’s Tale – Biblical Paradox Essay, Research Paper
To formulate any type of argument using the Bible as a reference is challenging, since the Bible is diversely perceived from person to person. These varied perceptions can be results of different translations of the Bible, the cultural background of the reader, or quite simply, a vagueness with which the Bible can lend itself to multiple interpretations. Nevertheless, there are certain topics which are void of much gray area, which are explicitly and consistently outlined by the authors of the various books found in the Bible. Marriage, while tirelessly mentioned throughout the entire Bible, can be included as one of these topics. There are certain elements about the topic which remain the same through the generations of contributors to the Sacred writ. Geoffrey Chaucer, in The Canterbury Tales, frequently alludes to marriage according to the Bible. While the book is not mentioned specifically in The Clerk?s Tale, it is interesting to examine how the Clerk?s characters, Walter and Grisilde, fulfill ? or do not fulfill – the roles of biblical husband and wife. At the outset, it would seem that, biblically, they fit the roles assigned to them. However, as the tale progresses, inconsistencies escalate into a rather puzzling conclusion.
The reader should first be aware of how Chaucer presents the Bible overall in The Canterbury Tales. This will lay the foundation for how one might expect it to be used in The Clerk?s Tale specifically, and why it would be worth studying. The first great reference to the Bible in The Canterbury Tales is the Wife of Bath?s argument for her multiple marriages. This comprises most of her Prologue, and she mentions the names of many biblical characters to support her argument. To give one of many examples, she specifically mentions King Solomon when she says of him, ?I trowe he hadde wyves mo than oon? (36). Other characters include Abraham (55), Jacob (56), Paul (64, 79, 160), and Mark (145). Another hugely obvious biblical reference is the Prioress? Prologue and Tale. She begins her Prologue with, ?O Lord, oure Lord, thy name how marveillous / Is in this large worlde y-sprad? (19). The Prioress? Tale itself is centered around the Virgin Mary and Christian ideals. These are only two of many of The Canterbury Tales which have religious references.
Furthermore, the very fact that Chaucer?s characters are on a pilgrimage would suggest that they have some sort of religious upbringing. In fact, there are even clergy on the trip: The Nun, the Monk, the Friar and the Pardoner (immoral men, but clergy nonetheless), and the Parson. While some of these pilgrims are not very representative of the Bible?s teachings, this assortment of characters does confirm that religion and the Bible are important parts of these people?s lives. Therefore, it would follow that their tales might reflect some of this aspect of life. While The Clerk?s Tale does not make specific mention of characters from the Bible, biblical traits are illustrated ? and contrasted ? between the two main characters.
The Clerk introduces Walter to the audience as a pleasant man, describing him as ?A fair persone, and strong, and yong of age / And ful of honour and of curteisye? (73-74). However, Walter does have one fault: He refuses to marry. This troubles his vassals, as they lament to him,
For certes, lord, so wel us lyketh yow
And al your werk, and ever han doon, that we
Ne coude nat us self devysen how
We mighte liven in more felicitee,
Save o think, lord, if it youre will be,
That for to been a wedded man yow leste::
Than were your peple in sovereyn hertes reste.
(106-112)
Now, according to the New Testament teachings of Paul in the Bible, being a bachelor is actually commendable. Paul specifically states in 1 Corinthians 7:1, ?It is good for a man not to marry.? He goes on to write in verse 3, ?But since there is so much immorality, each man should have his own wife.? So, under much pressure from his people, Walter concedes and marries Grisilde.
At first, the marriage seems wonderful. The Clerk says that Walter ?Wedded with fortunate honestee / In Goddes pees liveth ful esily / At hoom, and outward grace y-nogh had he? (422-425). Grisilde fits the picture of the perfect wife described in Proverbs 31:10-12: ?A wife of noble character who can find? She is worth far more than rubies. Her husband has full confidence in her and lacks nothing of value. She brings him good, not harm, all the days of her life.? She faithfully serves Walter and yields to his every wish. It pleases Grisilde to do so, as she says to Walter, ?Ne I desyre no thing for to have / Ne drede for to lese, save only ye / This wil is in myn herte and ay shall be? (507-509). This too is biblical, as Paul commands, ?Now as the church submits to Christ, so also wives should submit to their husbands in everything? (Ephesians 5:24)?.
Here is where the major conflict arises. On one hand, there is Grisilde, the good and faithful wife, who perfectly fits the mold described in the Bible. On the other hand, there is Walter, who started out just fine; he had married with honor, seemingly with the best of intentions for his new bride. However, Walter takes a turn for the worst, as he begins ?testing? his wife. He has ?in his herte a longeth so / To tempt his wyf, hir sadnesse for to knowe? (451-52). First of all, Paul not only commands wives to submit to their husbands, but he also commissions husbands to love their wives ?as Christ loved the church? (Ephesians 5:25). It is important to note how Christ loves the church, to clearly understand what is expected of the husband. Concerning this, Paul goes on to write, ??as Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her, to make her holy, cleansing her by the washing with water through the word?In the same way, husbands ought to love their wives as their own bodies? (Ephesians 5:25-28).
Another huge blunder made by Walter is that he sends Griselde away to test her again. He says to her,
Be of strong herte , and voyde anon hir place;
And thilke dowere that ye broughten me
Tak it agayn, I graunte it of my grace.
Retourneth to your fadres house?(806-809)
Obviously, Walter does not love his wife as Christ loved the church. Not only does he send Grisilde away, he says he will take another wife (lines 953-987). According to the Bible, to divorce is bad enough (God says in Malaichi 2:16, ?I hate divorce?), but to remarry is even worse. Jesus himself claimed that “Anyone who divorces his wife and marries another woman commits adultery against her? (Mark 10:11). Throughout all of these trials, however, Griselde remains faithful. She has completely fulfilled everything expected of a Godly wife. Walter, on the other hand, is a complete opposite, going against everything the Bible says about marriage. It is unclear as to whether Chaucer purposely used The Clerk?s Tale to create this type of paradox. Nevertheless, it is clear that the contrast is there, and the religious pilgrims of The Canterbury Tales would have no doubt recognized such a biblical conflict.
? Other references to this command include, but are not limited to: Romans 7:2, 1 Corinthians 7:39, Colossians 3:18, 1 Peter 3:1
Sources:Chaucer, Geoffrey. The Canterbury Tales: Nine Tales and the General Prologue. Eds. V.A. Kolve and Glending Olson. New York: W.W. Norton & Company Inc, 1989
The Holy Bible, New International Version. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Corp., 1984.
Другие работы по теме:
Телескоп Джеймса Кларка Максвелла
находится: Мауна-Кеа, Гавайи, США Телескоп Джеймса Кларка Максвелла (англ. James Clerk Maxwell Telescope или JCMT) — инфракрасный телескоп с диаметром главного зеркала 15 метров. Название дано в честь Джеймса Кларка Максвелла (1831—1879) — создателя электромагнитной теории света и одно из основателей современной физики и техники.
Подорож 2
НЕТРАДИЦІЙНИЙ УРОК з англійської мови у 7 класі на тему: “Подорож” Урок – рольова гра в 7-му класі Мета: — систематизувати навички діалогічного та монологічного мовлення з тем "Подорож", "Вокзал", "Місто";
Jusstice For All Essay Research Paper When
Jusstice For All Essay, Research Paper When we are young, most of us are somewhat naive. We are inherently taught that good will always triumph over evil. A courthouse is the forum where evil should be dealt with. But, in reality, this is seldom the case.
Clerk Typist Essay Research Paper There is
Clerk Typist Essay, Research Paper There is something mysterious and powerful about dreams. For many years, I have wondered what dreams are really made of. I came up with two possible answers. First, I think dreams can provide an escape from or evaluation of every day reality. And secondly, I believe that certain images can be translated to provide hidden answers to daily problems.
James Clerk Maxwell Essay Research Paper IntroductionHave
James Clerk Maxwell Essay, Research Paper Introduction Have you ever left a football outside? If you have you probably noticed it got smaller. And when you took it inside and set it next to a furnace or a vent blowing hot air, the ball tends to get a little bigger. This process can be best described by the Kinetic Molecular theory.
Law Case Essay Research Paper In the
Law Case Essay, Research Paper In the case of Denise, the single mother, and her eight year old daughter, Sally, the two of them face a moral dilemma. Denise cannot afford the anticonvulsant drugs needed to control Sally s extreme seizures. Since she cannot afford them she steals the medicine from the drug store where she is employed as a check-out clerk.
Cloning Essay Research Paper ClerksClerks is
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Clerks Clerks is a raunchy, obscene, cheap, and extremely funny movie. It was written and directed by film school dropout, Kevin Smith in 1994. Clerks is an independent film that was funded for under 30,000 dollars. Smith raised the money by selling his comic book collection. (Ellis) The film ended up grossing $3.1 million on its initial domestic release by Miramax. (Humpry) Films produced for this amount of money would be considered amateur.
Fear Essay Research Paper FEAR Aaa choo
Fear Essay, Research Paper FEAR ? Aaa choo ?? ?I think you are catching a cold sweetheart?, said Sonia, as she was opening her apartment door. ? I think you I should take you to the doctor.?
Filing For A Quick Divorce Essay Research
Paper Filing for divorce has become a simple and quick process with the release of self-help kits. In the past a simple divorce would cost an average of fifteen hundred to two thousand dollars and take about six months to complete. Now for a fraction of the cost and time you can file for a divorce without hiring an attorney.
Phoenix Essay Research Paper She slowly made
Phoenix, Essay, Research Paper She slowly made her way down to bottom the stairs, moving a little from side to side, she gently and tediously pushed open the glass doors and trod out onto the gray sidewalk.
Same Thing Different Price Essay Research Paper
Same Thing, Different Price What can I say about college life? It is one of those times where you will spend the most money you will ever spend in your life. It becomes even more expensive when you have to pay out of state fees. Out of state students should not have to pay for these fees. Simply because the students are paying for the same classes that the in state students are paying for.
James Clerk Maxwell Essay Research Paper James
James Clerk Maxwell Essay, Research Paper James Clerk Maxwell Introduction James Clerk Maxwell was a British physicist. Maxwell was born in Edinburgh, Scotland on November 13, 1831. He was educated at Edinburgh Academy from 1841 to 1847. He then entered the University of Edinburgh, and went on to study at the University of Cambridge in 1850, graduating with a bachelor’s degree in mathematics in 1854.
The Wife Canterbury Tales Essay Research Paper
The clerk tells his tale as a rebuttal to the “Wife of Bath’s” story, each tale has an opposing view about which sex is more dominant than another. The woman of Bath is a woman that speaks her mind without being afraid of her image, which was very uncommon during this time. She is very knowledgeable about history and real life experiences.
Prejudice Essay Research Paper As I walk
Prejudice Essay, Research Paper As I walk down the aisle, the sales clerk glares at me with contemptible eyes, watching every move I make, unquestionably thinking if she turns her head for the slightest moment that I will slip everything of value into my purse. Prejudging people for their appearance is a common practice that humans perform.
Nelle Harper Lee Essay Research Paper Miss
Nelle Harper Lee Essay, Research Paper Miss. Nelle Harper Lee was born on April 28, 1926, in Moroeville Alabama, where her father practiced as a lawyer and served as a state senator. She grew up as the youngest out of 4 children, and was the only one to pursue a literary career. She received her early education in public schools, and from 1945-1949 she attended University of Alabama, studying law.
Point Of View In Aandp Essay Research
Paper Point of View This story is written entirely from the perspective of nineteen year old Sammy, a grocery clerk. Updike has created an atmosphere of striking opposites warring with one another throughout the entire story. Sammy is bored and excited at the same time. He has worked in the A&P long enough to have memorized every item that is sold in the aisle directly in front of his cash register as well as what is generally for sale in all the areas of the store.
Personal Computers And Laptop Computers Essay Research
Paper The two types of computers that are the most common people use are the Personal computer, and the Laptop computer. Most people would say that there is not that much difference between the two, but they have no idea how wrong they are.
Hiroshima Essay Research Paper Hiroshima is a
Hiroshima Essay, Research Paper Hiroshima is a book about human existence. There is several main characters in the book. The book goes through each of the persons lives from the day the Atom bomb was dropped until approximately one year later. The characters range from a clerk that works in a tin factory, a Dr. that owns his own hospital, a tailors widow, a German priest, another young doctor that is a member of a hospitals surgical staff and, a Reverend.
David Copperfield Summary Essay Research Paper David
David Copperfield Summary Essay, Research Paper David Copperfield enjoys his early childhood with his mother and their kindly servant, Peggotty. But when his mother marries the cruel Mr. Murdstone, he is sent away to Salem House, a run-down London boarding school where the boys are beaten by Mr. Creakle.
Canterbury
– Humour In Two Tales Essay, Research Paper Humor was used in the medieval time period to express one’s ideas and thoughts. Geoffrey Chaucer also used humor in The Canterbury Tales in different instances. In “The Nun’s Priest Tale” and “The Miller’s Tale” I will show you how he uses humor to describe characters, his use of language and the actual events that take place.
CourtA Essay Research Paper Court Trip Essay
Court(A) Essay, Research Paper Court Trip Essay – Efficiency and Effectiveness of our Criminal Court System Our court systems have, in recent years, been said to beinefficient, sometimes ineffective, and even backlogged to thepoint where cases have to be dismissed because of how long ittakes for them to get to court.
Metamorphosis Essay Research Paper When reading Franz
Metamorphosis Essay, Research Paper When reading Franz Kafka?s, ?The Metamorphosis? there are three main insecurities that Gregor Samsa experiences. The title ?The Metamorphosis?, suggests that changes in Samsa?s life are causing him to feel insecure about the relationships between: Gregor and himself, Gregor and his job, and Gregor and his family.
Machiavelli 2 Essay Research Paper Niccolo Machiavelli
Machiavelli 2 Essay, Research Paper Niccolo Machiavelli was born in Florence on May 3, 1469. While working as a clerk in the government, he gained stature when the Florentine Republic was established in 1498. Machiavelli supervised the military operations of the republic. He also was the secretary of the ten-man council that conducted the diplomatic negotiations.
Concealed Weapons In Michigan Essay Research Paper
When applying for a license to carry a concealed firearm, in Michigan you must first submit an application containing two references, a letter from your employer, a set of finger prints, and it must all be notarized. The forms are then taken to the chief of police or township supervisor for their approval who will then forward the forms to the county clerk.
A Bill Becomes A Law Essay Research
Paper When a Senator or a Representative introduces a bill, he or she sends it to the clerk of his or her house, who gives it a number and title. This is the first reading, and the bill is referred to the proper committee.
How A Bill Becomes A Law Essay
, Research Paper A delegate or senator has an idea for a bill, usually from a constituent. He or she presents the idea to the Division of Legislative Services and requests that it be drafted into a bill. The bill is signed by the patron, introduced, and printed.
Charles Dickens Essay Research Paper Charles John
Charles Dickens Essay, Research Paper Charles John Huffam Dickens was born in Portsmouth in 1812, the second child of a large family. His father was the son of a butler and a housekeeper, and worked as a clerk in the Navy Pay Office. The family moved to London when Dickens was three and to Chatham in Kent two years later.
The Assistant Character Analysis Essay Research Paper
The Assistant: Character Analysis The Assistant is a novel written by Bernard Malamud. It is a story set during the Depression. This story involves several key characters. The two protagonists are Frank Alpine, a drifter, and Morris Bober, a Jewish grocery store clerk. Morris’ wife Ida and daughter Helen are also heavily involved in the story.
Robert Browning Essay Research Paper BJ GilstrapEnglishMarch
Robert Browning Essay, Research Paper B.J. Gilstrap English March 20, 1999 Biography of Robert Browning Robert Browning was born on May 7, 1812, in Camberwell (a suburb of London), the first child of Robert and Sarah Anna Browning. His mother was a fervent and an accomplished pianist. Mr. Browning had angered his own father and forgone a fortune: the poet’s grandfather had sent his son to oversee a West Indies sugar plantation, but the young man had found the institution of slavery so abhorrent that he gave up his prospects and returned home, to become a clerk in the Bank of England.
Updike John Essay Research Paper John Updike
Updike, John Essay, Research Paper John Updike A & P Gone are the days that humans could live impulsively, only taking physical pain and pleasure into account when making decisions. Or so one would like to believe. In a display of sheer innocence and ignorance, Sammy, a grocery clerk at the A & P, managed to revert back to the original behavior patterns of his ape-like ancestors.
Bill Clinton Vs Paula Jones Essay Research
Paper A lawsuit has been filed by Paula Jones, a clerk for the Arkansas Industrial Development Commission, for sexual harassment by then Governor Clinton. In her lawsuit, Paula Jones states that Clinton told an Arkansas State trooper to escort her to a private hotel room where she claims that she was sexually harassed.
The Metamorphosis Essay Research Paper Gregor was
The Metamorphosis Essay, Research Paper Gregor was the most unselfish person in The Metamorphosis. This characteristic shows with his dedication to his work. He was the only family member with a job, believing he was the only one capable of it.