Napoleon And Stalin Essay, Research Paper
Napoleon and Stalin:
In his Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx described his vision of the future, where the proletariat, or working class, rises up to topple the bourgeoisie and create a society without social classes. The Russian revolution of 1917, led by Vladimir Lenin, attempted to do just that. Lenin died in 1924, several years after the revolution, and Joseph Stalin rose to replace him, forcing rival Leon Trotsky to resign. In George Orwell’s Animal Farm, Napoleon the pig represents Stalin, and he uses many of the same tactics as Stalin to obtain power. In order to secure their positions, both Stalin and Napoleon spread lies about their enemies, withhold information with the goal of spreading ignorance among their subjects, and force possible dissenters to confess to crimes that they have not committed.
Napoleon and Stalin each envision a society where they have authoritarian control, and they manipulate others to ensure their success. After Lenin died, “Stalin forced Trotsky to resign as a war minister and in 1927 expelled him from the [Communist] party.” Later, Stalin “had him assassinated” (Compton’s 2). Napoleon uses a similar method of eliminating his chief rival. During a debate about the windmill, “there [is] a terrible baying sound outside, and nine enormous dogs wearing brass-studded collars [come bounding into the barn. They [dash] strait for Snowball” (Animal Farm 57). After their respective rivals are gone, Stalin and Napoleon spread lies about them. Their goal in doing this is to divert the attention of the people and animals away from their miserable economic conditions. Another action that both Napoleon and Stalin cognate is to establish five-year plans in order to catch up with competitors. These plans set extremely high goals for production which are rarely met. Additionally, the plans involve the rationing of goods. A final part of the economic plan for both Napoleon and Stalin is a large construction project; for Napoleon it is a windmill, and for Stalin it is a dam. The animals have a hard time building the windmill. “All year the animals [work] like slaves. But they [are] happy in their work this work [is] strictly voluntary, but any animal who [absents] himself from it [will] have his rations reduced by half” (Animal Farm 63). Deceit such as this is used commonly used by both dictators to ensure the happiness of the masses.
While Napoleon and Stalin resort to drastic measures to preserve their power, neither is successful in creating the society he envisioned. A reason for their failure is selfishness; each ruler betters his own conditions while the masses suffer. Stalin “[creates] a famine in Ukraine” and “[conducts] a series of purges” to secure support for his policies and suppress any resistance to him (Compton’s 2). Napoleon resorts to similar measures , and additionally bestows upon himself pleasures that were once forbidden. “You did not suppose, surely, that there was ever a ruling against beds? The rule was against sheets , which are a human invention” (Animal Farm 70). Napoleon’s selfishness leads to pain among the animals. “For days at a time the animals [have] nothing to eat but chaff and mangels. Starvation [seems] to stare them in the face” (Animal Farm 75). Napoleon, however, does not care about his subjects. Like Stalin, he is only concerned about how his competitors see him, and as a result both he and Stalin fail in their mission of creating an egalitarian society. Each does succeed , however, in acquiring and abusing power.
In Animal Farm, the initially hopeful revolution comes to a hopeless end after Napoleon takes over. From this we learn that while the members of a society ma hold certain ideals, their ruler will probably be self-motivated and ignore those ideals as much as possible. Throughout history, we have seen that the ideals of a revolution are rarely upheld, and visions of an ideal society usually disagree with the final reality. While such visions usually end in failure, they do have worth, for it is impossible to improve conditions without knowing how to improve them or what the final goal is. Hope, though not always satisfied, is necessary for survival, and those who live in bleak conditions need hope to look past the pains of life.
Works Cited
Orwell, George. Animal Farm. New York: New American Library, 1946.
“Stalin Joseph.” Compton’s Multimedia Encyclopedia. 3rd ed. 1999.
32e
Другие работы по теме:
Napoleon Bonaparte Essay Research Paper NAPOLEON BONAPARTENapoleon
Napoleon Bonaparte Essay, Research Paper NAPOLEON BONAPARTE Napoleon was born at a time when society was changing very quickly during the French revolution. This was a time of opportunity for a person with his talents ambitions. The old rules and ways of doing thing were gone and new society had not taken place yet.
Arc De Triomph Essay Research Paper Jeremy
Arc De Triomph Essay, Research Paper Jeremy Crowe Arch de Triomphe The famous Arch de Triomphe was a monument of all the battles Napoleon won during his rein in France. The Arch was dedicated to Paris in 1836. The designer of the Arch was a man named named Jean Francois-Therese Chalgrin. The designer wanted it to be an impresive Arch so he made the arch 165 feet high and 145 feet long.
The Civil Code Napolean Essay Research Paper
Civil Code Napoleon had many impact on Europe and the World. Napoleon’s greatest impact was The Civil Code in my perspective. Napoleon considered the Civil Code to be the most significant of his achievements. Napoleon himself appears to have regarded the Civil Code of 1804 as the masterpiece of his reign, ”My true glory”.
Why Napoleon Was Successful Essay Research Paper
Why Napleon Was a Success Essay Napoleon Bonaparte, was born on August 15, 1769 in Ajaccio, Corsica. He had 7 brothers and sisters. His original nationality was Corsican-Italian. He also despised the French. He thought they were oppressors of his native land. His father was a lawyer, and was also anti-French.
Napolean Bonaparte Essay Research Paper Napoleon Bonaparte
Napolean Bonaparte Essay, Research Paper Napoleon Bonaparte ? French Revolution Napoleon was the cure of the French Revolution when he came to power. It would be impossible to put them together. From what was chaos throughout France during the Revolution, came a new government that Napoleon created. He was able to balance the government?s budgets and setting up national banks thus helping and supporting the economy of France.
Napolean Essay Research Paper The qualities of
Napolean Essay, Research Paper The qualities of a Romantic hero are clearly displayed through the ambitions and actions of Napoleon Bonaparte. Napoleon’s triumphs and ideas for France’s future truly made him a Romantic hero.
Napolean Essay Research Paper During the French
Napolean Essay, Research Paper During the French Revolution the years of 1799-1815, France was ruled by Napoleon Bonaparte. Although many people feel that Napoleon is one of dictatorship, the truth is he one for the country and did what he felt was in the best interest of France. Napoleon was a democratic leader for his country.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Animal FarmMr Jones
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Animal FarmMr. Jones owned and managed Manor Farm. He was a bad man who liked to drink. Things on the farm got so bad one night that he fell asleep so drunk that he forgot to lock in the animals. The beasts took advantage of the situation and held a secret meeting. Led by the pigs, they ran the Joneses from their home.The animals of the renamed “Animal Farm” formed a system they called “Animalism.
Was Napoleon Good Essay Research Paper Was
Was Napoleon Good? Essay, Research Paper Was Napoleon a good leader for France? There have been many successful military leaders throughout history, but no leader has ever taken over the whole world. This was nearly accomplished by the greatest military leader in history better known as Napoleon Bonaparte.
Animal Farm Strong Vs Weak Essay Research
Paper The pigs had objectives other than the benefits and the good of the other animals. On the contrary, their objectives were to use, conquer, and capitalize on them. One of the conflicts in Animal
The Relationship Between Snowball And Napoleon In
Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper The relationship surrounding Snowball and Napoleon in George Orwell s Animal Farm tends to be on rocky grounds. Snowball, a clever pig, tends to be loyal, brave, and outgoing. These are just a few excellent qualities of a leader. Napoleon, a boar, on the other hand, is quite frankly rude, wretched, and full of greed.
Is Napoleon Bonaparte Machiavellian In Nature Essay
, Research Paper In 1513, Niccolo Machiavelli wrote a piece of work called, “The Prince”. It was written to all principalities, and that which is parallel to what Machiavelli suggests is often referred to as being “Machiavellian”. The purpose of this essay is to ask the question “Is Napoleon Bonaparte Machiavellian in Nature?” By the evidence found from Napoleon’s life and accomplishments it can said that he was not Machiavellian in nature, which can be demonstrated by numerous accounts as well as some suggested characteristics given by Machiavelli, to support this theory.
Book Review Essay Research Paper Animal Farmby
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Animal Farm by: George Orwell Book Review by George Lacy Mrs. Spain Fall 96 Character Analysis of Napoleon “Napoleon was a large rather fierce looking Berkshire boar,” that was spoiled and always got his way. He was the only pig of the kind on the farm. Napoleon was a great rival to Snowball.
Summary Of Orwells
’ Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper Summary of Orwells’ Animal Farm In the beginning of Orewell’s novel the animals rebel against the “Manor Farm” they take it over, and drive the humans off of the farm. In doing this
The Overthrow Of A Corrupted Government In
Orwell’s “Animal Farm” Essay, Research Paper In the novel, Animal Farm the characters, portrayed as animals show the deterioration of moral rules that relate to human activities.
Napoleon Vs Snowball In Animal Farm Essay
, Research Paper When we first read Animal Farm by George Orwell we find it to be an amusing fairy tale, although it has a much deeper meaning. In Orwell?s novel the animals revolt against their human rulers talk and harvest crops. This whole idea of the revolt is based on the Russian Revolution, in which the revolt started of as a foundation of an idealistic society but as time flew by dictatorship returned [Animal Farm: downtown.ala].
Animal Farm Stalin And Napoleon Essay Research
Paper The novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell, was an allegory about the Russian Revolution in which the author used a farm and it?s members to symbolize major characters and their actions. In this composition, I will reveal to you many of Joseph Stalin? s important contributions and how they relate to the actions of Napoleon from Animal Farm.
Animal Farm napoleon Essay Research Paper Animal
Animal Farm (napoleon) Essay, Research Paper Animal farm Napoleon The great rebellion on animal farm was a great event for all the animals. The pigs in particular were very supportive in these events as was seen in snowball during the battle of the cow-shed. Napoleon, because he was the bigger of the boars was seen as a figure of small authority on the farm and was usually seen to be caring and supportive towards the ideas of the rebellion.
Animal Farm Essay Essay Research Paper December
Animal Farm Essay Essay, Research Paper December 2, 1996 Period 5 Animal Farm Essay The name of the book is Animal Farm, which is written by George Orwell. This book is about a farm with animals who dislike the treatment, and
Napoleon Essay Research Paper Nationalism is the
Napoleon Essay, Research Paper Nationalism is the devotion of people to the interests of its nation or the love of one’s country to stay independent. Nationalism played a major role in the downfall of Napoleon in that he wanted an empire and his opponent’s wanted independence.As Napoleon was conquering lands and creating a vast empire his troops stressed in the far lands that they conquered life, liberty and equality.
Animal Farm 3 Essay Research Paper ANIMAL
Animal Farm 3 Essay, Research Paper ANIMAL FARM Animal Farm, a novel by George Orwell, was a story of courage and corrupt government. It was set on a farm in England. This setting is very important to the story itself and the characters in it. It made the plot a lot more interesting and influenced all the characters.
Animal Farm And The Russian Revolution Essay
, Research Paper Animal Farm and the Russian Revolution have many similarities and ideas. The characters, settings, and the plots are the same. In addition Animal Farm is a satire and allegory of the Russian
Animal Farm Essay Research Paper Although George
Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper Although George Orwell was a Socialist, he was critical of Communism. He hated totalitarianism, and it has been said that his “Animal Farm” was written as a biting satire of the 1917 Russian Revolution. In fact, many of the characters in “Animal Farm” are thought to be caricatures of the main figures of the Russian Revolution.
And On That Farm He Had A
Pig Essay, Research Paper In his controversial novella, Animal Farm, George Orwell cleverly hides political satire in his character, Napoleon, who destroys Old Major s idea of a utopian society. Orwell not only models this farm and what happens on it after the Russian Revolution, but he also portrays his revolutionary leaders as pigs as opposed to humans.
Napoleon Essay Research Paper Although he inspired
Napoleon Essay, Research Paper Although he inspired new social, economic, and political ideas, Napoleon Bonaparte is better known for his military tactics. Even today, his battle plans are used and studied by many in the military. Napoleon, who started out as an extremely short and wimpy foreigner who rose to become Emperor of France, died in 1821 at St.
Animal Farm Essay Research Paper The Russian
Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper The Russian Revolution is an example that absolute power often corrupts society. In the novel Animal Farm, author George Orwell shows through
Animal Farm NapoleanStalin Essay Research Paper Animal
Animal Farm: Napolean-Stalin Essay, Research Paper Animal Farm Research Paper Animal Farm is one of George Orwell s most controversial pieces of work. One would say that Animal Farm is an allegory of Stalinism, growing out from the Russian Revolution in 1917. Because it is cast as an animal fable it gives the reader/viewer, some distance from the specific political events.
Napoleon Essay Research Paper NapoleonThere are never
Napoleon Essay, Research Paper Napoleon There are never ending inquiries on the nature of Napoleonic power. But reason can prove to one that the Age of Napoleon was infact a time of democratic rule. Through Political, Social, and Economical reforms, Napoleon Bonaparte did not only transcend France, but he changed the course of history for Europe and the World today.