’s Honor Essay, Research Paper
Michael Ignatieff’s The Warrior’s Honor is a graphic and unflinching portrait of modern warfare and humanitarian engagements to make war more “civilized.” While Ignatieff is skeptical towards avowedly “neutral” engagements such as the Swiss Red Cross, he retains a measure of hope or at least reserved optimism for the prospect that warring parties can reconcile if “rituals in which communities once at war learn to mourn their dead together” (190). The tone of the book is both journalistic and literary, and the conclusion could be described as visionary and prophetic. Ignatieff offers a challenge to individuals to challenge their assumptions about themselves to break the cycle of narcissism, bigotry, and violence. He has an anthropological understanding of why groups of people act in particular violent ways given their histories and myths, but he tempers this with a social psychology drawing from Freud and Hobbes to understand what happens in anarchic situations of brutal warfare. He is at his best when he shows that recent liberal humanitarian engagements are not so removed from the colonialist legacy of the 20th century and Conrad’s depiction of Kurtz’s “moral disgust.”
Ignatieff’s work is very political, arguing that governments or NGOs simply cannot take the neutral political stance towards modern wars. He argues that war should first be seen as a natural human condition (a very Hobbesian view), and secondly, that war is one solution to ethnic conflict. Is he arguing for a return to T.R.’s “Gunboat Diplomacy?” I assume that he believes that since the UN, or the U.S. or EU, will become involved in these armed conflicts around the world anyway, they should act decisively, firmly, and quickly rather than make half-fast engagements and muddy up the situation through food-aid relief, inadvertently prolonging conflicts. The harsh criticism over the UN’s foot-dragging in Rwanda makes this an easy argument to make. The opposite stance would be an isolationist position, but in the current political climate, this is a morally unacceptable option. By beginning the book with a discussion of the power of the television, Ignatieff shows how this powerful medium has led to the emergence of a moral universalism, while at the same time conflicting with the general feeling that family has a moral priority over the welfare of strangers. The end of this argument is that the moral stakes of siding with the victims may lead to misanthropy. Arguing for a more ethical television treatment of atrocities is a step in the right direction. Ignatieff touches on the issue of distance and space issues, but these could be expanded more. There is perhaps an anxiety, which may be an undercurrent of current immigration policies, that horrors around the world cannot be contained, and the sovereign borders of the U.S., for example are not immune to such crises. Cries of “secession” are currently being heard among separatists in Alabama. Will there be a call for “revenge” sometime in the U.S.’s future for the dead Confederates of our own Civil War? With the recent change of leadership in Austria and the continuing woes of the former Yugoslavia, it is increasingly obvious that problems of wartorn disintegrating states are not confined to borders of first or third world. Ignatieff offers no solutions for the mess we are in – he is certainly not an advocate of civil disobedience – nevertheless, there are some directions we can work towards, and two methods, reconciliation and shame, combat for a temporary peace, or at least for an illusory justice.
Другие работы по теме:
In What Ways Was Napoleon A Warrior
Overloard In His Treatment Of His Subjects? Essay, Research Paper The question asks what was Napoleons treatment of his European subjects. However first we need to learn what these subjects were and distinguish the differences between them.
The Dream Of The Rood Essay Research
Paper ?Creating a Warrior?: Analyzing The Dream of the Rood The story of Christ’s crucifixion is one of the most important and well known stories of the Bible. It has been told through many different perspectives but none more unique then the one shared in ?The Dream of the Rood?. Told through the view of the cross ?The Dream of the Rood? is based on the story of the crucifixion.
Echoes Of MonstrsitiesBeowulf Essay Research Paper Echoes
Echoes Of Monstrsities-Beowulf Essay, Research Paper Echoes of Monstrosities Every society has demons and monsters that the members of that society are fearful of. Those fears are only reflections of the society that are seen in that monster. In the long epic poem, Beowulf, there are three monsters that reflect aspects of Germanic warrior society.
Beowulf 6 Essay Research Paper Beowulf A
Beowulf 6 Essay, Research Paper Beowulf: A Brochure of the Anglo-Saxon Beliefs Beowulf is a terrific example of a story that portrays the beliefs the Anglo-Saxon people. Their entire culture was based on heroism and loyalty. They encouraged heroic action in the face of doom and generously rewarded bravery.
MacBeth Essay Research Paper The play
MacBeth Essay, Research Paper The play “MacBeth” written by profound author and playwright William Shakespeare is a story of good, evil, power, and envy. MacBeth ,who is the main character of this play, is a courageous, brave, ruthless, and sometimes asinine soldier who also carries the title of Thane of Glamis.
Jewish Essay Research Paper Beowulf EssayThere were
Jewish Essay, Research Paper Beowulf Essay There were many differences between Beowulf the play and 13th Warrior the movie. In the play Beowulf was depicted as a soul warrior who?s strength and ability was
Beowulf 11 Essay Research Paper Different cultures
Beowulf 11 Essay, Research Paper Different cultures around the world admire and appreciate certain traits or characteristics of a person to make them ideal. In the story of Beowulf, which narrates the heroics of a Scandinavian warrior, we grasp some traits that where appreciated by the Scandinavian culture.
The Day The Devil Struck Heaven Essay
, Research Paper The Day The Devil Struck HeavenIt was a spooky night. The shutters slammed, the Lightning cracked, everything was terrible. Satin had risen from the dead for the final show down to try to break the pearly gates of heaven that stop him from resurrecting every angel. Satin and his crew of Devil’s began their fly through the sky towards heaven to invade heaven.
The Samurais The Ultimate Stoics Essay Research
Paper The Samurais, The Ultimate Stoics For seven centuries, the Samurai were Japan’s warrior class. As a class of warriors and knights, they dominated society in feudal Japan. Their code or ?
Janie Essay Research Paper J
Janie Essay, Research Paper J A N I E In Zora Neale Hurston s “Their Eyes Were Watching God”, Janie, a southern black woman, finds herself in several bad relationships before finding true love. Throughout the novel, being a dynamic character, Janie changes her ways in between each relationship. In Hurston s book, Janie grows from a wanderer to a martyr, before finally becoming a warrior.
The Hutu And Tutsi Tribes In Rwanda
Essay, Research Paper The Hutu and Tutsi Tribes In Rwanda The Hutu and Tutsi’s tribes of Rwanda have been at war for centuries. The fighting began 5 centuries ago when the Tutsi a warrior tribe of Hamatic
Greek Archaeology Falling Warrior Essay Research Paper
As I began my search for an artifact to identify from the Late Bronze Age in Ancient Greece, I looked for a piece that would symbolize a major difference in stylistic change from the previous period. The artifact that captured my attention and satisfied my requirement, was none other than the Falling Warrior from the East Pediment at the Temple of Aphaia at Aegina.
Response Paper On Othello Essay Research Paper
HUM 125 Response Paper Othello was confronted with many betrayals that lead him in killing his beautiful wife, Desdemona. When though Othello was a great warrior as well as a person of wisdom, but even his strength or his wisdom could not stop him from felling into the hands of a villain. The hands he fell into were Iago’s.
Sir Lanval Essay Research Paper Intro paragraph
Sir Lanval Essay, Research Paper Intro paragraph: A warrior is a person that values his country and will protect it at all costs. He is brave and valient and does not care whether he dies in battle just as long as he’s fighting for his country and for a good cause. Sometimes warriors sacrifice their beliefs in the case of love or religion.
Storyteling Essay Research Paper Sophia ChenEcomp 100Essay
Story-teling Essay, Research Paper Sophia Chen Ecomp 100 Essay #5 24 Oct 1996 Story-Telling Storytelling has helped humankind evolve into a wiser species by allowing those with enough attentiveness and intelligence to learn from the mistakes of their predecessors. The Chinese culture, like many others world wide, base their beliefs largely on stories passed down from generation to generation.
The Woman Warrior Essay Research Paper The
The Woman Warrior Essay, Research Paper The Woman Warrior The most important theme that really stood out to me was the talk stories. The whole book mainly deals with the talk stories. The second theme that I felt
Woman Warrior Essay Research Paper In her
Woman Warrior Essay, Research Paper In her autobiography, The Woman Warrior, Maxine talks-story about how she grew up surrounded by the Chinese culture but went to American schools. How her mother told her stories of herself as a shaman and of Fa Mu Lan when Maxine brought home good grades. How she was put down by the Chinese sexism and rebelled from it.
Beowulf And Macbeth Essay Research Paper Warrior
Beowulf And Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Warrior, gladiator, knight, or soldier, what ever you call it, they are the ones that do the dirty work in a certain society. A warrior is a defined as a man
Martin The Warrior Essay Research Paper The
Martin The Warrior Essay, Research Paper The novel, Martin the Warrior by Brian Jacques, is a book about a young mouse warrior named Martin, son of Luke the Warrior, a mouse that fought sea rats, One
Warrior Cultures Essay Research Paper Warrior Cultures
Warrior Cultures Essay, Research Paper Warrior Cultures: The Samurai Through the ages every culture has had their warriors. These warriors have defended and fought for their land, homes, countries, and deeply held beliefs (either political or spiritual). The samurai were self-proclaimed warriors. “The members achieve their reputations by fighting, even killing”(Bohannan 1992).
Beowulf Essay Research Paper BeowulfThe epic poem
Beowulf Essay, Research Paper Beowulf The epic poem Beowulf, one of the sources for a Western paradigm portrays Christ as a warrior. The Anglo-Saxon tradions emphasises Christainity as a herioc code,
The Wine Of Astonishment By Earl Lovelace
Essay, Research Paper The Wine of Astonishment by Earl Lovelace In Earl Lovelace’s book “The Wine of Astonishment” two main characters arise Bee and Bolo. Bolo’s character is a warrior and he directs the people to the path of empowerment by way of the warrior for that is what he knows and who he is. Bee’s character is a man of faith, patience, and a man of his people.
Macbeth Story Essay Research Paper MacBeth is
Macbeth Story Essay, Research Paper MacBeth is the story of a great warrior who is tempted by evil and allows his ambition to corrupt his strength. MacBeth himself begins the story as being the
Beowulf The Brave Hero Essay Research Paper
Beowulf: The Brave Hero English literature begins with Beowulf, an Anglo-Saxon folk epic written by an unknown author. The epic presents the story of Beowulf, an ideal Anglo-Saxon hero who through his exploits includes Anglo-Saxon values. One value which Beowulf teaches is love of bravery, a value which he demonstrates through two distinct events.
The Epic Hero Beowulf Thesis Essay Research
Paper The Epic Hero Beowulf An epic is a long narriative peom about the adventures of a legendary or historic hero. The hero is a figure is high social status, one with great strenght or ability, and historical importance. There are many characteristics one must demonstrate ti be considered an epic hero. An epic hero is a brave and courageous warrior, admired for his achievements and courageous qualities.
The Iliad By Homer Essay Research Paper
He Wore Honor on His Sleeve The poem The Iliad written by Homer is the story of the tenth year of the Trojan War. It depicts the nobility and honor given to a slayer in warfare and the humanity that warriors show to the slain. It also illustrates the Greek code of ethics, that was in that time honor. Warriors fought for honor to insure a reputation that would outlive them.
Significance Of The Hands Of Achilleus Essay
, Research Paper Achilleus’ hands are a prevalent image in Homer’s Iliad. By focusing on Achilleus’ hands, we as the audience, gain insight on not only the character of Achilleus but also the customs of the society in which he lived. Much of this insight is not directly conveyed to the reader but a deeper look into the reasoning behind why the hands were focused on will reveal the insight mentioned before.
Beowulf The Epic Hero Essay Research Paper
Beowulf the Epic Hero What does it mean to be a hero? Like anything else in this world, the definition of the word hero can be argued. Some may say that a hero can be passive, that is if he or she refrains from doing a certain action it makes them heroic. Others would argue that to be truly heroic the character must never turn tail and always face the obstacle head on even though he or she may die in the process.
Shaka Zulu Essay Research Paper Shaka was
Shaka Zulu Essay, Research Paper Shaka was born the son of Senzakhona, the Zulu chief, and the Langeni princess Nandi. Senzakhona had unintentionally impregnated Nandi, but was obligated to take her as his third wife her in spite of the fact that she was from the lowly regarded Langeni clan. Due to this, she and her son were treated as outcasts and were unhappy.
The Cause Of Evil Macbeth Essay Research
Paper The Cause of Evil Macbeth Macbeth, once a noble and courageous warrior is transformed into an egotistical and ruthless tyrant. In the play Macbeth, by William Shakespeare, Macbeth encounters a transformation which brings him the crown, as well as his death. However, this transformation reached the point it did because three motivational factors.