Essay, Research Paper
Haig v. Agee: Power to Revoke Passports
Whether a passport can be revoked or not has been a major question since
the mid- 1800’s. Haig v. Agee is a landmark Supreme Court case charging that
the Secretary of State can not revoke a passport on the grounds that the power
has never been granted by the Congress to the Secretary, and that revoking a
passport violates the first and fifth amendments of the Constitution of the
United States. Not only does the Secretary of State have implied powers, but
revoking Agee’s passport did not violate any laws or rights.
In Haig v. Agee, the defendant claims that the Passport Act of 1926 does
not grant the Secretary of State the right to revoke passports. However, the
Passport Act does state that the Secretary of State is the only person who can
grant and withhold passport applications. And based upon later provisions, the
Secretary can withhold applications if the party is involved with illegal
activities. If the Secretary of State can grant and withhold passports, was it
implied by the Congress that the Secretary has the powers to revoke passports?
“The Secretary of State may grant and issue passports, and cause passports to be
granted, issued, and verified in foreign countries by diplomatic representatives
of the United States . . . under such rules as the President shall designated
and prescribe for and on behalf of the United States, and no other person shall
grant, issue, or verify such passports.” 22 U.S.C. 211a (1976 ed., Supp. IV).
Since the Congress did not specify who has the powers to revoke passports, it
should be assumed that because the Secretary is the only person who can grant
passports, they are the only ones who can revoke passports on grounds of illegal
activities, such as treason. If you consider that Agee’s passport was revoked
because he was uncovering secret CIA agents, he was undoubtedly committing
treason. Though treason is usually considered to be evident during times of war,
treason can also be defined as placing national security in jeopardy, such as
the case of Agee. Agee’s passport should not only have been taken, he should
have been extradited and tried by a jury for the crime of treason.
Agee also claims that since the power to revoke passports was not
directly given to the Secretary of State or the President, then in order to show
they have the power, they must have revoked many passports in the past and have
the Congress’ approval. However, the need to revoke passports on the grounds of
treason has not come up many times before; There is always a first and Agee
might just have been it. The Congress did show approval when they voted to
approve the President’s provisions and amendments on the matter of revoking
passports in 1978. This shows that the Congress agrees that the Executive
branch has been recognized as having the power to revoke passports.
By revoking a passport, the government is not infringing on the party’s
first amendment rights, freedom of speech. The party involved is merely being
told that they cannot leave the country, not that they cannot speak out against
the government. For example, if a person is sentenced to jail, they cannot roam
around the world, but they can speak out against the government. Revoking
Agee’s passport only limits where he can go, not what he can say; This does not
infringe on any of his rights granted in the Constitution. Revoking a passport
also does not infringe upon the fifth amendment because illegal activities are
involved. For example, if you commit a crime, the police do not wait until
after you go before a judge and/or jury before they put you in jail; They
immediately incarcerate you as a precautionary move. Revoking a passport on
grounds of national security does not require a hearing before hand because it
is only a precautionary move.
Agee’s grounds for suit are totally ludicrous. None of his rights have
been violated, considering that he should have none because he is committing
treason by revealing secrets of the United States and by compromising national
security. Congress may not have said exactly who has the power to revoke
passports, but they did mention that the Secretary of state is the only person
who can grant and verify them; Why wouldn’t the Secretary of State be the only
person who can revoke them?
Sources:
U.S. Supreme Court, HAIG v. AGEE, 453 U.S. 280 (1981)
Другие работы по теме:
Power Essay Research Paper Power is as
Power Essay, Research Paper Power is, as anyone will tell you, a tantalizing addiction. The natural human craving for power derives from the simple ideals of a genuflecting mass of humanity; bowing, scraping, praising and carrying out one?s every whim. The sheer exhilaration of controlling, manipulating, and yes, even hurting someone is almost too much for out feeble minds to overcome.
Examples Of The 4 Faces Of Power
Essay, Research Paper Four Faces of Power An example of the first face of power would be what we called ?Initiation Day? at my old high school. At the beginning of the season, my field hockey team would be divided into ?big sisters? and ?little sisters.? The ?big sister? (which is an upperclassman) has power over the ?little sister? (an underclassman), to the extent that the ?little sister? would do something she would not normally do.
Famine Essay Research Paper The Battles of
Famine Essay, Research Paper The Battles of Ypres, 1914, 1915, 1917 There were in fact three battles fought around the Ypres salient during the War. The first, in 1914 was an attempt by theBEF to halt the rapid advances made by the Germans. The second, in 1915, was notable for the first use of poison gas bythe Germans.
Mrs Pollifax Essay Research Paper The Elusive
Mrs. Pollifax Essay, Research Paper The Elusive Mrs. Pollifax is one of my favorite books of all times! An old, brittle woman in the CIA has to sneak eight forged passports into Bulgaria, and get out as fast as possible without being suspicious. But
Power In Macbeth Essay Research Paper There
Power In Macbeth Essay, Research Paper There are many different types of power which a person may have. Some of the time, however, the person in that power is not the best person to be in that power. This is especially true in William Shakespeare’s Macbeth. Throughout the course of the play, the Three Witches and Lady Macbeth are the people with the most power over Macbeth’s life.
Is General Haig A Butcher Essay Research
Paper The Battle of the Somme: Haig was ultimately responsible for the planning and direction of the series of battles known collectively as the Battle of the Somme. Despite his awareness of what had gone wrong at Neuve Chappelle, and again at Loos, and the failure of these battles, Haig still repeated the same principles of attack, although on a vastly greater scale.
Walker Evans Essay Research Paper One of
Walker Evans Essay, Research Paper One of America s greatest and most influential photographers, Walker Evans is credited with creating a vision of life in the 1930 s as Americans would wish to see themselves: dignified and indomitable, even in the face of poverty and despair. He was a documentary photography pioneer whose portraits of the common man have earned him comparison with another American artist, Walt Whitman, Yet Evans might well have died in obscurity if not for a collaboration with the writer James Agee in 1936.
The Power Of One One Person Can
Change The World Essay, Research Paper The Power Of One: One Person Can Change the World Dave Brown W. History per. 7 4/17/96 I believe very firmly that one person can change the world. That one
Main Thought Of Hamlet Essay Research Paper
What I believe to be the main and most important theme of Hamlet is that power corrupts and kills. This is evident in many parts of this play. In the first half of this tale, Shakespeare shows us that the power King Hamlet gave to his brother (free run of the castle, ability to get where the king slept) let to the king’s death.
Power Essay Research Paper Hydro Power
Power Essay, Research Paper Hydro Power My alternative power source is Hydro power. It comes from water. The oldest and simplest form was the water wheel first used in ancient Greece for grinding grain. The water wheel design was changed by Jean Victor Poncelet in the 18th century. He made the blades curved which raised the efficiency by 70 percent.
Medea By Euripides Essay Research Paper Through
Medea By Euripides Essay, Research Paper Through the play Medea, Euripides shows us the importance of keeping a promise given. At the beginning of the story, we see the play?s two opposing views of
Field Marshal Haig Essay Research Paper Douglas
Field Marshal Haig Essay, Research Paper Douglas Haig was born on June 19 1861, the son of a wealthy whiskey distiller, he was educated at Oxford and Sandhurst. Haig participated in the Omdurman campaign (1897 – 1898) and the Boer War (1899 – 1902). His rank remained inspector of general cavalry in India from 1903 until 1906, when he became director of military training at the war office.
Power In Negotiating Essay Research Paper What
Power In Negotiating Essay, Research Paper What is power in negotiating? Is it finesse? Is a real? Is it perceived? It could be all these things and more. Power in negotiating is defined by the book pass “the ability to bring about outcomes they desire” or “the ability to get things done the way one wants to be to to”.
An Extended Abstract Defintion Of
‘Power’ Essay, Research Paper Power is many things. It is the ability to control people in their sayings and/or actions. It is the ability to get whatever you want. Power is a necessary component in any society,
Is The WW1 Stalemate The General
’s Fault? Essay, Research Paper Was the Four Years on the Western Front the Generalsґ fault? There are many different perspectives to the question above. I intend to look at some and say reasons why they are to blame and why some blame could be put on other people. Most people think they are to blame but most of them have not heard the arguments why they are not to blame.
Percy ShelleyS Hymn To Intellectual Beauty Essay
, Research Paper In Percy Shelley?s poem ?Hymn to Intellectual Beauty?, he writes about many abstract powers. Through his usage of similes, the reader is able to get a sense of what his relationships are with abstract thoughts, in particular Power and Beauty. We are especially able to get this feel by looking at Shelley?s infusion of mortal phenomena with these abstracts.
The State Essay Research Paper The state
The State Essay, Research Paper The state is like God, some believe that it?s the all mighty powerful being that controls all and others just think it?s a big overblown idea. The idea of the state (and God) is fairly confusing but rarely ever challenged, except by those rare few who seem to form their own opinions.
Nuclear Power Plant In Saskatchewan Essay Research
Paper Should There Be A Nuclear Power Plant In Saskatchewan? I think there should be a nuclear power plant built in Saskatchewan because I believe it would contribute to the province a great deal. There is a
Fellowship Of The Ring Essay Research Paper
The Fellowship of the Ring, by J.R.R. Tolkien, is the first book in the fantasy-based trilogy of the Lord of the Rings. The book begins with Bilbo Baggins celebrating his one hundred and eleventh birthday. After his party, he
American Government And Politics Essay Research Paper
American Government and Politics The founders of this country wanted a government with have power, but they didn t want a government with too much of it. To accomplish this they wrote ways to limit the government s use of power. By doing this they also enable the citizens of he country to remain free and not have to worry about the government have too much power.
The Godfather Essay Research Paper Violence and
The Godfather Essay, Research Paper Violence and The Godfather Throughout time there have always been people who held more power than others. There are many different methods used to both demonstrate and maintain the power which they possess. Often times violence is the method chosen to achieve these goals.
Ignorance Is Not Bliss Essay Research Paper
Nicholas Sine Period Four 4-6-98 Ignorance is Not Bliss “Ignorance is the primary source of all misery and vice.” –Victor Cousin. As knowledge gives us the power to create, ignorance gives us the power to destroy. Over
Maltese Falcon Essay Research Paper The Portrayal
Maltese Falcon Essay, Research Paper The Portrayal of the Characters in the Maltesse Falcon suffers from transistion to the Huston film. Spade is portrayed to have much more power in the Huston film than in the book. He seems to have more control over Brigid and the whole on going situation.
Hoop Dreams Essay Research Paper HOOP DREAMS
Hoop Dreams Essay, Research Paper HOOP DREAMS “Hoop Dreams” by Ben Joravsky, is about two kids Arthur Agee and William Gates who are just starting high-school and playing high-school basketball. These two kids from the projects of Chicago’s West Side are chasing their dreams of playing basketball in the NBA, and making it through life.
Hoop Dreams Essay Research Paper HOOP DREAMSMain
Hoop Dreams Essay, Research Paper HOOP DREAMS Main Idea The book Hoop Dreams Paul Robert Walker shows how life can work against you in every way imagined no matter how hard you work. It shows how all good can turn to
The Importance Of Balance Of Power In
Europe Essay, Research Paper B.O.P. essay Without losers, there would be no winners. Moreover, if there were no evil in the world, then kindness would not exist. This is exactly the way the principle of balance of power in Europe operates. It prevented empires, and helped to aid lesser states in their times of need.
Pollution Essay Research Paper Pollution What is
Pollution Essay, Research Paper Pollution. What is pollution? According to the Merriam Webster Dictionary pollution is ?the action of polluting esp. by environmental contamination with man-made waste.? The United States runs on power. Much of the United States? powers come from various nuclear power plants all across the country.
Euthansia Article Analysis And Opinion Essay Research
Paper Euthanasia is the help with a death and is also known as ?mercy killing?. There are two types of Euthanasia: Active euthanasia and passive euthanasia. There is also active voluntary euthanasia and active involuntary euthanasia. Euthanasia is illegal in all states but Oregon, who passed a bill making it legal in 1994 under certain circumstances.
Power Corruption In The Book Kindred
Essay, Research Paper Power itself contains two sides, depending on the individual who possesses it. Power is like a plague, very contagious. Power in the right hands creates freedom, peace and fairness. Power in the wrong hands induces despotism, tyranny and persecution. In the novel “Kindred”, composed by Octavia Butler, power corrupted characters constantly.
Political Power Essay Research Paper Political power
Political Power Political power can simply be defined as the power to influence. The power to influence is essentially the power to control. When pertaining to political matters, the most influential people in any form of government have the most power. The underlying argument is between who has the most influence.
The Battle Of Passchendale Essay Research Paper
Passchendaele was a battle that began in July of 1917, and the British commander in charge was Sir Douglas Haig. He conducted the battle under the orders from General Robert Nivelle, while the reorganization of the French army (due to mutiny) was happening. After careful planning, Douglas Haig prepared to attack, the preliminary attack was the heaviest to occur so far, in a period of ten days approximately 3100 guns fired more than four and a half million shells.
MS Power Point Essay Research Paper Reflection
MS Power Point Essay, Research Paper Reflection on MS Power Point The Microsoft Power Point presentation that we just completed was a fun project. I learned how to set up Power Point slides while infiltrating animation and sound.
The Misuse Of Power Essay Research Paper
The Misuse of Power If a person hears the word power, he/she would probably think of the power of the Presidency of the Unites States, the power of a Supreme Court Justice, the power of a CEO of a major corporation, or even the power of a police officer. All of these positions are excellent examples of power, but there is no greater power than the power of a parent over a child.
Case study Ford and Honda
Case study: Ford and Honda Haig Simonian on two car groups' different routes to the global market. Rising costs and the worldwide spread of shared tastes in car styling have prompted the industry's giants to exploit global economies of scale. But rivals such as Ford and Honda have approached the task very differently.