– Mellville And Darwin Essay, Research Paper
Galapagos Islands: Mellville and DarwinDuring the nineteenth century, two prominent writers, Herman Mellville and Charles Darwin both voyaged to the Galapagos islands off the coast of Ecuador. Both of these individuals wrote descriptive passages about the physical attributes and atmosphere of the Galapagos Islands. The passages vary in specific content due to the intentions and interests of the respective authors, even though the object described is the same. Charles Darwin, best known for the theory of evolution, wrote for the purpose of science; Herman Mellville, best known for Moby Dick, for the purpose of entertainment. The audience intended, the tone of the author, and the terms used in description-these all vary between the two passages. These passages exemplify that a single subject, under varying conditions, can be seen and portrayed using differing style and rhetoric. Mellville’s passage uses allusions, analogies, and comparisons to well-known entities to better illustrate the Galapagos Islands to the common reader. Mellville assumes that the reader is unfamiliar with the Galapagos islands, or “Encantadas,” as he chooses to refer to them as and paints a picture of the Galapagos Islands using everyday terms. An important part of Mellville s style is that the he never directly describes the islands. “Take five-and-twenty heaps of cinders dumped here and there in an outside city lot” is how Mellville’s description of the Galapagos Islands begins. This reduces the Galapagos islands from a large, nearly inconceivable place to objects of which most any reader can create a mental picture. When Mellville describes the flora of the Galapagos Islands, he compares it with drying “Syrian gourds,” aching for water. Mellville discusses the solitude of the Galapagos Islands in comparison with Greenland, a familiar place of solitude, the clear water in terms of Lake Erie, and the “azure ice” in terms of malachite. They know not autumn writes Mellville, as if these heaps of cinder are conscious of anything at all. All these segments of Mellvilles passage are illustrations of how Mellville creates a personal relationship between the Island and the reader. Darwin uses scientific and specific words, gearing the passage for a highly specialized audience. He centers his writing around the vegetation and related matters; rarely straying from direct description or using comparisons. Darwin in one of his few comparisons, relates the vegetation of the Galapagos Islands with that of “the volcanic island of Fernando de Noronha,” unheard of by all, except the most worldly. This shows that Darwin makes no investment in the creation of an image in the minds of the common reader. Darwin writes of a specific island, Chatham Island, and replaces Mellville s heaps of cinders with “A broken field of black basaltic lava,…crossed by great fissures.” Using specifics, Darwin notes on the abundance of “Euphorbiaceae”; not only unheard of by the common reader, but unpronounceable as well. This illustrates that the intended readers of Darwin s passage are perhaps botanists or biologists. As if in a laboratory report or scientific analysis, Darwin describes the physical element of the Galapagos Islands, rarely straying into emotions.
Varying themes found in the diction of the two passages creates different overall impressions for the reader. In Darwin’s diction, one finds an obvious theme, the repeated use of words involving heat. “Lava,” “sun-burnt,” “dry,”"parched,” “heated,”sun” and “stove” are all used within the first four sentences. It is not uncommon to find a subject-verb-complement structure only slightly modified; Nothing could be less inviting than the first appearance. is a example of this. Primarily, Darwin uses mild variations on the simple sentence structure; Mellville, varied structures. The third paragraph of Mellville’s passage consists solely of one long sentence, formed by piling images: And as for solitariness; the great forests of the north, the expanses of unnavigated waters, the Greenland icefields, are the profoundest of solitudes to a human observer; still the magic of their changeable tides and seasons mitigates their terror; because, though unvisited by men, those forests are visited by the May; the remotest seas reflect stars even as Lake Erie does; and in the clear air of a fine polar day, the irradiated azure ice shows beautifully as malachite. This sentence, both in complexity and uniquity, displays the immense variations in sentence structure at Mellville s disposal. The mood of Mellville s entire passage is both sad and lonely; words throughout the passage display this: “solitariness,” “solitudes,” “desolation,” “sympathy,” “sorrows” and “sad.” Mellville awakens thoughts of sympathy as he compares The Encantadas with withering cities and disheveled cemeteries. Towards the end, Mellville displays this superbly, Have mercy on me, the wailing spirit of the Encantadas seems to cry. With emotion and personification, Mellville approaches the Galapagos Islands poetically. He describes the terror as well as the solitude experienced on the islands; giving the reader a sense of atmosphere. In conclusion, these points demonstrate possible ways to relate a subject to a reader using varied style and rhetoric. Such drastic differences can be found elsewhere as well. The Bible outlines rules and restrictions for its followers to live by; books of law, rules for all who live in the United States. Even though there are major differences found between passages of Darwin and Mellville, similar to those between the Bible and formal law books, there are obvious similarities. Both passages talk of the scattered black hills that form the Galapagos Islands. Both portray an uninviting island; Darwin writes: “We fancied that even the bushes smelt unpleasantly.” The use of “even” by Darwin implies that other objects on the island emit a stench as well. With a similar outlook, Mellville writes: “ruin itself can work little more upon them.” These passages, both written about the Galapagos Islands, have many significant differences, as well as some similarities. They demonstrate contrasting ways to perceive and relate a subject as well as the Bible and books of law.
356
Другие работы по теме:
The Allegory Of The Cave By Plato
Essay, Research Paper Plato was born 427 B.C. and died 347 B.C. He was a pupil under Socrates. During his studies, Plato wrote the Dialogues, which are a collection of Socrates’ teachings. One of the parables included in the Dialogues is “The Allegory of the Cave”. “The Allegory…” symbolizes man’s struggle to reach understanding and enlightenment.
Galapogos Essay Research Paper GalapagosKurt Vonnegut
Galapogos Essay, Research Paper Galapagos Kurt Vonnegut’s Galapagos was written one million years ahead of the year 1986 AD. The novel was written in the narrative style of a story being told from a grandfather to a grandson. The author Kurt Vonnegut express the theme very well throughout the novel, it is presented from cover to cover: That’s man’s intelligence will be the downfall and destruction of the human race.
Charles Darwin 2 Essay Research Paper Throughout
Charles Darwin 2 Essay, Research Paper Throughout history, man has always wondered about the question; Where did life come from? Many had tried, but failed to answer this puzzling question with evidence to back it up. Most people interpreted the Bible as the key to the debate of our existence. But it was not until 1859 that a bright scientist by the name of Charles Darwin revealed the truth to the world.
The Harvesting Of Sea Cucumbers In The
Galapagos Islands Essay, Research Paper Sea cucumbers in the Galapagos are being fished out illegally in spite of a four-year ban that is unsuccessfully enforced by the Ecuadorian government. Most sea cucumbers are dried and exported to Taiwan and Hong Kong. The waters off of mainland Ecuador have already been stripped of commercially valuable sea cucumbers.
Darwin Essay Research Paper The question of
Darwin Essay, Research Paper The question of how man evolved has been pondered since man first stepped foot on this planet. Many great philosophers and explorers have made attempts to try to answer this question. Charles Darwin was one of these people. Darwin led a full life of exploration, and during these adventures, he accumulated much information about evolution.
Charlse Darwin Essay Research Paper Charles Robert
Charlse Darwin Essay, Research Paper Charles Robert Darwin is considered by many to be the father of modern biology. He introduced the theory of evolution and natural selection to a time in which science was based of the words on the Bible. He revolutionized the way life science was studied.
Hati Essay Research Paper The Caribbean Islands
Hati Essay, Research Paper The Caribbean Islands are one of the most traveled to place in the world. One of these islands in the Caribbean Sea is the island of Hispano, which is both the countries of Haiti and the Dominican Republic. This country has a recorded history of about 552 years. They also have special culture.
Biogeography Essay Research Paper bBiogeographyAfter reading the
Biogeography Essay, Research Paper bBiogeography After reading the text on David Quammen?s voyage through many different islands of the world, I was hit with a certain impression of the world. The first thing that amazed me about how David Quammen wrote the book is that, within a few chapters I felt that the timeline of the creation of earth and suddenly shrunk immensely.
Hawaii Essay Research Paper Nicole Maguire
Hawaii Essay, Research Paper Nicole Maguire Prof. Mills Native Hawaiians Hawaii is an archipelago of enchanting and exotic islands that remained unknown to the rest of the world for thousands of years. When the islands were finally discovered they weren t desolate, they were inhabited by a whole group of people that were very capable.
Creation Essay Research Paper Charles Darwin was
Creation Essay, Research Paper Charles Darwin was born in Shrewsbury, Shropshire. He was the son of Robert Waring Darwin and his wife Susannah, and the grandson of the scientist Erasmus Darwin. His mother died when he was eight years old, and he was brought up by his sister. He was taught the classics at Shrewsbury, then sent to Edinburgh to study medicine, which he hated.
Carribbean Politics Essay Research Paper Ethnic Affairs
Carribbean Politics Essay, Research Paper Ethnic Affairs of The State All men are created equal. In the books this statement is valid, but in everyday life we have a long way to go before this becomes more than just a perception. The Caribbean Islands that were once only populated by blacks has now become a white man s world.
Interview Edward Larson Essay Research Paper
A voyage to the origin of speciesEdward Larson writes the first drafts of his books in pencil on yellow pads of paper, but he writes his articles straight onto a computer. For him, books are different things. And Evolution’s Workshop, newly paperbacked by Penguin this week, is a word-lover’s book: it evokes the desolate, cinder-strewn and tortoise-trodden Galapagos Islands, as seen by writers and voyagers over 300 years.
The Aran Islands Essay Research Paper Synges
?The Aran Islands? Essay, Research Paper Synge?s Romantic Vision of the Aran Islands When John Millington Synge made his way to the western most islands of Ireland he was in search of inspiration for his writing. The fruit of his journey was the fame-winning book entitled ?The Aran Islands?. Synge had many purposes for this book, but one of the most compelling was his desire to write an anthropologically geared account of the people and lifestyle of what many believed to be the last bastion of true Irishness.
ANTS Essay Research Paper In the following
ANTS Essay, Research Paper In the following assignment I will be talking about fire ants. My assignment is mostly based up on an article wich I chosed from the magasin Scientific American February 1999.
Ecuador Essay Research Paper Ecuador South America
Ecuador Essay, Research Paper Ecuador, South America s second smallest country, is regarded as one of the most geographically and ethnically diverse countries on the continent. This culture-rich country is largely uncharted, making it an exciting and adventurous place to visit. Simply learning about this country is a remarkable experience.
Ecuador Essay Research Paper EcuadorI picked this
Ecuador Essay, Research Paper Ecuador I picked this country because when we saw the video on Ecuador it made me want to learn more about the country. Ecuador has a population approximately 10,500,000 and is a little bit smaller than Nevada. 85% of the people aged 15 or older are literate. The Galapagos Islands are also part of Ecuador and the total population is about 10,000 people.
Charles Darwin Essay Research Paper Worms tortoises
Charles Darwin Essay, Research Paper Worms, tortoises, ostriches, and flies; what do these things have in common? They are all part of Charles Darwin s theories. Darwin spent five years aboard the HMS Beagle studying animal and plant life all over the world. This time, plus the many subsequent years he spent conversing with experts in various fields, led him to write The Origin of Species , often called the book that shook the world .
Letter From Thoreau To Darwin Essay Research
Paper Dear Charles Darwin, Hello, I have recently read your theory on natural selection and the Origin of Species. Although each of us approach life differently, for example your ambition being on
Penguins Essay Research Paper I They are
Penguins Essay, Research Paper I They are small white and black bird like creatures that live in cold regions. Penguins are the most fascinating creature around.
New Discoveries In Biogeograph Essay Research Paper
New Discoveries in Biogeography About thirty years ago, two men, Robert H. MacArthur and Edward O. Wilson began a journey to test a theory of biogeography. They developed their theory by observing how on an island when one species of ant becomes extinct, a new one replaces it. From this they concluded that large islands have more species than small islands and that remote islands have fewer species than less remote ones.
The Creole Crontraversy Essay Research Paper Creole
The Creole Crontraversy Essay, Research Paper Creole Controversy Many different definitions, as well as beliefs, have been formed for the term ?Creole?. The text book definition is ?one that is native to the New World?. Euro-Colonial settlements around the world defined the term differently, and the meanings have altered over time.
Sea Lion Essay Research Paper The Sea
Sea Lion Essay, Research Paper The Sea Lion is found in the West Coast of North America and the Galapagos Islands. The name of the sea lion is the California Sea Lion or the Zaluphus Californianus. The phylum is the
Greeks Essay Research Paper The Greek International
Greeks Essay, Research Paper The Greek International System The Greeks settled around the Greek peninsula and the islands in the Aegean Sea. They also went to areas located in India. Through the International system, city-states are formed sovereign within themselves. With the Greeks, there was a conglomeration of city-states that had external pressures by the Persians.
Charles Darwin His Life Story Of Dicovery
Essay, Research Paper Charles Darwin: His Life Story of Dicovery Andy Zerzan Biology Mr Herron 1st Hour Extra Credit 10/95 “The Catholic church has absolutely no view on ‘Darwin’s Theory of Evolution’
Earthquakes Essay Research Paper Major Earthquakes for
Earthquakes Essay, Research Paper Major Earthquakes for 60s and 70s. In the map have plotted the major earthquakes for the 60s and 70s. The major earthquake areas are in the area around the Pacific Ocean. Most of the earthquakes happened at these areas and for this reason they call it “Pacific Ring of Fire”.
Charles Darwin 2 Essay Research Paper Charles
Charles Darwin 2 Essay, Research Paper Charles Robert Darwin In 1859 when Charles Darwin published his book “The Origin of Species”, it caused much controversy between the scientific and religious worlds. It caused many people to question their belief in the teaching of the Bible. The strongly held belief that the Bible was the literal truth clashed with the Darwin theory.
The Geographical Location of Great Britain
The full and official name of the country is the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The United Kingdom is situated on the British Isles. The British Isles consist of two large islands, Great Britain and Ireland and a great number of small islands. Their total area is over 244,000 square kilometres.
Charles Darwin Before Origin Of Species Essay
, Research Paper Like many modern students, Charles Darwin exceeded only in subjects that intrigued him. Although his father was a physician, Darwin was uninterested in medicine and he was unable to stand the sight of surgery. He did eventually obtain a degree in theology from Cambridge University, although theology too was of minor interest to him.
Charles Darwin Essay Research Paper Charles Darwin
Charles Darwin Essay, Research Paper Charles Darwin Like many students, Charles Darwin was only intrested in topics that was intresting to him and although his father was a doctor, Darwin was very unintrested in medicine and he also couldnt stand the sight of surgery. He did eventually get a degree in Theology from Cambridge University, Although Theology was a minor intrest to him.
On The Theory Of Evolution Essay Research
Paper On the Theory of EvolutionWhether it is Lamarck+s theory that evolution is driven by an innate tendency towards greater complexity, Darwin+s theory of natural selection, or the belief that the evolution of plant and animal life is controlled by a higher being, the process of evolution cannot be denied.