Social Security Essay, Research Paper
Abbott 1
Josh A. Abbott
Professor Adams
Principles of Microeconomics
14 November 2000
Financial Concerns About the Future of Social Security
“Will Social Security Have future financial difficulty?”
In my view, Social security doesn’t face a true financial crisis. But it does face a crisis of confidence among younger workers. One widely publicized survey showed more young workers believed in UFOs than believed Social Security would pay them full benefits when they need them. By the time young workers, such as myself, reach the retirement age; confidence should be very high in Social Security, not low. This is just one of the problems overlooked when discussing issues on the future retirement plan.
This crisis of confidence is the strongest argument to allow workers to invest part of their payroll tax in private accounts. Social Security gives today’s workers just a 2 percent return on their investment (Bulling 21). Giving them a better rate of return, even the 4 or 5 percent they could get from federal bonds, would obviously help their retirement. But it would also empower workers. Workers would control their private plans and might, for example, choose to spend just their dividends and leave their stocks to their heirs.
Abbott 2
When Social Security was launched in 1935, in the middle of the Great Depression, there was no way to fund it like a normal retirement program by setting contributions aside for 40 years before paying out the first benefits. Instead, President Franklin D. Roosevelt opted to tax active workers and use that money to pay benefits to people who were already at or near the normal retirement age of 65 (Erickson).
That plan was a prize for the original retirees and those who followed in the first few decades of the program. But the system of using most of today’s taxes to pay today’s benefits will come under severe strain when baby boomers begin to retire in 2015, and the surpluses now piling up in the system begin to decline. By 2037, some experts think those surpluses will be gone and taxes coming into the system will only be adequate to pay 70 percent of promised benefits (Erickson).
It’s worth noting that those projections are based on extremely pessimistic, “worst case” scenarios, and the booming American economy already has caused the supposed “day of reckoning” to be pushed back repeatedly to its current 2037 date. But critics who moan that the system is ruined overlook an even more important fact: No law of God or man says that Social Security benefits can only be paid from the current, and extremely regressive, Social Security payroll taxes. If there truly is a Social Security shortfall in 2037, the federal government could use general revenues to supplement the fund. The government also could borrow money to pay Social Security benefits in 2037- just as it
Abbott 3
has borrowed in the past to pay for everything from aircraft carriers to hydroelectric projects.
Even if the federal government had to divert an additional $1 trillion of general tax revenues to Social Security over the next 40 years, that sum would be less than one-half of one percent of projected federal revenues over that same 40 years (Bulling 25). That’s a modest price to restore public confidence in America’s most important social program.
Until recently, all sides in the debate over Social Security reform agreed that this moment of economic prosperity is the right time to fix the nation’s ailing retirement system- that we should “fix the roof while the sun is shining,” as President Clinton put it. But now an increasingly vocal minority of people is denying that the roof even needs fixing and questioning whether the “rain will ever come” (Austin).
To these “crisis deniers,” Social Security’s problems are simply the product of pessimistic economic assumptions. If the economy grows faster in coming years than the 1.7 percent projected by the program’s trustees, Social Security becomes “a crisis that doesn’t exist, ” according to Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-N.Y.). Even Vice President Gore got on board, saying, “If Social Security ain’t broke, why fix it?” Gore offers a Security storm is gathering strength, and the longer we put off preparation the worse the damage will eventually be (Austin).
Abbott 4
Politicians aren’t the only ones doubting the Social Security crisis. Financial columnist Jane Bryant Quinn went from saying in 1998 that “we can’t drag our feet any longer on Social Security reform” to today calling herself “the only kid in the village who’s not crying wolf.” In an editorial, Business Week said the Social Security trustees’ “ridiculously low” economic projections make the reform debate a “phony problem” (Bulling 29).
But tow expert panels found just the opposite. Accounting giant PricewaterhouseCoopers examined the Trustees’ projections at the request of Rep. Nadler and concluded that the “methods used in preparing the long-range? projections of the Social Security trust funds were sound and the assumptions used in preparing the projections in the Trustees’ report were individually reasonable” (Bulling 20).
A nonpartisan panel of government-appointed economists and demographers went further, finding the trustees, if anything, optimistic about Social Security’s future. The trustees greatly underestimate increases in life expectancy. If people live as long as expert demographers predict they will, the retiree population will swell and Social Security’s $20 trillion long-term deficit would increase by one quarter (Wells).
Even so, Dean Baker and Mark Weisbrot, authors of “Social Security: The Phony Crisis,” claim that “using any remotely realistic projection for the growth of wages
Abbott 5
and the economy, the Social Security system will be solvent into the stratosphere of America’s science-fiction future.” Well, let’s look at the numbers. For Social Security to stay technically solvent until 2075, wages would have to grow 2.9 percent annually above
inflation. That is 3.7 times faster than over the past 30 years, and 41 percent faster than during the booming 1960’s (Wells). — “Technically” solvent means little, since the Social Security trust fund is not a true savings vehicle but a mere bookkeeping account full of IOUs—-something even the Clinton administration, in a moment of candor, was forced to admit.
Then there’s the fact that the more workers earn and pay in taxes, the more they are owed in retirement benefits. So it’s almost impossible to use economic growth to get ahead of the game. Social Security solvency into the “science-fiction future” demands truly science-fiction levels of economic growth.
How do we prepare for a future with fewer workers and more retirees? How do we build confidence in young individuals minds about Social Security in the future? The key is saving, and the best way is through personal retirement accounts: Allow today’s workers to invest a portion of their payroll taxes in accounts similar to IRA’s and 401(k)s, where money will rapidly accumulate to help pay future benefits.
Abbott 6
Social Security’s problems are not “greatly exaggerated.” In fact, independent studies show precisely the opposite to be true. If tomorrow’s retirees hope to enjoy a secure retirement, Social Security must stop simply redistributing wealth and start creating it. This is the only way confidence and success will be derived from Social Security.
Bibliography
Abbott 7
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Austin, Marsha J., “Candidates differ on Social Security,” Denver Post Home Page,
October 1, 2000,
(November 8, 2000).
Bulling, David, Jr., “Social Security: A Problem?” Business Week, May 29, 2000, pp.
19-31.
Erickson, Dinah J., “Saving Social Security,” Chicago Tribune. Home Page, November
13, 2000,
(October 25, 2000).
Wells, Andrew G., “Wishful Thinking on Social Security,” Today’s Commentary. Home
Page, September 14, 2000,
(September 19, 2000).
Другие работы по теме:
Jim Abbott Essay Research Paper It is
Jim Abbott Essay, Research Paper It is a clear summer night at Fenway Park in Boston. The Boston Red Sox and the California Angels are in a hot pennant race. The Boston Red Sox are the best hitting team in the American League. The Angels need a win and are counting on their rookie pitcher. The old green stadium is overflowing with die-hard Red Sox fans as the rookie takes the mound.
Begging Essay Research Paper By the middle
Begging Essay, Research Paper By the middle of the fourteenth century, begging was becoming a social problem. During periods of economic dislocation, the unemployed began to roam the countryside and migrated to the towns looking for work. Capitalism, wage labor, and poverty continued to grow. The American welfare state is dated from the Social Security Act of 1935.the act continued and hardened the categorical programs that had been enacted by the states between 1910 and the 1920s.
Abbott 2
Abbott &Costello Essay, Research Paper In 1931, at Empire theater in New York City, Lou Costello and his crew grew worried that they would not be able to find a replacement for his straight man who became ill and was unable to perform. Fortunately, a fellow by the name of Bud Abbott was working the box office at the theater and offered to substitute.
Social Ills Essay Research Paper Every society
Social Ills Essay, Research Paper Every society of every civilization known to man has had its share of social ills. Even dating back to biblical times people have struggled with an ever-increasing number of hardships. All of which have led to the downfall of its social structure. As we all know, nothing lasts forever, but with the help of strong minds and able bodies, societies can curb their ills and ?clean up their act?.
Private Pension Plan Essay Research Paper Private
Private Pension Plan Essay, Research Paper Private Pension System The Current Social Security system should be replaced by a mandatory Private Pension plan. There are different types of investment plans one could choose before or even after they retire. Social Security is what everyone depends on once they retire at 65.
Eveline Mabel Burns Essay Research Paper As
Eveline Mabel Burns Essay, Research Paper As a social worker, one is intertwined in the broad realm of Social Welfare. One aspect that makes up Social Welfare is our country?s Social Security System. Without Social Security, many retired citizens of our country would not have any source of income. One person in this country?s history mostly responsible for devising the plan of Social Security is Eveline Mabel Burns.
The Computer Age Essay Research Paper Ben
The Computer Age Essay, Research Paper Ben Purdue 8/24/01 It is my prediction that the biggest issue we will face in the coming century not only as a nation but also as a planet is finding a blind between security of protected information and freedom of information. I say this because as a computer security consultant I understand the need for security of important information, however I as a programmer I understand such issues as the battle for open source code and freedom of information as a hole.
Congressional Project Essay Research Paper Between these
Congressional Project Essay, Research Paper Between these two great men Steve Rothman and Robert Torricelli. I have learned a lot about congressmen and politics but I am going to go into both of their biography and tell you a little about them.
Social Security 2 Essay Research Paper Social
Social Security 2 Essay, Research Paper Social security is very essential for most of today s older Americans. Since it was begun, it has been a sort of protection for retired workers, and for disabled workers. Social Security allows people to live independently and still have their dignity. There are about 150 million workers protected by Social security and more then 44 million people receive Social Security benefits.
Land Mines Essay Research Paper Land mines
Land Mines Essay, Research Paper Land mines greatly contribute to the danger of international security because they are used as military weapons. Because land mines have caused great destruction there has been an effort from international and non-governmental organizations to ban mines and clear areas infected with them.
Archeo Essay Research Paper A Cross Cultural
Archeo Essay, Research Paper A Cross Cultural Perspective of Polygyny As an institution, polygyny, the social arrangement that permits a man to have more than one wife at the same
Issue Paper Essay Research Paper Issue paperIn
Issue Paper Essay, Research Paper Issue paper In the two thousand presidential elections there are two main candidates. The candidates are Al Gore and Governor George W Bush. Al Gore is the candidate running for the Democratic Party and Bush is running for the Republic party. Each candidate has great points on certain issues.
Information Security Essay Research Paper Emerging Opportunities
Information Security Essay, Research Paper Emerging Opportunities and The Internet – Information Security by Margaret Headley “Using encryption on the Internet is the equivalent of arranging an armoured car to deliver credit card information from someone living in a cardboard box to someone living on a park bench.” Gene Spafford, computer security researcher, Purdue University.
Mass Media And The Right To Think
Essay, Research Paper Mass Media and The Right To Think University admission costs are a deceitful practice that needs to be investigated and changed for the good of the honest student. After having a topic chosen for the past week this, sadly, is all I can come up with. I have written this essay many times, and it always ends with failure.
Social Work Essay Research Paper Social Workers
Social Work Essay, Research Paper Social Workers in the United States have many roles and needs to fill in society. They are seen as the people that nurse the homeless, unemployed, hunger-stricken, and destitute back to life. It is their choice to help those more unfortunate than themselves, and although it is considered a “job”, it is really a way of life.
Social Security Essay Research Paper Social securityThe
Social Security Essay, Research Paper Social security The issue I am addressing today is what to do about social security. There is going to be a large problem with our social security in years to come. Both Al Gore and Bush
No One
’s A Mystery Essay, Research Paper Career choice, for many individuals in our society, is a sociological issue. (Brooks-Gunn & Schempp-Matthews, 1979). We tend to imitate what we see that we
Gore Vs Bush Essay Research Paper Term
Gore Vs Bush Essay, Research Paper Term Paper State and Local Government Steve Wenzel Michael Virnig There were several major issues that separated the Republican and Democratic candidates during the 2000 presidential campaign.
Bush Essay Research Paper George W Bush
Bush Essay, Research Paper George W. Bush Taxes: Governor Bush believes that roughly one-quarter of the surplus should be returned to the people who earned it through broad tax cuts otherwise, Washington will spend it. His plan will promote economic growth and increase access to the middle class by cutting high marginal rates.
Goverment Essay Research Paper THE RISE OF
Goverment Essay, Research Paper THE RISE OF THE BUREAUCRATIC STATE The bureaucracy has been constantly growing since its beginning. At the end of the Federalist period, only 3,000 civilian officials were appointed; then in 1925 about half a million were employees in the bureaucracy. However, the size of the bureaucracy is completely insignificant.
Social Security
–Drawbacks Of Privitization Essay, Research Paper Federal emplyoment retirement fund Based on way budget defined… way to get 50% annual benefits for aging, because of including paying insurance into
Social Role Essay Research Paper About Its
Social Role Essay, Research Paper About Its Social Role Waxing eloquent about stakeholder management and corporate social responsibility is in some circles the surest way to stifle a business conversation, if not a business career. Corporate philanthropy brings satisfaction to those who give and receive, the argument goes, but let us not get carried away by talk of give-aways.
The Difference Essay Research Paper The DifferenceBush
The Difference Essay, Research Paper The Difference Bush or Gore? Will it be the vice president or the governor of Texas to fill the presidency? Even after election day, this is still a very questionable topic. Because of the peoples’ split views, it seems the country has divided itself: half for Gore, half for Bush.
Suicide Essay Research Paper Social Problem Teen
Suicide Essay, Research Paper -Social Problem: Teen Suicide -Social Problem- Any problem that may cause pain and may affect a person?s life. ? Teen Suicide- Intentional and self-inflicted death.
Social Security Essay Research Paper Will Social
Social Security Essay, Research Paper Will Social Security be here in the future Social Security is a system that was set up in 1935 after the Great depression to help people get through tough times. “Social Security is now used by nearly 44 million Americans”(policy). Only people who payed into social security are eligible to collect when they retire.
Budget Negotiations Essay Research Paper
——————————————————————————– In the midst of the current budget negotiations, there is one neglected question worth asking: what does the public really want? Tax cuts? Paying down the national debt? More spending? If so, more spending on what? The available polling data, analyzed in this report, helps answer these questions.
Music In The World Essay Research Paper
Ways in Which to Balance the Federal Budget In order to start balancing the U.S. federal budget we have to limit the amount of foreign aid we are giving out. Currently we have aid going out to countries helping birth control, world hunger and military protection. We need to cut these links off and focus on our own problems in this country.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
Kant
’s Fundamental Principles Of The Metaphysics Of Moral Essay, Research Paper Kant’s Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Moral The central concept of Kant’s Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of