even think that it is working. ?It hasn?t reduced the number of ?bad? things students do, merely relocated them? (Parker, 1997, 1). That?s what the very respectable teacher said about the so called ?solution? of closed campus.
A Midsummer Nights Dream 2 Essay Research
Paper In Shakespeare’s “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” the mortal teenage characters fall in love foolishly, and the character Bottom states, “O what fools these mortals be”. They are foolish because they act like children. Although Lysander, Hermia, Demetrius, and Helena appear grown-up, when they are in love they act foolishly.
Character Analysis Marc Antony Essay Research Paper
Marc Antony, of Shakespeare?s Julius Caesar, changes dramatically throughout the play. He begins the play a foolish reveler and ends it as a power hungry, vengeful, cold hearted member of the Second Triumvirate. What prompts this dramatic change of character in Antony? A number of things, chiefly the death of Caesar, and the power he gains in the Second Triumvirate.
Analysis Of Sonnet 2 Essay Research Paper
Sonnet 2 In Sonnet 2, Shakespeare stresses to his lover that beauty will not last, and that it is selfish and foolish for anyone not to prepare for the loss of beauty
To Build A Fire Man
’s Intelligence Is Foolish Essay, Research Paper To Build a Fire: Man’s Intelligence is Foolish How many times have you seen birds flying south for the winter? They do
Julius Caesar Character Analysis Essay Research Paper
Julius Caesar In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, the title character’s three prominent characteristics, that he displays for the short time while in the novel, are his egotistical attitude, his intelligence, and foolish courage. During the second scene of the first act, we get an idea of what kind of man Caesar believes himself to be when Anthony declares “When Caesar says ‘Do this’, it is perform’d.” This lets us known that Caesar believes his word to be higher than any other persons, this was probably caused by the inflation of his ego.
Stopping By Woods 2 Essay Research
Paper The topic of my essay will explain how Beowulf becomes both a tragic hero and a proud fool. Beowulf becomes a world-renowned hero, but like many, his self-pride leads him to a horrible downfall, ultimately ending his life in tragedy. In the same way he becomes a proud fool by letting his ego overpower his rationale and as a result he makes a foolish decision that abandons the Geats forever.
Reflection As Revision Essay Research Paper Reflection
Reflection As Revision Essay, Research Paper Reflection as RevisionAll through life I have always been told by people that it’s quality not quantity that matters. I cannot even remember the first time I heard it. If I only had a dollar for every time I was told that. If ever asked for the ultimate clichi, I would have to say quality not quantity.
Descartes Essay Research Paper Descartes Ren
Descartes Essay, Research Paper Descartes, Ren Ren Descartes was born on March 31, 1596 and died on February 11, 1650. Ren Descartes was a man of many things. He was a French mathematician, philosopher and scientist. He made contributions to the theory of equations and his rule of signs, but the most distinguished contribution that Descartes made to the world of mathematics was analytic geometry.
Compare And Contrast The Tudor And Stuart
Dynasties Essay, Research Paper Throughout history, dynasties, or a series of rulers who belong to the same family, have come and gone. No two are exactly alike. They all have similarities and differences when compared to each other. The Stuart and Tudor dynasties are no exception to the rule. Each had different views on how to rule.
The Irish Question Essay Research Paper For
The Irish Question Essay, Research Paper For many weary years Home Rule or “The Irish Question” had confused the British Parliament. The Roman Catholic Irish despised the Union of 1801 that had abolished the Irish Parliament. It had not saved Ireland from appalling misery, death and depopulation in the famines of the mid-nineteenth century.
Kant S Ethics Essay Research Paper Kant
Kant S Ethics Essay, Research Paper Kant s Ethics In the Metaphysics of Ethics (1797) Kant described his ethical system, which is based on a belief that the reason is the final authority for morality. Actions of any sort, he believed, must be undertaken from a sense of duty dictated by reason, and no action performed for expediency