Ernest Sosa: Externalism Essay, Research Paper
Ernest Sosa: Externalism
Ross Goldberg
PHIL 4311
Dr. Stonewald
Ernest Sosa likes externalism. He thinks that it is intuitively correct.
But he must and does agree that it must be clarified in order to avoid certain
problems. So, his mission in this paper is to first define what he calls
“Generic Reliabilism,” then to show how it is susceptible to certain objections,
then to present a modified version of it, and to show that this new version is,
in general, better than its predecessor. Let us look at his argument.
First, we get the usual definition of generic reliabilism: S is
justified in his belief that p at t if the belief is produced by some faculty
that usually produces true beliefs. Then, we get a couple of Alvin Goldman’s
notions of justification with Sosa’s revisions. A belief is strongly justified
iff it is well formed, and by means of a truth conducive process. A belief is
weakly justified iff it is “blameless” (not the result of an intentional
mistake?) but ill-formed, and the believer is not aware that the belief is ill-
formed. A belief is superweakly justified iff the process that produces the
belief is unreliable but the subject did not intentionally come to hold the
belief because it was acquired unreliably. And, finally, a belief has strong
meta-justification iff the subject neither believes that nor can determine if
the belief is ill-formed (hence the “meta-” prefix), and the subject is aware of
the process by which he got the belief and that the process is reliable.
OK, seems reasonable enough. But, Sosa points out, there are a couple of
scenarios (actually, three, but Sosa concentrates mainly on the two listed
below) in which these conceptions of justification just do not work. The “new
evil demon” problem takes a couple of forms in the article, but what it amounts
to is that if a person S attains beliefs through something other than his usual
faculties (e.g. senses, reasoning, etc.) like evil demons or random neurological
stimulators, or whatever, then that person’s beliefs are not attained through a
reliable process (we are assuming that demons are, as usual, not benevolent
bearers of truth). But, we do not want to say, or at least Sosa doesn’t, that
the deceived believer is completely unjustified in his beliefs; so, what level
of justification do we assign to his situation? If, by some amazing coincidence,
the random processes or demons generate a consistent and coherent set of beliefs,
then we can say that the subject is weakly and meta- justified. But, t hat
situation is not very likely, and thus we need the notion of superweak
justification. At this point, the analysis and comparison between normal people
and deceived people stops at superweak justification. Sosa thinks we need more.
Now, Sosa introduces his proposal for a criterion for justification -
virtue (clever word choice, eh?). Notation: E = environment; C = conditions; F =
field of propositions; S = subject; P = specific proposition in question; and X =
arbitrary proposition. Then, S believes P at time t out of intellectual virtue
only if there exists F and C such that: a) P is in F; b) S is in C with respect
to P; and c) S would usually be right in believing an X in F while in C with
respect to X. Whew. One attractive feature of this theory in contrast with
Goldman’s historical reliabilism is that the faculty through which we believe in
our existence (cogito) is immediate, and by Sosa’s definition of virtue, it is,
well, “virtuous” and infallible I guess, and in the historical conception, would
rely on memory, which is fallible. This is a good thing.
Note that since the virtue is a function of E, C, P, and X, there are
several places from which an error could originate. But, all things considered,
Sosa arrives at the conclusion that the amount of virtue sufficient to
internally justify a belief is attained by the following: relative to E, S holds
P, P is in F, S in C with respect to P, and S would not be in C with respect to
an X in F in E without S being likely to believe correctly with regard to P.
Having so defined virtue and its relation to justification, we can see that the
focus has been shifted from a generic reliable mechanism of belief acquisition
to the mechanism of intellectual virtue.
How, then, does this solve our evil demon problem? Sosa says that
relative to our actual environment, our belief acquiring mechanisms (senses,
etc.) are virtuous enough to justify our beliefs. But, in a demonic environment,
our senses are deceived and so forth, so we are not justified. But, a person,
even in a demonic environment, is still justified in his beliefs relative to the
actual environment, assuming that he has sound cognitive traits. For, although
Sosa’s view allows us to say whether or not someone is justified in belief
relative to an environment even if that person is not in that environment. We
have examined the demon problem and ignored the meta-incoherence problem, but
they are formulated and solved in analogous ways.
Другие работы по теме:
The Importance Of Being Earnest Essay Research
Paper While some critics contend that The Importance of Being Earnest is completely fanciful and has no relation to the real world, others maintain that Oscar Wilde?s “trivial comedy for serious people” does make significant comments about social class and the institution of marriage. These observations include the prevalent utilization of deceit in everyday affairs.
Communism Vs Democracy Essay Research Paper
“The Old Man and The Sea” Essay Ernest Hemingway, in The Old Man and The Sea, wrote a book about a man with little wealth and little friends, but this man has a very high goal, which he wants to accomplish even if it means he might die in the process. In this story Ernest Hemingway describes struggles between life and death.
Rutherford Essay Research Paper Ernest Rutherford 18711937Ernest
Rutherford Essay, Research Paper Ernest Rutherford (1871-1937) Ernest Rutherford was born in Nelson, New Zealand. Rutherford demonstrated his abilities as a scientist early on while working on his B.Sc. at the University of New Zealand in 1894. He showed that the magnetization can be removed from a magnetized iron needle by dissolving the surface layer of the metal in acid.
Hemingway And Theme Essay Research Paper Ernest
Hemingway And Theme Essay, Research Paper Ernest Hemingway uses many themes and subtle nuances, to bring his short stories alive, with imagination and adventure. These short stories all revolve around certain things that are present in each of his stories. In Another Country, The Big Two Hearted River, and Indian Camp, all contain similarities, which are sometimes very evident, and very subtle.
A Farewell To Arms Finial Thinking Essay
, Research Paper A Farewell to Arms by Ernest Hemingway is a thought provoking anti-war novel. Hemingway?s powerful descriptions and direct realism almost moved me to tears by the end. He is an effective writer, and I thoroughly enjoyed reading his work.
Night And A Farewell To Arms Eliezer
And Frederic Essay, Research Paper In Night and A Farewell to Arms, the reader follows the characters of Elie Wiesel and Ernest Hemingway through their personal struggles between love and war. In Night, Eliezer faces malnutrition,
Perseverance Essay Research Paper PerseverancePeople wonder what
Perseverance Essay, Research Paper Perseverance People wonder what perseverance is? According to The America Heritage Dictionary perseverance means: To persist in or remain constant to a purpose, idea, or task in spite of obstacles. In the book, The Old Man and the Sea, by Ernest Hemingway, the main character Santiago shows many ways of perseverance.
Indian Camp Essay Research Paper Ernest Hemingway
Indian Camp Essay, Research Paper Ernest Hemingway’s “Indian Camp” is a story in which a man looks back upon a very influential event in his childhood. The story tells of a young boy named Nick, who watches as his father aids in the birth of a young Indian child. The circumstances that arrive during this event shape the “older Nick’s” perception of his father, as well as life and mortality.
Hemmingway 2 Essay Research Paper The themes
Hemmingway 2 Essay, Research Paper The themes of alienation and isolation go hand in hand with the role nature plays in Ernest Hemmingway s short story The Big Two-Hearted River. Nick Adams, whose life and personality parallels that of Hemmingway, constantly retreats to nature to find a quiet place of reflection and self-examination.
ERNEST MILLER HEMINGWAY Essay Research Paper Ernest
ERNEST MILLER HEMINGWAY Essay, Research Paper Ernest Hemingway was one of America?s favorite authors his writings touched the lives of those who read his books everywhere. He put a lot of emphasis on his experienced, and adventurous life into all of his books. He truly shows how one writer?s life can be another?s entertainment without being too personal.
Ernest Hemingway 2 Essay Research Paper A
Ernest Hemingway 2 Essay, Research Paper A person can easily recognize Ernest Hemingway s writing style by his simple sentence structure, clear dialogue, and the hopelessness of his characters. Soldier s Home , Hills Like White Elephants , and A Clean well-Lighted Place are perfect examples of three short stories that easily define his unique style.
Ernest M Hemingway Essay Research Paper Ernest
Ernest M. Hemingway Essay, Research Paper Ernest M. Hemingway Do you ever ask yourself what makes life meaningful? For American novelist and short-story writer Ernest Hemingway, it was courage. The characters in his works might not win, but they always live and die bravely. Hemingway told it how it was and didn’t hold anything back.
Hemingway Essay Research Paper NonFiction Book ReportThe
Hemingway Essay, Research Paper Non-Fiction Book Report The book Ernest Hemingway and his world was written by Anthony Burgess and it was published in 1978 by Charles Scribners Sons. Its main concept is about the life of Ernest Hemingway and how he differed from his fellow writers in being a very strong man of action.
Third Eye Blind Essay Research Paper Dr
Third Eye Blind Essay, Research Paper Dr. Ernest Everett Just, was born in 1883 and he died in 1941. He spent most of his life trying to understand the mystery of biology, being a biologist himself. He has many contributions to the branches of science, for instance the facts about fertilization and pointed the way toward a better knowledge of the way all cells work.
Ernest Everett Essay Research Paper Ernest Everett
Ernest Everett Essay, Research Paper Ernest Everett Just Ernest Everett Just was born in Charleston, South Carolina on August 14, 1883 to parents Charles Frazier and Mary Matthews Just. He prepared for college at Kimball Hall Academy, New Hampshire, where he completed the four-year course of study in only three years.
Interpretations Of Hills Like White Elephants
Essay, Research Paper Interpretations of Hills Like White Elephants The woman in the story realizes a lot about her husband in the story. He got her pregnant and they were deciding on having an abortion or not to have an abortion. Ernest Hemingway sort of hid this in his story. He does not say in his story that they are talking about an abortion and if the reader does not catch this the story does not make much sense.
Ernest Hemingway Thesis Paper Essay Research Paper
Thesis Ernest Hemingway?s writing style mirrored the way he lived his own life. Ernest lived the way he wrote creating situations, setting scenes and events leading to their consequences. Hemingway leaves morals and conclusions to the reader. In his short story, Hills like White Elephants these writing characteristics can be illustrated by the following outline.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Retired professor and
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Retired professor and psychoanalyst Ernest Van den Haag, by defending the right to commit suicide, made an appeal to J.S. Mill?s principle. Van den Haag said that people should have the right to choose as they please, as long as no one else is hurt (Hallock 13). According to the constitution, people have the right to decide death, not the government (Dority 8).
Alienation Paper Hemmingway Essay Research Paper Alienation
Alienation Paper Hemmingway Essay, Research Paper Alienation Paper The novels The Old Man and the Sea and The Sun Also Rises are both written by Ernest Hemingway. Some of the aspects of the stories are similar, and some are different. Each book presents a character that has been alienated, but the method used to present the character varies.
Role Of Huckleberry Finn By Mark Train
In American Literature Essay, Research Paper “All modern American literature comes from one book by Mark Twain called Huckleberry Finn,” according to Ernest Hemingway. Along with Ernest, many others believe that Huckleberry Finn is a great book, but is the novel subversive? Since this question is frequently asked, people have begun to look deeper into the question to see if this novel is acceptable for students in schools to read.
Ernest Hemingway Essay Essay Research Paper Final
Ernest Hemingway Essay Essay, Research Paper Final Draft Hemingway Essay A good writer s objective is to say as much as possible as briefly as possible. This enables the thinking about the implications of the word s presented. Ernest Hemingway explained this idea in his iceberg theory of writing fiction in an interview for Paris Review: If it is any use to know it, I always try to write on the principle of the iceberg.
Ernest Hemingway Style Essay Research Paper Ernest
Ernest Hemingway: Style Essay, Research Paper Ernest Hemingway was a writer whose style was very different to that of most writers in his time. Instead of using more drawn out, overly descriptive writing, his stories were more of a “get to the point” style. This gave his works a much different feel and set them aside from what was common during his lifetime.
The Mountain And The Valley Essay Research
Paper A sudden death of a loved one often needs to be followed with a time period of reflection and contemplation of one’s past with, and future without, the deceased. Everyone has their own way to cope with the loss of someone they love. In The Mountain and the Valley, Effie’s death causes David to reflect
Sun Also Rises Essay Research Paper Ernest
Sun Also Rises Essay, Research Paper Ernest Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises is set in Europe after World War I and talks about the life of a group of expatriates, and their summer journey from Paris to Pamplona in Spain. This novel vividly depicts the time period since it shows the atmosphere of despair and disillusionment following the First World War.
A Farewell To Arms Essay Research Paper 2
A Farewell To Arms- Essay, Research Paper A Farewell to Arms- The book A Farewell to Arms, written by Ernest Hemingway, is a classic about the love story of a nurse and a war ridden soldier. The story
The Importance Of Being Earnest -A Review
Essay, Research Paper The play The Importance of Being Earnest by Oscar Wilde definitely proved itself to be ?A Trivial Comedy for Serious People.? I saw the play at Lindenwood University?s Jelkyl Theatre. The play was long, in a three-act structure, yet it moved along at a good pace. They did a nice job of preparing the audience, there was an interesting lobby display with sketches of each of the costumes with fabric samples and they played music to fit the time period before the show began.
Book Review Essay Research Paper Book ReviewFor
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Book Review For Whom The Bell Tolls Ernest Hemingway Pages Read: 74 (really busy) For Whom The Bell Tolls begins with a pyrotechnic for the Russian army reviewing the land where he must blow a bridge to stop enemy movement. He is a little overwhelmed by the task he is assigned to complete yet he is mentally sound in his manner and seems to know exactly how to handle himself in the situation.
The Sun Also Rises By Ernest Hemingway
Essay, Research Paper The Sun Also Rises In Ernest Hemingway s The Sun Also Rises, Jake Barnes is a lost man who wastes his life on drinking. Towards the beginning of the book Robert Cohn asks Jake, Don t you ever get the feeling that all your life is going by and you re not taking advantage of it? Do you realize that you ve lived nearly half the time you have to live already? Jake weakly answers, Yes, every once in a while.
Jefferson Essay Research Paper Jefferson Dies But
Jefferson Essay, Research Paper Jefferson Dies, But Is Not Defeated Jefferson, a black man condemned to die by the electric chair in the novel A Lesson Before Dying by Ernest J. Gaines, is perhaps the strongest character in African-American literature today. Jefferson is a courageous young black man that a jury of all white men convicts of a murder he has not committed ; yet he still does not let this defeat destroy his personal character.
Animals As Symbols Essay Research Paper Animals
Animals As Symbols Essay, Research Paper Animals as Symbols In both of Ernest Hemingway s short stories, The Snows of Kilimanjaro and The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber, he uses animals as symbols to the character’s death. In each of the stories the animals are used differently to symbolize the death.