Essay, Research Paper
Sunrise, Sunset
In Shakespeare’s play, Henry IV part 1, there is a contrast established between a bloody rebellion and drunken frivolity, which establishes the question of the play; honor in death or cowardice in life. Their are several contrasting characters and events which help to establish this question; the foils are Prince Hal to Hotspur, Falstaff to King Henry, and the robbing of crowns, money or monarchy. Shakespeare’s addition of the Falstaff scenes to the story of the rebellion is an effective way to create laughter and life in the play and to establish the contrast between honor and enjoyment of life. The contrast between these groups of men is like the contrast between night and day. In Act 1, Scene 2, Falstaff argues for the men of night, “let not us that are squires of the night’s body be called thieves of the day’s beauty; let us be Diana’s foresters, gentlemen of the shade, minions of the moon and let men say we be men of good government as the sea is, by our noble and chaste mistress the moon, under whose countenance we steal.” (ln. 19-24) Falstaff is arguing that the men of night should be judged by the rules and standards of the night and not by those of the day. This plea shows the central issue of the play, honor in death or frivolous cowardice in life.
Though Henry and Hotspur are bitter enemies and Falstaff and Hal are comical ones, both pairings of men have a father-son relationship. Until the final act of the play, Hal is estranged from his father, because of his reputation as a thief and a drunkard. Without Henry as an active father, Hal’s role model of sorts is Falstaff. Like any son, Hal follows Falstaff’s example, robbing and drinking, but would deny any association between his acts and Falstaff’s. When he was younger he would rob with Falstaff, follow Falstaff’s example, but when he reached an age of rebellion, he stole from Falstaff. This situation is like the situation between King Henry and Hotspur. In Hotspur’s youth, he helped steal the crown from Richard, for Henry, but when he reached an age of rebellion, he tried to steal the crown from Henry.
The thievery of Gadshill and the battle for the crown are two contrasting battles which show the similarity between the day men, Henry and Hotspur, and the night men, Falstaff and Hal. Hal is motivated by a desire for money, a desire to rebel against Falstaff, and a desire for fun. Though before Gadshill, he has robbed with Falstaff, at Gadshill he steals from Falstaff. He is not motivated to steal from Falstaff because Falstaff is wrong and he wishes to punish him. Hal is not stealing for what is right. Hal steals for the hell of it. This battle for money is like the battle for the crown. Hotspur is motivated to take the crown from King Henry, not because the King is wrong, but because of his own motivations. Hotspur is motivated by a desire for the crown, a desire to rebel against the King, and a desire for honor. Hotspur is not rebelling for what’s right. Hotspur’s motivations are not concrete enough to be worthy of the loss of life they will cause. He does not want to relinquish his prisoners, because of an issue of pride established on the battlefield. He does not want to release the men who he fought. The king’s request for their release is not enough to start a rebellion. Also, if Hotspur’s rebellion is based on the release of Mortimer, then he should not have to fight, because by the time of the battle, Mortimer is free. Hotspur’s rebellion could not be based on a desire to return the crown to its rightful line, because he took the crown from this line. Hotspur’s rebellion is based on his own ideas of honor. There are other similarities between the two battles. When Poins hides Falstaff’s horse, he takes away his ability to steal effectively. At the rebellion battle, Douglas knocks the kings crown from him, taking away his ability to rule effectively, because a King needs a crown to rule as a thief needs a horse to steal. Also, at Gadshill, Poins and Hal disguise themselves, in order to achieve their goal, to steal the money. At the rebellion battle, the king disguises many lords as Kings to accomplish his goal, keep the crown. These two battles show what’s really important to these men, frivolity and honor. If frivolity is the goal of night and honor the goal of day, then they both accomplish what they set out for, but neither is fighting or stealing for what is right.
The setup of the play is contrasting scenes, rebellion and thievery, are not directly linked until the end of the play. Though Hal and Hotspur are very closely linked, they are only mentioned once each until the final battle. Shakespeare uses both of their scenes as to show similar ideas, rebellion of youth from their elder’s in attempt for honor or fun, but he does not link the two directly. He creates an ingenious device by not saying what he’s saying. At the beginning of the play, their seems to be no connection between the two story lines. As the play proceeds, the connection is made, but by the audience, not by the characters saying it. The similarities are rampant, but not apparent immediately. For example, the King begins the play by speaking of time, “Find we a time for frighted peace to pant,”(Act 1. Scene 1. ln. 2); his foil, Falstaff, begins scene two by asking “what time of day is it, lad?”(Act 1. Scene 2. ln.1) Both men then establish the situations for their stories. The king establishes the rebellion is about and Hal establishes that Falstaff is a thief. Though there seems to be no connection between thievery and rebellion, as the play moves on, it becomes apparent that their is a very real connection between the two. By having the audience figure out the connection for themselves, Shakespeare makes the connection much stronger in their minds then if he told them himself. The audience then is forced to compare the two and come up with their own ideas about honor of death versus enjoyment of life, so when the ending comes they will be interested to see what solution Shakespeare comes up with.
The main foils in Henry IV part 1 are Hotspur and Hal. Hotspur is the representative of the day and Hal the representative of the night. The intention of the day is to be honorable and the intention of the night is to enjoy life. If both these characters are looked at with a relative eye, then they are the same. Separately they are the same, but together they are diametric opposites. If they were compared during the day, Hal would be a fool, but if they were compared at night, Hotspur would be the fool. In Act 2, Scene 4, Hal mocks Hotspur; “I am not of Percy’s Mind, the Hotspur of the north, he that kills me some six or seven dozen Scots at a breakfast, washes his hands, and says to his wife ‘Fie upon this quiet life! I want work.’”(ln. 84-87) Meanwhile, Hotspur despises Hal as a drunkard and a fool; “And that same sword-and-buckler Prince of Wales, but that I think that his father loves him not….I would have him poisoned with a pot of ale.”(Act 1. Scene 3. ln. 230-233) The sword-and buckle and ale are both representative of the lower class, which a prince should not be, according to Hotspur. The irony that Shakespeare creates by having Hotspur and Hal think each other fools shows that they are both fools. By picking day over night and night over day, neither can be a full man. They must fight at the end, because they represent the two contrasting ideas of the play, honor of life and love of life.
Shakespeare transforms Hal at the end of the play, to show the best example of a man. The Hal of the first acts would not be a hero in the end as he is in the end, but instead would not even show up for the war. By having Hal take responsibility for himself in the end, Shakespeare shows what he thinks of the issue of honor and fun. Hal does not become Hotspur, if he did then honor would be right. Hal does not fight the good fight and forget his past. He becomes a combination of day and night. If he forgot about the night, then Shakespeare would be saying that honor was greater. If he ran away and did not fight, then Shakespeare would be saying that enjoyment of life was greater. When Hal sees Falstaff and thinks him dead, he weeps for his friend. Hotspur would probably kill Falstaff himself. Later, when Falstaff pretends that he killed Hotspur, Hal goes along with it, because he does not have the same desire for honor as Hotspur. The setup of the play shows this combination. In the first acts, Hal and Hotspur’s story-lines were separate, but in the end they combine. This models the transformation that creates the Hal of the last acts. The new Hal that shows himself in the end is Shakespeare’s answer to his own question. By having Hal win the fight and act as he does with Falstaff, Shakespeare is saying that life is to be fought for, but it is also to be enjoyed. If life is not enjoyed, then their is nothing to fight for. If life is not fought for, then it is not worth being enjoyed. Shakespeare is saying that a sunrise or sunset is much better then the sun or the moon.
Другие работы по теме:
The Little Business Man Essay Research Paper
The Little Business Man By Morley Callaghan In this story, The Little Business Man, by Morley Callaghan, we met several different characters. The most important characters, Luke and Uncle Henry, had several different values. Luke s values were care, protection and optimism, while his uncle s values were organization, insensibility, and efficiency.
King Henry IV And Joseph Strorm
: Archtypical Fathers Essay, Research Paper King Henry IV and Joseph Strorm: Archtypical Fathers An ideal father is one who is both caring and understanding. To fit this
Queen Elizabeth And Henry VIII Essay Research
Paper She took over the position of England’s leader when her father Henry VIII died. She didn’t care one way or the other what every ones religion was. So she made Anglican the national
Becket Essay Essay Research Paper
“Friendship often does collapse over such unjust ideas.” This quote alone illustrates the dissolution of friendship that occurs between Thomas Becket and Henry II in early English history. What would one think if a trusted friend turns on them and stabs them in the back? Certain situations in the lives of Thomas Becket and Henry II build up then dissolve their friendship.
Becket Essay Research Paper Summary of Becket
Becket Essay, Research Paper Summary of Becket by Jean Anouilh Becket is a movie that portrays the conflict of power between the throne and the church. It is the story of Henry II and his companion Thomas Becket. The movie begins by giving a brief summary of the history up to the point where the movie begins. This information is crucial to the understanding of the situation.
The Sunset Surfer Essay Research Paper The
The Sunset Surfer Essay, Research Paper The Sunset Surfer An older man sat on his classic 9′6 with joy in his eyes, salt water in his veins, and a genuine love for his board underneath him, and the waves rolling in. He had just got off work and paddled out into the sunset for a half an hour of spiritual rejuvenation.
The Red Badge Of Courage Essay Essay
, Research Paper The Red Badge of Courage is not a war novel. It is a novel about life. This novel illustrates the trials and tribulations of everyday life. Stephen Crane uses the war as a comparison to everyday life. He is semi-saying that life is like a war. It is a struggle of warriors the every day people against the odds.
Henry Iv Essay Research Paper Henry IV
Henry Iv Essay, Research Paper Henry IV, A Look at a Machiavellian Ruler When looking at Henry IV while studying Niccolo Machiavelli’s The Prince, one can see that henry was extremely Machiavellian in his ways. The Prince, written by Machiavelli, was written to guide a ruler in the key concepts of being able to have a kingdom that endures and to obtain and control and power in order to succeed during his reign.
The Red Convertible Essay Research Paper In
The Red Convertible Essay, Research Paper In the Red Convertible by Louise Erdrich, the main character Henry loses his hold on reality. The story takes place in North Dakota on an Indian Reservation where Henry lives with his brother Lyman. Henry and Lyman buy a Red Convertible that later in the story illustrates Henry?s lack of ability to stay sane.
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay, Research Paper Henry Cabot Lodge Henry Cabot Lodge was an American diplomat. He was born on July 5th 1902. He was born in Nahant Massachusetts. He did alot for our country so in the next few paragraphs I will tell you about Henry Cabot Lodge and some of his accomplishments.
A Battle Into Adulthood Red Badge
Essay, Research Paper A Battle for Adulthood Throughout the novel The Red Badge of Courage, written by Stephen Crane, a theme is portrayed within a battle that takes place during the Civil War. It is that each person must find the courage to win his or her won battle for maturity or adulthood. A soldier, who is also the main character, Henry Fleming, exemplifies this theme.
Evolution Of A Soldier Essay Research Paper
Henry Becomes A Man In the book The Red Badge of Courage, Henry changes in many ways as a soldier. In the beginning of the story he is scared of battle and runs, yet by the end of the book he is a true soldier. Many important events shape Henry s evolution into a veteran soldier. Many of Henry s own glorified notions of war are what make him so wary and unsure of himself.
Soliloquoy From Henry IV Essay Research Paper
William Shakespeare’s Henry IV, Part II, contains a soliloquy in which King Henry grieves over his difficulty sleeping. Shakespeare illustrates the King’s musings through exquisite diction, imagery, and syntax. These literary elements effectively demonstrate the King’s state of mind.
Red Badg Of Courage Essay Essay Research
Paper Henry Fleming was just a child when he entered the army. Even though his journey into manhood took a while, he finally got where he was headed . This journey included many people and things, that help Henry along the way.
Red Badge Of CourageHenry Fleming
’s Growth Essay, Research Paper Growing Up Throughout the novel The Red Badge of Courage, Henry Fleming is in a constant struggle between his illusions of war and reality. When Henry first decides to enlist their is a perception of war that he has in his mind; he later finds out that war is not as glorious and courageous as his mind had perceived.
Fighting On Two Fronts- Henry Fleming In
Red Badge Of Courage Essay, Research Paper “Fighting on Two Fronts”: Henry Fleming in Red Badge of Courage The Civil War forced many young boys out of childhood and into adulthood. Most of these young boys were not prepared for war, and Henry Fleming was one of these boys.
Buddha And Buddhism Essay Research Paper Meeting
Buddha And Buddhism Essay, Research Paper Meeting Islam’s Challenge: The 5 Pillars of Islam Background The Quran is the book of guidance as revealed to the prophet Muhammad. It is the main source of
Henry David Thorea Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry David Thorea Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau conducted an experiment, living simple, and peaceful in a small cabin that he built himself. The observations about nature, the importance of the individual, value of a simple life, and more relevant today, as environment abuses multiply, the pressure to consume increases, and the pace o life continues to speed up.
Henry Ford Essay Research Paper Option 1
Henry Ford Essay, Research Paper Option 1 The naming of the school is an important decision. Think about an important person for whom a new school should be named write to
Henry Ford Essay Research Paper Transportation has
Henry Ford Essay, Research Paper Transportation has become a major necessity in today’s society. Without the industrial revolution introducing the automobile, most people would find it very hard and frustrating to get around. Henry Ford had become a big part of starting this faster and safer “transportation era”.
Claude Monet Essay Research Paper Claude Monet 2
Claude Monet Essay, Research Paper Claude Monet: Grainstack (Sunset) Claude Monet’s Grainstack (Sunset) is the painting I chose from the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. Monet was an impressionist painter in France, and did most of his work at his home at Giverny. Impressionism got is name from a painting that Monet painted, Impression Sunrise.
Henry Foyal Essay Research Paper Henry Fayol
Henry Foyal Essay, Research Paper Henry Fayol’s Principal of management Fayol was a key figure in the turn-of-the-century Classical School of management theory. He saw a manager’s job as:
Pro Tips Of Hunting Essay Research Paper
Pro Tips The first hour of dawn and the last hour of dusk are magical and highly productive deer hunting times. The whitetail deer prefers the low-light periods surrounding sunrise and
Expository Essay On A Farewell To Arms
Essay, Research Paper Ernest Hemmingway’s A Farewell to Arms, the protagonist, Frederic Henry is both dysfunctional and tragic. Throughout the story Henry lives up to this
The Courtship Of Miles Standish By Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow (1807-1882) Essay, Research Paper Henry Wadsworth Longfellow was brought up as a New England aristocrat steeped in European culture. His works,
The Life Of Sir Thomas More Essay
, Research Paper The Life of Sir Thomas More Thomas More was born on February 7, 1478. His life is chronicled in historic writing. He was well schooled and very self-disciplined. His accomplishments throughout his life were, and still are, amazing. More was liked and respected by many.
Book Review A Farewell To Arms Essay
, Research Paper A Farewell to Arms is about Frederick Henry, an American second lieutenant in the Italian army who falls in love with an English volunteer nurse named Catherine Barkley during the first World War. After Henry is wounded, he is sent the hospital where Catherine is stationed. This where their love affair begins.
Luke Essay Research Paper Baldwins s Vow
Luke Essay, Research Paper Baldwins s Vow Luke Baldwin’s Vow is a story written by Morley Callaghan. It is a story about the vow Luke makes. In this essay I will tell you about the good and bad things that Luke goes through.
Civil Disobeiance Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Disobeiance Essay, Research Paper Civil Disobedience Civil disobedience is the refusal to obey civil laws. This refusal is in the form of nonviolence. People who use civil disobedience are usually protesting a
Impression Sunrise Essay Research Paper Impression SunriseTowards
Impression, Sunrise Essay, Research Paper Impression, Sunrise Towards the later half of the nineteenth century, many artists were pursuing new avenues in their artistic representations. They were perturbed at the rigid and constricting regulations of the Salon, and some artists decided to form and independent exhibition.
Characterization Of Uncle Henry Essay Research Paper
Characterization of Uncle Henry This characterization of Uncle Henry focuses on the two main ways that he is portrayed in “Luke Baldwin’s Vow.” These two ways are: what Morley Callaghan, the author, reveals through the narrator and what other characters say about Henry. In this short story, Henry is usual referred to as Uncle Henry because he is Luke’s uncle.
Patrick Henry Essay Research Paper
“If this be treason make the worst of it!” These were the words I spoke in my speech against the Stamp Act of 1765. As explained to me by my father and mother, John and Sarah Winston, I, Patrick Henry was born May
Patrick Henry Fight Against The Constitution Essay
, Research Paper Although Henry refused to serve on the Constitutional Convention, Madison needed Henry’s persuasive ways. Henry had a way to make people agree with his ideas. Even though Henry didn’t serve on the Constitutional Convention, he was still present to put in his word. As soon as the meetings opened, Henry began to argue against the Constitution.