The Cogito Ergo Sum is the heart of Cartesian philosophy and represents the starting point of his method. It set Descartes apart from the Scholastics who began with real things in a really existing world. He was obviously influenced by the Protestant Reformation and its challenge of authority, tradition and medieval Aristotelianism. Opposing himself to this tradition, Descartes began simply within the certitude of self as a thinking being. Like the pre-Socratics, Descartes was searching for the first principle. This self-evident principle for him was the cogito ergo sum. If I doubt the existence of things, then I think, and if I think, I am! This principle inaugurates “the great anthropocentric shift in philosophy” (John Paul II, pg. 51) and links us to the first rule of his method.
The cogito had its beginning in small, hot German apartment where Descartes began to reflect upon his own knowledge and its sources. He began by imagining the most perfect building, of which he feels “called” to be the architect of, and which cannot be constructed using the “old walls” (i.e. wisdom of the ages) of the past, but must begin with an entirely new foundation and a sigle founder. Therefore, the founding principle of his new method is to “overturn and scatter to the four winds all that men had tried to build up through past ages, and must make a clean sweep of all thinking that has been possible up to his time” (Maritain, pg 23).
The first rule of Descartes’ method then is to accept nothing as true which he didn’t clearly recognize to be so. He would only accept that which is clearly and distinctly in his mind and the only thing which initially meets this mathematically certainty is self-existence. Man is reduced to a thinking thing. We cannot even say that we are a thinking being in a body, since our senses may be deceiving us into thinking we are embodied.
Though he claims to begin with an emptying of all pre-conceived notions, his method is full of pre-suppositions. For example, he assumed that the principle of mathematical certainty could step outside its boundaries and be applied to all things as if they were all mathematical and quantifiable. He reversed the traditional order of acquiring human knowledge. In reality, the mind begins with sense data from real objects and then proceeds to concepts. In Descartes’ dream world, the mind begins with clear and distinct notions which will give it a true knowledge of all objects. Rather than physics advancing to metaphysics, Descartes buries metaphysics below ground and focuses his attention on the trunk of the tree (physics) which will, in his dream, branch out into the sciences and give us the fruit of medicine, mechanics and ethics (Gilson, pg. 59).
When I first read Descartes I was lured in by his apparent humility of speech. It reminded me of Socrates self-depracating dialogue. His early thirst for knowledge was fascinating and his survey of the academic disciplines was almost poetic. His intention to discover truth by emptying his mind and re-examining each piece of knowledge is noble, but it is hard not to believe his self-emptying included the loss of common sense and the real world, which he can never get back again. There is no fault in testing their veracity of each truth offered to us in our education. But Descartes fails to make an important distinction which John Henry Cardinal Newman makes in his Development of Doctrine. It is there that he distinguishes between questioning a truth and investigating it. We may withhold our assent from a proposed truth while we try and discover whether it is true or not. We can also investigate a doctrine when we assent to it but keep trying to understand it better. In either case it is not required that we cast doubt upon it immediately and seek to prove its veracity by unnaturally subjecting it to the principles of mathematical certainty. That is one of the fundamental flaws in Descartes methodology.
To begin with a wholesale rejection of all previous knowledge is as foolish as trying to separate oneself from his genetic history. Man cannot stand long in the winds that blow when separated from the wisdom of the ages, in fact he will soon stoop to the frame of an ape, returning to his basest passions and turn hopelessly in on himself. This is precisely why John Paul II insists “on the need for a close relationship of continuity between contemporary philosophy and the philosophy developed in the Christian tradition [which] is intended to avert the danger which lies hidden in some currents of thought which are especially prevalent today” (Fides et Ratio, para. 86).
This false autonomy Descartes offers philosophy ends in the unraveling of any certitude about anything. That is why Fides et Ratio correctly labels it as “primal disobedience” which transports us back to that terrestrial paradise where man first decided he alone would discern and decide what was good and evil (true and false). Our first parents failed, how much more futile an enterprise for us with “wounded reason”. This exposes the underlying pride in his feigned humility.
Though touted to be a new method for the emerging science of his day, no serious scientist of the 21st century could operate according to these principles. It would be impossible to conduct research unless scientists first assent to the fundamental laws of their discipline.
There is nothing dangerous about a philosophy that includes a focus on the subject. The great command of the pre-Christian Oracle at Delphi, know thyself is a valid pursuit. Descartes failed in that he focused upon man in a way that overlooks or denies the fact that there are truths that transcends us – which we cannot fully perceive by reason alone. Experimental data and technological knowledge on their own, cannot lift us to full truth and the purpose of our very existence.
Beginning with the cogito ergo sum, Descartes developed a new science “that promised everything and denied everything?and which has made so many men, led astray by it from the eternal verities, into sorrowful beings” (Maritain, pg. 29).
535
Ariew, Roger and Eric Watkins, eds. 1998. Modern Philosophy: An Anthology of
Primary Sources (Indianapolis: Hacket Publishing Co.).
Gilson, Etienne and Thomas Langan, Modern Philosophy: Descartes to Kant (NewYork: Image, 1963).
John Paul II. Crossing the Threshold of Hope. ed. by Vittorio Messori (New York:
AlfredA. Knopf, 1994).
Maritain, Jacques. The Dream of Descartes. tr. by Mabelle L. Andison (London: EditionsPoetry, 1946).
Другие работы по теме:
Reasons For Undertaking A Project On Land
Essay, Research Paper The reason that I decided to undertake this particular project was that I live on a farm and with doing so I had a rather broad spectrum of things I could do on the land, but nothing else interested me as
September 11 Essay Research Paper During the
September 11 Essay, Research Paper During the summer of tenth grade, I took a number theory course at Johns Hopkins University with students from Alaska, California, and Bogota, Colombia. My attendance of the New Jersey Governor’s School in the Sciences is another accomplishment that exemplifies my dedication to knowledge.
Should I Vote Essay Research Paper TTH
Should I Vote Essay, Research Paper T-TH 9:15-10:30 Does it Matter if I Vote? The 2000 presidential election is soon approaching, but should I really care? When the time comes to cast the ballot, most people either feel obligated or apathetic. As in any case, there are many sides to this argument; some reasons that I should vote include civic duty and sustaining the democracy for which our “founding fathers” fought.
Nutrition Essay Research Paper Nutrition and Diet
Nutrition Essay, Research Paper Nutrition and Diet Project My average calorie intake per day was 1531.8. My caloric need per day was 3326. My intake is supposed to be way more than what it is. This is really surprising to me. The average percentage of carbohydrates, fat and protein is in the chart below. DAY FAT CARBS PROTEIN SUGAR1 20% 34% 20% 25%2 10% 73% 17% 0%3 21% 47% 13% 19%4 18% 52% 15% 16%5 20% 48% 17% 15% These numbers are around what I should have.
War On Poverty Project South Essay Research
Paper War On Poverty: Project South Another project that is trying to make lead way in the poverty war. Is the Project South(PS) is a program that is felt strongly felt though out the
Spike Lee Essay Research Paper The project
Spike Lee Essay, Research Paper The project that we did was on Spike Lee. This topic was a very interesting one. When we first started I didn’t realize just how much work there was to do but luckily we started early enough t get every thing done. Me and my partner Lindsay Clarke found the PowerPoint part to be the most interesting.
River Project Essay Research Paper Since the
River Project Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of the Americas the rivers have been a very important source of transportation. If not for the river the shipment of goods would have taken a very long time and would have been almost impossible through the dense forests of the New World. The Mississippi in time has been used for transportation.
Reflective Paper Essay Research Paper Reflective PaperI
Reflective Paper Essay, Research Paper Reflective Paper I think that as a group our project turned out great. We made the time limit our script was good. I liked this project, I had fun making it and so did the rest of the guys in my group. I think that the class liked our movie and I know we all had fun making it.
War Of 1812 Essay Research Paper Our
War Of 1812 Essay, Research Paper Our government has gone through many changes. Our founding fathers had different ideas of how or government should be. Alexander Hamilton wanted a strong centralized government while Thomas Jefferson wanted a Democratic form of government. Today the government is a blend of both ideas.
Religion Essay Research Paper Religion912
Religion Essay, Research Paper Religion912 There are many different cultures and religions in this world. I was assigned to attend a different denomination church then my own. I attended St.Nick s liturgy. St.Nick s is a Greek Orthodox Church.
Weather Modification Essay Research Paper Weather ModificationHistoryWeather
Weather Modification Essay, Research Paper Weather Modification History Weather Modification was founding 1946 by Vincent Schaefer who was attempting to find a way to induce artificial clouds to produce precipitation in a cold cloud chamber ( modified freezer). The experiment done with a block of dry ice in the freezer was a success when his colleague Bernard Vonnegut found a chemical, silver iodide, that is almost like ice in its molecular structure, but can be carried and applied more easily.
Beowulf Values Essay Research Paper Some Things
Beowulf Values Essay, Research Paper Some Things Change But Most Remain the Same Masculine values have both changed and remained constant since the writing of Beowulf. The values that Beowulf and
Ag Research Project Essay Research Paper RESEARCH
Ag Research Project Essay, Research Paper RESEARCH PROJECT RESEARCH QUESTION: How does the level of acid in a soil effect plant growth and yield? METHOD: First potting mix was put into twelve equally sized pots. The pots will be divided into three groups of four pots. Three of the four groups was treated with solutions of water and hydrochloric acids, these solutions were of varying degrees of acidity.
Slavery And The Founding Fathers Essay Research
Paper When the issue of slavery and the Founding Father’s arise, it is clear that despite some of their noble actions, the Founding Fathers were indeed hypocritical to true American ideals in both action and in thought. Among the Founding Fathers, Thomas Jefferson’s disposition on slavery was ambiguous as he contradicted himself many times on an issue that affected America for hundreds of years.
Diabetes Mellentus Essay Research Paper Project ProposalMy
Diabetes Mellentus Essay, Research Paper Project Proposal My Independent Project is on Diabetes Mellitus, type1 Diabetes, or juvenile-onset diabetes. No matter what you call it, its all the same. Your pancreas has died and you have no other way to survive other than to inject insulin multiple times a day.
Bureaucracy Essay Research Paper Bureaucracy has many
Bureaucracy Essay, Research Paper Bureaucracy has many components and characteristics to it that both help and hurt it. The most obvious characteristic is the size of bureaucracy. The size of this organization both helps and hurts in the effectiveness of government.
Whitman Essay Research Paper In my opinion
Whitman Essay, Research Paper In my opinion the poet which best exemplifies modernism is Walt Whitman. Walt Whitman?s stylistic preference is not exactly mine, but it is definitely a good example of ?modern poetry.? He has broken down many walls of traditional poetry, using the style of long, free verse prose.
Op Essay Research Paper Article Critique
Op Essay, Research Paper Article Critique ? New Hotel Project The article talks about the possibilities of making ?One card, For Many Doors?. They are trying to make a room key with an internal credit card. Using a new system guests will be able to check in and issue a room key (double encoded) using their own credit card.
Modern Atom Model Essay Research Paper The
Modern Atom Model Essay, Research Paper The evolution of the modern atom model took several years to evolved with contribution from different scientists. One of these scientists, the first to come up with a modern model of the atom is JJ Thomson. Thomson proposes that the structure of an atom is mainly a sphere.
Personal Essay The Yemin Order Project Essay
, Research Paper Personal Essay: The Yemin Order Project I am extremely happy at school which has helped and encouraged me to develop all my skills both educational and social. I was also part of the Yemin Orde project
St Augustine Essay Research Paper Augustine of
St. Augustine Essay, Research Paper Augustine of Hippo (354-430 AD) took great pains to create and project a powerful image of himself beyond the churches and towns where he wrote and taught in Roman
Government Essay Research Paper 2 We know
Government Essay, Research Paper 2. We know that the fundamental difference between ancient political science and modern political science has to do with the relationship of the individual to the state. For Aristotle, a person was an inherently political animal. For modern political philosophers (social contract theorists), individual rights existed prior to the formation of government.
In The Life Of A Modern Man
Born In The Renaissance Essay, Research Paper Have you ever pondered the birth of your hobbies? Or have you ever wondered who invented the mechanisms you use in your everyday life? Well, modern art, today’s religion, and the present printing press had to originate some point in time. And what could be a better time then during the Renaissance and the Reformation? These three points were a major part of those years.
Blah Essay Research Paper For my senior
Blah Essay, Research Paper For my senior thesis, I will be conducting further research on my project, and the idea from which my project came. This research will include different experimental approaches and setups, the outcomes of these new schematics, and the way in which the project was originally approached.
Buddhist Economics Essay Research Paper Buddhist EconomicsMost
Buddhist Economics Essay, Research Paper Buddhist Economics Most people think that religion and economics don?t mix. So you would think the same in the case with Buddhism and economics. But actually the there is a set of rules that go along with our modern day economics that have their own meanings. Buddhists believe that spiritual health and well being go hand in hand.
Evolution Of Modern Atom Essay Research Paper
The evolution of the modern atom model took several years to evolved with contribution from different scientists. One of these scientists, the first to come up with a modern model of the atom is JJ Thomson. Thomson proposes that the structure of an atom is mainly a sphere. A sphere that is filled with positive electronic field and contains tiny particles that has a negative charge.
Java Project Essay Research Paper Jennifer
Java Project Essay, Research Paper // Jennifer Farley // Java Term Project import java.awt.*; import java.applet.*; public class scroll extends java.applet.Applet implements Runnable {
Community Service Essay Research Paper My community
Community Service Essay, Research Paper My community service project My project consisted of helping out my school’s music department during my time off. My original intent was to learn and appreciate what our music department does for our community and school. Instead I learned much more. I learned how dedicated and how much hours they put I to helping out and representing our school in community activities.
MS Power Point Essay Research Paper Reflection
MS Power Point Essay, Research Paper Reflection on MS Power Point The Microsoft Power Point presentation that we just completed was a fun project. I learned how to set up Power Point slides while infiltrating animation and sound.