Census Returns Essay, Research Paper
Explain how you would evaluate the reliability of parish records and census returns as written sources.
Sources are never completely reliable or unreliable. It is the Historians job to evaluate the sources and from that reach drawn conclusions. However, different people, who may or may not see certain points as, for instance, biased, can interpret sources in different ways.
Both Parish records and census returns are public records, more so local records as they are kept in local record offices. They are made to keep account of the population and give other important information such as social structure, literacy and occupations.
Parish records, prior to 1837, would be kept by the parishes Vicar; they would record baptisms, marriages and burials. Basically the Vicar recorded all the ceremonies that took place in his church.
Other information that would be kept with the parish records would be; minutes of the vestry, registers of church services, records of church schools, tithe maps and awards.
The earliest parish registers were introduced to England and Wales in1538 and these would include baptisms, marriages and burials. This lasted until 1753, after this, marriages were recorded in a different register. Then in 1813 baptisms and burials also separated.
Everything changed in 1836 when the Government ruled that all births, deaths, and marriages should be told to local registrars who sent the information off to the General Register Office in London, becoming mandatory in 1874. It was called civil registration, and it meant the church now had no duty. As in most sources there are factors in the history of parish records which make them unreliable in parts, on the other hand there is a lot of useful information which can be drawn from them.
Parish records were not always accurate especially during the Civil War, because of increased numbers of deaths and other factors that contributed to civil unrest. A Parish Register was appointed to record the necessary information during harder times such as the Commonwealth period, but some were nearly illiterate and/or werenґt that concerned with their duties. This meant even more mistakes were made, adding to confusion and meaning the reliability is to some degree questionable.
Only civil marriages were accepted from 1653 to 1657, this means that only a few would have been recorded in the parish records. But as the period ran from 1645 to 1660, when the monarchy was reinstated, the registers may be incorrect and deficient. This may mean only a small percentage of the marriages which took place were actually recorded, making in short this period unreliable.
However the deficiency of the parish records does show that the problems at that time affected such things as marriage, and because of that it is still useful.
They were always hand-written so legibility was sometimes bad and when the information was copied out mistakes could have been made. Abbreviations would have often been used and also at the beginning they would have been written in Latin, which may be unknown to us, making reading it problematic.
Some parish records may have been badly handled therefore damaging them, this may mean some information is impossible to retrieve.
Parish records are very useful with careful studying. They can give information on, for instance, when there was an outbreak of disease. You could get this information from the burial register, as a lot of people would have died at a particular time, you would have to substantiate this with further sources such as death certificates.
By looking carefully you could tell if women were pregnant when they married, as the baptism would be less than nine months after the marriage. However this type of event may bring around inaccurate information as the parents would lie to cover this fact up, so distorting the records. You had to register the birth either the first or second Sunday after the birth.
On the Baptism records the date, name of the child and parents would be included sometimes adding their address and fathers occupation or status, all of this information had to be include after 1813, so it would give a large range of information. On Burial records it shows the name and abode of deceased, when buried, by whom and age. Marriage records also show similar information to the previous two. This gives us insights into the wealth of the area, the main professions, common names etc.
Overall I think Parish records can be taken as fairly reliable, becoming more so in later years, because they were completed by the Clergy and then officials who should have no reason to lie or show bias in completing simple forms. Problems may arise through presentation and any abbreviations used. Censusґ first started in 1801 and have taken place every 10 years since, apart from 1941 as it was a virtual impossible with the war going on. Some people say the first census was The Doomsday Book, this was when William I carried out a survey on his new kingdom to find out about it.
‘A census is the official numbering of the inhabitants of a country.ґ Not only does a census let the government know how many people they rule, but also provides them with other information, such as the wealth of the country so they know how much tax we should be paying.
The country is split into Enumeration Districts; an Enumerator was given the responsibility for overseeing the census in his district. He (always a man) would deliver a census to each house and later collect them on a set Sunday night and Monday morning. Everyone sleeping in the house that night was included. All the information was then gathered together and compiled to produce an Enumeratorґs Return. Before 1841 several things were different about the census. They had been the responsibility of the clergy and the overseer of the poor but then it was given to the Registrar General and Superintendent Registrar. This meant the same people who handled the registering of births, deaths and marriages were dealing with it. It could therefore be seen that it would be more reliable, as professionals with experience were dealing with it.
More information was gathered from the 1841 census as the questions had been changed. They now gained information on occupations and relations; this would make it more reliable than previous ones, as it was clearer, with more detail. As more questions have been added with time the census has become more detailed but with this more reliable as a primary source.
Census reports mean the government can make predictions and so work around these for the good of the country. E.g. see how many children are going to need school places in two years time. If there is going to be a boom then more teachers will need to be employed maybe more schools built and so forth. It has to be reliable so they can have accurate statistics.
Census material isnґt allowed to be seen by the public for one hundred years. This stops embarrassment by other people seeing personal information about you. This makes the censuses more reliable as people wonґt feel embarrassed and so wonґt want to conceal anything, therefore being honest.
Unfortunately many records had not been kept or were destroyed from before; this would make it hard to check the reliability of later census against the earlier ones, to see any discrepancies.
The 1841 census was taken in June whereas later ones were taken in March or April. This meant the 1841 census might be unreliable, as many people would be moving around at that time in search of summer work, e.g. helping at farms.
Another point which made the 1841 and before census unreliable was the fact that they rounded down ages of people over 15. This could mean if someoneґs age was written as 25, they could be any age between 25 and 29.
Census reports would only allow the inclusion of one occupation. For women this held a problem as many had part time jobs which they couldnґt include so instead they had to leave blank as to say they were house wives. This meant the number of women working isnґt truly representative, this is proved through looking at work records, which shows a much stronger female workforce.
Other problems on census included that if the head of the family had gone away to find work, he would be missing from the census, this can be confusing and makes things like income unclear. Also older relatives living with a family were recorded as servants on censuses. This was because they had to have an occupation, they couldnґt be retired. This leads to confusion as you may think the family is richer than you think as they have servants but also means you think the relatives are still working.
Enumerator returns were written by hand. This causes problems as they can be illegible, and mistakes were often made. Shortened names or nicknames were sometimes included; this makes the results inaccurate. They also used abbreviations that must be known before you can attempt to understand the returns. Both Parish Records and Census Returns give important historical information, such as percentage of men to women. Both allow you to trace ancestry over a long time but neither are completely reliable. The parish records only give limited information and so do early census reports. However with time, both have become more reliable with more efficient methods/ questions being used.
Census returns and parish records can be cross-referenced to check the reliability of each. Such things as addressґ, dates of birth and so on, can often be seen on both and so checked off for accuracy.
To evaluate the census and parish records as reliable written sources, I think to begin with the date plays a crucial role. The older sources are less detailed and are harder to read and understand clearly. Yet they all give us some clue to the lives and deaths of our ancestors. The individual source has to be looked at to gain a definite claim of reliability but there are certain things one can look for within the source. Itґs date, where it is from, whom it is written by and about and whether there are other sources which can be cross-referenced to check the reliability of the sources in question.
Другие работы по теме:
Мемориальная церковь Мартина Лютера Берлин
План Введение 1 История церкви 1.1 В Третьем рейхе 1.2 Послевоенный период 2 Архитектура 3 Интерьер Список литературы Введение Мемориальная церковь Мартина Лютера (нем. Martin-Luther-Gedдchtniskirche) — лютеранская церковь в южном Берлине. Первоначально заложенная как приходская, в 30-е годы церковь стала одним из центров немецких христиан, что нашло отражение в оформлении здания.
Confidentiality And The Law Essay Research Paper
Confidentiality and the Law Confidentiality regarding the information in children’s school records is of large concern to parents. Parents worry about the information being accurate, and they also worry about access being restricted to those individuals with a justifiable reason. The issue of confidentiality has received a great deal of attention, hence several laws designed to protect not only the student, but also teachers, school counselors, and other administrators.
1967 Referendum Essay Research Paper The 1967
1967 Referendum Essay, Research Paper The 1967 Referendum On 27 May 1967 a Federal referendum was held. The first question, referred to as the nexus question’ was an attempt to alter the balance of numbers in the Senate and the House of Representatives. The second question was to determine whether two references in the Australian Constitution which discriminated against Aboriginal people should be removed.
Pysch Essay Research Paper Research Methods is
Pysch Essay, Research Paper Research Methods- is when you make and test prediction of the relations between variables. Its the study of behaviour. Variables is any condition, event, characteristic or behaviour.
History Of Parish Councils Essay Research Paper
A Brief History of Parish Councils To understand the history and development of Parish Councils a contrast has to be made between parish councils in the 1960s and 70s with councils in the 80s and 90s. One difference, which is overwhelmingly apparent, is the amount of authority and control the parish council has.
Clerk Typist Essay Research Paper There is
Clerk Typist Essay, Research Paper There is something mysterious and powerful about dreams. For many years, I have wondered what dreams are really made of. I came up with two possible answers. First, I think dreams can provide an escape from or evaluation of every day reality. And secondly, I believe that certain images can be translated to provide hidden answers to daily problems.
Common Law Essay Research Paper Communications LawIn
Common Law Essay, Research Paper Communications Law In San Franciso, two of Alameda County’s six municipal courts have limited public access to criminal court records after a Legal Aid Society lawyer requested it; others are waiting an opinion from the county counsel about its constitutionality.
Opening Adoption Records Essay Research Paper Opening
Opening Adoption Records Essay, Research Paper Opening Adoption Records When a child is adopted, it is standard procedure for a new birth certificate to be issued. On this new certificate the adoptee s new name appears, along with the names of the adoptive parents. All references to the adoptee s birth name, the name of the adoptee s birth parents and the fact of the adoption, are omitted.
Aims Essay Research Paper
Dearth contemporary sources, mainly Romans ones, require careful evaluation,. ? Dio says that ?threatening to recover everything which the Persians of old once used to
Reliability Of Narrator Essay Research Paper Reliability
Reliability Of Narrator Essay, Research Paper Reliability of a Narrator Stories are often told by a narrator giving his/her point of view, by using omniscient, limited omniscient, or first person. The purpose of the narrator is to give facts
Servqual Essay Research Paper PS1 What is
Servqual Essay, Research Paper PS.1 What is the ServQual model ? PS.2 What are the advantages and disadvantages of the model? PS.3 In what situation can it be used?
Cadillac Essay Research Paper IntroductionNow that we
Cadillac Essay, Research Paper Introduction Now that we have looked at the Cadillac Escalade?s environment and target markets, lets look at the marketing mix to show what cadillac does to influence the demand of the Escalade.
Confidentiality Of Individually Identifiable Health Information Essay
, Research Paper Criterion A: Describing the issueThe misuse of private health care information can cause discrimination against others in society. Nowadays we trust and depend upon the medical professionals to secure our private records. The computer revolution has made the process of transmitting information convenient, thus allowing our family secrets to travel from our family doctor to hospitals to insurance companies – increasing the level of insecurity.
Validity Essay Research Paper Key Terms pp
Validity Essay, Research Paper Key Terms (pp. 344-347) concurrent validity- A classification of criterion validity whereby a new measure correlates with a criterion measure taken at the same time (p. 344.)
Density Of Urine Essay Research Paper The
Density Of Urine Essay, Research Paper The term ‘density’ refers to the proportion of an object’s mass to it’s volume (Grasse, 1996). The ratio between the density of a substance and the density of water is called specific gravity and is used in many diagnostic tests. ONe example is the specific gravity of urine which is normally determined as part of a laboratory evaluation of the health of an individual.
Music Quality And Marketing Essay Research Paper
Over the years the music industry has grown from a fairly profitable industry with a few major stars into a billion dollar industry with many major stars. The music industry has evolved in many different ways through such
Chad Vonder Haar Essay Research Paper AvistonDefineIrresponsibility
Chad Vonder Haar Essay, Research Paper Aviston Define Irresponsibility is a problem with today’s youth. Many young men and women believe that when they turn eighteen they automatically become adults. These beliefs show how immature some adolescents are. Adulthood encompasses a great deal of independence, responsibility, and reliability.
Hip Hop Essay Research Paper Music AppreciationHipHop
Hip Hop Essay, Research Paper Music Appreciation Hip-Hop is one of the newest forms of music. It has expanded and is now the most popular form of music for people ages 11-25. In the last 2 years, hip-hop is the most lucrative form of music. It has sold billions of records and has made record companies billions of dollars.
Abigail Adams Essay Research Paper Abigail Adams
Abigail Adams Essay, Research Paper Abigail Adams was a unique woman because she had an education and an interest in politics. She learned how to read and write and enjoyed poems most. She was also very resourceful by helping her husband on difficult problems.
The Logic Of Evaluation Essay Research Paper
The Logic of Evaluation Along with questions there are answers, most questions must be evaluated before arriving to those answers. Usually when I am asking a question I go through a mental process of evaluating the question at hand before giving what I considered to be the most accurate answer.
Ethics And Computer Security Essay Research Paper
1. The Problem In the recent discussion of the required specifications of our new computer security product, the issue of including backdoor in the product was brought up. This backdoor would allow anyone knowing this special password to access anything going on in the system and would also allow one possessing the password to read personal files and email of employees.
Expert Systems In Health Care Essay Research
Paper A case referring to the beneficial use of the expert systems in the health sector was the attempt of the LDS Hospital in Salt Lake city,Utah to build the most complex artificial intelligence system ever created according to the words of DR David Classen.Its name was AIC or Antibiotic Computer Consultant and it was part of HELP(Health Evaluation through Logical Processing), which was LDS s hospital information system.
Dieting Essay Research Paper The assessment of
Dieting Essay, Research Paper The assessment of diet is often a difficult task: accurate evaluation of a person’s diet is dependent on that person’s ability to give a precise account of their food intake; yet the act of recording a person’s intake can easily influence what the person eats during that time, and people tend to have difficulty remembering what they have eaten.
Computer Skills Evaluation For New Trainees Essay
, Research Paper Computer Skills Evaluation for New Trainees In order to establish the purpose and behavioral objectives of the educational program, discussions with administrative staff project team members, and area supervisors took place. Subsequently, a framework for required skills and content for the program were identified.
Action Research Plan Essay Research Paper Do
Action Research Plan Essay, Research Paper Do Rubrics Enhance and Improve Students? Writing Products? Research: H. Andrade. (2000). Using Rubrics to promote thinking and learning. Educational Leadership. ASCD. Volume 57 NO. 5. February.
Computer Privacy Essay Research Paper Today a
Computer Privacy Essay, Research Paper Today a profound shift in the privacy equation is under way. Technology brings enormous efficiency to the collection, sorting and distribution of personal information. This efficiency has revolutionized countless organizations but it has also increased opportunities for snooping.
Killing For Sport Essay Research Paper ENGLISH
Killing For Sport Essay, Research Paper ENGLISH I . 1613 PAPER 7 KILLING FOR SPORT “Killing for Sport” by Joseph Wood Krutch is an opinionated work on the subject of hunting for sport. He uses rational appeals to press the point of the sportsman as having less to gain out of the killing than the liar, the thief, or the murderer.
Crucible Evaluation Essay Research Paper The Crucible
Crucible Evaluation Essay, Research Paper The Crucible Evaluation When Arthur Miller sat down to write the Crucible, it is obvious he took many things into account. The presentation of the book is very well thought out. As for the history aspect of the book, it is obvious that he did a lot of research even though there are still some discrepancies.
Home Computer Network Essay Research Paper Have
Home Computer Network Essay, Research Paper Have you ever needed to have more than one home computer for you and your family? Do you have two or more computers, but need to copy and/or share files and/or programs between them, but you don t know how? Do all of your computers need Internet access, but you don t want to have a phone line installed for each of them? Well, you can do all of this.
Ford Focus Copying Honda Civics Essay Research
Paper Ford Focus Copying Honda Civics? Have you ever heard of a live commercial? Or better yet ever seen one? Well Ford Motor Company is about to launch the new Focus. The Focus is targeted at the first time buyers market. Ford Motors is spending at least $100 million dollars in this new approach marketing strategy.
Sports Fans Essay Research Paper Psycologists often
Sports Fans Essay, Research Paper Psycologists often look to find patterns of behavior among similar peoplein similar circumstances. One such study is that of the psycological effect of sports teams and their fans. In a study atMurry State University, Daniel L. Wann and Thomas J. Dolan tried to prove that fans that had a high associationwith their favorite team would be biassed in their evaluation of the past, preasent, and future preformances.