Poetry Essay, Research Paper
Blackmur R.P., Form and Value in Modern Poetry, Doubleday, 1957.
Justification
This critique was first published as a journal article in The Southern Review, 1936 and later reprinted in the text entitled Form and Value in Modern Poetry. The author of the critique describes the meaning behind Yates poetry. He also describes Yates view of the world and explains how this influences the poetry and the response by many readers towards the work.
Blackmur uses a comparison with other poets of the same era. Blackmur also describes in a way that is easily understood, the poetic devices employed by Yates in his works.
Position of the writer
The position of the writer, is that Yates is a great poet who combines technique with imagination. However, the content of his work and its symbolism is confronting to many readers and may not therefore appreciate the greatness of the poetry.
The critics argument
The poet (and, as always the reader) has to combine, or fuse inextricably into something like an organic unity the constructed or derived symbolism of his special insight with the symbolism animating the language itself. It is, on the poet s plane, the labor of bringing the representative forms of knowledge home to the experience which stirred them: the labor of keeping in mind what our knowledge is of: the labor of craft. With the poetry of Yates this labor is, as I say, doubly hard, because the forms of knowledge, being magical, do not fit naturally with the forms of knowledge that ordinarily preoccupy us.
What Blackmur is arguing, is that magic and the interpretation of this, is dependent on the reader s knowledge of magic. He continues the argument, by implying that Yates believed that imagination was as valid a way of understanding the world as was logic. Blackmur also argues that because Yates has a view of life, that many readers do not share, the poetry is often interpreted as sterile .
Exposition of the critics ideas and relevance
Following the line of Blackmurs argument one can only appreciate the greatness of Yates poetry by understanding more about magic as a force in real life. However Blackmur claims that use of magic as a tool for poetry has two radical defects. The first defect is a lack of conventional authority outside the poem. The other defect is that Yates understanding of magic was not and could not be given in the words of the poem.
Use of appropriate technical language
Blackmur does not critique Yates work in terms of its metre or rhyme but rather offers an analysis of the themes and content. The language used is appropriate to this analysis.
Evaluation of the critique
Blackmur gives a feel for the emotions that he experiences in studying Yates poetry. That emotion is probably confusion or perhaps disbelief. While this is an interesting study, Blackmur points out that this is only one approach to understanding the poetry and it should be combined with others for a more comprehensive analysis.
Blackmur R.P., Form and Value in Modern Poetry, Doubleday, 1957.
Justification
This critique was first published as a journal article in The Southern Review, 1936 and later reprinted in the text entitled Form and Value in Modern Poetry. The author of the critique describes the meaning behind Yates poetry. He also describes Yates view of the world and explains how this influences the poetry and the response by many readers towards the work.
Blackmur uses a comparison with other poets of the same era. Blackmur also describes in a way that is easily understood, the poetic devices employed by Yates in his works.
Position of the writer
The position of the writer, is that Yates is a great poet who combines technique with imagination. However, the content of his work and its symbolism is confronting to many readers and may not therefore appreciate the greatness of the poetry.
The critics argument
The poet (and, as always the reader) has to combine, or fuse inextricably into something like an organic unity the constructed or derived symbolism of his special insight with the symbolism animating the language itself. It is, on the poet s plane, the labor of bringing the representative forms of knowledge home to the experience which stirred them: the labor of keeping in mind what our knowledge is of: the labor of craft. With the poetry of Yates this labor is, as I say, doubly hard, because the forms of knowledge, being magical, do not fit naturally with the forms of knowledge that ordinarily preoccupy us.
What Blackmur is arguing, is that magic and the interpretation of this, is dependent on the reader s knowledge of magic. He continues the argument, by implying that Yates believed that imagination was as valid a way of understanding the world as was logic. Blackmur also argues that because Yates has a view of life, that many readers do not share, the poetry is often interpreted as sterile .
Exposition of the critics ideas and relevance
Following the line of Blackmurs argument one can only appreciate the greatness of Yates poetry by understanding more about magic as a force in real life. However Blackmur claims that use of magic as a tool for poetry has two radical defects. The first defect is a lack of conventional authority outside the poem. The other defect is that Yates understanding of magic was not and could not be given in the words of the poem.
Use of appropriate technical language
Blackmur does not critique Yates work in terms of its metre or rhyme but rather offers an analysis of the themes and content. The language used is appropriate to this analysis.
Evaluation of the critique
Blackmur gives a feel for the emotions that he experiences in studying Yates poetry. That emotion is probably confusion or perhaps disbelief. While this is an interesting study, Blackmur points out that this is only one approach to understanding the poetry and it should be combined with others for a more comprehensive analysis.
Другие работы по теме:
Punishment
Punishment, in modern criminal law, is a penalty inflicted by the state upon a person for committing a criminal offence. Many countries of the world have abolished the death penalty. The most severe form of punishment in Ukraine is life imprisonment.
Modern Tourism Narrows the Mind
Until recently, we all believed that travel broadened the mind, but now many believe the exact opposite: “Modern tourism narrows the mind”.
Shakespeare In Love Essay Research Paper Modern
Shakespeare In Love Essay, Research Paper Modern theatre still falls more or less in the category of popular culture, it is the cinema that equates more to the Elizabethan drama than the theatre. Thus it is a film Shakespeare in love, that we see exploring a fictional depiction of the life of William Shakespeare.
The Three Basic Laws Of Chemis Essay
, Research Paper John Dalton was born in 1766 and died in 1844. Around 1803 he developed the first atomic theory of matter. He was a meteorologist and was very important to study of chemistry. Dalton discovered the three basic laws of chemistry. The law of conservation of mass, The law of definite proportions, and The law of multiple proportions.
SciFi Gibberish Or A Glance At Oneself
Essay, Research Paper Science fiction: gibberish or a glance at oneself? Since the very rudiment of mankind humans have dreamed Dreamed of understanding nature’s phenomena, dreamed of finding out the secrets of the infinite universe and dreamed of perception of their own place in its vast continuity. These dreams, passed orally through the lips of generations eventually took form of what we now call a myth.
Jane Eyre As A Modern Woman Essay
, Research Paper Jane Eyre as a Modern Woman Throughout the course of Charlotte Bronte s novel, Jane Eyre, Jane is used as a representation of a modern woman. Jane does many things which women of her time didn t do. She started reading as a little girl. This was a talent that most women at the time didn t acquire throughout their entire lives.
Edgar Degas Essay Research Paper Degas pronounced
Edgar Degas Essay, Research Paper Degas, pronounced duh GAH, Edgar (1834-1917), was a French impressionist painter. Like the other impressionists, he wanted to portray situations from modern life. However, he did not share his fellow impressionists’ concentration on light and color. Degas emphasized composition, drawing, and form more than did the other members of the movement.
Modernist Art In Europe Essay Research Paper
Modernist Art in Europe 1910-25 by Robert l. Herbert Herbert?s thesis of his essay is to investigate the arrival of the machine and modern art and its complexities. During WWI, modernist painting and sculpture paid major attention to machinery, science and industry. Modern art during that time has become a central factor in our culture due to its dominance in public art, museums, media and literature.
Techniques Of William Shakespeare Essay Research Paper
Writing Style The English language, as we know it in the modern world has changed dramatically since the dawn of the Elizabethan era. Shakespeare and many other writer’s of his time looked towards the English language as alive and changing. They did not consider it fixed for all time in a set of correct and unbreakable rules.
The Changing American Family Essay Research Paper
The family is important to people all over the world although the structure of the family is quite different from one country to another. In the united States, as in many countries in the world, the family is changing. A generation or two ago, the traditional family, in which the father was boss, was customrary.
What Is Modern Music Essay Research Paper
The most important thing that was expressed about the definition of modern music is that the degree of modernism depends on the experience and taste of those whom are listening. This means that each person can have vastly different views on which musicians and what styles are considered modern, because the critique of all arts is merely opinion.
America The Modern Day Athens Essay Research
Paper America: The Modern Day Athens “We do not copy our Ancestors, but are an example to them. It is true we are called a Democracy, for the administration is in the hands of the many and
Bureucracy And LegalRational Essay Research Paper BUREAUCRACY
Bureucracy And Legal-Rational Essay, Research Paper BUREAUCRACY AND LEGAL-RATIONAL AUTHORITY IN WEBER S WORK According to Weber, bureaucracy is a product of the legal-rational form of authority which is itself a product of the process of rationalisation which defines modern societies. Max Weber was a sociologist of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries who was concerned with understanding social actions and the effects they had on modern, Western civilisation.
Beowulf Values Essay Research Paper Some Things
Beowulf Values Essay, Research Paper Some Things Change But Most Remain the Same Masculine values have both changed and remained constant since the writing of Beowulf. The values that Beowulf and
The Chamber Essay Research Paper A Question
The Chamber Essay, Research Paper A Question of Life or Death The novel The Chamber, by John Grisham, is an emotional account of a lawyer’s struggle to liberate his racist grandfather from death row. This attorney not only battles to save a life but skirmishes against of the most debated topics of modern society: capital punishment.
The Ancient City Essay Research Paper The
The Ancient City Essay, Research Paper The Ancient City Pompeii How democratic was Pompeian politics? In order to answer the above question, it is first necessary to consider the exact meaning of the term democracy . Whilst it is difficult to give an exact definition of the word, it is certainly possible to create a list of the implications of democratic government for a society and its citizens.
Seminars In Modern Art Essay Research Paper
SEMINARS IN MODERN ART Reel#2 Question #2 Pablo Ruiz y Picasso was born on Oct. 25, 1881, in Malaga, on the Mediterranean coast of Spain. His father was an art teacher and taught his smart son. Picasso studied at
Whitman Essay Research Paper In my opinion
Whitman Essay, Research Paper In my opinion the poet which best exemplifies modernism is Walt Whitman. Walt Whitman?s stylistic preference is not exactly mine, but it is definitely a good example of ?modern poetry.? He has broken down many walls of traditional poetry, using the style of long, free verse prose.
Architecture Now Vs Dark Ages Essay Research
Paper Architectural Designs of Castles Vs. Modern Homes2000-07-03 Is the architectural design of modern homes slowly changing back to the architectural design of castles in the Middle Ages? If design of
Modern Atom Model Essay Research Paper The
Modern Atom Model Essay, Research Paper The evolution of the modern atom model took several years to evolved with contribution from different scientists. One of these scientists, the first to come up with a modern model of the atom is JJ Thomson. Thomson proposes that the structure of an atom is mainly a sphere.
Ucla Bus Trip Essay Research Paper UCLA
Ucla Bus Trip Essay, Research Paper UCLA Bus TripWilliam Zorach conceived a sculpture entitled “Victory” that shows an indebtedness to the late classical fourth century B.C. idealized images of Venus, combined with a figural attitude of flight that is perhaps derived from the twisting torso of the conceptions of flight in the winged Victory of Samothrace.
On The Universality Of Poetry Essay Research
Paper Like any art form, poetry is considered universal. It ranks with music, dance, and fine arts as a form or process of expressing Man’s thoughts and passions. Unlike other art forms, however, poetry — and in fact literature — has a peculiar characteristic. As a medium it uses language, and unlike other mediums — like rocks, paints, beat — language is not universal, it is cultural.
Government Essay Research Paper 2 We know
Government Essay, Research Paper 2. We know that the fundamental difference between ancient political science and modern political science has to do with the relationship of the individual to the state. For Aristotle, a person was an inherently political animal. For modern political philosophers (social contract theorists), individual rights existed prior to the formation of government.
The Stone Age Essay Research Paper The
The Stone Age Essay, Research Paper The Stone Age The Stone Age shaped, developed and formed our modern day form of living. There are numerous facts and events that have occurred throughout time that are
Construction Technology Essay Research Paper Construction Technology
Construction Technology Essay, Research Paper Construction Technology’s Place in Architecture A major question in modern architecture is how construction technology plays into architectural form. Does construction technology validate a building as modern architecture? Can modern architecture exist without construction technology? My answer to both questions is no.
In The Life Of A Modern Man
Born In The Renaissance Essay, Research Paper Have you ever pondered the birth of your hobbies? Or have you ever wondered who invented the mechanisms you use in your everyday life? Well, modern art, today’s religion, and the present printing press had to originate some point in time. And what could be a better time then during the Renaissance and the Reformation? These three points were a major part of those years.
Evolution Of Modern Atom Essay Research Paper
The evolution of the modern atom model took several years to evolved with contribution from different scientists. One of these scientists, the first to come up with a modern model of the atom is JJ Thomson. Thomson proposes that the structure of an atom is mainly a sphere. A sphere that is filled with positive electronic field and contains tiny particles that has a negative charge.
Is Traditional Religion Incompatible With Modern Society
Essay, Research Paper When traditional religion is pitted against modern society, it is a clash of the titans, a clash between Science and Religion. Everyone has their own interpretation of what religion means to themselves and the people around them. Traditional religion is an organized community of many different types of groups that believe in their own divine being(s), stories about why something is the way that it is, and have some type of religious participation.
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper The Destroyer
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper The Destroyer As the demon slowly emerged from the place where he had been entombed for nearly a thousand years, He thought to himself,”This world will once again feel my wrath , nothing will stop me from opening the gates of Hell and realesing my brothern into this world and taking for our own.” Then realizing that he was still in his demonic form he assumed the idenity of modern day human.His journey began at that very moment, destined for the “Holy City of Rome.” Meanwhile:In Newyork City It’s two oclock in the mourning.
Bridges 2 Essay Research Paper Beam Bridge
Bridges 2 Essay, Research Paper Beam Bridge Beam bridges are the simplest form of bridge. They have developed from a log across a river to the large box girder bridges that you see today. In between there have
Adam Bede Essay Research Paper Adam Bede
Adam Bede Essay, Research Paper Adam Bede Technology advances with time. Though, technological advancement is needed to move a civilization forward, it also has its downsides. With more products and services available, it is impossible to live a life of relaxation as people once did long before. In George Eliot’s “Adam Bede,” one can see the difference in the purity of “old leisure” and the corruption of modern leisure through Eliot’s use of diction, imagery, and personification.