Ancient Times Essay, Research Paper
The Role of The Healer and “Payment” in Ancient Times
It is evident through ancient writings that forms of healing were present as far back as is recorded. Medicine, healers and forms of payment seem to have played an important role in the past, like they do now. However, over the centuries changes have taken place. From the time of Galen in ancient Rome to the 14th and 15th centuries in England the relationships between doctors and patients have evolved, along with the way medicine is defined and practiced. Specifically I would like to focus on forms of payment and their effect on the doctor-patient relationship and how payment and the practice of medicine have changed over time. These changes led to a healer-patient relationship that was not as personal as it was in the time of Galen. Instead of the healer playing the role of a friend helping his neighbor, we find that being a doctor became a form of trade and the doctor started selling his services for money.
The relationship between a doctor and his patient is a theme that is present in many of the writings we have from ancient times. There was a personal knowledge of the patient and an ongoing relationship with them that most doctors nowadays do not have with their own patients. Patients in our day and age walk in to a doctor’s office and wait for a long period of time, and then see a doctor for a few minutes. In the ancient world the healer would actually come to the house and perform services for the patient there (Prognosis, 170). Healers have always tried to provide an explanation to their patient while treating their illness. However, in the time of antiquity the shared closeness of patient and healer gave the patient an added assurance that their trusted friend or neighbor had their best interests in mind.
There is also evidence of this type of relationship in the Hippocratic society. The writings of Galen describe how he was treated Eudemus, a neighbor of his, and how he came to visit him every night (Galen, 77-79). Galen was with this man through every step of his illness. One interesting thing is the way the man sits and waits for Galen every night. After Galen takes his pulse, Eudemus hangs on Galen’s every word and feels better after he has talked to him. This shows again the close relationship between healer and patient and how Galen’s presence and prognosis gave him peace of mind, which promotes healing. Other writings, such as “Epidemics, Book 1” in which there are day-by-day accounts of each patient’s condition also give us a sense of the doctor’s intimate knowledge of the person they are treating (Epidemics, 44-45). These doctors recorded every detail of sickness and any and all symptoms that the patient reported to them. These doctors wanted to try their hardest to heal their patients or if nothing else try to tell them when they would die. It appears that healers took better care of each individual and focused more of their time on each sick person.
I have mentioned that the relationship between healers and patients in ancient times was different and therefore payment in ancient times was also different. Many times, healers in ancient Rome were not paid at all, or if they were paid, payment was usually not in the form of money. Vivian Nutton says in his article that, “A doctor was a person, male or female, who carried out medical treatment for a fee, or who, like Galen, devoted much of his time to healing, even if he never actually made any monetary charge but merely received presents” (32). This proves that many times doctors did not heal for the money but to learn and to heal for the satisfaction of helping others. Galen himself does not specifically mention payment but there was for him the satisfaction of knowing that he had cured Eudemus and had predicted what happened to him better than all the other doctors. By doing this he became better known in his practice.
Being well known was important because as Vivian Nutton tells us in “Patients and Practitioners”, there were many doctors to compete with. Anyone could declare himself or herself a doctor, “There is (here) no examination, no qualifying-test or oral, only the doctor’s own attestation before a magistrate that he is a doctor” (Nutton, 30). Also, knowledge was easily achieved because of the accessibility of medical ideas and the relative absence of any medical terms and language. This enabled medicine to take a prominent place in the general literary culture (Nutton, 32). Nutton also says that, “participation of all classes throughout the ancient world proves beyond any doubt that medical knowledge was by no means confined to those who called themselves doctors” (Nutton, 33). What Nutton is trying to tell us is that a doctor could be anyone in ancient times and therefore in order to become a paid and prestigious doctor you had to be able to successfully heal the patients.
Even into some of the later centuries this “competition” between doctors seemed to be evident. Carole Rawcliffe talks specifically in her article, “The Profits of Practice: the Wealth and Status of Medical Men in the Later Medieval England”, how physicians in the later Middle Ages came by payment in two ways: either by money, if they were treating nobility, or in exchange for something else like food or a place to live and other types of goods. In order to treat the Royalty and actually earn a decent amount of money, it was necessary to earn the trust of the laymen and then work your way up to wealthier patients (62-65). This was necessary because many times even though, “an agreement…establishing in precise detail when and how a mutually acceptable fee was to be handed over”, that sum was never paid. We know this through the many lawsuits brought on by the doctors (Rawcliffe, 65). So the doctor in the Middle Ages in England really had only one option if they wanted to make a descent living and that was to become one of the best and most well known doctors so that they could treat the wealthier patients.
This subject is brought up again in Rawcliffe’s article along with a few other issues. One is the fact that because doctors were trying to work their way up on the social ladder to treat wealthier patients it is a good assumption that by this time in the world doctors were starting to lose the closeness of the doctor-patient relationship found in a small community. I make this assumption based on the fact that in ancient times when there was a close doctor patient relationship it was because the doctor knew his patients. When communities started growing it became more difficult to know everyone in it and keep that same kind of close relationship. Also, when doctors started to earn a living their pursuit of the wealthiest patients probably limited their chances of a close relationship with them. There is also evidence of this when it tells us that there were many lawsuits brought on by doctors because people did not pay their bills (Rawcliffe, 65). I would say as a general rule in most societies usually a person does not sue a close friend or neighbor for not paying so this indicates to me that by this time doctors had started practicing on more than just the locals around them.
The doctors that I just mentioned who were the personal physicians to kings and queens may not have had the high status in society that one may imagine they would. If you were to read the writings of Galen you would probably get the impression that doctors were respected and high on the social ladder because of the way Galen makes it sound like he is well respected in society. But, according to Vivian Nutton even the wealthiest and most well known physicians were not always thought of as coming from the right social bracket. “In a society such as the Roman Empire, where landed wealth and the ability to enjoy a life of ease and honour…were the marks of a true aristocrat, any connection with medicine was to some extent demeaning” (Nutton, 39). This statement tells us that the physician was not of incredibly high status in the ancient society. Some may have become very rich but medicine was not as respected a subject as it became in later centuries.
In these later centuries “payment” was starting to become more of a set sum for doctors (Rawcliffe 65). Yet with many lower class patients “payment” still could be a variety of items. In a sense healing was becoming more of a trade than a service. The doctors in this later medieval time period traded their services for food, shelter and perhaps other services. But before this time in the writings of Galen and Hippocrates “payment” was not always received and those who were doctors were not in it just for the money. Doctors in ancient times seemed to care more about their patients and their relationship with them, it was not all about how much money they could get or what they would receive for healing each person. This is what it had become in 14th and 15th centuries. Even in the 12th century we find healing as a free service, first to the poor and then to anyone who was in need (Miller, 719). It is also evident that becoming a doctor in ancient times was not a way to make a lot of money; it was at best a “minimum wage” job.
So, the methods of payment have changed from the time of ancient Rome through the 14th and 15th centuries. At first ancient people were willing to heal their friends and neighbors for very small fees in various forms, then as we move through time people started paying for services of healing. As the relationship between the patient and doctor got weaker, the role of a doctor changed too. In the middle ages we start to see the development of doctors as being specific people with more knowledge of medicine that the average man. Not just anyone was a doctor. The people started making rules for who could practice medicine, and only those who succeeded got to advance as trusted doctors. As the link between doctors and patients became more separated, the forms of payment became more defined. It was no longer two men trading services as neighbors; it was a professional that a patient had to pay in order to receive treatment. Doctors started to practice medicine for the money and not just for the satisfaction of healing patients (Rawcliffe, 65-70).
As you can see the role of patient and healer used to be of one neighbor helping another or of a doctor healing for the satisfaction of healing and for his own learning and understanding of disease. But over time that has changed into a form of trade, a doctor selling a service for money. The healer of the ancient times had so much more personal knowledge of their patients that they would be able to not only heal their physical aliments but also give them hope and set them at ease. Therefore, forms of payment have changed from ancient Rome through the 14th and 15th centuries along with the relationship of healer and patient.
Bibliography
1. Carole Rawcliffe, “The Profits of Practice: the Wealth and Status of Medical Men in Later Medieval England.” Social History of Medicine 1988, 1: 61-78.
2. Galen, On Prognosis. Edited and translated with an introduction by Vivian Nutton (Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 1979), pp. 69-101.
3. G.E.R. Lloyd (ed), “Epidemics, Book 1.” Hippocratic Writings (New York: Penguin, 1978), pp. 29-47.
4. Timothy Miller, “The Knights of St. John and the Hospitals of the Latin West.” Speculum 1978, 53: 709-33.
5. Vivian Nutton, “Murders and Miracles: Lay Attitudes Towards Medicine in Classical Antiquity.” In Roy Porter (ed), Patients and Practitioners: Lay Perceptions of Medicine in Pre-Industrial Society (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Pr., 1985), pp. 23-53.
6. G.E.R. Lloyd (ed), “Prognosis” Hippocratic Writings (New York: Penguin, 1978), pp. 170-3.
Другие работы по теме:
The Good Earth Wang Lung As A
Rolemodel Essay, Research Paper The Good Earth: Wang Lung as a Role Model This is my definition of a role model: someone who does something that is admirable. One would be considered ignorant to think that a role model is perfect. In Pearl S. Buck?s The Good Earth, Wang Lung is set up to be a role model for his children.
Role Model Essay Research Paper Role ModelEveryone
Role Model Essay, Research Paper Role Model Everyone has a role model. Whether an athlete, an older sibling, a parent or relative, or just a special someone everyone wants to be “just like” that certain person. I am a role model to my younger siblings, my cousins, and I hope to be a role model to all of the Wild Life kids.
Bribes Essay Research Paper A bribe as
Bribes Essay, Research Paper A bribe as defined by Tom Carson is a payment to someone in exchange for special consideration that is incompatible with the duties of his position. An example of this would be if you offered a judge payment in secrecy, to rule in your favor. Your offer was accepted by the judge and you were not found guilty because of the payment received.
Princess Diana Essay Research Paper
“I?ve always thought, to provide some light along the way”. This quote is in the words of one of the most caring that people need to feel good about themselves and I see my role as offering support to them and devoted ladies of our time. This lady is known to us as Diana, Princess of Wales. Princess Diana possessed every attribute that we consider role models to exhibit.
Qualities Of A Pastoral Carer Essay Research
Paper Describe the essential qualities of a pastoral caregiver. Outline literature used to support your assumptions. Discuss the qualities you believe that you have already and what you recognise you need to develop. Include how you intend to do this.
Juniper Flower Essay Research Paper Term Paper
Juniper F;lower Essay, Research Paper Term Paper Sites – Only the Highest Quality Sites on the Net We are currently charging an application Fee of only $50 for the first 10 sites to join. Your payment and participation guarantees that within seven business days a member of Term Paper Sites’s editorial staff will look at your site and consider it for a membership.
The Petro Pumper Essay Research Paper
“Fill her up? Check your oil sir? Would you like me to wash your window?”Depending on where you buy your gas, I’m sure that everyone has been asked these questions at one time or another. However is that all that a gas bar attendant does? Just stick the nozzle in and start pumping, perhaps washing the odd window? Maybe some do, but to be a great attendant requires much more.
Nisa The Life And Words Of Kung
Woman By Marjorie Shostak Essay, Research Paper In this paper I am going to discuss the book Nisa The Life and Words of a !Kung Woman, by Marjorie Shostak. In doing this I will describe the culture of the !Kung people, a small hunter-gatherer tribe in Africa. Then I will go on with telling about their sociocultural systems that I have read about in this book.
Criptography Essay Research Paper We are living
Criptography Essay, Research Paper We are living in the age of Digital Revolution, which is swiftly starting to affect every aspect of our life. WebTV is replacing regular TV’s, radio stations are moving into broadcasting life-on-line. All business related operations are rapidly moving to the World Wide Web.
Cunsumer Credits Essay Research Paper ASK CONSUMERS
Cunsumer Credits Essay, Research Paper ASK CONSUMERS CREDIT SERVICES, INC. FEE AGREEMENT CONTRACT COPYRIGHT 1997 1. Have CLIENT send for his/her file from each of the three (3) major credit reporting agencies to review his/her credit files in order to evaluate the problems and develop the best course of action for correcting the errors therein for CLIENT, as spelled out in the AGREEMENT CONTRACT, paragraph number 1.
Relevance Of Recent War With Persia Essay
, Research Paper Rationing system does not help the mobility of Byzantines against Muslims Question marks over command structure and logistics Cases of non-payment ? Arab stipends, waggoners in
Women In The Workplace Essay Research Paper
Women in the Workplace The emergence of an urban, industrialized society affected the lives of American women in the late nineteenth century. Women during this time were beginning to see that not only did they belong in the home, but they could also find a role in the workplace. Men, on the other hand, maintained their role in the job market.
Affirmative Action 14 Essay Research Paper Affirmative
Affirmative Action 14 Essay, Research Paper Affirmative Action is not the same as Equal Opportunity. Affirmative Action is idea that minorities and women will have more of a chance to achieve positions in business and industry. I call this an idea because in the long run Affirmative Action in my eyes will only hurt people than improve their lives.
Spiritual Healing Essay Research Paper An Exploration
Spiritual Healing Essay, Research Paper An Exploration of Spiritual Healing Throughout time, mankind has constantly been seeking ways to maintain their health and to cure those that had not been so fortunate in that task. Just about everything has been experimented with as a cure for some type of illness; whether physical or mental.
Death Of A Salesman The American Dream
Essay, Research Paper For Willy and Linda, life’s accomplishments and sources of pleasure are simple. This statement gives an excellent judgment of their lives because they lead very average lives for the time, and any depth is ignored on their part. This little scene exemplifies this point by showing a focus in their lives, being the mortgage on the house.
Role Of Faith Essay Research Paper Role
Role Of Faith Essay, Research Paper Role of Faith Society’s investigation for adequate evidence to sustain rational belief in God may seem unsatisfactory. Throughout history, people have been appealing to reason and looking for evidence to substantiate these beliefs. However, we have not yet taken into consideration the role of faith.
Communication Roles Essay Research Paper In my
Communication Roles Essay, Research Paper In my life, the five most important roles I fill are as follows: father, head of household, son, student, and friend. Each role is very challenging and requires a lot of attention.
The Role Of Friar Lawrence Essay Research
Paper In Romeo and Juliet, a tragedy by William Shakespeare, Friar Lawrence plays a dominate role in the eventual death of Romeo and Juliet even though he is not on stage for most of the play. There are basically three major parts that lead to the tragedy; the marriage, the plan, and the inevitable deaths in all which Friar Lawrence plays a vital role.Friar Lawrence plays an essential role in the marriage of young Romeo and Juliet.
A Woman Supporting Her Man Essay Research
Paper A WOMAN SUPPORTING HER MAN There is nothing enduring in life for a woman, except what she builds in a man s heart. This quote by Judith Anderson provides a very accurate description of the role a woman was expected to play in med-evil times. This is the time frame in which Marie de France wrote the lay she called Eliduc.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper Disease as Imagery
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Disease as Imagery in Macbeth Imagery plays a predominant role in Shakespeare?s play Macbeth. This stylistic device appears in several different forms throughout the play. Imagery of animals, nature, and darkness help create a foreboding atmosphere. In particular, the imagery of disease acts as a metaphor for evil and corruption.
There Is A Price To Be Paid
Essay, Research Paper There is a Price to be Paid As the clich? goes, the best things in life are free. However, most people would debate the merit of this old saying. Whether you are buying yourself a suitable lifestyle or considering matters of the heart, a price just may be paid even if the payment isn?t a dollar amount.
Grendel Essay Research Paper Grendel
Grendel Essay, Research Paper Grendel Grendel is an unhappy soul in John Gardner’s book “Grendel”, because he feels useless in society and doesn’t want to accept his given role. Throughout
Role Of Women In The 19Th Century
Essay, Research Paper Role of Females In the nineteenth century women were perceived in many different ways. Two noted nineteenth century writer were john Stuart Mill and Henrik Ibsen. Even though most of their stories were greatly different they did share the common thought that women are their own people and should be free.
Social Role Essay Research Paper About Its
Social Role Essay, Research Paper About Its Social Role Waxing eloquent about stakeholder management and corporate social responsibility is in some circles the surest way to stifle a business conversation, if not a business career. Corporate philanthropy brings satisfaction to those who give and receive, the argument goes, but let us not get carried away by talk of give-aways.
Saint Raphael The Archangel Essay Research Paper
Saint Raphael the Archangel The saint I?ve chosen for my confirmation is Saint Raphael the Archangel. Saint Raphael is also known as the Angel of Love and the Angel of Joy. A few things he is a patron of are the blind, love, lovers, travelers, young people, and guardian angels. His name means ? God has healed?, or ? Healer of God?.
Grendel Essay Research Paper Grendel is an
Grendel Essay, Research Paper Grendel is an unhappy soul in John Gardner?s book ?Grendel?, because he feels useless in society and doesn?t want to accept his given role. Throughout the whole book, Grendel feels he has no friend in the outside word and no one to accept him besides his own mother. He doesn?t want to except his role in society, which is to be considered as the Great Destroyer.
Review Of Good Wives Essay Research Paper
Review of Good Wives Today, women are an intricate part of our working society. There are more women holding full-time jobs than ever before. A women’s role is just not in the house; it extends far beyond into the working world where women are even holding positions such as chief executive officers of Fortune 500 Companies.
Canadian Health Care VS US Health Care
Essay, Research Paper One of the major differences between the U.S. and Canadian health care system is the payment system. In the United States, physicians are paid more for doing more, and the return on their time is higher if they perform a procedure than if they use their cognitive skills. Because of the fact that procedures often require hospital care, this approach translates into higher expenditures for hospital care.
The Magic Circle Essay Research Paper The
The Magic Circle Essay, Research Paper The Magic Circle The Magic Circle, by Donna Jo Napoli dealt with three main characters. In the story a woman named The Ugly One possesses the power to heal. The woman has a beautiful daughter named Asa. The Ugly one is a sorcerer; who also helps sick people who are possessed by demons.
Macbeth And Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper
Macbeth and Oedipus Rex Analysis Oedipus Rex and Macbeth are both tragic plays. They have many similarities and differences. Some of them are in the role of fate, the characters, and the setting and the
Tarantella Essay Research Paper Tarantella
Tarantella Essay, Research Paper Tarantella “Five o’clock. Seven hours till midnight; and then four-and-twenty hours till the next midnight. Then the tarantella will be over. Twenty-four and seven? Thirty-one hours to live” (Ibsen 50). Nora ponders a moment about how not even the tarantella can save her now.
Role Models Essay Research Paper Role Models
Role Models Essay, Research Paper Role Models Who are the Role Model?s of Today? Who are the role models of today? It seems as though the culture of today has the tendency to mistake who a role model is rather then what a role model should be. How, then, is a role model defined? A role model is a person in our lives that give us inspiration, hope and keep our spirits up.