A Crushing Burden? Essay, Research Paper
Are immigrants a fortune of diversity, or a crushing burden? America has longed
battled the issue about immigration. Today people in general have a very mixed feeling
about the issue of immigration. Immigrants escaping from prosecution built the United
States. Gladly today, America firmly tries to solve many of our economical, political and
social difficulties due to the burden of the thousand immigrants that enters the United
States. Many people argue that immigrants steal jobs from the loyal Americans,
Overcrowds schools, ruin health care system and abuse health and public and federal
services. Michael Huffington, a former member of the U.S House of Representatives
from California, explains: ?Spending on illegal immigrants is out of control.? On the
other hand, many argue that immigrants are actually good for America?s present and
future status. Statistics show that immigrants lower unemployment rates, pay more taxes
and expand our economy by consumption of goods and other services. Immigrants also
increase jobs and improve schools. As more Americans become aware of the issue, the
more questions are aroused and the fewer answers we come across. By exploring the
differing views in this matter, we can define our personal vision of what we should do to
come closer to finding the answer we need to solve this problem.
Are immigrants job-takers or job-makers? One of the first issues that came with the
wave of immigrants, was the fact that Americans believe that immigrants steals jobs from
native-born Americans, and increase the competition for jobs. Statistics showed that for
every 100 working low-skill immigrant replace 25 U.S low-skilled worker. The Urban
Institute also estimates that 74% of immigrants hold jobs, against the 72% of the general
male population. Immigrants usually have most of the low-wage jobs that many
Americans would refuse to do. Most immigrants agree with the long hours and low- pay,
this is what makes the unemployment rate to diminish. Immigrant workers for sure
increase the competitiveness for both local and international industries. Most of these
high-paying immigrants are multilingual, with various degrees and with international
knowledge. These immigrants increase payments, multiply the number of jobs for both
Americans and other immigrants. So, there is no reason for natives to worry, or is there?
The National Immigration Forrum explains, ?the whole job stealing jobs is a myth.
Almost all the relevant research has found that immigrants do not displace native
workers.? It said. ?In truth Immigrants workers stimulate local economies, create jobs
and pay far more in taxes than they receive in public services. Those who oppose this
theory conclude that immigrants displace more than 1 million natives in 1992, and those
Americans displaced cost the U.S $6.1 billion dollars annually from immigrant
competition. Both of these views were based on costs and unemployment, but another
chapter in this issue, is the education element.
How far should we go to educate our immigrant?s children? As more
Immigrants pour in the United States, more and more immigrant children enter the U.S
schools. Many critics argue that educating immigrants are too expensive. All in all the
U.S spends $175-200 million annually on bilingual programs. These bilingual programs
cost $650 a year for each student. Keep in mind that there are over two million immigrant
students enrolled in the U.S schools. Just think if the United States took $1 billion we
spend educating illegal immigrants in California Schools, it would allow us to put anew
computer on every 5th grader school desk. Still there are many factors that many people
realize when constructing their opinion. When educating immigrant children we teach
they laws and rules of the American country. When immigrants attend schools they are
obligated to learn the American ways, and that will make them citizens and part of our
society. Educating the immigrants also enhance the American?s understanding of foreign
cultures and nationality. By exposing kids at a young age to foreign tolerance,
ethnocentrism will be forgotten. The immigrants taught today would receive the same
amount of knowledge as an American would. Therefore, the immigrants would create an
equal opportunity when the job opportunity gets scarce. Immigration at this time is a
growing problem in schools all across the U.S, the decision that comes from this issue
will have a lasting scar on the non-English-speaking children.
Another issue that troubles the U.S are the immigrant?s right to benefits and
public services. Do immigrants pay their way in the welfare state? Some of these benefits
include housing and Urban Development, General Assistance, Medicaid, emergency
services, services for pregnancy women and many other benefits. Michael Huffington
explains, ?Many illegal immigrants come for two purposes that are both destructive and
expensive: to commit crimes or to receive government benefits.? Illegal immigrants with
citizen children are eligible for food stamps and many other benefits just as an American
child would have received. Many Americans find we need means testing as a solution, to
find those who commit entitlement fraud. Except the means testing would cost million of
dollars that America can not afford. The National Forrum presented the second view.
Immigrants overall pay more in tax ($85 billion) than they use in welfare ($24 billion.).
They said that most immigrants do not use welfare, and use fewer social services than
United States-born residents. The immigrants do not seem more likely than the natives do
receive the government benefits. Therefore to create more doubts and
mistrust among both immigrants and Americans.
After all the information I have presented to you, it is time to create an
unprejudiced resolution of the improvements and impacts of immigrants. Do they hurt or
improve our economy? Do their tax money support the health programs and public
services they receive? How far does America have to go to educate both immigrants and
their children? In addition, the biggest question, how can we solve this? These different
views are what cause many of the problems and question that create the insecurity and
doubt among the American today. Maybe with these facts and different analysis, we will
eventually have the power and will to solve this infinite puzzle in the United States
today.
Footnotes
1.Michael Huffington. The 1994 ?Illegal Immigration.?
Book- Illegal Immigration Opposing Points. Introduction/page 12.
2.The impact of Immigrants on the U.S. ?Shattering the Myths.?
Book- The Challenge of Immigration. Chapter 4, Page 59
3. Michael Huffington. The 1994 ?Illegal Immigration.?
Book- Illegal Immigration Opposing Points. Chapter preface, Page 63
37e
Другие работы по теме:
Immigration Policy Essay Research Paper The United
Immigration Policy Essay, Research Paper The United States is having its largest surge of immigrants since the states became united . Who knows what will stop these immigrants from endlessly flowing into the country? The changes in our immigration policies of the past have allowed immigration to greatly change.
Immigration Essay Research Paper I feel really
Immigration Essay, Research Paper I feel really bad for the people who turn to immigration to save their lives. Americans unwillingly use their tax dollars to pay for the salary of illegal immigrants. It is a big problem for people in the US. I feel that immigration is okay, but the problem is illegal immigration.
Importance Of Diversity Training Essay Research Paper
Diversity training has become a necessity in businesses today. Diversity training is necessary because of people s differences in our work force. Some of these differences are race, gender, culture, age, and disabilities. Because our organization is so diverse, this program will help educate, sensitize and prepare people to get along in our workplace.
Immigration Essay Research Paper
`+ + h h 4 , Undesirable conditions at home, such as poverty and famine, drew numerous foreigners to the idea of migrating to the United States. The U.S. was the answer to economic opportunity, religious freedom, and land acquisition. Because the move for many seemed to be a promise of fortune and freedom, a mass migration of millions had occurred in the late 19th century.
Is Third Worlld Immigration A Threat To
Americas Way Of Life Essay, Research Paper “Is Third world immigration a threat to America’s way of life”? Is Third world immigration a threat to America’s way of life? I do not believe it is. I agree with Isbister. He argues that cultural impacts of immigration “are positive, constructive changes, that most Americans will benefit from living in a more multicultural society, and that tension between the different ethnic groups can be alleviated.
Changing Cities Essay Research Paper The late
Changing Cities Essay, Research Paper The late 1800’s were a time of changing of immigration, transportation, and government, which in turn changed cities to a drastic amount. Immigration played a big part in changing the culture of the cities into their own unique culture for every city. Transportation let the people still be connected to other cities without having to travel for months to get there.
America And Imigration Essay Research Paper History
America And Imigration Essay, Research Paper History 53 Spring 2000 Immigration/Migration America and Immigration When reading two articles that are decades apart, one sees that the nation?s, as a whole, opinion has changed about immigrants. In an article from 1905 the South wanted immigrants because they were cheap labor.
Immigration And Its Effects Essay Research Paper
People are pieced together by their experiences. The United States is like a person in that way. Every single person who has lived in America has added his or her patch to the red, white, and blue quilt. Each patch is a story. Without one patch the entire quilt would be different. The contributions to the quilt by the early immigrants are very important to the history of America.
Canadian Immigration Essay Research Paper
For a long time Canada has been a multi cultural country, and because of this, ourcitizens are more socially and globally aware of what s going on around them. Canada sImmigration Act and system helps our country be more culturally diverse, it increases economicgrowth, and it makes Canada a safer place to be.
Increase Immigration Into Canada Essay Research Paper
Increase Immigration into Canada Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen. As we all now we are all gathered here today to debate, argue over a bill concerning an increase in immigration. We may not all be on the same side. But personally I am for
Immigration In Canada Essay Research Paper IMMIGRATION
Immigration In Canada Essay, Research Paper IMMIGRATION IN CANADA Canada should support immigration as it isneeded and should be encouraged. Most Canadians forget,they are descendants of immigrants. In this essay thefollowing will be discussed : – need for immigrants – the myths about immigrants – illegal and inadmissible immigrants.
Immigration 2
Immigration’s Role In The Development Of The United States As A Nation Essay, Research Paper In the beginning of our country, the first people to settle in the United States were immigrants. They
Should Immigration Laws Be More Restrictive Essay
, Research Paper Should Immigration Laws Be More Restrictive? In any public place nowadays we can see people of different races everywhere mostly begging or asking us to buy things we usually do not want. Should immigration laws be more restrictive? Many people say this phenomenon is irreversible and that our future is that of a multiracial, multiethnic society regardless of whether laws are changed or not.
The Jewish American Family Essay Research Paper
The Jewish American Family Historical Background The settlement of Jews in America is an old one. Jews have been in America since the colonial period, though they began arriving in large numbers only one hundred years ago. The immigration of Jews to America occurred in three major historical waves involving people from three national locations:
Chinese Exclution Act Essay Research Paper Chinese
Chinese Exclution Act Essay, Research Paper Chinese Exclution Act Be it enacted, That from and after the expiration of ninety days next after the passage of this act, and until the expirationof ten years next after the passage of this act, the coming ofChinese laborers to the United States be, Suspended; andDuring such suspension it shall not be lawful for any ChineseLaborer to come, or, having so come after the expiration ofSaid ninety days, to remain within the United States. (ChineseExclusion Act, The, 257) The Chinese exclusion act was a harsh act passed during the time of immigration for the Chinese.
Immigration Essay Research Paper ImmigrationI am driving
Immigration Essay, Research Paper Immigration I am driving my car and trying to get to Miami. I get lost. I stop at a gas station because I need someone to direct me in the right direction. I end up in a city called Hialeah where there are very few English speaking people. The people that are there only speak Spanish.
Immigration In Australia Essay Research Paper ImmigrationAustralia
Immigration In Australia Essay, Research Paper Immigration Australia should increase its migrant intake. Immigration is an asset to any country. It encourages economic growth, reduces unemployment, and creates more cultural diversity and understanding of different nations. It benefits population growth, especially for a small nation, like Australia.
America And Its Policy Toward Immigration Essay
, Research Paper America and Its Policy Toward Immigration During the late nineteenth century, a wave of immigration known as the New Immigration swept across the United States. The Northern and Western Europeans of the 1840s immigration period continued to arrive, but the new wave brought significantly more people from eastern and southern Europe in addition to smaller groups from Canada, Mexico, and Japan.
Immigrants Essay Research Paper Are Immigrants A
Immigrants Essay, Research Paper Are Immigrants A To the U.S? Immigrants are not a burden to the U.S. Therefore, we shouldn’t stop all immigration . Immigrants are hard workers and are not causing unemployment for
Immigration 4 Essay Research Paper WHAT ROLE
Immigration 4 Essay, Research Paper WHAT ROLE HAS IMMIGRATION PLAYED IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE UNITED STATES AS A NATION? Immigration is an event that has been occurring in the United States since the 1620 s when the Mayflower brought the Pilgrims to our country. Like the Pilgrims, many immigrants came to our nation looking for opportunities that their country could not provide for them.
History Of Korean 2
History Of Korean & Chinese Immigration Essay, Research Paper The first immigration of Koreans to the North Americas happened in the early 1900??s near the year 1902. They came to America to work on the sugar plantations in Hawaii.
Chinese Immigration Essay Research Paper
“The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was the first significant law restricting immigration into the United States. Those on the West Coast were especially prone to attribute declining wages and economic ills on the despised Chinese workers. Although the Chinese composed only .002 percent of the nation’s population, Congress passed the exclusion act to placate worker demands and assuage prevalent concerns about maintaining white “racial purity.”
Immigration To Canada Essay Research Paper Early
Immigration To Canada Essay, Research Paper Early immigration to Canada was generated by a network of emigration agents who were salesman who advertised to Canada?s attraction?s to prospected immigrants. They targeted wealthy farmers, agricultural laborers and female domestics, preferably from Great Britain, the United States and Northern Europe.
To Welcome With Open Arms Essay Research
Paper Many Americans have skewed notions about immigration, and those perceptions influence decision in Washington and presidential candidates on the campaign trail. Some people think immigration is out of control; a few suggest that it should be stopped altogether. The problem is that many people have illegal immigration and legal immigration mixed up.
Immigration The Maker And Breaker Of America
Essay, Research Paper There are many issues concerning the immigration into America by peoples of other races and cultures, and a hundred more opinions to go with them. At the time of the largest immigration boom into this country, between 1880 and 1920, many people thought of immigration as a negative thing.
Diversity Essay Research Paper DiversityDiversity is a
Diversity Essay, Research Paper Diversity Diversity is a big part of today?s society. But to understand diversity we have to know what it is. Diversity is where there are many different backgrounds, religion, and races. Ralph Bunch said ?I have a deep seated bias against hate and intolerance. I have a bias against racial and religious bigotry.
ImmigrationPauline Hanson Is Wrong Essay Research Paper
Pauline Hanson?s view on migration is incorrect. Ceasing migration would not be good for Australia either culturally or economically. An intelligent and sophisticated immigration program, which focuses strongly on skilled and business migration, can have a beneficial impact on our economy.
Shakespear Essay Research Paper
“That even our loves should with our fortune change; for tis a question left us yet to prove, whether love lead fortune or else fortune love.” – Player king, act 3 scene 2
Immigration 3 Essay Research Paper Analysis of
Immigration 3 Essay, Research Paper Analysis of a Disagreement over Immigration The authors of the 3 articles on immigration reform all seem to agree that the 1990 immigration law is inadequate, but they agree on little else. They find different impacts on the workforce, positive and negative. And they differ sharply over whether recent levels of immigration help or hurt the economy: one writer suggesting higher levels of immigrants and the other two suggesting a reduced level.
Mexican Immigration Essay Research Paper I am
Mexican Immigration Essay, Research Paper I am a sixteen-year-old boy from southern Mexico City. My family lived in poverty and when my father was killed in an accident the flow of money abruptly stopped. My brother, fifteen-year-old Jose, and I am planned to cross the border and head to the United States.
The Melting Pot Is Overflowing Essay Research
Paper The Melting Pot is Overflowing Since the founding of Jamestown, Virginia, in 1607, immigrants have been coming to America. Immigration is usually caused by push and pull factors meaning, certain elements that attract immigrants to the United States, and certain influences, which force them to leave their native country.