! Essay, Research Paper
In this paper I will demonstrate why I believe, contrary to widespread opinion and possible even his own, that Aristophanes, not Euripides, was, of the four major dramatists fo Athens’ Golden Age, the one who least respected women.
Having become aware at the ouset of this leterrature course of the position of women in the otherwise enlightened thought of Greece in the Fifth Century B.C., I kept my eyes open during our reading for evidences of, if I may comit an anchronism, chauvinism in the plays of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides. Consoled by the knoledge presented in the text that Aristophanes had accused Euripides of hating women. I didn’t look for it in Lysistrata. Nevertheless, that is where I found it.
In interpreting attitudes toward women in the dramas, I accepts certain prevailing tradtions as given and tried to give the playwrights the benefit of the doubt, turning my head at such practices as using only male actors in the plays and leaving the women in the kitchen while attending the plays. Having concedes those points, I set about “listening” to the playwrights.
In Agamemnon, Aeschylus addresses some remarks toward his Clytaemnestra which could possibly be interpreted as disparaging. She is said to “maneuver like a man,” and Cassandra exclaims, “What outrage–the woman kills the man!” The chorus asks her “What drove her insane” enough to kill a man. Her lover, Aegisthus, although he gloats over the body he cringed from cutting down, allows that “the treachery was the woman’s work, clearly.” Far from denigrating women, however, I believe these parrotings of the prevailing attitudes, when juxtaposed with Aeschylus’ portrayal of an intelligent, capable Clytaemnestra, a gullible, ususpecting Agamemnon and a spineless, parasitical Aegisthus, achieve the result of satirizing those attitudes. At the close of the play, Clytaemnestra challenges her listeners, on-stage and off: “That is what a woman has to say. Can you accept the truth?”
Sophocles takes it one step further. His heroine is not a murderess, but a young women driven by deeply held ideals and familial love. I don’t know there could be any doubt in any viewer’s mind as to who is the “good guy” and who the bad. Antogone is more ethical and intelligent than Creon. Creon’s rejection of “one whose friend has stronger claims upon her than her country” she meets with her own bold philosophy: “I do not think your edicts have such power that they can override the laws of heaven,” humbling Creon in his egoism. The remarks dergrading women do come along: Ismeme avers that, “We who are women should not contend with,: we who are weak are ruuled by the stronger.” Creon vows that if Antione “triumphs and goes unpunished, I am no man, she is,” instructing Haemon not to “unseat your reason for a women’s sake” and to “support the law, and never be beaten by a women” and ejaculates, “This boy defends a woman, it appears….Infamous! Giving first place to a woman!” However, the contrast between Creon and Antigone renders these remarks part of the blindeness, egoism an stupidity that make Creon remiscent of Agamemnon and Oedipus.
I was prepared to bristle at Euripides’ treatment of women. Even in his own time, he was accused of misogyny by, among others, Aristophanes. In fact, legend has it that at his death he was torn apart by dogs or women. I found, instead, surprising sensitivity. Medea laments the husband’s possession fo the wife’s body, the impossibility of divorce by a woman, the double standard of fidelity. She scoffs at the men’s excuse that women live free from danger while they (the men) go out the battle with the pointed, “Fools, I’d rather stand three times in the front line than bear a child.” The adulterous Jason sounds supercilious and hard-hearted adjuring her that she has “talked like a fool” instead of “quietly accepting the decisions of those in power” and banishing her–prancing to his own fate. Medea is, as the Nurse puts it, a “frightenning woman.” She does murder her own children. However, she does so in a red haze of pain and anger. Her entire identity has been wrapped up in her man; she has no other life of her own. Abandoned and rejected by the man who means so much to her, subjugated woman is thus robbed of her very personhood. She has no legal or emotional recourse. After the fact, Jason incredulously asks Medea, “You thought that reason enough to murder them, that I no longer slept with you?” Medea replies with a question of her own: “And is that injury a slight one, do you imagine, to a woman?” Jason doesn’t really hear the queston and–perhaps unwittingly–get off his paring shot: “Yes, to a modest woman….” Medea eloquently expresses the feelings of every woman who has been spurned by the man who commands her sense fo worth. I don’t believe this agony could be more movingly depicted by a woman.
Aristophases lampoons Euripiedsa and his perceived hatred of women. I have not read Thesmophosriazusae, in which the text informs us women avenge themselves on Euripides, so I cannot respond to it. I have, however some reactions to Lysistrata. The very concept of the sex strike gives credence to the idea that sevice of men is the only value women have, that withholding that sevice is their only way of wielding power. The status quo is defended. In that light, the “humorous” self-deprecating comments of he women do not achieve satire and I don’t believe are meant as satire,. The satire is on the war. Indeed, to all appearances, the heroines believe the myths. Lysistrata remarks, “The way we women behave! I don’t blame the men for what they say about us.” When she tells Kalonike that “only we women can save Greece,” Kalonike responds, “only we women? poor Greece….We belong at home. Our only armor’s our perfumes, our saffron dresses and our pretty little shoes!”
Aristophanes names one of his heroines Myrrhine, a pun on the Greek word for female genitalia, and has her hail from Anagyros, a stinking marshland. The sybolism is very pointed, and very derogatory. There are several references in the play, by both men and women, to men slapping their wives to make them comply, as well as to spousal rape. The men, when the battle lines are drawn, call the women bitches, subersive whores, trollops, wild animals, with no evidence of anything but approval. There is also an upholding of the male phallus as that which women most need. Kalonike objects to Lysistrata, “I’d walk through fire for you….but don’t ask us to give up that!” A Boiotian woman says it again: “I’d rather walk through fire.” Even Lysistrata herself later moans, “There’s only one thing we can think of.”
Aristophanes does employ satire when he has the Comissioner say, “The idea of women bothering themselves about peace and war!” and, “It would take a woman to reduce state questions to a matter of carding and weaving.” I believe Lysistrata does clumsily try to do women justice, and that is precisely why I believe Aristophanes to have been the most profoundly smitten with the disease of perceived male superiority. At one point, when the women respond to the taunts and threats of the men with taunts and threats of their own, the male chorus calls out, “Euripides! Master! How well you knew women!” I believe Euripides did understand a great deal more about women than was common in his time. I believe Aristophanes thought he knew women, and I don’t think he ever even realized the serious injustice Lysistrata does them.
Другие работы по теме:
Slavery Essay Research Paper Slavery 2
Slavery Essay, Research Paper Slavery During the 1500’s the slave trade was popular all over the world. Many of the negative effects fell upon the Africans who have to suffer through immense mistreatment
Bacchae Essay Research Paper MoralSocial Values in
Bacchae Essay, Research Paper Moral-Social Values in The Bacchae One prevailing argument about The Bacchae as with many of his other works is whether Euripides propounds a revolutionary or a reactionary message about society. This outlook, however, is skirting an essential element of The Bacchae’s theme.
Medea As A Heroine Essay Research Paper
In Euripides’ Medea, the main character of the same name is a controversial heroine. Medea takes whatever steps necessary to achieve what she believes is right and fair. She lived in a time when women were expected to sit in the shadows and take the hand that life dealt them without a blink of their eye. Medea took very radical steps to liberate herself and destroys the life of the man who ruined hers.
Playwrights Aeschylus Sophocles And Euripides Essay Research
Paper The starting point when discussing comedy and tragedy would be to define the main terms. Comedy is the dramatic genre that focuses on human weakness through humor. Comedy celebrates the regeneration of life through love and reconciliation. Tragedy is the dramatic genre initiated by ancient Greek playwrights such as Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides.
Medea Essay Research Paper Stephen EkstromIn ancient
Medea Essay, Research Paper Stephen Ekstrom In ancient Greece women were viewed as many things. They were not viewed as equivalent to males by any means. Women were portrayed usually as submissive domestic, and controlled. They played supporting or secondary roles in life to men, who tended to be demanding of their wives, but expected them to adhere to their wishes.
Deeper Philosophical Meanings Of The Baccai Essay
, Research Paper One of ancient Greece s tragic plays in entitled The Bacchae , written by Euripides. Many larger and deeper philosophical views are expressed in the play. The plot contains many speeches, and one might think at certain points that they would be the moral. The actual moral, however, is almost impossible to define.
Medea 2
Medea – An Abandonment Of Gender Roles Essay, Research Paper In Euripides? Medea, the protagonist abandoned the gender roles of ancient Greek society. Medea defied perceptions of gender by exhibiting both “male” and “female” tendencies. She was able to detach herself from her “womanly” emotions at times and perform acts that society did not see women capable of doing.
Artistic Theme Of The Bacchae Essay Research
Paper My artistic theme is about the play The Bacchae of Euripides and how the god Dionysusis irrational behavior is in accord with that of Alcibiades in Plato s Symposium. In both books the above named character s behavior was reactive to their situations rather than proactive.
Euripides Treatments Of The Myth Of
Heracles First Marriage In His Play Heracles. Essay, Research Paper Euripides treatments of the myth of Heracles first marriage in his play Heracles. The Heracles of Euripides is innovative in its treatment of the Heracles myth. Heracles is perhaps the greatest hero of the ancient Greek world. Stories about Heracles are varied and abundant however, the traditional nature of the myth does logically place many constraints upon the playwright.
Medea By Euripides Essay Research Paper Through
Medea By Euripides Essay, Research Paper Through the play Medea, Euripides shows us the importance of keeping a promise given. At the beginning of the story, we see the play?s two opposing views of
Euripides Medea Essay Research Paper MedeaThe Greek
Euripides? Medea Essay, Research Paper Medea The Greek tragedy Medea is a tale of a woman scorn and the wrath that follows. The story is one of outright deceit, crippling revenge and questionable justice. It is typical of Greek tragedies in its simplicity, but atypical in the way it justifies horrific revenge.
Sophocles Vs Euripides Essay Research Paper While
Sophocles Vs. Euripides Essay, Research Paper While both Sophocles and Euripides are considered writers of Greek tragedy, their plays (Antigone, Oedipus Rex, Medea) have some subtle and some profound differences. In both Antigone and Oedipus Rex, the ?tragic heroes? suffer from a major character flaw- hubris.
Medea 3 Essay Research Paper The tragic
Medea 3 Essay, Research Paper The tragic play Medea, originally written by Euripides then later translated by Philip Vellacott, describes the intense love that Medea expresses towards Jason, a prince on a quest for the Golden Fleece. In an attempt to become closer to the throne, Jason marries Medea, and they parent two children together.
Did Gender Make A Difference Essay Research
Paper Did Gender Make a Difference? Within slavery there were harsh conditions which Frederick Douglass tries to convey in his biography “Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass.”
Golden Age Of Athens And Women Essay
, Research Paper The Golden Age of Athens was one of the most brilliant eras in Athenian history. Yet this brilliance did not reflect women?s roles during this time period. The Golden Age of Athens was a low point for women; through society?s opinion of women, the city?s politics, and their household lives.
A Comparison Of Dionysus
& Jesus Christ As Mythic Characters Essay, Research Paper “He rises from the ruins of the once mighty house, that he himself has laid to dust. Here he comes, the son of God” (Euripides 34). Jesus, right? Although this would probably be the answer of almost any American (or Christian), this passage describes not Jesus Christ, but Dionysus, the son of Zeus.
Progressive Era Essay Research Paper PhilipsUS History
Progressive Era Essay, Research Paper Philips US History II During the Progressive Era in the United States, there were many changes happening. Some were happening with the people in the United States, some with the people controlling the United States, and some changes were just going on around both of them.
Medea Essay Research Paper Love and Deception
Medea Essay, Research Paper Love and Deception There are many pieces of literature that may entail more than one theme throughout the story. The tragedy, Medea, by Euripides is very good example of this. Throughout this story, the themes of betrayal and love, revenge, and women s rights arise. Euripides brings these points up to help the reader to realize that women are powerful also.
Medea Vs Lysistrata Essay Research Paper Medea
Medea Vs. Lysistrata Essay, Research Paper Medea vs. Lysistrata ? Contrasting two strong Greek females Both Medea by Euripides and Lysistrata by Aristophanes illustrate the injustices that women suffered. Each author uses strong-willed characters to protest social situations.
Medea And Jason Essay Research Paper Much
Medea And Jason Essay, Research Paper Much of what has been written on slavery in Euripides has to do with the captive women taken in the Trojan War. But even ordinary household slaves like Medea’s Nurse may ‘betray characteristics of the free which the free themselves do not possess’ (N. T. Croally, Euripidean Polemic, Cambridge, 1994:102-3) and in this way cast some light on the status of their masters and what the slave/free definition means in the play and in a wider context.
Medea Essay Research Paper Medea Medea is
Medea Essay, Research Paper Medea Medea is a Greek tragedy which was written in 431 BC by the Greek philosopher Euripides. The story of Medea is one filled with anger, jealousy, and death. The main character, Medea, has to overcome the personal heartache of seeing her husband, Jason, marry another woman. The ensuing struggle she has with this notion is the focus of this play.
Medea By Euripides Essay Research Paper MEDEAEuripides
Medea By Euripides Essay, Research Paper MEDEA Euripides was intrigued by the old Greek myths that surrounded him. Some writers 1 feel that he represented a critical, sceptical mind at work on these myths, being more interested in individual psychology and removed from the ritual origins of drama. Considered to be third in time of the three great tragic poets of Greek theatre, his reputation grew even after his death in 406 B.C.
A Doll HouseMidterm Essay Research Paper A
A Doll House(Midterm) Essay, Research Paper A Doll House I believe that when the Doll House was written, the power within relationships was not equal. The women had no say in what they did. They had to take orders from the male figure. They were house wives. In the Doll House, Nora Helmer was ahead of her time. She did stuff that she shouldn t have done.
Medea And The Chorus Essay Research Paper
Medea and the Chorus The exchange that takes place between Medea and the Chorus serves several purposes in Euripides’ tragedy, The Medea. It allows us to sympathize with Medea in spite of her tragic flaws. It also foreshadows the tragic events that will come to pass. Finally, it contrasts rationality against vengeance and excess.
A Comparison Of A Tragic Hero From
Euripides?s Medea And Aeschylus?s Agamemnon Essay, Research Paper A Comparison of a Tragic Hero from Euripides?s Medea and Aeschylus?s Agamemnon Tragic heroes from Greek tragedies almost always share similar characteristics.
The Role Of Women In Medea Essay
, Research Paper Medea is the tragic tale of a woman scorned. It was written in 431 B.C. by the Greek playwright, Euripides. Eruipides was the first Greek poet to suffer the fate of so many of the great
Feminism In Medea Essay Research Paper Feminism
Feminism In Medea Essay, Research Paper Feminism in Medea The play Medea by Euripides challenges the dominant views of femininity in the patriarchal society of the Greeks. While pursuing her ambition Medea disregards many of the feminine stereotypes/ characteristics of the patriarchal Greek society.
Role Of Women In The 19Th Century
Essay, Research Paper Role of Females In the nineteenth century women were perceived in many different ways. Two noted nineteenth century writer were john Stuart Mill and Henrik Ibsen. Even though most of their stories were greatly different they did share the common thought that women are their own people and should be free.
Dionysus Essay Research Paper Dionysus
Dionysus Essay, Research Paper Dionysus–Bacchae The god, Dionysus, fills an integral role in Grecian Myth. According to Euripides’ Bacchae, Dionysus represents the animalistic and mystic life force that connects humanity to its innate earthy roots—roots that are illogical, chaotic, and instinctual.
Fashion In The 1920
’s Essay, Research Paper Women’s Fashion of the 1920’s The fashion of the 1920’s was a good indicator of women’s incredible, rapid change that pushed women into a more prominent position during the 1920’s. Women began to get wilder, more rebellious and were dubbed “Flappers” by Scott Fitzgerald, coincidentally, the writer of The Great Gatsby.
Tragic World Essay Research Paper The Greeks
Tragic World Essay, Research Paper The Greeks had a tragic world view. I believe that a tragic world view is a view of the world in which there is little hope for any progress; everything grows, matures, and dies. The values taught by such a tragic world are bravery, fate, humanism, and reasoning. There are many examples of the teaching of these values in the Grecian literary works.
Men And Women Are Different Essay Research
Paper Men and Women Different? Are women and men really that different? I think so. I am at a stage in my life where I think all men are after one thing. Sex. When I sit here and think about it, I really have to think, do women and men have anything in common. Women communicate in a completely different manner than women.