Admitting The Holocaust Essay, Research Paper
Admitting the Holocaust by Lawrence L. Langer is a collection of essays
about the Holocaust and how it is perceived in literature by our culture.
Langer explores oral testimonies, diaries and fiction that consider the
devastation of the Holocaust a central theme. He takes a look at human
values in the light of that devastation. He exhibits the concern between
literature and testimony. His hope is that the Holocaust experience will not
be sentimentalized in the various forms of literature and media. Langer wants
the Holocaust to be presented as it really was — evil.
Throughout his book Langer makes reference to various other writers
novels and articles about the death camps. He criticizes such authors as
William Styron and Bernard Malamud. According to Langer ( Beyond
Theodicy: Jewish Victims and the Holocaust and Malamud s Jews and
the Holocaust Experience, ), too many historical and cultural
representations of the Nazis murderers try, by portraying the Jewish victims
as dignified martyrs, to introduce the notion of spiritual redemption into the
accounts of atrocities that need to be confronted without moral
oversimplification. He rejects the works of Malamud who found in
suffering a source or spiritual strength, a moral advantage. In the essays
A Tainted Legacy: Remembering the Warsaw Ghetto and Ghetto
Chronicles: Life at the Brink Langer criticizes accounts that present
heroism, suffering and religious experience as a central theme. He writes:
Jews were destroyed by humans, not God … in a historical, not religious,
moment of suffering … whether they chose or not, men died for nothing.
He finds it unimaginable that any sane person could write, It is a great
privilege to have been chosen to bear this. (Etty Hilsum)
He also criticizes the usual portrayal of the Holocaust on television and
stage ( The Americanization of the Holocaust on Stage and Screen ). To
Langer, the language used in the portrayals is designed to console, not to
confront. In describing his review of historical studies of the Holocaust,
Langer strongly objects to the use of abstract terms like the murder of 6
million and says that the accounts of the total destruction of the European
Jewry should be told in graphic detail. In Cultural Resistance to
Genocide, Langer points out that by the use of the expression cultural
resistance to genocide we are given some type of consolation to the events
before we even begin to grasp any type of understanding. He suggests that
we are more accurate if we use the expression cultural witness to genocide.
He is offended by memorials such as Yad Vashem in Jerusalem because it
was created by the Heroes and Martyrs Remembrance Authority. Langer
says: Jews were nullified, not sacrificed, murdered, not martyred.
Lawrence Langer refers to the movie Schindler s List which gave a
depiction of Holocaust victims, resisters or survivors. Although a candid
portrayal of the Jewish ordeal in World War II, leaves the viewer with
memories of a healing wound rather than a throbbing scar. He writes: the
Holocaust story cannot be told in terms of heroic dignity, moral courage and
the triumph of the human spirit. He strives to point out that the media has
its limitations in what they put out to the public. In this aspect, there must
be a more conscience effort made to effectively communicate the absolute
horror of the Holocaust to the public.
In Fictional Facts and Factual Fictions: History in Holocaust
literature, he criticizes Leslie Epstein s account of Chaim Rumkowski s
leadership in King of the Jews. The actual details were not full of comedy
and farce as Epstein related. He finds the same sort of artistic exploitation
in other author s works which he suggests that maybe the fact of time has
diminished the absolute horror, however, objects strongly to these renditions.
He also criticizes Polish author, Tadeusz Borowski, ( The Americanization
of the Holocaust on Stage and Screen ) and points out that the true accounts
are those that tell of the graphic details of the destruction of European Jews.
In Myth and Truth in Cynthia Osick s The Shawl and Rosa , he
praises the writings of author Cynthia Ozick who points out that like Rosa s
underpants the truth is what has been lost can never be found. He praises
the accounts of Charlotte Delbo in None of Us Will Return. Several times
Langer refers to Jean Amery s (Beyond Guilt and Atonement; translated into
English-At the Mind s Limit) observation that no bridge led from death in
Auschwitz to Death in Venice. Langer suggests that Auschwitz
introduced the realm of the unthinkable into the human drama ( The
Literature of Auschwitz ).
Langer gives much of his focus to the issue of authors, movie producers
and others using the events of the Holocaust for the purpose of promoting
some type of private agenda such as: women s plight in the concentration
camps; the conflicting claims of individual and community survival in the
Kovno ghetto; the current tendency to compare the Holocaust with other
modern atrocities so that the distinctive feature of each is blurred; and the
impulse to put the place less emphasis on the crime, criminals and victims
and more emphasis on the question of forgiveness and the need for healing.
It is more important to Langer that true, graphic, and devastating accounts
reach the present and future generations who will undoubtedly try to
understand how and why the atrocities of Holocaust could happen.
Through these essays, Langer tries to show some way to save us from
fatal results of building a society on a fragile foundation of naive idealism
that is only a virtuous name for self delusion … colored with a rosy
tinge to help them manage the unimaginable without having to look at it naked
and ugly face.
In Admitting the Holocaust, Langer argues that new moral and linguistic
categories are necessary in order to respond properly and honestly to the
reality of the Holocaust. Lawrence L. Langer defines the Holocaust as a
rupture in the images and values of modern western culture. In the essay
Understanding the Atrocity: Killers and Victims in the Holocaust , he says
that we will never understand the crimes of the Holocaust, or the roots of
the Holocaust unless we can fathom the kind of thinking that allows a human
being to consider the destruction of lives as inconsequential.
In Admitting the Holocaust, I perceive Langer as having an on-going
struggle with the facts versus fiction; the myths versus reality. The book is
a very compelling series of essays which stress his overwhelming concern with
the exploitation of the Holocaust in literature and art. In Admitting the
Holocaust, Langer becomes a conscience, demanding that we grapple with
the real implications of the Holocaust–its evil. ( Michael Berebaum,
Survivors of the Shoah Visual History Foundation) He insists that the events
of the Holocaust offer neither a lesson nor a moral but instead those horrible
events defy all reasoning, civilization, society and culture. The Holocaust
leaves an irreparable legacy for present and future generations.
The collection of essays in Admitting the Holocaust are clear, persuasive
and gripping. They offer thoughtful and provocative questions to complex
issues. Can simple words transport the true sense of what the Holocaust
was? What is the particular value and limitations of the various media when
trying to convey the utter devastation of the Holocaust? Just how can the
enormity of the Holocaust be communicated? Perhaps it cannot. Perhaps we
will never find the answer. Perhaps there is no answer. Lawrence L. Langer
has demonstrated to me that no matter what we read, see, hear or feel, we, the
members of this generation and future generations will never be able to
understand the why and how of such a tragic and devastating event. We can
only hope to continue the study so that the Holocaust will be seen as it truly
was — evil.
336
Другие работы по теме:
Briar Rose Essay Research Paper In a
Briar Rose Essay, Research Paper In a nutshell: Briar Rose is the story of the Holocaust intertwined with the fairy tale of Sleeping Beauty. The story begins with the death of the “Gemma,” the grandmother of Becca. Through out Becca?s life
Post Modernism Essay Research Paper Essay
Post Modernism Essay, Research Paper Essay #3 Art Spiegelman’s Maus II is a book that tells more than the story of one family’s struggle to live thought the Holocaust. It gives us a look into the psyche of a survivor’s child and how the Holocaust affected him and many other generations of people who were never there at all.
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay Research Paper Holocaust
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay, Research Paper Holocaust Unit SummaryI was mostly affected by this unit because it showed me that in the midst of allthe unkindness of the Nazi party, that there were still some people left who were kindenough to put their own lives on the line to save someone else’s. I didn’t understand,until the stories and the movies cleared it up, how the people could not figure out thatthere was something wrong when they were being pushed around by the Nazi soldiers.
Us And The Holocaust Essay Research Paper
The Response of the United States One of the questions that we frequently hear is about how the United States reacted to the Holocaust. Our answer is not a happy one. During World War II the United States took virtually no action to impede the Holocaust or rescue the victims from the concentration camps even though both Great Britain and the United States knew about that genocide.
K Essay Research Paper 2a Why does
K Essay, Research Paper 2.a) Why does the Athenian jury convict Socrates, and why does Socrates maintain his innocence? b) Do you think it was right for Socrates to accept his punishment of death without fleeing, even though he thought he was innocent?
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay Research Paper I
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay, Research Paper I was mostly affected by this unit because it showed me that in the midst of all the unkindness of the Nazi party, that there were still some people left who were kind
Inhumane Treatment Essay Research Paper When groups
Inhumane Treatment Essay, Research Paper When groups and nations come into conflict, they sometimes act in inhumane ways. They use cruel and harsh treatment toward others. Two conflicts that occurred between 1900 and 1945 that resulted in the inhumane treatment of people are the Nazi Holocaust and the Salt March.
Christianity And Holocaust Essay Research Paper As
Christianity And Holocaust Essay, Research Paper As a Jew, I agree with the statement “If the time was ever ripe for Christians to finally abandon their age-old obsession with converting Jews, that time is now. ” I think its way to late for Christians to try and convert Jews. I think these obsessed people missed their chance long ago.
HALOCUST Essay Research Paper Prejudice was the
HALOCUST Essay, Research Paper Prejudice was the main factor that led to the holocaust. For some, resisting these forms of oppression was survival. Considering the dehumanizing the Nazis had forced upon the Jews, people took whatever courage and strength they had to get through this period of time. I believe luck also had a part to play in survival.
Holocaust Essay Research Paper Hitler and the
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper Hitler and the Nazi Party gained power in Germany in 1933 and lost power in 1945 — only 12 years. And yet, by the end of the Hitler regime, the world had been plunged into a global world war, Europe was in shambles and nearly 30 million died. Among the dead were over SIX MILLION Jews — men, women and children –who were systematically and efficiently slaughtered for no other reason than that they were Jews.
Hilter
’s Willing Executioners Essay, Research Paper Hitler’s Willing Executioners This book explains why the Holocaust occured. The cause of the Holocaust is
Men Essay Research Paper Experiment Aims to
Men Essay, Research Paper Experiment Aims to Get Real Men to Go to the Doctor This article from the New York Times explains men not admitting their sick or hurt. The men which were tested in this article men would ignore their aches and pains, mental and physical, until it is too late. I think that it is true that some men are afraid to look ?wimpy? or be called.
Schildler
’s List Essay, Research Paper Steven Speilberg s main purpose for directing the film Schindler s List was to tell the best story to ever come out of the Holocaust, whilst informing the viewer of the horrific events that occurred during the Holocaust was his secondary motive. Due to the fact that the movie is based around the life of one man, it is obvious that this is correct.
Bearing Witness
’ Essay, Research Paper Bearing Witnesses, Stories of the Holocaust, selected by Hazel Rochman and Darlene Z. McCampbell is a wonderful book that illustrates the horror of the Holocaust. I believe that this book helped me to better understand what really happened during the tragic event.
Sustainablity Essay Research Paper What is an
Sustainablity Essay, Research Paper What is an unsustainable city? An unsustainable city: Requires continual input of non-renewable resources uses renewable sources faster than the rate of renewal
Dawn Elie Wiesel Essay Research Paper Elie
Dawn Elie Wiesel Essay, Research Paper Elie Wiesel?s, Dawn Elie Wiesel was only fifteen when German troops deported him and his family from their home in Romania to the concentration camp, Auschwitz. His father, mother and younger sister all died in result to the hands of the Nazis. The young boy survived forced labor, forced marches, starvation, disease, beatings and torture to become a world-renowned writer, teacher and spokesmen for the oppressed peoples of the earth.
Treatment Of The Prisoners In The Concentration
Camps Essay, Research Paper Interdisciplinary Research Research Proposal The Treatment of the Prisoners in the Concentration Camps The topic that I plan to focus on in my research paper is treatment inside different concentration camps during the Holocaust. I plan to focus on three different camps, but I have not narrowed down my choices yet.
Holocaust Essay Research Paper In Memory
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper In Memory of the Holocaust In Germany during World War II, 6 million Jews were exterminated by Nazis. Exterminated means to be destroyed completely. Extermination, however, is usually only enacted only upon animals. Sadly, the Jews were treated like pesky animals, and the Germans were the self-apointed exterminators.
Hamlet Act 2 Scene 2
– Compare Hamlet’s Reaction To Arrival Of Rosencrantz And Guildenstern And To The Players Essay, Research Paper Hamlet: Act 2 Scene 2 – Compare Hamlet’s Reaction to Arrival of Rosencrantz and
Holocaust Essay Research Paper The Holocaust Does
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper The Holocaust: Does History Repeat Itself? The Holocaust was a period in time lasting from 1933-1945, where Adolph Hitler tried to exterminate people that he considered to be inferior to him. He wanted his country to be full of Arians, his perception of the perfect person.
Why The Jews Essay Research Paper Why
Why The Jews Essay, Research Paper Why the Jews? People frequently ask why the Jews were the target of the Holocaust or why the Holocaust happened. The first is an easy question to answer. Jews were the targets of the Holocaust because Hitler hated Jews and blamed them for all of the problems in the world. He especially blamed them for Germany’s loss of World War I.
Holocaust Essay Research Paper The Holocaust was
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper The Holocaust was one of the greatest atrocities known to man. This paper will clearly show the cruelty, death destruction that was caused during the Holocaust. In addition, this paper will overview the background and goals of the one man responsible for this great tragedy.
Scarlet Letter Essay Research Paper In Hawthorne
Scarlet Letter Essay, Research Paper In Hawthorne s The Scarlet Letter, life is centered around a crappy , Puritanistic society in which one is unable to divulge his or her innermost thoughts and secrets. Every human being needs the opportunity to express how they truly feel, or the emotion is bottled up until it becomes volatile.
Clinical Depression 2 Essay Research Paper Clinical
Clinical Depression 2 Essay, Research Paper Clinical depression is very common. Over nine million Americans are diagnosed with clinical depression at some point in their lives. Many more people suffer from clinical depression because they do not seek treatment. They may feel that depression is a personal weakness, or try to cope with their symptoms alone.
Holocaust Essay Research Paper Holocaust
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper Holocaust Essay submitted by Yogi36@mailexcite I’ve thought, and thought about resistance in the Holocaust and I’ve come to this
Holocaust Essay Research Paper The Holocaust In
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper The Holocaust: In Memory of Millions Response Paper I have always known the holocaust to be one of the worst events in all of history. I remember learning all about it in history class in the ninth grade and being appalled by all the horrors that were shown to us. We learned all about the intense persecution of the Jews, how they were forced into terrible concentration camps where they either worked or were killed, and how the Germans just walked around beating on them and destroying every part of their lives.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Joe PrestonEnglish 10
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Joe Preston English 10 period 1 Antigone Essay Mrs. Bleeke 18 November 1999 Antigone Essay Antigone is an admirable character in some aspects through out the play. Her pride
Comp Of 1850 Essay Research Paper The
Comp Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper The Compromise of 1850 The Compromise of 1850 was a series of five legislative enactment’s, passed by the US Congress during August and September 1850. These measures were designed
Holocaust Essay Research Paper Polish children imprisoned
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper Polish children imprisoned in Auschwitz look out from behind the barbed wire fence. Approximately 40,000 Polish children were imprisoned in the camp before being transferred to Germany during the “Heuaktion” (Hay Action). The blond boy at the lower right may be Kalman Cylberszac (b.1934), the son of Rachel and Nachum Cylberszac from Lask, Poland.
Holocaust Memorial Essay Research Paper The Holocaust
Holocaust Memorial Essay, Research Paper The Holocaust Memorial Located close to lively South Beach is one of the most haunting pieces of art I have ever seen. The deeply moving Holocaust Memorial in Miami is an art installation that combines the senses of sight, sound and a vivid array of emotions. The structure itself is a walled circle within a semicircle.
Smoking Essay Research Paper Smoking
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Smoking Studies of ex-smokers show that their risk of dying from smoking-related disease decreases with each year of non smoking. Encouraged by such evidence,
Human Rights Essay Research Paper Human RightsThroughout
Human Rights Essay, Research Paper Human Rights Throughout history, people?s human rights have been violated, but efforts have also been made to address the violations, and protect their rights. Human rights are rights as regarded as belonging fundamentally to all persons. Today, everyone is entitled to the same rights.