Paper
Hunting and Gathering VS Agriculture
From the early prehistoric society until now, we often heard the word “adaptation”, which means the process of changing something or changing our behavior to deal with new situations. The ways people adjust their natural environment varies according to time, place, and tribe. Foraging is common way of adaptation that people uses for most of human history; however because of the population pressure, some people adopt agriculture to fulfill their need. This essay, will discuss the positive and negative aspects of life in hunting and gathering societies compared to the agricultural societies based on Martin Harris’ article “Murders in Eden” and Jared Diamond’s article “The Worst Mistake in the History of Human Race.”
Hunting and gathering is the longest-lasting lifestyle for most of human history. In addition to their way of life, hunter-gatherers are often regarded as “nasty, brutish, and short” (Diamond 114). Progressivists also suggested our hunter-gatherer ancestors adopt agriculture because of “its efficient way to get more food for less work”(Diamond 114). However, as archaeologists observe in some aspects of their lives, hunter-gatherers societies are not necessarily “nasty, brutish, and short.” Some issues that we need to compare between hunting and gathering and agricultural societies include workloads, nutrition, production, starvation, infanticide, health and disease, and differences in wealth.
From the work loads, it shows that in the barren environment of the Kalahari dessert, the present day Bushmen need only 12 to 19 hours per week to obtaining a diet rich in protein and a high nutritional standard, while their farmer neighbors, the Hadza nomads of Tanzania, need 14 hours per week and get less protein. It also takes more additional hours of food preparation to make it is suitable for consumption. It appears that hunter-gatherers have more leisure time than farmers. On the other hand, an agricultural system absorbs more labor and increased workload per capita.
Based on the output of production, agriculture is perceived as an advance because farmers can produce more food within a smaller area than they could possibly obtain as hunter-gatherers. Harris says that this situation happened since farmers control “the rate of plant reproduction” (Harris 219), which means that immediate adverse consequences could be prevented with the intensification of production. On the other hand, hunter-gatherers, which depend on the availability of natural plants and animals; consequently, can raise their output very little. However, although farmers can produce more food than hunter-gatherers do, the numbers of crops are limited; therefore, when the crops failed, there is risk of starvation.
In order to keep their standard of living, hunter-gatherers have to keep their population low. They use many ways to prevent pregnancy, such as herbal contraceptives, plant and animal poisons, and many mechanical techniques for abortion. Hunter-gatherers are also likely to use infanticide and geronticide, which means the killing of infant and old people. Commonly, the mothers executed infanticide by neglecting their babies. On the contrary, people who adopt agriculture do have this practice; they do not keep their population low, conversely, they need more population to help their relatives to plant and harvest their crops.
This high population density, however, has its downside. People in agricultural societies tend to bear the risk of infection by many diseases. It happened because they have to trade with other crowded societies in order satisfy their needs. In contrast, hunter-gatherers who live in dry land and with low population, have less risk to contaminate disease because epidemics is less likely to occur in a small population.
Agriculture also brings class divisions because farming introduced the concept of land ownership and thereby, there is a division among labor and owner, and on the one hand, it causes the elite become wealthier, but on the other hand, most people become poorer. In hunting and gathering society, which store little food; people have equal social standing.
Both Hunting and gathering as well as agricultural societies have their positive and negative sides. Archeologists; however, tend to think that hunting and gathering is better. I, myself, as a woman, prefer to live in agricultural society, which I think is more civilized, in the sense that they do not have the practice of infanticide and geronticide. Furthermore, I consider this practice of favoring male babies over female, and even killing or abandoning female babies is very cruel and brutal. In fact, people of this modern day society, tend to choose agriculture over hunting and gathering because it is steadier, calmer, and less risky.
Другие работы по теме:
Apathy Towards Hunting Essay Research Paper Apathy
Apathy Towards Hunting Essay, Research Paper Apathy Towards Hunting When I was around eleven years old I wanted to go deer hunting more than anything else I could remember. There was one problem my dad would not let me go with out a hunter’s safety certification. So that year I enrolled in a class and got my certification.
Deer Hunting Essay Research Paper There
Deer Hunting Essay, Research Paper There are many things to do in the fall. One of my favorite things to do is to go deer hunting. To me it is more than just hunting, it is a time to get away and be with
Pastoralism Essay Research Paper Pastoralism is an
Pastoralism Essay, Research Paper Pastoralism is an economy based on herding. Pastoralists maintain herds of animals and use their products to support themselves directly and to exchange with other civilizations. It is especially associated with such terrain as steppes, rolling hills, grasslands, and the like-areas of low rainfall where cultivation is difficult without irrigation, but where grasses are plentiful enough to support herds of animals.1 Pastoralism was originally founded in the old world.
Barn Burning Essay Research Paper To present
Barn Burning Essay, Research Paper To present all of the behaviors of chimpanzees in one paper is virtually impossible. So, I am going to attempt to present only certain major behaviors such as
BioTechnology Essay Research Paper The shortterm future
Bio-Technology Essay, Research Paper The short-term future of biotechnology in production agriculture looks bleak. The unattractive truth is that economics, not science can play a larger role in the future of biotechnology.
Congressman Essay Research Paper The QuailIn Europe
Congressman Essay, Research Paper The Quail In Europe, it refers to several kinds of game birds of the pheasant family. A brood may include from 10 to 18 eggs or more. Bold face markings and tilting crests identify the males from the females. Their feathers usually are slate blue, olive-brown, and black and white.
Early Cultures Essay Research Paper Michael C
Early Cultures Essay, Research Paper Michael C. Morfenski ASB 222 Early Peruvian cultures evolved from the prehistoric hunter and gathering tribes. Around 9000 BC the large, hunted, animals were extinct, so supplementation of their diet was needed, and so started the trend toward domestication of plants and wildlife.
Prehistoric Religions Essay Research Paper Geoff Stock
Prehistoric Religions Essay, Research Paper Geoff Stock When looking at the history of the religions of the prehistoric age there is one event more than any other that changed the face of religion as well as society itself. This particular event was the development of agriculture. Previous to this religion and society were much different than they are now.
Two Types Of Division Of Labour In
Two Different Hunting-gathering Societies. Essay, Research Paper The division of labour in these hunter-gatherer societies is well balanced, and is organised to suit the needs of all of the
The Kung Shoshone And Mbuti Tribes Hunting
And Gathering Societies Essay, Research Paper The Kung, Shoshone, and Mbuti Tribes: Hunting and Gathering Societies As in many societies different groups of people are connected by similar
Latin America Essay Research Paper Early Farmers
Latin America Essay, Research Paper Early Farmers in Central America As the glaciers sheltered at the end of the last Ice Age, (when Asia and North America were connected by a piece of land) the hills and mountains of Mesoamerica, or
Symbolism In Cather And The Rye Essay
, Research Paper Symbols of catcher and The Rye In the book Catcher In The Rye by J.D. Salinger, there are many symbols. A symbol is something that represents something else by association or resemblance.
Greek Geography Essay Research Paper The geography
Greek Geography Essay, Research Paper The geography in Ancient Greece did affect the way the Greeks lived their day-to-day lives. Greek?s geography prevented most kinds of agriculture the opportunity to grow. Also, it forced most of the Greek city-states to develop their own customs and government. Being on the seafront of the Mediterranean Sea gave them many opportunities to make an empire.
Pro Tips Of Hunting Essay Research Paper
Pro Tips The first hour of dawn and the last hour of dusk are magical and highly productive deer hunting times. The whitetail deer prefers the low-light periods surrounding sunrise and
Hunting Is Bad Essay Research Paper A
Hunting Is Bad Essay, Research Paper A hunter walks through the woods, stalking an unsuspecting deer…Bang! The deer is dead. The hunter walks away feeling good about himself, and happy that he got a deer. Some people think this is wrong. They think that you should not kill animals for sport. It is important that hunting does not become extinct.
Agriculture Essay Research Paper AGRICULTURE THE WORLD
Agriculture Essay, Research Paper AGRICULTURE THE WORLD LEADER IN AGRICULTURE IS THE U.S. Since the agricultural transformation began in the United States, the United States only seemed to improve agriculturally. The Western Hemisphere was the first to progress towards this transformation, displaying the United States as a leader in agriculture.
Ideologies In Transition Essay Research Paper One
Ideologies In Transition Essay, Research Paper One would have to agree with the statement that the changes in ideology in the transition from Band to Chiefdom are a reflection of the changes in the infrastructure of the society. Using the course kit titled A Comparative and Evolutionary Approach by Peter Landstreet along with various notes from lectures and tutorials.
Young Hunting Essay Research Paper I finally
Young Hunting Essay, Research Paper ?I finally shot my first bird!? I said after I got the bird in my hands. I was very excited. I hunted almost all my life and finally shot something. I hunted and still hunt because I enjoy going out in nature, to relax, and learn new skills like finding the trace of an animal. Going out hunting is exciting because it is one of my favorite hobbies.
Women And The Agricultural Revolution Essay Research
Paper Analytical Summary: Women and the Agricultural Revolution Elise Boulding in her article, Women and the Agricultural Revolution, argues that women played a key role in initiating the Agricultural Revolution. She defines the
Wolf Spiders Essay Research Paper Wolf spiders
Wolf Spiders Essay, Research Paper Wolf spiders are a group of ground-dwelling hunting spiders. There are more than 2000 types of wolf spiders. They range from 2mm to 40mm. Some wolf spiders can even walk on the water of a pond. They can walk or run while chasing after it?s prey. They use their front legs to catch their prey, and then they bite and crush the prey with their powerful jaws.
Changes From The Paleolithic To The Neolithic
Age Essay, Research Paper There were changes that occurred from the Paleolithic Period to the Neolithic. Small changes were made in this time, from the culture, to bigger changes like economics, and agriculture. How did man deal with these changes and what kind of impact did it have on society?
Heracleitus Fragment 72 Essay Research Paper It
Heracleitus Fragment 72 Essay, Research Paper It is difficult for one to understand the direction of Heracleitus? fragments without looking at the fragments together as a whole. Thus, in drawing upon his fragment numbered 72, which states, ?The gathering (Logos): though men associate with it most closely, yet they are separated from it, and those things which they encounter daily seem to them strange,? one must refer to several other fragments before its meaning can be clear.
California Indians Essay Research Paper More languages
California Indians Essay, Research Paper More languages were spoken in the California area than in any other area In North America. The languages they spoke were mainly of Aztec-Tanoan, Hodan, Macra-Algonguian, Penutian and Na-Dene language groups.
Homo Erectus Essay Research Paper About one
Homo Erectus Essay, Research Paper About one million years ago, Homo erectus populations began migrating out of East Africa. They soon spread into South and West Africa, Asia and Europe. This adaptive radiation was the result of several biological and cultural factors.
Early Civilizations Essay Research Paper Native American
Early Civilizations Essay, Research Paper Native American civilizations thrived in the Western Hemisphere before Europeans discovered the New World. These civilizations had many similarities and contributed much to the development of the Latin American culture today. Each civilization was a part from each other, however they had accomplished almost the something and had ideas that were alike but they were so far apart its a astounding of what they came up with.
The Roots Of Dependency Essay Research Paper
Reemy Reem Anth. 307 The Roots of Dependency 1. The Navajos, Pawnees, and Choctaws all had to endure European, political, economical, and environmental threats to their own culture. When the life and subsistence system (hunting and gathering) of an Indian Nation is affected; in one way or another it has an affect on an Indian population as a hole.
The Evils Of Hunting Essay Research Paper
The Evils of Hunting Hunting is an unnecessary activity in the modern world. Slob hunting is the way many so-called sportsmen hunt these days. The phrase slob hunting refers
Hunting Essay Research Paper HuntingHunting is good
Hunting Essay, Research Paper Hunting Hunting is good in many ways. Hunting helps to stabilize deer so they don?t get on our property and eat our shrubs. It also brings families together on a Saturday or Sunday with a father and son or even just with friends. Some people even like it as a hobby for relaxation or fun.
Should Foxhunting Be Banned In Britain Essay
, Research Paper I would like to start this essay by stating that I am against the motion, and that I see no reason what so ever why fox hunting should be banned in this country.
Australlia
– Culture – Aborigines Essay, Research Paper Australlia – Culture – AborCopyright (c) 1996-1997 — School Sucks — schoolsucks The biggest FREE School papers database on the Net!
Canoecopia Exibition Essay Research Paper Once a
Canoecopia Exibition Essay, Research Paper Once a year, as winter begins to fade and the spring flowers begin to blossom, there is a gathering of a diverse group of outdoor enthusiasts. The one aspect that unites this band of individuals is their shared love for the sport of paddling. This gathering takes place in the 100,000 square foot exhibition hall of the Alliant Energy Center in Madison, Wisconsin near the beginning of March.