The Passsionate Shepherd Essay, Research Paper
Contrasting Conditions of the Heart
People cannot exist within the context of society, without encountering the contrasting polarities of the human heart. The theme in Christopher Marlowe’s poem “The Passionate Shepard to His Love” (circa 1600 A.D.), and the theme in Sir Walter Raleigh’s poem “The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepard” (circa 1552? -1618 A.D.), portray the contrasting themes of love and hate.
Christopher Marlowe’s poem “The Passionate Shepard to His Love” is a poem that manifest hope, love and eternal optimism. Marlowe’s character is the archetype of goodness and strength. Marlowe chose a shepherd for his character, because a shepherd represents; goodness, strength, and independence. The character recalls the biblical significance denominated to a shepherd that of a leader, a provider of sorts. To date some denominations of Christian religions still call their congregations “flocks” and their leader a “Pastor.”
The first stanza of Marlowe’s poem is about a proposal that offers a future and offers the most beautiful condition of human existence . . . love “Come live with me and be my love” (1). With this line the shepherd is making clear his intentions of marriage. The author chose the word “come” because of the conviction it conveys. He is not saying “would” or “could.” No doubt is placed as to the shepherd’s love. The shepherds love also is also boundless: “That valleys, groves, hills and fields/ Woods, or steepy mountain yields” (3-4).
Love is again offered in the form of symbolic gifts. Some gifts symbolize the shepherd’s inner beauty: “And I will make thee beds of roses/With a thousand fragrant poises” (9-10). These gifts are not material; they are labours of love meant to symbolize the beauty he is offering. Other gifts introduce a sense of materialism:
A gown made of the finest wool
Which from our pretty lambs we pull;
Fair lined slippers for the cold,
With buckles of the purest gold. (13-16)
The gown and the slippers are gifts designed to protect and provide warmth. However, the mention of fine wool and buckles of gold are designed to introduce the character’s ability to provide worldly wants. The final gifts offered are intended to appeal to the lover’s sense of materialism: “A belt of straw and ivy buds/With coral clasps and amber studs” (17-18). All of the senses of the lover are being appealed to, the shepherd is fulfilling his promise “And we will all the pleasures prove” (2).
Stanza number six concerns itself with the future “For thy delight each May morning” (22). The mention of each May morning is intended to let the shepherd’s love know that he is looking past the immediate and into the future. The future is also painted as an optimistic and cheerful future”The shepherds’ swains shall dance and sing” (21).
Overall “The Passionate Shepherd to His Love” is a poem that introduces a persona of goodness, offerings of gifts, and a future filled with love. In contrast Sir Walter Raleigh’s poem “The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd,” portrays the darkest of the conditions of the human heart . . . hate.
Sir Walter Raleigh’s character in “The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd,” is portrayed as a pessimistic, experienced persona who rejects love and all that the shepherd has to offer “If all the world and love were young/And truth in every shepherd’s tongue” (1-2). These two lines reveal the Nymph’s unrealistic and experienced outlook at life. Expecting all the world and love to remain young is not reasonable. The reference to truth in every shepherd’s tongue reveals that negative experiences have tainted the nymph’s soul.
There is hate in all of the Nymph’s replies, it is especially prevalent as the nymph refuses everything that the shepherd is offering, including his gifts “Soon break, soon whither, soon forgotten” (15). This line is intended to let the shepherd know that beautiful things can fulfill her. Further rejection comes in the fifth stanza “All these in me no means can move” (19). Nothing that the shepherd can do will appeal to her.
The nymph’s view of the future is also negative “The rest complains of care to come” (8). For every offer of the possibility of a future, the nymph has a hopeless reply “Is fancy’s spring, but sorrow’s fall” (12). The sixth stanza deals with the final rejection and demonstrates the impossibility for a future “But could youth last, and love still breed/Had joys no date, nor age no need” (21-22). Youth can not last forever, nor does joy have no date, nor age no need.
Marlowe’s poem and Sir Walter Raleigh’s poem depict two of the most powerful and contrasting emotions a human can feel. Marlowe’s poem is one of hope beauty and most important, endless love. By contrast Raleigh’s poem is jaded by tainted experiences, feelings of despair, and hate. In life let us pray that the people we meet will be more like the Shepherd and that we never meet a persona like the Nymph.
Другие работы по теме:
Psalm 23 Essay Research Paper The Good
Psalm 23 Essay, Research Paper The Good Shepherd: Psalm 23 Psalm 23 is probably the most familiar passage there is in the word of God. No portion in writing of any time or of any work has been so widely circulated. Much has been written about this psalm, although its six verses are short and simple. I appears that the author, David, wrote this when he was an adult.
Oedipus Essay Research Paper Oedipus the King
Oedipus Essay, Research Paper Oedipus the King Sophocles (c. 427 B.C.) Summary The play opens in front of the palace of Oedipus at Thebes. Oedipus asks a priest and his supplicants what they are wanting. The priest thanks him for saving them from the Sphinx, but tells him that the city needs saving again from a plague that has descended.
Contrasting Friendship Essay Research Paper Contrasting Friendship
Contrasting Friendship Essay, Research Paper Contrasting Friendship “The two ladies, who had been intimate since childhood, reflected how little they knew each other” (256). This is how, author, Edith Wharton shows the relationship of two characters, Mrs. Ansley and Mrs. Slade, in the short story “Roman Fever.” These two women who are supposed to be friends, led envious lives of each other, and because of the way they lived they were very contrasting and conflicting characters.
Compare And Contrast The Thrill Of The
Grass And The Balek Scales Essay, Research Paper Jan. 29 1999 Pettit 3rd period The two stories I am comparing and contrasting are, “The Thrill of the Grass” and “The Balek Scales.” The reason I chose these two stories is because out of all the stories that we have read this year these two were my favorites. In this paper I am going to be contrasting more than comparing because these stories have little in common.
Selfhelp Groups Essay Research Paper Selfhelp groups
Self-help Groups Essay, Research Paper ?Self-help groups consist of individuals who share the same problem or concern. Members provide emotional support to one another, learn ways to cope, discover strategies for improving their condition, and help others while helping themselves (Wituk, Shepherd, Slavich, Warren, & Meissen, 2000).?
12 Angry Men Essay Research Paper A
12 Angry Men Essay, Research Paper A persons surroundings can influence him. In “12 Angry Men” by Reginald Rose a young mans life is held by twelve men with contrasting views.
Mom Vs Dad Essay Research Paper Mom
Mom V.s. Dad Essay, Research Paper Mom vs. Dad In my family, trying to find two contrasting relatives is like trying to find a needle, in a stack of needles. Of course after a little thought, the two most obvious and contrasting family members turned out to be my parents. Although many differences exist between my mom and dad, three major ones include the way they act, the way the think, and the way they parent.
Oedipus Essay Essay Research Paper According to
Oedipus Essay Essay, Research Paper According to the Aristotelian characteristics of good tragedy, the tragic character should not fall due to either excessive virtue or excessive wickedness, but due to what Aristotle called hamartia. Hamartia may be interpreted as either a flaw in character or an error in judgement.
The Great Gatsby Essay Research Paper Nick
The Great Gatsby Essay, Research Paper Nick Carroway and Jay Gatsby are like an orange and an apple; either being what you want. Oranges and apples have similarities; such as, being a fruit, but have contrasting attributes, like apples are non-citric and oranges are full of citric that s why they never go brown.
Madame Bovary Essay Research Paper In Gustave
Madame Bovary Essay, Research Paper In Gustave Flaubert?s Madame Bovary, the characters Leon Dupuis and Rodolphe Boulanger share similar attributes as well as contrasting ones. The similarity and contrasting characteristics of their personalities are illustrated through their actions, words, as well as by the remarks made by the other characters in the novel concerning them.
Walden By Thoreau And Nature By Emerson
Essay, Research Paper Transcendentalism is used frequently as main topics in the stories ?Nature? and Walden. These two themes are heavily concentrated on though these two
Three Text Study Essay Research Paper Interpretive
Three Text Study Essay, Research Paper Interpretive Study The three texts I have read all have many similar and contrasting issues and characters. The texts 1984, Forest Gump, and To Kill A Mocking Bird are three very entertaining books well worth reading, while the texts all seem very diverse on the exterior they seem to be very similar on the interior.
English 101 Essay Research Paper In comparing
English 101 Essay, Research Paper In comparing and contrasting the stories ?Worn Path? and ?Young GoodMann Brown?. Several things come to mind . We see that both authors use a lot of symbolism
AmosThe Prophet Of The North Essay Research
Paper Amos: The Prophet of the North Around 750 BCE, Amos, a shepherd from Judah, goes north to preach against the sinful kingdom of Israel. Amos was a prophet from the town of Tekoh in Juda. He was unassuming, but bold and fearless when called to bear witness against the evils of his day. Prior to his call to the prophetic office, Amos was a shepherd who devoted a part of his time to tending sycamore trees and gathering their fruit.
Guide Dogs Essay Research Paper My report
Guide Dogs Essay, Research Paper My report is going to be on guide dogs. In this I will show how the guide dogs are used in everyday life. I will show how they are trained to help the blind. I will show you about guide dogs and service dogs. I will also show you the dog breeds used for guide and service dogs. In this I will show you the importance of guide dogs to the disabled.
Comparing Creation Accounts Essay Research Paper The
Comparing Creation Accounts Essay, Research Paper The creation of the earth and all that is within the earth is mysterious yet miraculous at the same time. Although there are probably hundreds of different accounts, they all seem to be different while almost identical in text. I will be comparing and contrasting between account one and account two in the book of Genesis.
Trans Essay Research Paper The Minister
Trans Essay, Research Paper The Minister’s Black Veil By Nathaniel Hawthorne Anti-Transcendentalists believed that everything has a good or evil side, and that the truths about these matters would be terrifying and
Marlowe And Raleigh Essay Research Paper LoveThe
Marlowe And Raleigh Essay, Research Paper Love The two poems written by Raleigh and Marlowe are interesting. Marlowe s poem, The Passionate Shepherd to His Love, basically propositions a woman to sleep with a man, where Raleigh s, The Nymph s Reply to the Shepherd, responds negatively. Marlowe s poem is a Shepherd asking a nymph for favors.
Madame Bovary-Compare And Contrast Between Rodolphe And
Leon Essay, Research Paper In Gustave Flaubert?s Madame Bovary, the characters Leon Dupuis and Rodolphe Boulanger share similar attributes as well as contrasting ones. The similarity and contrasting characteristics of their personalities are illustrated through their actions, words, as well as by the remarks made by the other characters in the novel concerning them.
Sex In Poetry Essay Research Paper Sex
Sex In Poetry Essay, Research Paper Sex in Poetry Although Marvell s To His Coy Mistress and Marlowe s The Passionate Shepherd to His Love share many similarities and differences, both men have one basic purpose for their poems, to talk the women into being their loves using promises of beautiful and mostly unattainable things.
Fate Of Oedipus Essay Research Paper Sophocles
Fate Of Oedipus Essay, Research Paper Sophocles Oedipus Tyrannus is a tragic play that discusses the tragic discovery of Oedipus that he has killed his father and married his mother. In Greek mythology, oracles or gods are rarely wrong in their predictions of the future. Yet Oedipus still tries to fight the predictions.
Teaching Methods Essay Research Paper When comparing
Teaching Methods Essay, Research Paper When comparing and contrasting the hands on method to the lecture method many people prefer the hands on method. This allows the students to further understand what the teachers are trying to teach. By using this method a majority of the students will learn more, and learn at a quicker pace.
Fate Vs Free Will In Oedipus Essay
, Research Paper FREE WILL VS. FATE IN OEDIPUS REX The great philosopher Socrates believes that humans rule themselves with a combination of fate and free will. In Oedipus Rex a combination of fate and free will
A Comparison And Contrast Of Love In
Christopher Marlowe’s Essay, Research Paper A Comparison and Contrast of Love in Christopher Marlowe?s “The Passionate Shepherd to his Love” and C. Day Lewis?s “Song”
Romeo And Juliet By William Shakespeare 1564
– 1616) Essay, Research Paper Perhaps Shakespeare’s most famous play, Romeo and Juliet combines the contrasting elements of humor and sorrow, bawdiness and civil strife, and innocent love and ignorant hate to rouse
The Nymph
’s Reply To The Shepherd Essay, Research Paper ? The Nymph?s Reply to the Shepherd? The poem ?The Nymph?s Reply to the Shepherd?, is a look into the mind of a realistic (or some may even say pessimistic) person. It was written as a response to the more idealistic poem, ? The Passionate Shepherd to His Love?, by Christopher Marlowe. ?The Passionate Shepherd?? is the story of a man trying to convince the lady he loves to spend the rest of her life with him.
Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper Dear Oedipus
Oedipus Rex Essay, Research Paper Dear Oedipus Rex, In so many ways I feel very sorry for you because you?ve had to deal with the guilt of having inadvertently murdered your father and married your mother. You deserve your
Oedipus Essay Research Paper Jocasta doesn
Oedipus Essay, Research Paper Jocasta doesn’t understand her husband’s concern about the details of Laius’ death. When she asks Oedipus why he wants to see the servant, he responds, I can hold nothing back from you, now I’ve reached this pitch of dark foreboding. Oedipus goes on to give the history of his childhood, as referenced in the fourth summary.
Conflicts Essay Research Paper There are many
Conflicts Essay, Research Paper There are many conflicts shown in ?The Bass, The River and Sheila Mant? that are different from ?The Cold Equations? In this English paper I will explain to you three
School Essay Research Paper DAVID One of
School Essay, Research Paper DAVID. One of the greatest heroes of ancient history was David, a poor shepherd boy who killed the giant Goliath. According to the Biblical story of his life, which is told in detail in the Old Testament, David was born about 3,000 years ago.
Passionate Shep To His Love Contractsed With
The Nymph’s Reply Essay, Research Paper Since the dawn of written history people have been compelled to record their notion of love in the form of novels and poems. Most of these writings and poems describe a
Contrasting Apollo
& Dionysus Essay, Research Paper Contrasting Apollo & Dionysus In Greek mythology, Apollo and Dionysus are nearly opposites of one another, and as with many opposites, life would not operate just quite right