Environmental Factors For Schizophrenia Essay, Research Paper
Critically Consider the Contribution of Biological and Environmental Factors for Schizophrenia
Schizophrenia is a common form of mental disorder, effecting 40-50% of psychiatric patients. Symptoms include hallucinations, delusions and disturbance of thought. Although sufferers do suffer a split in their mind- from themselves and the world around them, schizophrenia must not be confused with multiple personality disorder. It is the most serious of disorders in both ICD-10 and DSM-IV and both recognise the four different types of schizophrenia.
Each school of psychology has a theory for the aetiology of schizophrenia. The two main areas of thought to what causes the disorder are biological factors and environmental factors.
The biological approach is supported by the medical model in three sectors- the biochemical influence, the genetic influence and the neurodevelopment influence.
The biochemical theory proposes that schizophrenia be caused by chemical imbalances in the brain which, in turn are caused by an excess of the neurotransmitter- dopamine. There is evidence to support this claim. Firstly, post-mortem examinations of schizophrenics do tend to show high levels of dopamine, as found by Iverson in 1979. The problem with this evidence is that the levels of dopamine could indeed be a result of the disorder rather than a cause. The second area of evidence concentrates around the treatment of schizophrenics, drugs such as chlorpromazine work by binding to dopamine receptor sites, again the fact that there is dopamine there to begin with could be a result, not a cause of the disorder. Also, this evidence only tells us that dopamine is important for the action of anti-schizophrenic drugs, it doesn t tell us that high dopamine levels is the sole cause, or even cause of the disorder. The final piece of evidence for the dopamine hypothesis is that drugs such as amphetamines, LSD and L-dopa do increase the amount of dopamine in the brain, they also cause the user to portray schizophrenic behaviour. Osmond and Smythies, 1976 who noticed the similarities between the effects of hallucinogenic drugs and schizophrenic behaviour, support this. As does Murray, he found traces of the hallucinogen- DMT in schizophrenic s urine. Despite being fairly impressive, the dopamine hypothesis is a very reductionist argument, the dopamine is not proven to be a direct influence to schizophrenia. Crow et al criticises the theory using Kraepellin s positive and negative symptoms. He states that negative effects such as diminished social interaction and slight speech are not affected by the treatments given. Only positive symptoms- hallucinations, delusions etc. are helped. This suggests that these are the only symptoms that may be caused by dopamine.
The genetic theory appears to carry more weight than the other biological theories. A person has a 1in a 100 chance of becoming schizophrenic, if one parent has schizophrenia then the chances increase to 1 in 5 chance and if both parents have had schizophrenia the likelihood further increases to a 1 in 2 chance. There has been extensive research on twins and adoption studies.
Most research has been in the medium of concordance rates between identical (MZ) twins and between non- identical (DZ) twins. The first of these tests was carried out by Kallaman in 1938, he found that MZ twins had concordance rates of 86.2% and DZ twins had rates of 14.5%. This makes sense as identical twins share the same, identical genes. However, he has been heavily criticised, the experiments were carried out long before ICD and DSM were introduced, therefore subjects may not have bee correctly diagnosed. There was also no scientific way for Kallaman to distinguish between MZ and DZ twins, he could have been biased. There is also evidence of false hospital records and evidence that Kallaman tested twins who had not suffered any schizophrenic symptoms. There have been supporters but there has never bee concordance rates as high as Kallaman s. In 1966 Gottesman and Shields studied 57schizophrenics with twins in London between 1948-64. They found a rate of 48% for MZ twins and just 9% for DZ twins. The latest is Fischer in 1973 in Denmark; they found a broad concordance rate of 48% in MZ s and 20% in DZ s. Although rates vary, it is clear that generally they reduce in time, this is due to the introduction of DSM-IV and ICD-10, it also casts doubt on how reliable the rates in the early experiments were. Heston discovered that if an MZ twin had schizophrenia there was a 90% chance that the other twin would have a mental disorder, be it schizophrenia or not. Environmentalists argue that this is due to twins having the same upbringing under the same circumstances. This problem has been over-ruled, as there have been studies of twins separated at birth who still both have schizophrenia.
The other type of study to prove the genetic theory is adoption studies. Heston has studied adopted children born to schizophrenic mothers but raised by non-schizophrenic parents and compared them to children raised by their biological, non-schizophrenic parents. The results were that 10% of the adopted children suffered with schizophrenia and none of the biologically raised children suffered. Kety et al, 1968 showed that there are many flaws in an environmentalist s view of schizophrenia- In Denmark, a list was compiled of adopted children and whether they were or were not schizophrenic. The rate was low in both groups but of the children that were schizophrenic- 21% had schizophrenic, biological mothers. This suggests that schizophrenia is genetic. An environmentalist would believe it was how the children were brought up in their surrogate families that would determine whether or not they ever suffered.
There is a lot of evidence to support the genetic theory, however it cannot be proven as there is uncertainty as to which gene it is that causes the disorder. There have been breakthroughs but each one has been undermined in the light of new evidence.
There is also the neurodevelopment theory, which blames brain damage for schizophrenia and therefore claims to have evidence that schizophrenia is a brain disease. Harrison has shown evidence of schizophrenics undergoing difficult births and a temporary lack of oxygen to the brain. Bracha, 1991 also suggests that it occur during the time that the child is in the mother s womb. He has evidence suggesting that one MZ twin sufferer is more likely to have hand deformities than the other. The hands are developed in the second trimester of pregnancy and could be caused by a viral infection.
The evidence for neurodevelopment disorders is very inconclusive and in areas contradicts itself.
The other side of schizophrenia is the environmentalist view, although there is little evidence to point to an actual trigger but there have been suggestions;
Strole et al blame poverty, he found that the highest rates of schizophrenia are in inner-city areas and is supported by Clark who found a positive correlation between schizophrenia and low status jobs. In this case it could be the fact that a person is schizophrenic which is stopping them getting a high status job, not vice-versa. Clark uses a correlation, which are often put down to coincidence rather than fact.
Bateson supports R.D. Laing s view that the family is to blame. He says that children can be put into intolerable situations called double binds when they are told to do one thing, for example be more affectionate but at the same time told to do the opposite, for example that they are to old to give their parents a hug. Schizophrenia is a way out for these people. Wynne et al in 1977 stated that parents would sometimes refuse to use a word that a child had learnt and understood to be correct and fill it in with another word. This, according to Wynne can be a step towards the development of schizophrenia. This is thought to be a little far-fetched. R.D.Laing says that the society in which we live is the cause of schizophrenia, he gets his message across through writing three books, using existential psychology (where he tries to get inside the mind of a schizophrenic). The first book is called The Divided Self , Laing states that a schizophrenic is insecure and has fears that society will transform him/her into an automata. In his second book, Laing takes Szazs view that schizophrenia doesn t exist as an entity but a tool used by psychiatrists and such professionals to control people whom they see as different and a threat to the society because of their abnormal views. In his third book, which is rarely taken seriously, Laing states the psychedelic vision of schizophrenia, that sufferers are critics of our seemingly mad society and treatment for schizophrenia is just a deterrent to stop them believing such things. R.D.Laing is criticised for underestimating the horror that schizophrenia sufferer s experience.
So the battle between nature and nurture continues, one side believing that a chemical imbalance in the brain or genetics are to blame and the others uncertain about what actually triggers the disorder, it could be down to socio-economic-status, upbringing, the family, the society or life experience. There has been a lot of research and will continue to be large amounts of studies into the aetiology of the disorder but what actually causes it is controversial and more importantly unknown.
Другие работы по теме:
Shame
– Richard Gregory Essay, Research Paper SHAME By Dick Gregory Richard Gregory learned about the cruelty of poverty very early in life through two different experiences that marked his life and he tried to overcome by overachieving.
PLANTS Essay Research Paper With the everincreasing
PLANTS Essay, Research Paper With the ever-increasing problem of pest control, it is clear that some form biological must be implemented in order to help farmers. This biological control must be able to effectively control the pest population, this means not killing them but rather never letting the pest populations get too large.
Tapeworm2 Essay Research Paper Biological RelationshipIn nature
Tapeworm2 Essay, Research Paper Biological Relationship In nature you see many biological relationship in which two living aninamls have a relationship. One animal will benefits from the other aninaml that animal which lives off the other benefits from that animal or could suffers. A tapeworm and a human are example of a parasitism.
Huck Finns Real Father Essay Research Paper
Huck s True Father In Mark Twain s novel The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn young Huck seems to have two fathers. Pap, his biological father, and Jim, the runaway slave who befriends Huck and acts the way a real father should.
Taking Versus Giving Essay Research Paper Speak
Taking Versus Giving Essay, Research Paper Speak to the people of Israel and take for me a contribution from each person according to the generosity of his heart take My contribution (Shmot 25:2).
Opening Adoption Records Essay Research Paper Opening
Opening Adoption Records Essay, Research Paper Opening Adoption Records When a child is adopted, it is standard procedure for a new birth certificate to be issued. On this new certificate the adoptee s new name appears, along with the names of the adoptive parents. All references to the adoptee s birth name, the name of the adoptee s birth parents and the fact of the adoption, are omitted.
Critically Consider Two Psyshological Theories Of Crime
Essay, Research Paper CRITICALLY CONSIDER TWO PSYSHOLOGICAL THEORIES OF CRIME What is crime? Crime is an act of immoral and harmful behaviour. As crime is prohibited by the criminal law it is seen as an act against society. People who study crime are called criminologists. Criminology has many theories, which are based on biology, sociology and psychology.
Biology In Crime Essay Research Paper Of
Biology In Crime Essay, Research Paper Of all the factors that can influence criminal behavior, biological influences can definitely play one of the more important roles. Several areas of research support ideas of a genetic influence as well as neurological defects and chemical imbalances that play into motivations of criminal activity.
The Endagnered Species Act Essay Research Paper
The endangered species act, according to Stephen O’Brien, identifies and protects plant and animal species whose population is critically threatened. The three categories of biological taxa that the Act tries to protect include species, subspecies, and population. According to O’Brien, the meaning of terms such as taxonomy, and the occurrence of hybridization between species, has led to disaggreements by government officials.
Environmental Archaeology Essay Research Paper IF
Environmental Archaeology Essay, Research Paper IF we want to know how humans functioned we must know what their world was like ? thus environmental reconstruction Geomorphical and biological processes occurring
The Contempary Enlightend One Essay Research Paper
The Contemporary Enlightened One J.D. Salinger is considered one of the most critically reviewed author in modern literature. In particular his only novel Catcher in the Rye has received the most criticism.
Chemical 2
Chemical & Biological Warfare Essay, Research Paper Chemical & Biological Warfare Ever since the beginning of time people have used tools, which were later called weapons. People have
Sex And Gender Essay Research Paper Sex
Sex And Gender Essay, Research Paper Sex is a word that refers to the biological differences between male and female: the visible difference in genitalia, the related difference in procreative function. ‘Gender’ however is a matter of culture: it refers to social classification into ‘masculine’ and ‘feminine’ (Oakley, 1972: 16)
Benificial Insects Essay Research Paper Beneficial Insects
Benificial Insects Essay, Research Paper Beneficial Insects Insects have been roaming the earth for millions of years. They have adapted to every climate and terrain on earth. No matter what we do they will always be amongst us. This is not necessarily a bad thing; insects are actually beneficial to us. Insects help pollinate our crops each year.
Pesticides Essay Research Paper Give an account
Pesticides Essay, Research Paper Give an account of the ways in which biological control can be used to control pest numbers. The effect of predator-prey relationship in regulating populations has been exploited by humans as a method of controlling various pests. Biological pest control is where the natural predators (agent) of the pest ((target) are used to reduce its population to a tolerable level.
Gulf War Essay Research Paper Controversial Issues
Gulf War Essay, Research Paper Controversial Issues: Justifying the Persian Gulf War On January 16, 1991 the Gulf War had officially started, and for good reason. In August of 1990, Saddam Hussein sent armies to Kuwait, to take it over. When the United States had unwittingly given Saddam help when fighting against the Iranians, we had also given him a military that was one of the world’s largest and most lethal.
Cause Of Crime Essay Research Paper Criminals
Cause Of Crime Essay, Research Paper Criminals are born as with a different psychological scheme that persuades them to commit crime. Scientists believe that criminals develop such a complex from either a biological, however not genetic, chemicals in their body. These differences allow a psychological failure that leads the person not to develop a conscience.
Emotions Essay Research Paper Chad Geary142 82
Emotions Essay, Research Paper Chad Geary 142 82 8466 EMOTIONS Well in the past it was first thought by a man named Tomkins that emotion actually interfered with basic human drives, like lust and fear. It is known that humans by nature become stimulated by certain variables like a loud noise or possibly the sight of a spider.
Should Adopted Children Be Allowed To Locate
Their Biological Parents? Essay, Research Paper Should Adopted Children Be Allowed To Locate Their Biological Parents? A touchy topic these days is whether or not the option should be open
Perspective On The Healthcare Industry Essay Research
Paper Perspective on the Healthcare Industry Healthcare systems, whether in a well-developed nation or an economically poor society, should be viewed upon as a system which can improve or replace humanity?s biological misfortunes. In other words, the system is always existent and should be open to all members of a community, regardless of financial or socioeconomic status.
Taiwan Perspective Essay Research Paper Comment critically
Taiwan Perspective Essay, Research Paper Comment critically on at least two Taiwan futures. As United States policy states we support the “one China” idea but we will defend Taiwan if mainland China begins to attack. Thereby putting us at war with China. Taiwan would then be a free state, assuming we control and win the war, but at what cost to America? And for how long?
Transgenic Organisms Essay Research Paper Releasing a
Transgenic Organisms Essay, Research Paper Releasing a Transgenic Organism into Nature In the midst of our society’s ever advancing biological technology, scientists have created a plant that is herbicide and pesticide resistant. The question of whether the public should have access to this controversial plant raised many bioethical questions.
Tritts View Of Young Goodman Brown Essay
, Research Paper In the article, ??Young Goodman Brown? and the Psychology of Projection?, Michael Tritt critically analyzes Nathaniel Hawthorne?s ?Young Goodman Brown? to construct the process of how Hawthorne regards Goodman Brown?s behavior. Tritt examines the phenomenon of projection in psychology and believes that ?Brown?s compulsive condemnation of others, along with his consistent denial of his own culpability, illustrates a classically defined case of projection? (116).
Biological And Nuclear Weapons Essay Research Paper
Most people today believe that the world is a better place than it was 20 to 30 years ago. But I, on the other hand, believe that the world is becoming a very dangerous place. Even though the world’s superpowers condemn nuclear and biological warfare, I believe that the next millennium will bring a war that will make them change their beliefs toward weapons of mass destruction.
History Of Cell Membrane Essay Research Paper
In the early stages of the twentieth century, little was known about cell membranes. Until the early 1950s, the biological cell membrane was rarely mentioned in scientific literature. It was recognised that something was probably there, but hardly anything about it was known. Considering the lack of technical equipment available a century ago, scientists such as Charles Overton and Edwin Gorter were not only exploring new territory in looking at the properties of cell membranes, but laying the way for future cell biologists.
Peer Pressure Essay Research Paper Peer pressure
Peer Pressure Essay, Research Paper Peer pressure can influence a person to start smoking, drinking, or doing drugs and other things that are harmful to his/her body. However, peer pressure can also be helpful by influencing someone to do right instead of wrong. For example, a person can be an example to his/her friends and let them know he/she wants to do right and he/she wants to change how he/she acts or what he/she were like.
Child Poverty Essay Research Paper CHILDREN AND
Child Poverty Essay, Research Paper CHILDREN AND POVERTY IN CANADA The purpose of this project is to discuss child poverty and child welfare practice. There is a need to critically examine the issue and situate the causes of
Ecoftm Essay Research Paper EconomicsQuestion The most
Ecoftm Essay, Research Paper EconomicsQuestion: The most important contribution of the agricultural sector is to provideincremental markets for new products manufactured in the industrial sector. Answer: Thecontribution of the agricultural sector not only provide incremental markets for newproducts manufactured in the industrial sector, it also has contribution on increasing thesupply of food and new material to other sectors, tax revenue to the government to provide”investable surplus” to other expending sectors and to provide foreign exchange.
Piaget Theory Of Speech Development Essay Research
Paper Piaget theory of Speech Development There are two classical theories of Speech development. The one that I will focus on is Piaget’s theory of Speech development. Jean Piaget, a Swiss, educated, mollusk biologist lived from 1896 to 1980. He hypothesized that learning is a physical, biological function of dealing with successfully with the environment.
Descartes Essay Research Paper Descartes Ren
Descartes Essay, Research Paper Descartes, Ren Ren Descartes was born on March 31, 1596 and died on February 11, 1650. Ren Descartes was a man of many things. He was a French mathematician, philosopher and scientist. He made contributions to the theory of equations and his rule of signs, but the most distinguished contribution that Descartes made to the world of mathematics was analytic geometry.