Mccarthy And Faulkner Essay, Research Paper
I will never claim to be an expert as an undergrad at anything, but in my personal opinion, McCarthy is not the son of Faulkner in the Southern Literary Renaissance. McCarthy and Faulkner share common view in the complexities of nature and its subsequent weave with the human condition. The psychological complexity of Faulkner also stems from his desire to explore the true heart of people and not their surfaces (note his Nobel Prize Speech). While McCarthy exposes personalities and creates unbelievable characterizations (the Judge) I don’t personally feel that sometimes a true soul is left out. I do not believe that this takes away from his writing, but he would probably focus on distancing himself as far from the Faulkner stigma southern writers are labeled with in order to produce a distinct new form of literature (which in some realms he has).
The violence stems from human nature and has been a part of literature for centuries. Most notably, the Victorians may have influenced McCarthy with depressing yet duty bound works as Hardy’s Jude the Obscure and Browning’s poetry of destruction and desolation.
Then again, this is just my unqualified position dashed out at a first response. Thank you for your time and would like to read others opinions.
From: Christian the Heretic
What in God’s name are you talking about? You’re sounding as logical as Fat Freddie Freak after a long speed binge. How can you possibly say that Faulkner is not an influence on McCarthy’s fiction? It doesn’t make sense. I will agree with you that there are certainly other influences and these are as pervasive (perhaps) as Faulkner, but Faulkner is all through McCarthy’s work.
This is a “hot button” for me as well since I’m currently working on Light in August in comparison to Outer Dark and Child of God. First the writing style IS similar, although this is arguable from any perspective. While Faulkner uses huge and bulky sentences, McCarthy tends to use a similar rhythm broken by periodic periods. I realize that my explanation of this makes no sense. A more definable and arguable position is with the themes that lie in Faulkner’s work. Particularly when we view LIA, we see characters living on the “borderlands” of society. Joe Christmas, Lena Grove, Byron Bunch, Gail Hightower, Johanna Burden–all of them are characters who (like Rinthy and Lester Ballard and all the rest of them jake legged melon *censored*ing necrophiliac sons of bitches) exist on the borderlands. And there is certainly a mirroring of Faulkner’s treatment of Joe Christmas and McCarthy’s treatment of Lester Ballard, not to mention the Rinthy Holme / Lena Grove parallels. Both Faulkner and McCarthy like to play with Christian imagery (as characters with more than one father ala Christ and all the other Biblical imagery in LIA among others).
This is all to say that Faulkner is certainly an influence on McCarthy. True that scholars are perhaps beating that influence to death at the expense of looking at other influences but that doesn’t mean that it’s not there–any such argument smacks of a knee jerk reaction.
From: Anonymous
As you can see, there’s a good case to be made for McCarthy as an inheritor of Faulkner and as a new breed, more closely akin to O’Connor or (it pains me slightly to agree with Mr. Wallach) even Hemingway. My own opinion is that critics tend to lump McCarthy into the Faulknerian school primarily because he’s prone to using long, viny sentences. Secondarily, the fact that both authors usually address characters and situations which are outcast, marginalized, etc., makes for easy categorization. While these similarities are substantial, there is a difference in method (rather than style) which, I think, distinguishes the McC’s approach from Faulkner’s. At the core of this difference is the fact that Faulkner’s prose takes place, and is generally constructed around, the internal environments of his characters. To some degree his writing can be described as comparative psychological portraiture (forgive me for interjecting my own made-up jargon here). McCarthy, to make a slightly tired point, stays external in regard to his characters, treating them as artifacts or products of the world. They play roles in the “grand scheme of things” (especially evident in the closing of Blood Meridian) and their individual personalities are entirely secondary to these roles. Maybe you could say, or I could suggest, that in Faulkner the outside world is a reflection or a consequence of the characters’ internal makeup, while in McCarthy the internal makeup is only sufficient to the tasks of the outside world. Does this offend anyone’s sensibilities?
From: Rick Wallach
Probably it offends lots of sensibilities, but that’s surely no reason to retract your comments. The problem with studies of “influence” in modern criticism is that when we speak of influence, we usually mean “cause”…as in, Faulkner “causes” McCarthy’s style. This unfortunate (and often involuntary) brand of illogic is probably a byproduct of the pedagogic imperative to argue rather than demonstrate — which, in turn, is a subspecies of the old H.L. Mencken observation that “the reason academic politics is so vicious is that the stakes are so small.”
But if not “cause,” how then does “influence” operate? How do you prove that the mere fact of a sequence of two authors’ preoccupation with similar themes represents “influence” as opposed to mere observation of comparable phenomena in the world around both of them? Are we justified in using the term “influence” when what we observe is the dialogue between an author and a predecessor? Is one author’s deliberate parody of a situation or a character in an earlier author’s work…ie, the Rinthy Holme / Lena Grove correlation…a form of “influence” ? I’m not sure about that…such broad-form recourse to a term like “influence” empties it of specificity and makes a cliche out of it. I submit, however, that the only time McCarthy actually “sounds” anything like Faulkner is in The Crossing, where his sentences tend to get away from him and unravel like a dropped string ball, in an incidental mimicry of Absalom, Absalom’s torturously synthetic diction.
At any rate, I certainly agree with one thing Christian the Heretic said — that his “explanation”of the “similarity” between McCarthy’s sentence construction and Faulkner’s makes no sense at all. If I got this right, he seems to argue that Faulkner constructs his sentences the same way as McCarthy, except that he uses different types of words and punctuation. Uh…okay, I can live with that assertion, I suppose. But don’t look for it to surface in Chris’s forthcoming article in Southern Quarterly. Betcha he plays it safer there!
Другие работы по теме:
Faulkner And Mccarthy
– Styles Essay, Research Paper William Faulkner and Cormac McCarthy are known for their unusual, yet honest, styles of writing. Using a variety of sentence structure, vocabulary, and syntax, the two authors allow readers to explore deeper into the true meanings behind the well-told story lines. In Faulkner s The Unvanquished and McCarthy s All the Pretty Horses, these techniques, which parallel and contrast each other, are very apparent and convey messages to the reader that help to express the passage of boyhood into manhood.
Things Are Not What They Seem Essay
, Research Paper Things Are Not Always What They Seem William Faulkner s short story A Rose for Emily centers around Miss Emily and what the townspeople think of Miss Emily. One of the themes for A Rose for Emily is appearance versus reality. This theme of appearance versus reality can be seen through what the townspeople think of Miss Emily and by the actions taken by Miss Emily.
Usage Of Elements Of Fiction In A
Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper When a person reads a story, he or she is aware of many types of elements of fiction. An author uses elements of fiction to make his or her story move and read in a way that will make the story enjoyable and a thrill to read. By using these elements in the right way, the author creates an abundance of suspense within the reader, making the reader wonder what is to come.
Was Communism Feared Essay Research Paper Why
Was Communism Feared Essay, Research Paper Why Was Communism Feared? After WWII, Americans knew they lived in the strongest and “greatest” country on earth. They were however afraid
Rose For Emily Essay Research Paper Fall
Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper Fall of Emily Life is fickle and most people will be a victim of circumstance and the times. Some people choose not to let circumstance rule them and, as they say, “time waits for no man”. Faulkner?s Emily did not have the individual confidence, or maybe self-esteem and self-worth, to believe that she could stand alone and succeed at life especially in the face of changing times.
Narrator Description Essay Research Paper What is
Narrator Description Essay, Research Paper What is narrator? Narrator is the voice the author creates to tell the story. The possible ways of telling a story are many, and more than one way can be
Mccarthism Essay Research Paper Poli Sci 2304Prof
Mccarthism Essay, Research Paper Poli Sci 2304 Prof. Linehan What Senator Joseph McCarthy has taught me about Politics, America and Myself. Senator Joseph McCarthy was one of the most relentless, ambitious, and strongest anti-Communist Americans America has ever seen. America in the state of panic it was in formed the House Un-American Activities Committee, which was overshadowed by McCarthy alone.
Narrator Essay Research Paper What is narrator
Narrator Essay, Research Paper What is narrator? Narrator is the voice the author creates to tell the story. The possible ways of telling a story are many, and more than one way can be worked into a single story. Conventionally, the various narrators that storytellers draw upon can be grouped into four broad groups: the third-person narrator, the first-person narrator, the omniscient narrator and the witness narrator.
Critique On A Rose For Emily Essay
, Research Paper “A Rose for Emily is a very popular short story because of its, style , climax, and plot. The author, William Faulkner, was a “Southern” writer from Oxford, Mississippi. FAulkner bases this story on the tale of Oxford’s aristrocratic ” Miss Mary ” Neilson. She married Captain jack Hume, the charming yankee foreman of a street-paving crew, over her family’s shocked protests.
An Old South Feeling In
” A Rose For Emily.” Essay, Research Paper After the Civil War, many Confederate soldiers returned home and founded nothing and many had no place to stay. Many people that God was punishing them for all the sins that they had done to the blacks. But many other Southerners refuse to accept that they were defeated by the Union.
The Crucible My Point Of View Essay
, Research Paper The Crucible by Arthur Miller was written during the early 1950s at the time of Senator Joseph McCarthy’s House Un-American Activities Committee hearings on the infiltration of Communism in the United States and the loyalty to democracy of many prominent U.S. citizens. The McCarthy hearings pitted artists and performers against each other as they were called to testify about their own loyalty and what they knew about the loyalty of others.
The Good Earth Essay Research Paper Good
The Good Earth Essay, Research Paper Good evening, we the graduating class of blessed sacrament school would like to welcome you to our 8th grade graduation. On behalf of the graduating class I especially would like to welcome Fr. McCarthy and Fr. Hand, Dr. Rouke, Teachers, Parents, relatives, and friends to our graduating ceremony.
Letting Go Essay Research Paper Letting GoMany
Letting Go Essay, Research Paper Letting Go Many people hate to let things go. People find security and comfort in their possessions and the company they keep. If all this is ripped away from a person, it can
The Crucible Salem Witch Trials Vs. The Mccarthy
Hearings Essay, Research Paper In the play, The Crucible, many parallels can be found in reference to the 1950 Communist trials led by Joe McCarthy. In this work by Arthur Miller, the events of the 1692 Salem witch trials parallel those of the McCarthy trials, in that, both events were not only based on insubstantial evidence but caused mass hysteria that destroyed the lives and reputations of those involved.
Cold War Essay Research Paper The Nature
Cold War Essay, Research Paper The Nature of the Cold War during the Truman and Eisenhower Administrations In the 1950 s the fear of the cold war was felt in every home throughout America. Genuine fear was the feeling of the public. This fear was partially due to the government s way of informing the public of the threat of a cold war.
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper In William
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper In William Faulkner’s Nobel Prize Acceptance Speech, he says, “He writes not of love but of lust, of defeats in which nobody loses anything of value, and victories without hope and worst of all, without pity or compassion.” William Faulkner is referring to “He” as the typical writer today.
Senator Joeseph Mccarthy
– Life History Essay, Research Paper Who was Joseph McCarthy? Joseph R. McCarthy was born in 1908 on a family farm in Wisconsin. He went to a country school and decided he was done with his education at the young age of 14. After that, he explained to his family that he was finished with his studies and wanted to become a farmer like his father.
Barn Burning By Faulkner Essay Research Paper
In William Faulkner?s ?Barn Burning,? the main character is Colonel Sartoris Snopes, or ?Sarty? for short. This young boy is torn between loyalty to his father and morality, and this story deals with that struggle.
The Crucible And The Mccarthy Era Essay
, Research Paper The Crucible and the McCarthy Era Arthur Miller s The Crucible, depicts the Salem witchcraft trials of 1692 but is analogous to the McCarthy trials of the 1950s. In both situations, widespread hysteria occurs, stemming from existing fears of the people of that particular era. The Salem witchhunt trials parallel the McCarthy era in three major aspects: unfounded accusations, hostile interrogation of numerous innocent people and the ruination and death of various people s lives.
The Styles And Themes Of Willi Essay
, Research Paper One of the greatest writers of the 20th century is William Faulkner. He was born and raised in the southern state of Mississippi which greatly influenced his style of writing. Faulkner liked to use a variety of styles and themes in his works. In one of his most famous books, As I Lay Dying, he uses streams of consciousness, while in, A Rose for Emily, his style and theme is very morbid and grotesque.
Mccarthy Era And Salem Witch Trials Essay
, Research Paper The McCarthy Era and the Salem Witch Trials The McCarthy era is very similar to the Salem Witch trials. They are both similar, because they both dealt with hysteria. Hysteria is an
The Sound And The Fury By William
Faulkner 1929 Essay, Research Paper “They took the flag out, and they were hitting. Then they put the flag back and they went to the table, and he hit and the other hit. Then they went on, and I went along
After The Fall Essay Research Paper After
After The Fall Essay, Research Paper After the Fall Arthur Miller has written many great plays in his life, such as A View from the Bridge ,Death of a Salesman ,The Misfits, The Crucible, and After the Fall. Out of all his
William Faulkners
“As I Lay Dying” Essay, Research Paper The main purpose for most of William Faulkner?s novel, As I Lay Dying, is to bury their beloved mother and wife, Addie Bundren, in a town called Jefferson, which is a very long and strenuous trip for them to make. The statement death shapes life perfectly describes this chain of events.
The Barn Burning Blues Essay Research Paper
William Faulkner’s short story, “Barn Burning”, is about a family’s struggle created by their father. the main character and father, Abner Snopes, is a self-ritous “no-good” who
A Rose For Emily By William Faulkner
Essay, Research Paper The story A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner in my opinion was a very interesting story. The story was about a old and troubled woman named Emily Grierson who because of her father?s death had become one of the towns obligation?s and also one of it?s problems. Emily a very stubborn old lady who refused to pay her taxes because of a little tale that Colonel Sartoris who was the mayor at the time had told her.
A Roses For Emily Essay Research Paper
william faulkner’s “A Rose For Emily’, and Charlotte Gilman’s “A Yellow Wall paper” are alike in many ways. The two women are in similar situations, both are violated by
A Rose For Emily Critical Analysis Essay
, Research Paper William Faulkner, a writer brought up in the South, displayed the upbringing and lifestyles of people in a certain town. The theme revolved around the life of a lady name Emily Grierson. She is a southern woman, whose failed attempt at life is kept secret from her town until her death. By explaining her upbringing by a stern father, her midlife climax and her slow journey through a secluded life to her death, Faulkner shows how clinging on to tradition by Emily’s father ruined her life.
Transendentalism Through Franklin Emerson And Thoreau Essay
, Research Paper With the amount of changes in the narrative, it is no surprise Faulkner is known as the most inventive experimenter in the American modernist prose, and that later American novelists look back fearfully at his shadow (Parker cover). Throughout each of these chapters Faulkner has presented the story in non-sequential bits and pieces, with many flashbacks into the past through the minds of several different people.
A Rose Essay Research Paper A Rose
A Rose Essay, Research Paper A Rose In the 1930’s people still thrive on gossip, particularly in a small town. People are overly curious and cruel at times, especially when it comes to Emily Grierson’s mental disorder. In “ A Rose for Emily,” William Faulkner traces Miss Emily’s increasing dementia and foreshadows the surprise ending.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper The witch
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper The witch trials in Salem, Massachusetts in the early sixteen hundreds was a time of uneasiness and suspicion. Anyone could easily turn in his or her neighbor on the
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper Biography on
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper Biography on William Faulkner William Faulkner was born in New Albany, Mississippi on September 25, 1897 and then moved to Oxford, Mississippi with his family at the age of 5. Most of the novels written by William Faulkner take place in the area in which he himself was born and raised.
Rose For Emily Essay Research Paper Analysis
Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper Analysis of ?A Rose for Emily? In William Faulkner?s short story, ?A Rose for Emily,? obsession plays a key role in the developing personality of the protagonist, Emily Grierson. Because Emily was
Symbolism In A Rose For Emily Essay
, Research Paper William Faulkner?s ?A Rose for Emily? is a story that addresses the symbolic changes in the South after the civil war. Miss Emily’s house symbolizes neglect and poverty of the new times in the town of Jefferson. The rampant symbolism and Faulkner’s descriptions of the decaying house, coincide with Miss Emily’s physical and emotional decay, and also emphasize her mental degeneration, and further illustrate the outcome of Faulkner’s story.